[go: up one dir, main page]

Tony's Reviews > Independent People

Independent People by Halldór Laxness
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
33771
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: icelandic

I kept waiting, waiting, for Bjartur Jonsson to break from his character. Not about his politics, which were entirely pragmatic. And not about his essential philosophy, that a man must be independent and reliant on no one. But surely to his family. Surely there would be one wife or a child that would turn his soul - when one has a flower. There were moments, or more precisely near-moments. And you could read into the text, I suppose, and believe that he actually had a moment when he loved a daughter or a son. But Bjartur spoke only in insults; and, given a choice between a family member or one of his sheep, well, can you say baaaaaa?

It would have been a lesser book, though, if he had ever warmed. Through two wives, more children than Laxness could count, some stillborn, but all dying in one way or another, Laxness assures us. Bjartur remains resolute in his beliefs. And so we learn about Iceland's winters, and her nascent politics. Life and government are reduced to their simplest terms. Hardscrabble, brutal. There are lessons learned:

-- Someone, somewhere, will benefit from a war.

-- Never forego a pre-paid trip to America because of some girl.

-- Sooner or later, all sheep get worms.

-- And this, from a deathbed:

"There are two things I want to ask you to remember when you've gone," she said, the wrinkled old face trembling much more than usual. "I want to ask you never to be insolent to those who hold a lowly position in the world. And never ill-treat any animal."

There are discourses within about politics, religion, and the nature of war. This is a land where people read about Noah and sniff, having experienced 200 days of steady rain without a flood. A land where the World War was the most bountiful blessing that God has sent our country.

There is plot here, too, but in one vignette after another. You get invested. Bjartur, don't kill the cow. Bjartur, don't kill the cow! Bjartur............!!!!

Bjartur, as I said, does not stray from character, even as you grip the seat and beg him to.

----- ----- ----- ----- -----

There is an old woman here, Bjartur's second mother-in-law. She is mostly bedridden, but as she asks for little, Bjartur is not overtly annoyed with her. She has her oracle moments, which I like in my female octogenarians. In Bjartur's hovel, with diminishing children, and a dog and a cat, she remains.

When the bitch had gone, the cat would spring down on the old woman's bed and, after washing himself with meticulous care, would lie down to sleep with his head across his hind legs. The old woman never called him anything but that scum of a cat or that brute of a tom, and yet he liked her best, for he valued not vocabulary but disposition. She had never been known to hurt any animal. It is strange what a great liking cats have for old people. They appreciate the lack of inventiveness, rich in security, which is the chief virtue of old age; or was it that they understood the grey in each other, that which lies behind Christianity and behind the soul?

Such a place.
46 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Independent People.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 18, 2014 – Started Reading
October 18, 2014 – Shelved
October 18, 2014 –
page 132
27.39%
October 20, 2014 –
page 274
56.85%
October 21, 2014 –
page 373
77.39% "---this war began with the shooting of a scruffy little foreigner, a chap called Ferdinand or something, and the death of this Ferdinand was taken so much to heart by various ill-disposed citizens that they kept on hacking one another to pieces like suet in a trough, for four consecutive years and more."
October 22, 2014 –
page 445
92.32% "When one is unmarried, one must tell people to shut up in a roundabout fashion."
October 23, 2014 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-6 of 6 (6 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Fionnuala (last edited 24 oct. 2014 09:19) (new) - added it

Fionnuala 8.45am. Mutton broth for breakfast?
Perhaps not ideal morning fare but I'll take it.
In fact I would stand in rain to read about this book, it left such an impression on me. So the original and entertaining revisit you've offered us here, Tony is a real treat. You've caught Bjartur perfectly, the absolutely out-and-out frustrating aspects of him and, yes, the heroic aspects too. Not that the world really need heroes like Bjartur.
And that line, when one has a flower...


message 2: by Tony (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tony Better lamb broth than fish refuse. What is that, anyway?


message 3: by Karen· (new)

Karen· Fish refuse what?

Oh, fish REFuse. The bits we would throw out, presumably, the head and the guts? Gulls love it.


message 4: by Ted (new) - added it

Ted Thanks for the review Tony. I hope I get to this book. It sits in my living room in a small turntable bookshelf, between 's Nachts komen de vossen (The Foxes Come at Night) and The Long Ships.


message 5: by Michael (new) - added it

Michael Very entertaining. Your quotes sure help make the sale.


message 6: by Tony (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tony Barbara Lemon wrote: "Great review! This novel is unique and beautifully written. I truly hated Bjartur when he killed the calf! But, the beauty of the writing is nearly hypnotic in some places."

Thank you, Barbara. I still have good memories of this book.


back to top