Hey everybody,
Last week, I finished reading Cataclysm, the second novel in the second phase of The High Republic publishing programme. There were three phases, each of which had a mix of adult, YA and junior novels, and comic books that all told a story set over two hundred years before the events of the prequels. Phase Two was a prequel to Phase One, which has confused the issue a little bit! But anyway. We’ve mainly been concerned with the ongoing war between the neighbouring worlds of Eiram and E’ronoh, which was set to have concluded at the end of the first book, Convergence, with the marriage of the heirs to each world, however the audio drama The Battle of Jedha told the story of the machinations of the Path of the Open Hand to continue the war.
The Path is a religious group that feels the Jedi are using the Force as a tool, and have spread a message of hate against them as a result. After the events on Jedha, the Path members have retreated to their farming world of Dalna, where they begin to prepare for the next phase of the Mother’s plan. The Mother, their spiritual leader, has sent her operative Binnot Ullo to break Axel Greylark out of prison, although Jedi Knight Gella Nettai has already gone to visit him in prison to find out what he knew about the events on Jedha. Binnot is able to capture the wayward son of Chancellor Greylark and bring him back to Dalna, where the Mother tells him he needs to ask for the Chancellor to come to the world so she can enact the next phase of her plan.
Kyong Greylark realises that she has always put her career before her family, and so agrees to come to Dalna, but resigns before doing so. The Mother realises Axel is of no use to her as a political pawn anymore, and so he is summarily dismissed from his position in her schemes. Several other groups of Jedi, including Yaddle, have also arrived on Dalna to see what’s going on there, and a massive pitched battle erupts during a rainstorm. The Mother unleashes several creatures that kill Force-sensitives by turning them into husks, and leaves the planet.
Obviously the Jedi are able to turn the tide, thanks to the timely arrival of soldiers from Eiram and E’ronoh, who have at last put their war aside and united to defeat the Path once and for all.
This story was almost marginally better than Catalyst, though not by much. I found it somewhat confusing, and in at least 3-4 places in desperate need of an editor as the narrative was jumping around a bit too much. For instance, on one page some characters would be discussing something while waiting to arrive at a planet, but without any mention of movement, they were suddenly on-world. It was jarring, to say the least.
I’ve missed out quite a few odd little bits in the summary above, but there is a lot going on with the various Jedi groups going to Dalna, and it all got a bit confusing because they just blended into one. There were a number of Jedi who were, I think, fairly significant characters, but I just couldn’t work out who was who. It led to some strange moments where a character I had thought had died was then walking about like nothing had happened.
The subject of character deaths does make me realise that I didn’t care about any of these people I was reading about. I don’t know if it was because the cast was so large, with a lot of these characters being given a lot of focus, but where everyone is treated equally, nobody stands out. Also, so many characters make very stupid decisions. I swear, the Jedi characters are dumbed-down at times to allow these cardboard villains their moment of moustache-twirling, it’s just dire. It made me feel like a bit of a reading snob, because I felt very strongly like this book was a YA novel, in fact both of them in this phase felt like that. I personally have nothing against YA novels, but if I’m going into a book that is ostensibly an adult novel, I expect a different feel. I’m not saying it needs to be violent or something, but the plot, the characters, the pacing, everything felt really off in here.
Going back to the subject of Jedi, one was called Enya, and one was called Aida. I was either thinking about Orinoco Flow, or the opera by Giuseppe Verdi. It wasn’t exactly a great Star Wars experience.
But then, that’s been the difficulty with a lot of these High Republic stories that I’ve read now, and it’s becoming a serious problem. They just don’t feel like Star Wars, somehow. Tales of the Jedi was set 4000 years before the original trilogy, and managed to feel like Star Wars while also feeling removed from the main storyline. I’m not sure if there’s actually an effort made to distance these stories sometimes, as I’ve previously mentioned some of the aspects in Convergence feeling like they could have taken place in the days before Episode I. However, after reading through this book, aside from the fact that certain characters are described as Jedi and who are using lightsabers, there’s very little else to make this book feel like it is set in the galaxy far, far away. It really feels like a let down, in that sense. Now, I haven’t read anything from Phase Three of the High Republic yet, and it’s entirely probable that these stories will have some bearing on those to come, but I’m left feeling a bit deflated, like I’ve spent my time reading a book that is only very, very tangentially related to Star Wars, but otherwise has no impact.







