[go: up one dir, main page]

JP2008039224A - Structure of constant pressure once-through boiler and operating method therefor - Google Patents

Structure of constant pressure once-through boiler and operating method therefor Download PDF

Info

Publication number
JP2008039224A
JP2008039224A JP2006211333A JP2006211333A JP2008039224A JP 2008039224 A JP2008039224 A JP 2008039224A JP 2006211333 A JP2006211333 A JP 2006211333A JP 2006211333 A JP2006211333 A JP 2006211333A JP 2008039224 A JP2008039224 A JP 2008039224A
Authority
JP
Japan
Prior art keywords
superheater
pressure
primary
boiler
primary superheater
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Pending
Application number
JP2006211333A
Other languages
Japanese (ja)
Inventor
Hitoshi Migaki
仁志 三垣
Hideaki Tamai
秀明 玉井
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Mitsubishi Power Ltd
Original Assignee
Babcock Hitachi KK
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Babcock Hitachi KK filed Critical Babcock Hitachi KK
Priority to JP2006211333A priority Critical patent/JP2008039224A/en
Publication of JP2008039224A publication Critical patent/JP2008039224A/en
Pending legal-status Critical Current

Links

Images

Landscapes

  • Control Of Steam Boilers And Waste-Gas Boilers (AREA)

Abstract

<P>PROBLEM TO BE SOLVED: To specify a part where output pressure of the primary superheater of a constant pressure once-through boiler is suddenly increased, and to provide countermeasures therefor. <P>SOLUTION: In the start bypass system of a once-through boiler and an operating method therefor, cleaning timing or replacement timing for a resistor tube 22, or cleaning timing or replacement timing for a primary superheater bypass valve 23 is predicted on the basis of a deviation of pressure in each of tubes measured by a pressure gauge 35 in the outlet of the primary superheater 13 and a pressure gauge 36 between the resistor tube 22 and the primary superheater valve 23, or a deviation of pressure in each of tubes measured by the pressure gauge 36 between the resistor tube 22 and the primary superheater bypass valve 23 and a pressure gauge 37 in the outlet of the primary superheater bypass valve 23. <P>COPYRIGHT: (C)2008,JPO&INPIT

Description

本発明は定圧貫流ボイラの過熱器バイパス系統に係り、特に過熱器バイパス系統の配管内の圧力損失増加の程度を監視しながら、配管類の更新時期及び化学洗浄時期を予測するための定圧貫流ボイラ構成とその運用方法に関するものである。   The present invention relates to a superheater bypass system for a constant pressure once-through boiler, and more particularly to a constant pressure once-through boiler for predicting the renewal time and chemical cleaning time of piping while monitoring the degree of increase in pressure loss in the piping of the superheater bypass system. It relates to the configuration and its operation method.

図3に従来の定圧貫流ボイラの起動バイパス系統図を示す。
図示しない復水器からの復水は脱気器1で脱気された後、ボイラ給水ポンプ2により吐出した給水は出口側の給水流量調節弁4により流量が調整され、給水配管7に設けられた給水流量計8及び高圧ヒータ9を通してボイラ本体100の節炭器10に入る。なお、ポンプ出口止弁5は、該止弁5から下流と上流とを分離するために設けられ、配管内の酸洗い時などにおいて該止弁5から下流に酸洗い液が流入しないようにするために設けられる。なお、ボイラ給水ポンプ2はモータで駆動し、該ポンプ2の出口には給水流量調節弁4が設けられている。また、脱気器1の出口には図示しない蒸気タービンで駆動するポンプ3がポンプ2に並列配置されており、該ポンプ3の出口には前記ポンプ出口止弁5と同一の機能を奏するポンプ出口止弁6が設けられている。
FIG. 3 shows a startup bypass system diagram of a conventional constant pressure once-through boiler.
Condensate from a condenser (not shown) is deaerated by the deaerator 1, and then the feed water discharged by the boiler feed pump 2 is adjusted in flow rate by the feed water flow rate adjustment valve 4 on the outlet side and provided in the feed water pipe 7. It enters the economizer 10 of the boiler body 100 through the feed water flow meter 8 and the high pressure heater 9. The pump outlet stop valve 5 is provided to separate the upstream and downstream from the stop valve 5 so that the pickling solution does not flow downstream from the stop valve 5 when pickling the pipe. Provided for. The boiler feed pump 2 is driven by a motor, and a feed water flow rate adjustment valve 4 is provided at the outlet of the pump 2. A pump 3 driven by a steam turbine (not shown) is disposed in parallel with the pump 2 at the outlet of the deaerator 1, and the outlet of the pump 3 has the same function as the pump outlet stop valve 5. A stop valve 6 is provided.

また、ボイラ本体100は節炭器10、水冷壁11、ケージ壁12、一次過熱器13及び二次過熱器18などから構成され、ボイラ本体100で生成した蒸気は蒸気タービンで使用される。   Moreover, the boiler main body 100 is comprised from the economizer 10, the water cooling wall 11, the cage wall 12, the primary superheater 13, the secondary superheater 18, etc., The steam produced | generated with the boiler main body 100 is used with a steam turbine.

また、ボイラ起動時には蒸気タービンへ供給する蒸気条件が成立するまで、水及び/又は蒸気からなる流体を起動バイパス系統を使用してフラッシュタンク26に通し、復水器、脱気器1へ循環させる運転が行われる。   Further, when the boiler is started, a fluid consisting of water and / or steam is passed through the flash tank 26 using the startup bypass system and circulated to the condenser and deaerator 1 until the steam condition to be supplied to the steam turbine is satisfied. Driving is performed.

従来の定圧貫流ボイラの起動バイパス系統のうち、一次過熱器13のバイパス系統は、一次過熱器バイパス配管20、レジスタチューブバイパス弁21、レジスタチューブ22及び一次過熱器バイパス弁23などを設置した一次過熱器バイパス系統Aで構成され、二次過熱器18のバイパス系統は二次過熱器バイパス配管24、二次過熱器バイパス弁25、二次過熱器ウォーミング配管27及び二次過熱器ウォーミング弁28などを設置した二次過熱器バイパス系統Bで構成されている。   Among the startup bypass systems of conventional constant pressure once-through boilers, the primary superheater 13 bypass system is a primary superheater provided with a primary superheater bypass pipe 20, a register tube bypass valve 21, a register tube 22, a primary superheater bypass valve 23, and the like. The bypass system of the secondary superheater 18 includes a secondary superheater bypass pipe 24, a secondary superheater bypass valve 25, a secondary superheater warming pipe 27, and a secondary superheater warming valve 28. It is comprised by the secondary superheater bypass system B which installed etc.

上記起動バイパス系統において、それぞれ一次過熱器13及び二次過熱器18での過熱条件が成立するまでは各バイパス系統A、Bを流体が循環する。また、図示していないが、二次過熱器18の後流側の蒸気配管に三次過熱器以上の高次過熱器が設置される場合は、起動時の高次過熱蒸気条件が成立するまで流体が循環する高次過熱器バイパス系統が設けられている。   In the startup bypass system, the fluid circulates in each bypass system A and B until the superheat condition in the primary superheater 13 and the secondary superheater 18 is satisfied. Although not shown in the figure, when a higher-order superheater higher than the tertiary superheater is installed in the steam pipe on the downstream side of the secondary superheater 18, the fluid is maintained until the higher-order superheated steam condition at the time of starting is satisfied. A high-order superheater bypass system that circulates is provided.

さらに、フラッシュタンク26から復水器にはフラッシュタンクレベル調節弁32を備えた復水器供給配管31を経由して水及び/又は蒸気が供給される。また、復水器供給配管31から分岐した脱気器供給配管29(脱気器レベル調節弁30を備えている)から脱気器1に水及び/又は蒸気が供給される。   Further, water and / or steam is supplied from the flash tank 26 to the condenser via a condenser supply pipe 31 provided with a flash tank level control valve 32. Further, water and / or steam is supplied to the deaerator 1 from a deaerator supply pipe 29 (including a deaerator level control valve 30) branched from the condenser supply pipe 31.

また、一次過熱器入口温度計33が一次過熱器13の入口配管に設けられ、一次過熱器出口温度計34が一次・二次過熱器連絡管14に設けられている。また、一次・二次過熱器連絡管14には過熱器止弁15が設けられ、過熱器止弁バイパス配管16には過熱器減圧弁17が設けられている。   A primary superheater inlet thermometer 33 is provided in the inlet pipe of the primary superheater 13, and a primary superheater outlet thermometer 34 is provided in the primary / secondary superheater communication pipe 14. The primary / secondary superheater communication pipe 14 is provided with a superheater stop valve 15, and the superheater stop valve bypass pipe 16 is provided with a superheater pressure reducing valve 17.

貫流ボイラの起動時においては最終過熱器を二次過熱器18とした場合には、蒸気タービン通気とその後のタービン併入(蒸気タービン通気後に電力系統に電気が併入すること)のための二次過熱器18の出口蒸気条件が確立するまでは、次のように一次過熱器バイパス系統A及び/又は二次過熱器バイパス系統Bで水及び/又は蒸気からなる流体を循環させる。すなわち一次過熱器13の出口蒸気条件が確立するまでは一次過熱器バイパス系統Aを使用してフラッシュタンク26に前記流体を循環させ、一次過熱器13の出口蒸気条件が確立すると、一次過熱器バイパス系統Aを閉止して二次過熱器バイパス系統Bを使用してフラッシュタンク26に蒸気を循環させながら、ミニマム給水量で給水と復水の循環運転を行う。   If the final superheater is the secondary superheater 18 at the start-up of the once-through boiler, steam turbine ventilation and subsequent turbine insertion (electricity will be added to the power system after steam turbine ventilation) Until the outlet steam condition of the secondary superheater 18 is established, a fluid composed of water and / or steam is circulated in the primary superheater bypass system A and / or the secondary superheater bypass system B as follows. That is, until the outlet steam condition of the primary superheater 13 is established, the fluid is circulated through the flash tank 26 using the primary superheater bypass system A. When the outlet steam condition of the primary superheater 13 is established, the primary superheater bypass is established. While the system A is closed and the secondary superheater bypass system B is used to circulate the steam to the flash tank 26, the water supply and condensate circulation operations are performed with the minimum water supply amount.

このように起動バイパス系統A、Bなどは、ボイラ水張りとボイラ昇圧から始まりタービン通気とタービン併入までの間に、給水あるいは復水を前記バイパス系統A、Bなどを通してフラッシュタンク26から復水器に回収・循環する系統である。   As described above, the start-up bypass systems A, B, etc., start from boiler water filling and boiler pressure increase, and supply water or condensate from the flash tank 26 through the bypass systems A, B to the condenser between the turbine aeration and turbine entry. It is a system that collects and circulates.

一次過熱器13の入口温度条件が確立するまでは、第一段階として一次過熱器バイパス系統Aを使用してミニマム給水量の全量を循環する運転を行うが、このバイパス系統Aには高圧・低温流体を流すことによって発生する一次過熱器バイパス弁23の騒音及びエロージョンを防止するためのレジスタチューブ22を設けている。レジスタチューブ22は一次過熱器バイパス配管20の一部をバイパスする流体が迂回して流れるように設けられ、該レジスタチューブ22を迂回する一次過熱器バイパス配管20にレジスタチューブバイパス弁21を設置している。そして一次過熱器13の入口温度が規定値に達するまで、レジスタチューブバイパス弁21を閉じた状態でミニマム給水量の全量をレジスタチューブ22を経由して流す運用を行う。   Until the inlet temperature condition of the primary superheater 13 is established, as the first stage, the primary superheater bypass system A is used to circulate the entire minimum amount of water supply. A resistor tube 22 is provided to prevent noise and erosion of the primary superheater bypass valve 23 generated by flowing a fluid. The register tube 22 is provided such that a fluid bypassing a part of the primary superheater bypass pipe 20 flows around, and a register tube bypass valve 21 is installed in the primary superheater bypass pipe 20 bypassing the register tube 22. Yes. Then, until the inlet temperature of the primary superheater 13 reaches a specified value, the operation of flowing the entire amount of the minimum water supply amount through the register tube 22 with the register tube bypass valve 21 closed is performed.

上記レジスタチューブ22は、内径が24mm程度で、長さ約15mの配管を5本程度並列配置した構成からなり、レジスタチューブ22の各配管内に10Mpa以上の高差圧で給水する方式であるので通常の流れの場と異なり、高速流の場となる。   The register tube 22 has a configuration in which about five pipes having an inner diameter of about 24 mm and a length of about 15 m are arranged in parallel, and water is supplied into each pipe of the register tube 22 with a high differential pressure of 10 Mpa or more. Unlike a normal flow field, it becomes a high-speed flow field.

また、図3に示す一次過熱器バイパス系統Aには流体の温度・圧力を計測する機器を設けてなく、一次過熱器バイパス系統Aの流体自体の圧力・温度の監視は蒸気タービンに蒸気を供給する主流側の一次過熱器13の入口と出口に設置した入口温度計33と出口温度計34と一次過熱器出口圧力計35で行われるだけである。   In addition, the primary superheater bypass system A shown in FIG. 3 is not provided with a device for measuring the temperature / pressure of the fluid, and monitoring of the pressure / temperature of the fluid of the primary superheater bypass system A supplies steam to the steam turbine. It is only performed by an inlet thermometer 33, an outlet thermometer 34, and a primary superheater outlet pressure gauge 35 installed at the inlet and outlet of the primary superheater 13 on the mainstream side.

なお、過熱器内の主蒸気圧力により過熱器バイパス系統に流す蒸気流量を制御することは特許文献1、2などに開示されている。
特開2000−320801号公報 特開平6−213404号公報
Controlling the flow rate of steam flowing through the superheater bypass system by the main steam pressure in the superheater is disclosed in Patent Documents 1 and 2 and the like.
JP 2000-320801 A JP-A-6-213404

図3に示す定圧貫流ボイラの起動バイパス装置を設けた系統において運転実績のあるボイラ(既納缶)の一次過熱器13の出口圧力がボイラの運転を続けていくと上昇する傾向があることは従来から分っていたが、一次過熱器13の出口圧力が経年的に増加傾向にあるため、それを初期値と同等になるように抑えるために、一次過熱器バイパス弁23の開度を経時的に大きくして対応していた。しかし、運用を開始してから十数年が経過した後に一次過熱器13の出口圧力が急激に上昇する現象が発生して一次過熱器バイパス系統Aの圧力制御が不可能となる現象が生じていた。   In the system provided with the start-up bypass device for the constant-pressure once-through boiler shown in FIG. 3, the outlet pressure of the primary superheater 13 having a proven operation has a tendency to increase as the operation of the boiler continues. As previously known, since the outlet pressure of the primary superheater 13 tends to increase over time, the opening degree of the primary superheater bypass valve 23 is changed over time in order to keep it equal to the initial value. In response, it was enlarged. However, a phenomenon in which the outlet pressure of the primary superheater 13 suddenly rises after a decade has passed since the start of operation has occurred, and the pressure control of the primary superheater bypass system A has become impossible. It was.

このため、従来の対策では一次過熱器バイパス弁23の開度が制御上限値に達すると、一次過熱器バイパス系統Aに流す給水流量を落とさざるを得ず、その後、再び一次過熱器バイパス弁23の開度を再増加しても制御の上限を超えてしまい対応不能になって、バイパス系統を切断して硫酸などの強酸で酸洗いせざるを得なかった。このような問題は、二次過熱器バイパス系統B及びそれより高次の過熱器バイパス系統でも生じていた。   For this reason, in the conventional countermeasure, when the opening degree of the primary superheater bypass valve 23 reaches the control upper limit value, the feed water flow rate flowing to the primary superheater bypass system A must be reduced, and then the primary superheater bypass valve 23 again. Even if the degree of opening was increased again, the upper limit of control was exceeded, making it impossible to cope with it, and the bypass system had to be cut off and pickled with a strong acid such as sulfuric acid. Such a problem has also occurred in the secondary superheater bypass system B and higher superheater bypass systems.

そこで、本発明の課題は、定圧貫流ボイラの過熱器の出口圧力の急激な上昇が発生する箇所の特定と、その対応策を提供することである。   Then, the subject of this invention is specifying the location where the rapid rise of the outlet pressure of the superheater of a constant pressure once-through boiler generate | occur | produces, and providing the countermeasure.

本発明の上記課題は、次の解決手段により達成できる。
すなわち、請求項1記載の発明は、内部を水又は蒸気が流れる伝熱管パネルからなり、ボイラ火炉の周壁を構成する水冷壁(11)と、内部を水又は蒸気が流れる伝熱管パネルからなり、ボイラ火炉での燃料の燃焼により生成した燃焼ガスが火炉の下流側に配置される煙突に向かって排出される流路である煙道の周壁を構成するゲージ壁(12)と、内部を過熱蒸気が流れる伝熱管からなり、前記煙道内に設けられる一次過熱器(13)と、内部を過熱蒸気が流れる伝熱管からなり、前記一次過熱器(13)の下流側の煙道内に設けられる少なくとも二次過熱器(18)を含む高次過熱器と、内部を水が流通する伝熱管パネルからなり、前記二次過熱器(18)を含む高次過熱器の下流側の煙道内に設けられる節炭器(10)とを有する定圧貫流ボイラと、該貫流ボイラで得られた蒸気を負荷対象で使用した後に復水する復水器と、該復水器からの給水を前記節炭器(10)、水冷壁(11)、ゲージ壁(12)に順次供給した後、前記一次過熱器(13)の入口から復水器にバイパスさせる一次過熱器バイパス系統(A)と、前記一次過熱器(13)の出口からの過熱蒸気を二次過熱器(18)の入口から復水器にバイパスさせる二次過熱器バイパス系統(B)を含む高次過熱器バイパス系統とを備えた定圧貫流ボイラ構成において、前記一次過熱器バイパス系統(A)は、上流側からレジスタチューブ(22)とそのバイパス弁(21)と一次過熱器バイパス弁(23)を備え、節炭器(10)入口又は一次過熱器(13)出口の配管内の圧力を測定する圧力計(42又は35)と、前記レジスタチューブ(22)と一次過熱器バイパス弁(23)の間の配管(20)内の圧力を測定する圧力計(36)と、一次過熱器バイパス弁(23)の出口の配管(24)内の圧力を測定する圧力計(37)と、さらに二次過熱器(18)以上の高次過熱器の出口と入口の配管内の圧力をそれぞれ測定する圧力計(43など)を設けた定圧貫流ボイラ構成である。
The above-described problems of the present invention can be achieved by the following solution means.
That is, the invention of claim 1 consists of a heat transfer tube panel in which water or steam flows inside, a water cooling wall (11) constituting the peripheral wall of the boiler furnace, and a heat transfer tube panel in which water or steam flows inside, A gauge wall (12) that constitutes the peripheral wall of the flue that is a flow path through which combustion gas generated by the combustion of fuel in the boiler furnace is discharged toward the chimney disposed downstream of the furnace, and superheated steam inside A primary superheater (13) provided in the flue, and a heat transfer pipe through which superheated steam flows, and is provided in at least two flues downstream of the primary superheater (13). A high-order superheater including a secondary superheater (18) and a heat transfer tube panel through which water flows, and a node provided in a flue downstream of the high-order superheater including the secondary superheater (18) Constant pressure with charcoal (10) A flow boiler, a condenser for condensing the steam obtained in the once-through boiler after being used as a load target, and water saving from the condenser (10), water cooling wall (11), gauge After sequentially supplying to the wall (12), the primary superheater bypass system (A) for bypassing from the inlet of the primary superheater (13) to the condenser, and the superheated steam from the outlet of the primary superheater (13) In a constant pressure once-through boiler configuration including a high-order superheater bypass system including a secondary superheater bypass system (B) that is bypassed from the inlet of the secondary superheater (18) to the condenser, the primary superheater bypass system ( A) is provided with a register tube (22), its bypass valve (21) and a primary superheater bypass valve (23) from the upstream side, in the pipe of the economizer (10) inlet or the primary superheater (13) outlet. Pressure gauge to measure pressure (42 or 35 A pressure gauge (36) for measuring the pressure in the pipe (20) between the register tube (22) and the primary superheater bypass valve (23), and a pipe at the outlet of the primary superheater bypass valve (23) ( 24) A pressure gauge (37) for measuring the internal pressure, and a pressure gauge (43, etc.) for measuring the pressure in the outlet and inlet piping of the secondary superheater (18) and higher, respectively. It is a constant pressure once-through boiler configuration.

請求項2記載の発明は、請求項1記載の定圧貫流ボイラ構成の運用方法であって、(a)前記節炭器(10)入口又は一次過熱器(13)出口の圧力計(42又は35)と前記レジスタチューブ(22)と一次過熱器バイパス弁(23)の間の圧力計(36)とで測定した各配管内圧力の偏差又は(b)前記レジスタチューブ(22)と一次過熱器バイパス弁(23)の間の圧力計(36)と前記一次過熱器バイパス弁(23)の出口の圧力計(37)とで測定した各配管内圧力の偏差に基づきレジスタチューブ(22)の洗浄時期または取り替え時期又は一次過熱器バイパス弁(23)の洗浄時期または取り替え時期を予測する定圧貫流ボイラ構成の運用方法である。   Invention of Claim 2 is the operation method of the constant pressure once-through boiler structure of Claim 1, Comprising: (a) The pressure gauge (42 or 35) of the said economizer (10) entrance or primary superheater (13) exit ) And the pressure gauge (36) between the register tube (22) and the primary superheater bypass valve (23), or (b) the register tube (22) and the primary superheater bypass. Cleaning time of the register tube (22) based on the deviation of the pressure in each pipe measured by the pressure gauge (36) between the valves (23) and the pressure gauge (37) at the outlet of the primary superheater bypass valve (23) Or it is the operation method of the constant pressure once-through boiler configuration that predicts the replacement time or the cleaning time or replacement time of the primary superheater bypass valve (23).

請求項3記載の発明は、請求項1記載の定圧貫流ボイラ構成の運用方法であって、前記二次過熱器(18)以上の高次過熱器の入口と出口の蒸気が流通する配管(24,19など)内の圧力をそれぞれ測定する圧力計(35,43など)で測定した各配管内圧力の偏差に基づき前記二次過熱器(18)以上の高次過熱器バイパス弁の洗浄時期または取り替え時期を予測する定圧貫流ボイラ構成の運用方法である。   Invention of Claim 3 is an operation method of the constant pressure once-through boiler structure of Claim 1, Comprising: The pipe | tube (24) through which the vapor | steam of the inlet and outlet of a high-order superheater more than the said secondary superheater (18) distribute | circulates. , 19 etc.) The cleaning time of the high-order superheater bypass valve of the secondary superheater (18) or more based on the deviation of the pressure in each pipe measured by a pressure gauge (35, 43, etc.) that measures the pressure in the secondary superheater (18, etc.) This is an operation method of a constant pressure once-through boiler configuration for predicting the replacement time.

(作用)
図3に示すように定圧貫流ボイラの一次過熱器バイパス系統Aには差圧10Mpa以上の抵抗を負うレジスタチューブ22を設置しているが、該レジスタチューブ22の管径は非常に細く、管内の流れは通常の流れの場と異なり、約50m/sの高速流となるため、圧力損失はスケール付着、特に表面粗さにより非常に大きな影響を受ける。
(Function)
As shown in FIG. 3, the primary superheater bypass system A of the constant pressure once-through boiler is provided with a resistor tube 22 that bears a resistance of 10 Mpa or more. However, the tube diameter of the resistor tube 22 is very thin, Since the flow is a high-speed flow of about 50 m / s unlike a normal flow field, the pressure loss is greatly influenced by the scale adhesion, particularly the surface roughness.

さらに図3に示す一次過熱器バイパス系統Aには、ボイラ起動過程により水状態と蒸気状態の流れが発生するため、レジスタチューブ22や一次過熱器バイパス弁23などの管内表面に水系のスケール及び蒸気系のスケールが付着する。これらのスケール付着部位は化学洗浄が実施できない部位であることから、ボイラに取り付けた状態では前記スケール除去が不可能な部位でもある。   Further, in the primary superheater bypass system A shown in FIG. 3, the water state and the steam state flow are generated by the boiler starting process. Therefore, the scale and steam of the water system are formed on the pipe inner surfaces such as the register tube 22 and the primary superheater bypass valve 23. The scale of the system adheres. Since these scale adhering sites are sites where chemical cleaning cannot be performed, the scales cannot be removed when attached to the boiler.

水スケールはポーラス状態のスケールであるため、非破壊検査では測定困難であるだけでなく、一次過熱器バイパス系統Aのスケール付着部位が化学洗浄が実施できない部位であることからスケールの付着の程度を予測することができない。さらに、本発明により判明した一次過熱器バイパス弁23の制御不能の原因であるスケールの表面粗さが生じていることがサンプル調査で分かったとしても、このスケール表面粗さを的確に測定することは困難であることから、レジスタチューブ22の更新時期又は化学洗浄時期の予測監視が困難である。   Since the water scale is a porous scale, it is not only difficult to measure by non-destructive inspection, but also because the scale adhesion site of the primary superheater bypass system A cannot be subjected to chemical cleaning. It cannot be predicted. Furthermore, even if it is found by a sample survey that the surface roughness of the scale, which is the cause of the uncontrollability of the primary superheater bypass valve 23 found by the present invention, is obtained, this scale surface roughness should be accurately measured. Therefore, it is difficult to predict and monitor the update time of the register tube 22 or the chemical cleaning time.

また、図3に示す従来の一次バイパス系統Aには圧力の監視計器が設置されていないため、圧力損失が増加する特定部位の確定及び圧力損失の増加量を計測することが困難であった。   In addition, since the pressure monitoring instrument is not installed in the conventional primary bypass system A shown in FIG. 3, it is difficult to determine the specific portion where the pressure loss increases and to measure the amount of increase in the pressure loss.

ところで、図2(a)は、特定のボイラの運転経歴(運転時間経過)に対するレジスタチューブ22の圧力損失の変化を示すグラフであるが、このグラフに示すようにレジスタチューブ22の圧力損失の増加傾向は、ある時点から急激に上昇している。この圧力異常上昇の原因調査をボイラの定期検査時に実施したが、レジスタチューブ22や一次過熱器バイパス弁23などでの詰まり又は多大なスケール付着による管内径の縮小はないことが確認された。しかし、レジスタチューブ22の管内表面に20〜50μmの表面粗さ(凹凸)があることが確認された。なお、前記付着スケール層の内部には空隙が存在しており、このスケールはポーラスタイプの水スケールであることが確認された。   Incidentally, FIG. 2A is a graph showing a change in the pressure loss of the register tube 22 with respect to the operating history (elapsed operating time) of a specific boiler. As shown in this graph, the increase in the pressure loss of the register tube 22 is shown. The trend has risen sharply from a certain point. The cause of this abnormal pressure rise was investigated during boiler periodic inspection, but it was confirmed that there was no clogging of the register tube 22 or the primary superheater bypass valve 23 or a reduction in the inner diameter of the tube due to excessive scale adhesion. However, it was confirmed that the inner surface of the register tube 22 has a surface roughness (unevenness) of 20 to 50 μm. In addition, the space | gap exists in the inside of the said adhesion scale layer, and it was confirmed that this scale is a porous type water scale.

また、図2(b)には、特定のボイラの運転経歴(運転時間経過)に対するレジスタチューブ22の平均表面粗さを示すグラフを示す。   Moreover, in FIG.2 (b), the graph which shows the average surface roughness of the register | resistor tube 22 with respect to the operation history (operating time progress) of a specific boiler is shown.

本発明者は、図2(a)のデータと図2(b)のデータの比較からレジスタチューブ22の管内圧力の異常上昇はレジスタチューブ22などの管内に付着したスケールの表面粗さに起因したものであることを見出した。   The present inventor has found that the abnormal increase in the pressure inside the register tube 22 is caused by the surface roughness of the scale attached to the pipe such as the register tube 22 from the comparison between the data shown in FIG. 2A and the data shown in FIG. I found out that it was.

ところで、図2(a)、(b)に示すグラフが得られるボイラは油焚きボイラであり、図の左端の運用開始時には電力消費量のベースロードを補うために連続運転を行っており、その後、ボイラの起動停止回数は毎月一回程度である。このときのレジスタチューブ22の圧力損失と管内の付着スケールの平均表面粗さは、図2(a)、(b)共に経年的には右方に緩やかに上昇する傾向を示す。   By the way, the boiler from which the graphs shown in FIGS. 2 (a) and 2 (b) are obtained is an oil-fired boiler, and at the start of operation at the left end of the figure, continuous operation is performed to supplement the base load of power consumption. The number of times the boiler is started and stopped is about once a month. At this time, the pressure loss of the register tube 22 and the average surface roughness of the adhesion scale in the tube tend to gradually increase to the right over time in both FIGS. 2 (a) and 2 (b).

しかし、図2(a)、(b)に示す運転経歴のグラフの半ば頃からエネルギー事情が変わり、発電エネルギーとしては原子力発電がベースロードになり、高価な石油を使用する油焚きボイラは、日々または季節によるピークロード対応に使用されるようになった。そのため、火力発電用のボイラは、週末に起動と停止を繰り返す状態から毎日起動と停止を繰り返す運転DSS(Daily Start Daily Stop)へ、さらに時間ピーク対応に伴う急速負荷変化運転が課せられるようになった。図2(c)には火力発電用のボイラの起動・停止回数と運転経歴との関係を示すグラフである。   However, the energy situation changed from the middle of the operating history graphs shown in FIGS. 2 (a) and 2 (b), and nuclear power generation became the base load as power generation energy, and oil-fired boilers that use expensive oil are Or it is used for peak load according to the season. For this reason, boilers for thermal power generation are now subject to DSS (Daily Start Daily Stop) that repeats starting and stopping every day from a state where starting and stopping are repeated on weekends, and further, rapid load change operation in response to time peaks. It was. FIG. 2C is a graph showing the relationship between the number of times of starting and stopping the thermal power generation boiler and the operating history.

図2(c)に示す発電所の事情の変更で火力発電用のボイラが起動・停止回数を急増させ始めた時期が図2(a)に示すレジスタチューブ22の圧力損失が急上昇し始めた時期と一致していることが分かった。   The time when the boiler for the thermal power generation starts to suddenly increase the number of times of starting and stopping due to the change of the situation of the power plant shown in FIG. 2C, the time when the pressure loss of the register tube 22 shown in FIG. It was found to be consistent with

図2(c)に示すボイラの起動停止回数(近年、ボイラの起動停止回数が大幅に増加している)に圧力損失が関係していることが明らかとなったが、このことからボイラの起動時に使用される一次過熱器バイパス系統Aを流れる流体が水状態であり、この水状態の流体に含まれるスケール成分がレジスタチューブ22内に付着し易くなるためであると考えられる。   It has become clear that pressure loss is related to the number of boiler start / stop times shown in FIG. 2 (c) (in recent years, the number of boiler start / stop times has increased significantly). This is probably because the fluid flowing through the primary superheater bypass system A sometimes used is in a water state, and the scale component contained in the water state fluid is likely to adhere to the register tube 22.

図2(d)には火力発電用のボイラの起動弁の実開度と起動弁の計算開度との関係から弁の異常と正常を判定するためのグラフを示す。   FIG. 2 (d) shows a graph for determining whether the valve is abnormal or normal from the relationship between the actual opening of the start valve of the boiler for thermal power generation and the calculated opening of the start valve.

なお、図2(a)〜(c)の横軸は20〜30年間の運転時間を表しており、また、図2(a)〜(d)はそれぞれ概算データを図示している。   In addition, the horizontal axis of Fig.2 (a)-(c) represents the operating time for 20-30 years, and Fig.2 (a)-(d) has each shown approximate data.

図2(a)〜(d)に示すように、ボイラの起動停止回数が増加することが一次過熱器バイパス系統Aの管内のスケール付着量とスケールの表面粗さに密接に関係することが確認され、さらに、一次過熱器バイパス系統Aの配管内で圧力損失が大きくなる原因が発電所のボイラ運用が変化したためであることも判明した。   As shown in FIGS. 2 (a) to 2 (d), it is confirmed that the increase in the number of times the boiler is started and stopped is closely related to the amount of scale adhered in the pipe of the primary superheater bypass system A and the surface roughness of the scale. Furthermore, it has also been found that the cause of the pressure loss in the piping of the primary superheater bypass system A is that the boiler operation of the power plant has changed.

このように定圧貫流ボイラの一次過熱器13の出口圧力の上昇は一次過熱器バイパス系統Aにおけるレジスタチューブ22内のスケール付着が原因であり、レジスタチューブ22内のスケール付着による流体圧力損失の増大により一次過熱器13の出口圧力の上昇が生じていることが分かり、さらに、レジスタチューブ22管内のスケールの表面粗さが圧力損失の原因の一つであることが分かった。   As described above, the increase in the outlet pressure of the primary superheater 13 of the constant pressure once-through boiler is caused by the scale adhesion in the register tube 22 in the primary superheater bypass system A. The increase in fluid pressure loss due to the scale adhesion in the register tube 22 It was found that the outlet pressure of the primary superheater 13 increased, and further, it was found that the surface roughness of the scale in the register tube 22 was one of the causes of pressure loss.

本発明で分かったことであるが、例えばレジスタチューブ22の管内径が24mmの場合、1mmの厚さでチューブ内に均一厚さのスケールが付着した場合とスケール付着により平均表面粗さ25μmが生じた場合の圧力損失がほぼ同等となる。   As can be seen from the present invention, for example, when the inner diameter of the register tube 22 is 24 mm, an average surface roughness of 25 μm occurs when a uniform thickness scale adheres to the tube with a thickness of 1 mm and due to the scale adhesion. Pressure loss is almost the same.

上記知見により、レジスタチューブ22での圧力損失が特定できればそれだけを交換することができる。しかし一次過熱器バイパス系統A内には圧力損失が上昇する原因箇所としてはレジスタチューブ22の他に一次過熱器バイパス弁23がある。一次過熱器バイパス弁23が損傷することにより圧力損失が上昇することが考えられる。   If the pressure loss in the register tube 22 can be specified based on the above knowledge, it can be replaced only. However, in the primary superheater bypass system A, there is a primary superheater bypass valve 23 in addition to the resistor tube 22 as a cause of the pressure loss increase. It is conceivable that the pressure loss increases due to damage to the primary superheater bypass valve 23.

したがって、一次過熱器バイパス弁23での圧力損失の増加を検出するために、本発明で新たに設けた前記一次過熱器バイパス弁入口圧力計36と一次過熱器バイパス弁23の出口の圧力計37(圧力計37をフラッシュタンク26に設けたあるのはフラッシュタンク26の圧力損失を把握しておくことで、一次過熱器バイパス弁23の出口圧力が分かる)との差圧により検知することができる。もちろん前記フラッシュタンクに設けた圧力計37とは別に一次過熱器バイパス弁23の出口側に新たに圧力計(図示せず)を設け、それと一次過熱器バイパス弁入口圧力計36の差圧を計算しても良い。   Therefore, in order to detect an increase in pressure loss in the primary superheater bypass valve 23, the primary superheater bypass valve inlet pressure gauge 36 newly provided in the present invention and the pressure gauge 37 at the outlet of the primary superheater bypass valve 23 are provided. (The pressure gauge 37 is provided in the flash tank 26, and it is possible to detect the pressure loss of the flash tank 26 so that the outlet pressure of the primary superheater bypass valve 23 is known). . Of course, a pressure gauge (not shown) is newly provided on the outlet side of the primary superheater bypass valve 23 separately from the pressure gauge 37 provided in the flash tank, and the differential pressure between the pressure gauge 36 and the primary superheater bypass valve inlet pressure gauge 36 is calculated. You may do it.

本発明では図1に示すように一次過熱器バイパス弁23の入口の圧力を圧力計36で測定することにより、圧力増加要因部位がレジスタチューブ22であるか又はバイパス弁23であるかを特定し、また、一次過熱器バイパス系統Aの流量・圧力分布・温度データを計測することで、規定流量におけるレジスタチューブ22の圧力損失値、表面粗さ値が図2に示すデータに基づく計算処理により確認でき、これらを経時的に統計処理すれば圧力損失の増加特性、及び表面粗さの増加特性が監視でき、レジスタチューブ22の更新時期或いは化学洗浄時期を予測することができる。   In the present invention, as shown in FIG. 1, the pressure at the inlet of the primary superheater bypass valve 23 is measured with a pressure gauge 36 to identify whether the pressure increase factor site is the register tube 22 or the bypass valve 23. In addition, by measuring the flow rate, pressure distribution, and temperature data of the primary superheater bypass system A, the pressure loss value and surface roughness value of the register tube 22 at the specified flow rate are confirmed by calculation processing based on the data shown in FIG. If these are statistically processed over time, the increase characteristic of pressure loss and the increase characteristic of surface roughness can be monitored, and the update time or chemical cleaning time of the register tube 22 can be predicted.

このような過熱器バイパス系統内の圧力損失の問題は二次過熱器18以上の高次過熱器のバイパス系統でも生じていたが、本発明により二次過熱器18以上の高次過熱器バイパス弁の洗浄時期または取り替え時期を予測することができるようになった。   Such a problem of pressure loss in the superheater bypass system also occurred in the bypass system of the high-order superheater of the secondary superheater 18 or higher, but according to the present invention, the high-order superheater bypass valve of the secondary superheater 18 or higher is used. It is now possible to predict when to clean or replace.

本発明によれば、定圧貫流ボイラの起動において、一次過熱器バイパス系統及びそれ以上の高次過熱器バイパス系統の経時的なスケール付着による圧力損失の増加傾向が確認監視できるため、原因箇所の特定及びレジスタチューブの更新或いは化学洗浄時期の予測監視・最適化が図れ、メンテナンス費用の低減が図れる。   According to the present invention, in starting up a constant pressure once-through boiler, it is possible to confirm and monitor the increasing tendency of pressure loss due to the time scale adhesion of the primary superheater bypass system and the higher superheater bypass system. In addition, it is possible to predict and monitor and optimize the register tube renewal or chemical cleaning time, thereby reducing maintenance costs.

本発明の実施例を図面と共に説明する。
図1(a)には本実施例の定圧貫流ボイラの水蒸気系統図を示し、図1(b)には図1(a)の水蒸気系統の制御装置を示す。また、図3に示す従来の定圧貫流ボイラの水蒸気系統図と同一部材は同一番号を付して、その説明は省略する。
ボイラの水蒸気系統の機器は、脱気器1、ボイラ給水ポンプ2、高圧ヒータ9、ボイラ本体100(節炭器10、水冷壁11、ケージ壁12、一次過熱器13、二次過熱器18)、蒸気タービン(図示せず)、復水器(図示せず)、フラッシュタンク26等によって構成される。
Embodiments of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings.
FIG. 1 (a) shows a steam system diagram of the constant pressure once-through boiler of this embodiment, and FIG. 1 (b) shows a control device for the steam system of FIG. 1 (a). The same members as those in the steam system diagram of the conventional constant pressure once-through boiler shown in FIG.
The equipment of the steam system of the boiler is a deaerator 1, a boiler feed pump 2, a high-pressure heater 9, a boiler body 100 (a economizer 10, a water cooling wall 11, a cage wall 12, a primary superheater 13, and a secondary superheater 18). , A steam turbine (not shown), a condenser (not shown), a flash tank 26, and the like.

ボイラ給水ポンプ2から吐出した給水は出口側の給水流量調節弁4とポンプ出口止弁5により、その流量が調整され、給水流量計8、高圧ヒータ9を通してボイラ本体100の節炭器10に入る。   The flow rate of the feed water discharged from the boiler feed pump 2 is adjusted by the feed water flow rate adjustment valve 4 and the pump outlet stop valve 5 on the outlet side, and enters the economizer 10 of the boiler body 100 through the feed water flow meter 8 and the high pressure heater 9. .

ボイラ本体100に供給された水は、節炭器10、水冷壁11、ケージ壁12にて受熱・蒸発し蒸気となって一次過熱器13、二次過熱器18を通して必要な蒸気温度となって蒸気タービンへ供給される。   The water supplied to the boiler body 100 receives and evaporates at the economizer 10, the water cooling wall 11, and the cage wall 12 to become steam and becomes a necessary steam temperature through the primary superheater 13 and the secondary superheater 18. Supplied to the steam turbine.

ボイラ起動時には、蒸気タービンに供給する蒸気条件が成立するまで、起動バイパス系統を使用してフラッシュタンク26を通し、復水器、脱気器1への循環運転が行われる。この起動バイパス系統には一次過熱器バイパス系統Aと二次過熱器バイパス系統Bが設備されており、運転の初期ステップとして一次過熱器13の入口温度が規定温度になるまでは、ケージ壁12と一次過熱器13の入口間に設けられた一次過熱器バイパス配管20を有する一次過熱器バイパス系統を通して、ミニマム給水量の全量の循環運転を行う。   When the boiler is started, circulation operation to the condenser and deaerator 1 is performed through the flash tank 26 using the start bypass system until the steam condition to be supplied to the steam turbine is satisfied. The startup bypass system is provided with a primary superheater bypass system A and a secondary superheater bypass system B. As an initial step of operation, until the inlet temperature of the primary superheater 13 reaches a specified temperature, the cage wall 12 and Through the primary superheater bypass system having the primary superheater bypass pipe 20 provided between the inlets of the primary superheater 13, the circulation operation of the entire minimum amount of water supply is performed.

この初期運転状態においては、一次・二次過熱器連絡管14に設けられた過熱器止弁15、過熱器止弁バイパス配管16に設けられた過熱器減圧弁17、及び二次過熱器バイパス配管24に設けられた二次過熱器バイパス弁25は全閉状態の運転である。   In this initial operation state, the superheater stop valve 15 provided in the primary / secondary superheater communication pipe 14, the superheater pressure reducing valve 17 provided in the superheater stop valve bypass pipe 16, and the secondary superheater bypass pipe are provided. The secondary superheater bypass valve 25 provided at 24 is operated in a fully closed state.

起動バイパス運転における、一次過熱器バイパス系統Aは一次過熱器13の手前の流路からフラッシュタンク26に至るまでレジスタチューブバイパス弁21、レジスタチューブ22及び一次過熱器バイパス弁23などから構成され、ケージ壁12を出たミニマム給水量はバイパス配管20を通り、全量がレジスタチューブ22を通過して、一次過熱器バイパス弁23により一次過熱器13の出口圧力を一定に制御調整し、フラッシュタンク26に供給される。   In the start-up bypass operation, the primary superheater bypass system A is composed of a register tube bypass valve 21, a register tube 22, a primary superheater bypass valve 23 and the like from the flow path before the primary superheater 13 to the flash tank 26, and the cage. The minimum amount of water supplied from the wall 12 passes through the bypass pipe 20, and the entire amount passes through the register tube 22, and the outlet pressure of the primary superheater 13 is controlled and adjusted to be constant by the primary superheater bypass valve 23. Supplied.

ミニマム給水量が全量レジスタチューブ22を通過する際、レジスタチューブ22の圧力損失により一次過熱器バイパス弁23の入口圧力を下げてバイパス弁23の開度確保を図る。   When the minimum amount of water supply passes through the register tube 22, the inlet pressure of the primary superheater bypass valve 23 is lowered by the pressure loss of the register tube 22 to ensure the opening degree of the bypass valve 23.

一次過熱器13の入口温度が既定値に達すると、レジスタチューブバイパス弁21が開き、次に二次過熱器バイパス弁25が開き、二次過熱器バイパス系統Bの運用に入り、順次起動バイパス運用がなされ、タービンに必要な蒸気条件を確立する運用がなされる。   When the inlet temperature of the primary superheater 13 reaches a predetermined value, the register tube bypass valve 21 is opened, then the secondary superheater bypass valve 25 is opened, and the operation of the secondary superheater bypass system B is started. And the operation to establish the steam conditions necessary for the turbine is performed.

二次過熱器バイパス系統Bの二次過熱器バイパス配管24に設けられた二次過熱器バイパス弁25の上流側に一次過熱器出口圧力計35がある。また、一次過熱器バイパス系統Aの一次過熱器バイパス弁23の入口に圧力計36を設置する。また、図1(b)に示す制御装置38には監視装置39が設けられ、前記圧力計35,36の信号を以下に述べる計測装置の信号とともに監視装置39に入力して水蒸気系統の監視を行う。   There is a primary superheater outlet pressure gauge 35 on the upstream side of the secondary superheater bypass valve 25 provided in the secondary superheater bypass pipe 24 of the secondary superheater bypass system B. A pressure gauge 36 is installed at the inlet of the primary superheater bypass valve 23 of the primary superheater bypass system A. Further, the control device 38 shown in FIG. 1B is provided with a monitoring device 39, and the signals of the pressure gauges 35 and 36 are input to the monitoring device 39 together with the signals of the measuring device described below to monitor the water vapor system. Do.

また、制御装置38には、給水流量計8、一次過熱器入口温度計33、一次過熱器出口温度計34、一次過熱器出口圧力計35、一次過熱器バイパス弁入口圧力計36、フラッシュタンク圧力計37及び一次過熱器バイパス弁23の開度などの各種信号が入力され、前記一次過熱器出口圧力計35と一次過熱器バイパス弁入口圧力計36と共にレジスタチューブ22の圧力損失特性、一次過熱器バイパス弁23の開度特性を評価し、図2に示すようにレジスタチューブ22及び/又は一次過熱器バイパス弁23の更新・化洗実施時期及び圧力増加要因部位の予測・判定を行い、警報・表示する監視装置39とCRT40を設置する。   The control device 38 includes a feed water flow meter 8, a primary superheater inlet thermometer 33, a primary superheater outlet thermometer 34, a primary superheater outlet pressure gauge 35, a primary superheater bypass valve inlet pressure gauge 36, a flash tank pressure. Various signals such as the opening degree of the total 37 and the primary superheater bypass valve 23 are input, and the pressure loss characteristic of the register tube 22 together with the primary superheater outlet pressure gauge 35 and the primary superheater bypass valve inlet pressure gauge 36, the primary superheater The opening characteristic of the bypass valve 23 is evaluated, and as shown in FIG. 2, the update / chemical cleaning timing and the pressure increase factor part of the register tube 22 and / or the primary superheater bypass valve 23 are predicted and judged, A monitoring device 39 and a CRT 40 to be displayed are installed.

一次過熱器バイパス系統Aのレジスタチューブ22は一次過熱器バイパス弁23に高速、高圧の流体が通過することによる孔食を防止するために設けられたものであるが、そのレジスタチューブ22内でポーラスタイプのスケールが形成されることで圧力損失が増加してしまうと、一次過熱器バイパス弁23から所定のバイパス流量を流通させるために、その開度を大きくしても所定のバイパス流量が得られず、一次過熱器バイパス弁23の開度制御ができなくなる。   The register tube 22 of the primary superheater bypass system A is provided in order to prevent pitting caused by high-speed and high-pressure fluid passing through the primary superheater bypass valve 23. If pressure loss increases due to the formation of a scale of the type, a predetermined bypass flow rate can be obtained even if the opening degree is increased in order to distribute a predetermined bypass flow rate from the primary superheater bypass valve 23. Therefore, the opening degree of the primary superheater bypass valve 23 cannot be controlled.

一般的に流体が流れる配管に設けられる流体流量調整用の開閉弁の開度は70%〜80%を上限とする開閉制御が行われており、前記開閉弁をそれ以上の開度にすることは実質的に流体流量の制御の裕度がない危険領域となる。そこで、本実施例では一次過熱器バイパス系統Aにおける経時的なスケール付着による圧力損失の増加傾向を検知して、圧力損失が所定値に達するとレジスタチューブ22内のスケールを除く化学洗浄などの作業を行い、一次過熱器バイパス弁23の開度を大きくして所定のバイパス流量が得られるようにする。   In general, the opening / closing control of the fluid flow rate adjustment opening / closing valve provided in the pipe through which the fluid flows is performed in an opening / closing control with an upper limit of 70% to 80%. Is a dangerous area with virtually no tolerance for fluid flow control. Therefore, in this embodiment, an increase in pressure loss due to the scale adhesion with time in the primary superheater bypass system A is detected, and when the pressure loss reaches a predetermined value, work such as chemical cleaning excluding the scale in the register tube 22 is performed. And the opening degree of the primary superheater bypass valve 23 is increased so that a predetermined bypass flow rate is obtained.

一次過熱器バイパス系統Aの経時的なスケール付着による圧力損失の増加傾向の検知は次のようにして行う。
ボイラの起動の最初の段階ではボイラに供給される水は節炭器10、水冷壁11及びケージ壁12を流れ、一次過熱器バイパス系統Aを通り元の給水系に戻される。このとき二次過熱器バイパス系統Bは使用していないので、一次過熱器13の出口側に設けられた過熱器止弁15、過熱器減圧弁17及び二次過熱器バイパス弁25は全て閉としていることは既に述べた通りである。
The detection of the increasing tendency of the pressure loss due to the temporal scale adhesion of the primary superheater bypass system A is performed as follows.
In the first stage of startup of the boiler, water supplied to the boiler flows through the economizer 10, the water cooling wall 11 and the cage wall 12, and returns to the original water supply system through the primary superheater bypass system A. At this time, since the secondary superheater bypass system B is not used, the superheater stop valve 15, the superheater pressure reducing valve 17 and the secondary superheater bypass valve 25 provided on the outlet side of the primary superheater 13 are all closed. As already mentioned.

このボイラ起動時において、水と蒸気を含む流体が一次過熱器バイパス系統Aを循環する間は、ケージ壁12からの流体は一次過熱器13には流れないため一次過熱器13での流体の圧力損失はないので、一次過熱器出口圧力計35での圧力値は、一次過熱器13の入口の圧力を検出していることにもなる。   At the time of this boiler start-up, while the fluid containing water and steam circulates through the primary superheater bypass system A, the fluid from the cage wall 12 does not flow to the primary superheater 13, so the fluid pressure in the primary superheater 13 Since there is no loss, the pressure value at the primary superheater outlet pressure gauge 35 also detects the pressure at the inlet of the primary superheater 13.

従って、一次過熱器バイパス系統Aの圧力損失、正確には一次過熱器バイパス弁23の上流側までの圧力損失は、前記一次過熱器バイパス弁入口圧力計36と一次過熱器出口圧力計35を検出し、前記一次過熱器出口圧力計35と一次過熱器バイパス弁入口圧力計36の差圧を計算することで分かる。   Therefore, the pressure loss of the primary superheater bypass system A, more precisely the pressure loss up to the upstream side of the primary superheater bypass valve 23, is detected by the primary superheater bypass valve inlet pressure gauge 36 and the primary superheater outlet pressure gauge 35. It can be understood by calculating the differential pressure between the primary superheater outlet pressure gauge 35 and the primary superheater bypass valve inlet pressure gauge 36.

なお、レジスタチューブ22の管内での圧力損失を検知する方法として、前記したように一次過熱器出口圧力計35と一次過熱器バイパス弁入口圧力計36との差圧を計算する方法の他に、前記一次過熱器出口圧力計35に代えて、節炭器10の入口に設けられている圧力計42を使用してもよい。ただし、この場合は、節炭器10、水冷壁11及びケージ壁12での所定の圧力損失を把握しておく必要がある。   In addition, as a method of detecting the pressure loss in the pipe of the register tube 22, as described above, in addition to the method of calculating the differential pressure between the primary superheater outlet pressure gauge 35 and the primary superheater bypass valve inlet pressure gauge 36, Instead of the primary superheater outlet pressure gauge 35, a pressure gauge 42 provided at the inlet of the economizer 10 may be used. However, in this case, it is necessary to grasp the predetermined pressure loss in the economizer 10, the water cooling wall 11, and the cage wall 12.

一次過熱器バイパス系統Aの圧力損失の増加原因となるレジスタチューブ22を特定できればそれだけを交換することが良いが、一次過熱器バイパス系統A内には圧力損失が上昇する原因箇所としてはレジスタチューブ22の他に一次過熱器バイパス弁23がある。一次過熱器バイパス弁23が損傷することにより圧力損失が上昇することが考えられる。   If the register tube 22 that causes an increase in pressure loss in the primary superheater bypass system A can be identified, it is preferable to replace it. However, the cause of the pressure loss increase in the primary superheater bypass system A is the register tube 22. In addition, there is a primary superheater bypass valve 23. It is conceivable that the pressure loss increases due to damage to the primary superheater bypass valve 23.

したがって、一次過熱器バイパス弁23での圧力損失の増加を検出するために、本実施例では新たに設けた前記一次過熱器バイパス弁入口圧力計36と下流側のフラッシュタンク圧力計37との差圧により検知することができる。もちろん前記フラッシュタンク圧力計37とは別に一次過熱器バイパス弁23の出口側に新たに圧力計(図示せず)を設け、それと一次過熱器バイパス弁入口圧力計36の差圧を計算しても良い。   Therefore, in order to detect an increase in pressure loss in the primary superheater bypass valve 23, in this embodiment, a difference between the newly provided primary superheater bypass valve inlet pressure gauge 36 and the downstream flash tank pressure gauge 37 is used. It can be detected by pressure. Of course, a pressure gauge (not shown) is newly provided on the outlet side of the primary superheater bypass valve 23 separately from the flash tank pressure gauge 37, and the pressure difference between the pressure gauge and the primary superheater bypass valve inlet pressure gauge 36 is calculated. good.

また、通常は、数日〜数ヶ月のボイラ運転中に前記差圧の上昇があると、その都度、前記したようにどこかの弁を開いて対応していくが、その弁を開閉するだけでは前記差圧の解消ができなくなると、レジスタチューブ22の酸洗いか又は取り替え又は一次過熱器バイパス弁23の取り替えを行う。従ってレジスタチューブ22の酸洗い時期又は取り替え時期又は一次過熱器バイパス弁23の取り替え時期を判断する前記差圧の程度はプラント毎に適宜設定する。   Also, normally, when there is an increase in the differential pressure during the operation of the boiler for several days to several months, each time, the valve is opened as described above, but only the valve is opened and closed. If the pressure difference cannot be eliminated, the resistor tube 22 is pickled or replaced or the primary superheater bypass valve 23 is replaced. Therefore, the degree of the differential pressure for determining the pickling time or replacement time of the register tube 22 or the replacement time of the primary superheater bypass valve 23 is appropriately set for each plant.

また、前記差圧のデータを日々採取しておくことで(1)一次過熱器出口圧力計35と一次過熱器バイパス弁入口圧力計36との差圧及び/又は(2)一次過熱器バイパス弁入口圧力計36とフラッシュタンク圧力計37との差圧の上昇度合いが分かるので、次回のボイラの定期検査時期(定期検査は2週間程度に亘り行われる)の間に前記バイパス系統Aの配管を切り離して、酸洗いや取り替えを行う。   Further, by collecting the data of the differential pressure every day, (1) the differential pressure between the primary superheater outlet pressure gauge 35 and the primary superheater bypass valve inlet pressure gauge 36 and / or (2) the primary superheater bypass valve. Since the degree of increase in the differential pressure between the inlet pressure gauge 36 and the flash tank pressure gauge 37 can be known, the piping of the bypass system A is connected during the next periodic inspection period of the boiler (the periodic inspection is performed for about two weeks). Separate and pickle or replace.

また、一次過熱器バイパス系統Aは、元来、その設置目的が火炉出口(図1ではケージ壁12出口)からの蒸気条件が一次過熱器13に供給できるようになるまでは火炉内に供給される流体を一次過熱器13の上流側で復水器(図示せず)側へバイパスさせて循環させることにあるので、一次過熱器バイパス系統Aに圧力計などの計器を設ける必要が無かった。そのため本実施例のように一次過熱器バイパス弁入口圧力計36を設置する必要がなかったが、図1に示す本実施例は図3に示す従来技術の一次過熱器バイパス系統Aに一次過熱器バイパス弁入口圧力計36を新たに設置しただけで、管内にスケールが付着して、その表面粗さが管内流体の流れに圧力損失として影響が出てくることを予測することができる効果がある。そのためにレジスタチューブ22の内部壁面及び/又は一次過熱器バイパス弁23の圧力損失を正確に測定することができるようになった。   In addition, the primary superheater bypass system A is originally supplied into the furnace until the steam condition from the furnace outlet (cage wall 12 outlet in FIG. 1) can be supplied to the primary superheater 13. Therefore, there is no need to provide an instrument such as a pressure gauge in the primary superheater bypass system A because the fluid to be circulated is bypassed to the condenser (not shown) side upstream of the primary superheater 13. Therefore, it is not necessary to install the primary superheater bypass valve inlet pressure gauge 36 as in the present embodiment. However, in the present embodiment shown in FIG. 1, the primary superheater is added to the primary superheater bypass system A shown in FIG. By simply installing the bypass valve inlet pressure gauge 36, it is possible to predict that the scale adheres to the inside of the pipe and the surface roughness affects the flow of the pipe fluid as pressure loss. . Therefore, the pressure loss of the inner wall surface of the register tube 22 and / or the primary superheater bypass valve 23 can be accurately measured.

また、レジスタチューブ22の少なくとも1本を定期的に抜管し、その内部表面粗さを計測し、前回の内部表面粗さの計測値と比較して、その偏差が所定値(使用する水により適宜決定する)より小さい場合には、次のレジスタチューブ22の交換時期を予測し、また前記偏差が前記所定値より大きい場合には、直ちに交換又は洗浄を行い、新規又は洗浄後のレジスタチューブ22を元通りに戻しても良い。   In addition, at least one of the register tubes 22 is periodically withdrawn, its internal surface roughness is measured, and compared with the previous measurement value of the internal surface roughness, the deviation is a predetermined value (depending on the water used). If the deviation is larger than the predetermined value, replacement or cleaning is performed immediately, and a new or cleaned register tube 22 is replaced. You may return it to its original state.

また、圧力計35の蒸気圧力の測定値と圧力計43による二次過熱器18の出口蒸気配管19内の蒸気圧力の測定値の偏差に基づき二次過熱器バイパス弁24の洗浄時期または取り替え時期を予測することができる。同様に図示していないが二次過熱器18以上の高次過熱器の入口と出口の蒸気配管内の圧力偏差に基づき二次過熱器18以上の高次過熱器バイパス弁(図示せず)の洗浄時期または取り替え時期を予測することもできる。   Further, based on the deviation between the measured value of the steam pressure of the pressure gauge 35 and the measured value of the steam pressure in the outlet steam pipe 19 of the secondary superheater 18 by the pressure gauge 43, the cleaning time or replacement time of the secondary superheater bypass valve 24 Can be predicted. Similarly, although not shown, a high-order superheater bypass valve (not shown) of the secondary superheater 18 or higher is based on the pressure deviation in the steam piping at the inlet and outlet of the high-order superheater of the secondary superheater 18 or higher. It is also possible to predict the cleaning time or replacement time.

本発明は定圧貫流ボイラの起動時のバイパス系統の後進、洗浄時期を予測できるので、ボイラ運転性能が従来より格段によくなったので、定圧貫流ボイラの実機に適用して多大な効果を上げることができる。   Since the present invention can predict the reverse and cleaning time of the bypass system at the start of the constant pressure once-through boiler, the boiler operation performance has improved significantly compared to the conventional one, so that it can be applied to the actual machine of the constant pressure once-through boiler to achieve a great effect. Can do.

本発明の一実施例の定圧貫流ボイラの起動バイパス系統図である。It is a starting bypass system diagram of the constant pressure once-through boiler of one example of the present invention. 図1の起動バイパス系統を備えたボイラの特定のボイラの運転経歴(運転時間経過)に対するレジスタチューブの圧力損失の変化を示すグラフ(図2(a))、特定のボイラの運転経歴(運転時間経過)に対するレジスタチューブの平均表面粗さを示すグラフ(図2(b))、火力発電用のボイラの起動・停止回数と運転経歴との関係を示すグラフ(図2(c))、火力発電用のボイラの起動弁の実開度と起動弁の計算開度との関係から弁の異常と正常を判定するためのグラフ(図2(d))である。The graph (FIG. 2 (a)) which shows the change of the pressure loss of a register tube with respect to the operating history (operating time progress) of the specific boiler of the boiler provided with the starting bypass system of FIG. 1, the operating history (operating time of the specific boiler) Graph showing the average surface roughness of the register tube with respect to the progress) (FIG. 2B), a graph showing the relationship between the number of start / stop of the thermal power generation boiler and the operation history (FIG. 2C), thermal power generation It is a graph (Drawing 2 (d)) for judging abnormalities and normality of a valve from the relation between the actual opening of a starting valve of a boiler, and the calculation opening of a starting valve. 従来の定圧貫流ボイラの起動バイパス装置を示す系統図である。It is a systematic diagram which shows the starting bypass apparatus of the conventional constant pressure once-through boiler.

符号の説明Explanation of symbols

1 脱気器 2 モータ駆動給水ポンプ
3 タービン駆動給水ポンプ 4 給水流量調節弁
5 ポンプ出口止弁 6 ポンプ出口止弁
7 給水配管 8 給水流量計
9 高圧ヒータ 10 節炭器
11 水冷壁 12 ケージ壁
13 一次過熱器 14 一次・二次過熱器連絡管
15 過熱器止弁 16 過熱器止弁バイパス配管
17 過熱器減圧弁 18 二次過熱器
19 出口蒸気配管 20 一次過熱器バイパス配管
21 レジスタチューブバイパス弁
22 レジスタチューブ
23 一次過熱器バイパス弁
24 二次過熱器バイパス配管
25 二次過熱器バイパス弁
26 フラッシュタンク
27 二次過熱器ウォーミング配管
28 二次過熱器ウォーミング弁
29 脱気器供給復水配管
30 脱気器レベル調節弁
31 復水器供給復水配管
32 フラッシュタンクレベル調節弁
33 一次過熱器入口温度計
34 一次過熱器出口温度計
35 一次過熱器出口圧力計
36 一次過熱器バイパス弁入口圧力計
37 フラッシュタンク圧力計
38 制御装置 39 監視装置
40 CRT 42 節炭器入口圧力計
43 二次過熱器出口圧力計 100 ボイラ
DESCRIPTION OF SYMBOLS 1 Deaerator 2 Motor drive feed pump 3 Turbine drive feed pump 4 Feed water flow control valve 5 Pump exit stop valve 6 Pump exit stop valve 7 Feed pipe 8 Feed water flow meter 9 High-pressure heater 10 Eco-restrictor 11 Water cooling wall 12 Cage wall 13 Primary superheater 14 Primary / secondary superheater communication pipe 15 Superheater stop valve 16 Superheater stop valve bypass pipe 17 Superheater pressure reducing valve 18 Secondary superheater 19 Outlet steam pipe 20 Primary superheater bypass pipe 21 Register tube bypass valve 22 Register tube 23 Primary superheater bypass valve 24 Secondary superheater bypass pipe 25 Secondary superheater bypass valve 26 Flash tank 27 Secondary superheater warming pipe 28 Secondary superheater warming valve 29 Deaerator supply condensate pipe 30 Deaerator level control valve 31 Condenser supply condensate piping 32 Flash tank level control valve 33 Primary superheater inlet Thermometer 34 Primary superheater outlet thermometer 35 Primary superheater outlet pressure gauge 36 Primary superheater bypass valve inlet pressure gauge 37 Flash tank pressure gauge 38 Control device 39 Monitoring device 40 CRT 42 Eco-restrictor inlet pressure gauge 43 Secondary superheater Outlet pressure gauge 100 Boiler

Claims (3)

内部を水又は蒸気が流れる伝熱管パネルからなり、ボイラ火炉の周壁を構成する水冷壁と、
内部を水又は蒸気が流れる伝熱管パネルからなり、ボイラ火炉での燃料の燃焼により生成した燃焼ガスが火炉の下流側に配置される煙突に向かって排出される流路である煙道の周壁を構成するゲージ壁と、
内部を過熱蒸気が流れる伝熱管からなり、前記煙道内に設けられる一次過熱器と、
内部を過熱蒸気が流れる伝熱管からなり、前記一次過熱器の下流側の煙道内に設けられる少なくとも二次過熱器を含む高次過熱器と、
内部を水が流通する伝熱管パネルからなり、前記二次過熱器を含む高次過熱器の下流側の煙道内に設けられる節炭器と
を有する定圧貫流ボイラと、
該貫流ボイラで得られた蒸気を負荷対象で使用した後に復水する復水器と、該復水器からの給水を前記節炭器、水冷壁、ゲージ壁に順次供給した後、前記一次過熱器入口から復水器にバイパスさせる一次過熱器バイパス系統と、
前記一次過熱器の出口からの過熱蒸気を二次過熱器の入口から復水器にバイパスさせる二次過熱器バイパス系統を含む高次過熱器バイパス系統とを備えた定圧貫流ボイラ構成において、
前記一次過熱器バイパス系統は、上流側からレジスタチューブとそのバイパス弁と一次過熱器バイパス弁を備え、節炭器入口又は一次過熱器出口の配管内の圧力を測定する圧力計と、前記レジスタチューブと一次過熱器バイパス弁の間の配管内の圧力を測定する圧力計と、一次過熱器バイパス弁の出口の配管内の圧力を測定する圧力計と、さらに二次過熱器以上の高次過熱器の出口と入口の配管内の圧力をそれぞれ測定する圧力計を設けたことを特徴とする定圧貫流ボイラ構成。
It consists of a heat transfer tube panel through which water or steam flows, and a water cooling wall that constitutes the peripheral wall of the boiler furnace,
It consists of a heat transfer tube panel through which water or steam flows, and the flue wall that is the flow path through which the combustion gas generated by the combustion of fuel in the boiler furnace is discharged toward the chimney located downstream of the furnace A gauge wall that constitutes,
Consisting of a heat transfer tube through which superheated steam flows, a primary superheater provided in the flue,
A high-order superheater comprising a heat transfer tube through which superheated steam flows, and including at least a secondary superheater provided in a flue downstream of the primary superheater;
A constant-pressure once-through boiler comprising a heat transfer tube panel through which water flows, and having a economizer provided in a flue downstream of a high-order superheater including the secondary superheater;
A condenser that condenses the steam obtained in the once-through boiler after being used as a load target, and water supplied from the condenser is sequentially supplied to the economizer, water cooling wall, and gauge wall, and then the primary overheating. A primary superheater bypass system that bypasses the condenser inlet to the condenser;
In a constant pressure once-through boiler configuration comprising a high-order superheater bypass system including a secondary superheater bypass system for bypassing superheated steam from the outlet of the primary superheater to the condenser from the inlet of the secondary superheater,
The primary superheater bypass system includes a register tube, its bypass valve and a primary superheater bypass valve from the upstream side, a pressure gauge for measuring the pressure in the pipe of the economizer inlet or the primary superheater outlet, and the register tube A pressure gauge that measures the pressure in the piping between the primary superheater bypass valve, a pressure gauge that measures the pressure in the piping at the outlet of the primary superheater bypass valve, and a higher superheater that is higher than the secondary superheater A constant pressure once-through boiler configuration characterized in that pressure gauges for measuring the pressure in the outlet and inlet pipes are provided.
請求項1記載の定圧貫流ボイラ構成の運用方法であって、
(a)前記節炭器入口又は一次過熱器出口の圧力計と前記レジスタチューブと一次過熱器バイパス弁の間の圧力計とで測定した各配管内圧力の偏差又は
(b)前記レジスタチューブと一次過熱器バイパス弁の間の圧力計と前記一次過熱器バイパス弁の出口の圧力計とで測定した各配管内圧力の偏差
に基づきレジスタチューブの洗浄時期または取り替え時期又は一次過熱器バイパス弁の洗浄時期または取り替え時期を予測することを特徴とする定圧貫流ボイラ構成の運用方法。
An operation method of the constant pressure once-through boiler configuration according to claim 1,
(A) Deviation of pressure in each pipe measured by the pressure gauge at the economizer inlet or the primary superheater outlet and the pressure gauge between the resistor tube and the primary superheater bypass valve, or (b) the resistor tube and the primary The cleaning time or replacement time of the register tube or the cleaning time of the primary superheater bypass valve based on the deviation of the pressure in each pipe measured by the pressure gauge between the superheater bypass valve and the pressure gauge at the outlet of the primary superheater bypass valve Or the operation method of the constant pressure once-through boiler structure characterized by predicting replacement time.
請求項1記載の定圧貫流ボイラ構成の運用方法であって、
前記二次過熱器以上の高次過熱器の入口と出口の蒸気が流通する配管内の圧力をそれぞれ測定する圧力計で測定した各配管内圧力の偏差に基づき前記二次過熱器以上の高次過熱器バイパス弁の洗浄時期または取り替え時期を予測することを特徴とする定圧貫流ボイラ構成の運用方法。
An operation method of the constant pressure once-through boiler configuration according to claim 1,
The higher order higher than the secondary superheater based on the deviation of the pressure in each pipe measured by a pressure gauge that measures the pressure in the pipe through which the steam at the inlet and outlet of the higher superheater higher than the secondary superheater flows. A method for operating a constant pressure once-through boiler configuration, wherein the cleaning time or replacement time of a superheater bypass valve is predicted.
JP2006211333A 2006-08-02 2006-08-02 Structure of constant pressure once-through boiler and operating method therefor Pending JP2008039224A (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
JP2006211333A JP2008039224A (en) 2006-08-02 2006-08-02 Structure of constant pressure once-through boiler and operating method therefor

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
JP2006211333A JP2008039224A (en) 2006-08-02 2006-08-02 Structure of constant pressure once-through boiler and operating method therefor

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
JP2008039224A true JP2008039224A (en) 2008-02-21

Family

ID=39174444

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
JP2006211333A Pending JP2008039224A (en) 2006-08-02 2006-08-02 Structure of constant pressure once-through boiler and operating method therefor

Country Status (1)

Country Link
JP (1) JP2008039224A (en)

Cited By (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
KR101217835B1 (en) 2011-08-31 2013-01-02 한국남부발전 주식회사 Boiler safety apparatus of steam power plant
JP2013032907A (en) * 2012-11-12 2013-02-14 Chugoku Electric Power Co Inc:The Method of operating start bypass system in steam power generation facility
JP2021188859A (en) * 2020-06-03 2021-12-13 三菱重工環境・化学エンジニアリング株式会社 Boiler pipe group adhesion ash removal system
CN114321874A (en) * 2022-01-05 2022-04-12 国家能源集团国源电力有限公司 Boiler starting system

Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
JPS5549604A (en) * 1978-10-06 1980-04-10 Hitachi Ltd Method of controlling to stop pressure change of onceethrough boiler
JPS63275876A (en) * 1987-05-06 1988-11-14 Yamatake Honeywell Co Ltd Abnormality detector for regulation valve
JPH0694160A (en) * 1992-09-14 1994-04-05 Ishikawajima Harima Heavy Ind Co Ltd Diagnosing device for regulating valve

Patent Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
JPS5549604A (en) * 1978-10-06 1980-04-10 Hitachi Ltd Method of controlling to stop pressure change of onceethrough boiler
JPS63275876A (en) * 1987-05-06 1988-11-14 Yamatake Honeywell Co Ltd Abnormality detector for regulation valve
JPH0694160A (en) * 1992-09-14 1994-04-05 Ishikawajima Harima Heavy Ind Co Ltd Diagnosing device for regulating valve

Cited By (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
KR101217835B1 (en) 2011-08-31 2013-01-02 한국남부발전 주식회사 Boiler safety apparatus of steam power plant
JP2013032907A (en) * 2012-11-12 2013-02-14 Chugoku Electric Power Co Inc:The Method of operating start bypass system in steam power generation facility
JP2021188859A (en) * 2020-06-03 2021-12-13 三菱重工環境・化学エンジニアリング株式会社 Boiler pipe group adhesion ash removal system
CN114321874A (en) * 2022-01-05 2022-04-12 国家能源集团国源电力有限公司 Boiler starting system

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
US7890214B2 (en) Method and apparatus for controlling soot blowing using statistical process control
CN101657765B (en) Method and apparatus for generalized performance evaluation of equipment using achievable performance derived from statistics and real-time data
US8140296B2 (en) Method and apparatus for generalized performance evaluation of equipment using achievable performance derived from statistics and real-time data
JPH04217786A (en) Method and device for controlling condenser for power plant
JP7225025B2 (en) Corrosion control system, water treatment equipment and power plant, and corrosion control method and corrosion control program
US11371382B2 (en) Steam-using facility monitoring system
JP2008039224A (en) Structure of constant pressure once-through boiler and operating method therefor
JP4494817B2 (en) Operating method of supercritical pressure boiler
JPH1122909A (en) Heat exchanger thin tube leak detection method
JP5818337B1 (en) Steam monitoring system
JP2014159914A (en) Make-up water system control device and make-up water system control method
JP4347193B2 (en) Method and apparatus for predicting scale behavior of plant
JP7802491B2 (en) Heat transfer surface evaluation device, control device, heat transfer surface evaluation method, and heat transfer surface management method
Tomarov et al. Extending the erosion-corrosion service life of the tube system of heat-recovery boilers used as part of combined-cycle plants
AU2021387203B2 (en) Abnormality detection device and abnormality detection method
JP2010091221A (en) Device and method for detecting breakage of tube in gas heater
JP7380309B2 (en) Boiler chemical cleaning method
JP2010091221A5 (en)
KR20180119373A (en) Apparatus for preventing corrosion of power generation facility
Decoussemaeker et al. Review of HRSG capabilities for flexible operation
JP2006234736A (en) Evaluation method of scale adhesion

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
A621 Written request for application examination

Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: A621

Effective date: 20090707

A977 Report on retrieval

Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: A971007

Effective date: 20111114

A131 Notification of reasons for refusal

Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: A131

Effective date: 20111122

A02 Decision of refusal

Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: A02

Effective date: 20120403