Happy Birthday, Gemini

This play had significant personal meaning for me in the early 80s and I only recently found a copy of this film adaptation. Like many stage comedies, the translation to film falls flat in most scenes partly due to the absence of theatrical elements (including the audience) but the biggest problem with this version is the casting. With ethnicity at the core of much of the humor, it was less than convincing to have Rita Moreno as an Italian widow, Madeline Kahn as an Irish floozy, and other characters trying to "play" an ethnicity that was not natural for them. But I really liked the ending on this filmed version, and the scene between Francis and his father at the end was very real and touching making this a nice "coming out" film for the whole family.

Happy Birthday Gemini is a seriously flawed screenplay based on a respected stage play.

Madeline Kahn proved me wrong. I've always believed she could do ANYTHING and I would love her in it. Here, her Bunny Weinberger is so one-dimensional, vulgar and loud it's nearly drowns out completely the rest of an almost gentle madcap comedy and she almost single handedly sinks the entire proceedings. Kahn plays what could have been a complex portrayal as a one note song pushing the contours of the film out of shape, as though she's playing the Tuba in a string quartet. With little differentiation between moments played as bombed out of her mind or just out of her mind it's difficult to find one's way to Bunny. But, Kahn being Kahn, there are moments where she can't help but sparkle, e.g., her scene where she describes her faded youth and the current color and state of her hair "hepatitis." I couldn't help but think of the Recognition Scene from Strauss's opera "Elektra" this scene, one of the scripts most poignant, with Robert Viharo, played out.

Oddly, while the adult roles in this screen adaptation all have an over-the-top wildness, pronouncing their lines with a stage-like manner, the kids - Alan Rosenberg, Sarah Holcomb and David Marshall Grant - are absolutely wonderful. Each member of this trio captures perfectly the balance between naivete of youth, budding pretentiousness of the know-it-all college students, and the self doubt and fears of young adulthood, and awareness of budding sexuality.

While some scenes feel false there are enough moments that ring with a tenderness belying and overcoming the overwacky comic proceedings. These moments add nuance, balance and order. A terribly flawed, at times very funny and ultimately touching movie.

This film was funny and touching at times. I thought the actors and actresses captured the essence of the ethnic characters they were portraying and the social condition they were living in very well. It captured the difficulty that many people face when opening up and talking about really personal emotions because there is that fear that the other person will change how they feel about you. It showed that beneath the shallow appearance of everyday life, deeper themes are at work. In a way, this film is in the early stages of a trend that picked up pace dramatically through the 1990s and so one can look back on it as one of the precursor "coming out" films that undoubtedly inspired some people in a positive way.

Dull, self-obsessed people voice their self-obsession in this movie version of Albert Innaurato's Off-Broadway hit. The cast, including Madeline Kahn, and Rita Moreno try to make up for their inherent slovenliness by loudness.

If you were to make a burlesque of what people imagine to be an Off-Broadway play, you couldn't do better than this, with its annoying ethnic portrayals, and Alan Rosenberg's uncertainty about his sexual identity, as he announces to his girlfriend, Sarah Holcomb, that he's gay. When I write "you couldn't do better", in many ways I mean you couldn't do worse, as Miss Kahn swans around in the world's largest beehive hairdo.

These are just the sort of characters and situations that Neil Simon could and did make interesting and funny. I suspect that the people involved in this movie thought they were doing that, but they didn't.

Judith and Randy Hastings are siblings headed to South Philadelphia for Francis Geminiani's 21st birthday. Judith has a crush on Francis. Only he reveals that he thinks he's gay.

It's an indie comedy based on a play. Lead actress Sarah Holcomb had a short 4-movie career with two of the greatest comedies ever. This is not one of those iconic movies. This is a low budget indie. The story is a bit scattered. There are big names here. They are the reasons for my interest, but they can't save this. Madeline Kahn is going all out. The second half is basically her movie. It's hard to wrap my arms around all these characters. I just don't care about some of these people.