Fausses notes

By 1939, movie audiences were well acquainted with Dick Powell's singing talents. The absence of Powell's crooning in "Naughty But Nice" (NBN) probably wasn't a disappointment to movie-goers, and they were likely amused by his performance, which was against type. Theater audiences in 1939 wouldn't have expected Powell's character, uptight college professor and composer Donald Hardwick, to put in a singing performance in this film.

Don't miss the scene early in NBN that takes place in the dining room of the Hardwick home, as Donald's aunts reveal why they haven't spoken with their sister in years. Listen closely to the dialogue as they reveal the story of the brash musician she married, his instrument of choice, his nickname, and the title of the last song he performed before his untimely death. That dialogue had to have spawned at least a few laughs in theaters in 1939.

I don't place comments on most of the movies I watch (and I am a major film buff, particularly the classics of the late 30's, 40's and 50's, but I felt it necessary here as most of the comments are based on viewers with a Dick Powell focus. Powell's heyday was a little prior the timeframe of my expertise so I am not commenting upon those comments, however, Ann Sheridan is one of the most underrated actresses in film and she is outstanding in this, not to mention gorgeous. The movie is more entertaining than Powell's fans have let on with the final third of the movie quite entertaining for anyone. The increasing frustration of Powell's collegiate colleagues culminating in breaking a tree limb is well done. The scene prior to the court trial with Sheridan slapping everyone repeatedly in the producer's office is outstanding and a "must see" for film fans.

Oh MY.... so many fun names in this. Ann Sheridan could play big parts, small parts, and do it well. check her out in Man Who Came to Dinner. Dick Powell, started out as a singer, did some singing/actor roles, then more serious film roles without the singing. the awesome sidekick Grady Sutton. Ronald Reagan, actor, governor, president! Helen Broderick, the amazing wisecracker in so many Fred Astaire films. Allen Jenkins and Jerry Colonna, always the co-stars. Vera Lewis. Don't forget the incredible Zasu Pitts... probably best known as the sweet, innocent girl who is about to get taken to the cleaners. WOW. the producers sure rounded up the cream of the crop! Zelda and Don (Sheridan and Powell) hit the charts with their new numbers, and the rest of the actors circle around with supporting roles. Colonna was a professional musician, so it was hard work for him to pretend to be awful. the story itself is rawtha silly, but it's great to see all these big names, who would go on to be even bigger. Sadly, Powell and Sheridan would both die quite young. Directed by Ray Enright. started with Mack Sennett in silents, on to the talkies! Catch this one, just for the various hollywood big wigs.

NAUGHTY BUT NICE (Warner Brothers, 1939), directed by Ray Enright, began production in the summer of 1938, and was withheld theatrical release for almost a year, and it's easy to see why. The finished product, unfortunately, is a disappointment. Dick Powell, whose long and successful career in musical films at Warners since 1933, has come to a rather tepid end. Taking second billing to Ann Sheridan, who was being groomed to stardom by the studio, Powell sings no major hit tunes, and is transformed from a baby-faced crooner to a mature but dull college professor of classical music who wears glasses and quite naive of the outside world, a role more suitable to the likes and comedy antics of possibly Eddie Cantor. Of the supporting players, Gale Page, whose movie career was short-lived, comes off best as the nice girl who guides the professor along.

As for the plot, Professor Donald Hardwick (Dick Powell) of Winfield College, comes to New York City on a mission of getting his symphonic composition published. While there, he stays with his maiden Aunt Martha (Helen Broderick) who manages a speakeasy. Donald then meets Linda McKay (Gale Page) and Ed Clarke (Ronald Reagan), who mistake Donald for a waiter. After becoming acquainted, Linda, a songwriter, takes Donald's classical compositions and changes it into swing music without his knowledge. Upon his return to Winfield, Donald learns of the radio air-date as to when his composition is to be played so he and his college dean (Halliwell Hobbes), along with Professor Trill (Edward McWade) can join in and listen. Donald gets the shock of his life when he finds his composition changed to a jive number retitled "Hooray for Spinach" as sung by vocalist Zelda Manion (Ann Sheridan). The disgrace finds Donald returning to New York to straighten out matters, only to be further tricked into having his compositions changed into top pop tunes that make it to Number One on the Hit Parade, which eventually leads to a courtroom case.

With music and lyrics by Harry Warren and Jerry Mercer, with acknowledgments to classical composers Richard Wagner, Johannes Sebastian Bach, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart and Franz Lizst, the songs featured include: "Remember Dad" (sung by Jerry Colonna and Allen Jenkins); "Hooray for Spinach" (sung by Ann Sheridan); "I'm Happy About the Whole Thing" (sung by Dick Powell and Gale Page); "In a Moment of Weakness" (sung by Gale Page); "Corn Pickin'" (sung by Ann Sheridan/ jitterbug dancing by patrons); and "I Don't Believe in Signs" (sung by Ann Sheridan). Only "Hooray for Spinach" would be a tune more to the liking of the famous cartoon character of Popeye.

Other than the use of six forgettable songs based on classical compositions, NAUGHTY BUT NICE finds Powell in numerous comedic situations, such as being served an alcoholic beverage instead of his usual lemonade which gets him so drunk that he shouts out, "YA-HOO," only to get photographed by news-hounds and picture being placed on the front page of every newspaper showing Donald swinging from a chandelier; Powell getting a "hot foot" (lighted matches stuck on his shoes) by Joe Dirke (Allen Jenkins), which causes the naive professor to take hold of his foot and jump up and down as he moans, causing the night club patrons to do the same, thus, the creation of a new type of dancing, a jitterbug number called "Corn Pickin'"; Donald getting vamped by Zelda; among others. But what is supposed to be hilarious comes off somewhat forced. This type of comedy is not Powell's style, but sure is the way of studio contract termination, this making NAUGHTY BUT NICE Powell's "swan song."

Then there is the droll Helen Broderick as Powell's more down-to-earth Aunt Martha, along with his other maiden aunts, Penelope Louisa Hardwick (Zasu Pitts), an accurate-on-information know-it-all; Annabella (Vera Lewis) and Henrietta (Elizabeth Dunne), as lovers of classical music. Maxie Rosenbloom, a former boxer, is also featured as Broderick's man-servant who answers doors, cooks cakes and cleans house; Grady Sutton as a college student; and William B. Davidson, billed as Bill Davidson in the closing credits, a familiar face in numerous Warner Brothers features, playing as a crooked song publisher.

NAUGHTY BUT NICE is a good idea gone sour, and at 90 minutes, looks more like an overlong "B" movie. The age of the thirties musicals is over, changing to the swing of things of the more prosperous forties. Warners would produce other musicals, but didn't hit its stride again until YANKEE DOODLE DANDY (1942) starring none-other than James Cagney. By then Powell had moved on to other studios such as Paramount, Universal and MGM before he successfully transformed into a serious actor in "film-noir" dramas beginning with MURDER, MY SWEET (RKO, 1944), and later director.

NAUGHTY BUT NICE can be seen during the late night hours on Turner Classic Movies. (**)

As a Dick Powell fan, the premise of this picture sounded great: a college music professor, despite his disapproval of "swing" music, ends up becoming the best-selling composer on the pop hit parade. The comic opportunities in this scenario, not to mention Powell's mellifluous singing voice, are needlessly squandered however--no doubt this movie disappointed Powell's fans back in '39 as much as it did this viewer in 2001.

The story promises great things and delivers on none of them:

Powell writes hit songs with a beautiful lyricist, but we never see them working together. Powell never even sings in this picture, despite 5 new songs by the same team (Johnny Mercer & Harry Warren) who gave us "You Must Have Been a Beautiful Baby" which Powell crooned to Olivia de Havilland in the previous year's "Hard to Get".

They don't even let Dick Powell BE Dick Powell: he plays a nerdy guy lacking in social grace and appeal--and two women vie for his attention. Granted, Powell plays a convincing, somewhat lovable "four-eyed" geek, but the plot keeps hinting that, with a few potent "lemonades", he's a dancing dynamo and the life of the party! But everytime he heads out to the dance floor to strut his stuff there's a fade out and we only find out what a blast he had the night before from an item in the newspaper.

What great fun it might have been if the college prof learned to sing, swing and love. But he stays a nerd, writes hit tunes reluctantly and ends up with the girl formulaically without a spark between them. [Sigh...]