Gentleman Jack

I have spent far to much time watching period pieces, Jane Austin theater and everything on PBS. FINALLY a heroine who doesn't simper, have her value judged in her ability to marry and produce kids, but who is funny and daring and very much alive.

The music is awesome and only enhances her sense of purpose to take life on her defined terms. Can't wait for the next episode.

Season 2: 8/10. Season 2: 5/10 Gentleman Jack is based on the diaries of Anne Lister, an upper-class lesbian whose mannish clothes and manner perplexed the locals. Season one follows her wooing of the pretty, high-strung Ann Walker as well as her attempts to get into the coal mining business.

With its mines and good and bad nobles and soap operish love story, GJ is reminiscent of Poldark. Both series have a likable but sometimes horribly flawed lead and a bunch of really nice scenery.

Anne Lister is a rather unusual hero because in some ways she's terrible. She admirably flouts societal conventions, but only when it suits her. She doesn't believe in the rules if she doesn't like them, but she's a huge fan of the rules that make her part of the gentry, and while she has sympathy for the lower classes she clearly doesn't feel they should have much in the way of human rights beyond those she gifts them. She is a non-intersectional lesbian, and at times it is hard to like her. But brilliantly played by Suranne Jones, it's equally hard not to be fascinated by her.

Season 1 was well worth watching, but then came season 2.

While the first season had driving momentum, the second season seemed to wander about in aimless confusion. The whole season was basically devoted to an estate division, and when there were lengthy discussions of dividing plots of land it felt like some sort of land surveyor fan service. Plot lines started up and then the writers seemed to just forget about them. The series continued with the parallel lower-class story but at a certain point it just sort of drizzled out and disappeared (not that it was too interesting this season anyway).

It did have its moments. It was interesting to see Ann Walker slowly come into her own, and the final 10 minutes of the final episode was genuinely satisfying, even if it followed the unconvincing, contrived end of the estate nonsense. But I'm honestly not sad at all that it's been cancelled.

Still, great first season.

HBO hit it out of the park with this. Stellar cast, stellar script & story based on the real Anne Lister who refused to be left behind in her time nor conform to what proper society thought a lady should be or do. Leaves one to wonder how many other brave women stepped up like she did, but didn't leave a diary behind or no one cared enough to save it for prosperitys sake, sadly. I'd hate to think she's the only one. Thank you HBO & BBC for bringing this to life. It's by far the best of period pieces we've had to choose from in a while...I applaude BBC for always getting behind great period pieces and HBO for supporting BBC this time round for bringing this wonderful series to fruition.

Gentleman Jack have a superb casting all over. However. Suranne Jones is in a league of her own, as always. Why she is not up there, among the great Hollywood stars, is probably because she is best known as a tv-actor. Put her in a drama next to anyone and Suranne will overshine anyone. Best actor ever!

I have started watching some other series from HBO that were not even worth the time spent for one episode never mind seven or eight ," Succession "comes to mind. It matters not one bit what the subject matter of a mini series is when the script , acting , art direction and especially the character development are spot on. I don't think you'll grow impatient watching this as is the case with so many TV pieces ; impatient for the next episode would be more like it. The movies Phantom Thread and The Favourite , period pieces both, were not even close to being 1/2 as good as this and probably with twice the budget and "A List " players. Vision and ideas make good movies ; it takes more than just money. Hats off to HBO/BBC for green lighting this and getting it made. Recommended period. I came back to add to my review. It's a beautiful love story rendered in a natural and believable way no matter the subjects' orientation. The story is so naturally told and well woven together perhaps because they had Anne Lister's diaries to work from. Don't miss it.