[go: up one dir, main page]

Adina ( back from Vacay…slowly recovering) 's Reviews > The Woman in White

The Woman in White by Wilkie Collins
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
22189348
Too bloody long and overwritten. It sort of took away the tension and mystery.

I've wanted to read this for a long time, ever since I've ofunds out that Fingersmith by Sarah Waters was inspired by this novel. I can see the resemblance but they are different in many aspects.

The Woman in White is a serialised novel, which means it appeared first in many numbers of a literary magazine. The one owned by Charles Dickens, to be precise. The aim was to fill as many editions as possible so most of these novels tend to be on the longer side. Great Expectations is another example of these books but I loved that one. I lost my patience here, probably because it is written as a series of testimonials from different people. I saw this tactic used in many classics, with more or less successful results. This should have been a good one but I admit I got bored midway through.

Walter Hartright is employed as a drawing master to the beautiful Laura Fairlie. On the road to his employer he meets a mysterious Woman in White. He helps her get a cab and then continues on his way. There he falls in love with Laura, who is promised to Sir Percival Glyde. When Laura and her sister got to live in Glyde's estate, things become very dire and strange for the two women. Wilkie Collins is said to be the first author to combine Gothic horror with psychological realism. I thought the plot to be very well woven, and it would have gotten 5* from me ,were it 150 pages shorter. The way the author wrote a phrase tired me many time, I have to admit. It made me think of those houses that have too many ornaments.

248 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Woman in White.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 23, 2014 – Shelved as: to-read
September 23, 2014 – Shelved
October 10, 2014 – Shelved as: classics
October 10, 2014 – Shelved as: mystery
March 27, 2015 – Shelved as: british
September 20, 2017 – Shelved as: historical-mystery
January 30, 2018 – Shelved as: 1001
October 26, 2023 – Started Reading
October 26, 2023 – Shelved as: w-mwl-alternative
December 2, 2023 –
25.0%
December 6, 2023 –
40.0%
January 6, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ken (new)

Ken I'm not sure, but isn't Wilkie Collins a Victorian? If so, "Too bloody long and overwritten" is not only to be expected but required! ;-)

Weirdly, I find many modern-day novels are also overwritten. It's as if the forgiving nature of the genre gives writers the green light on abusing the genre.


TXGAL1 Great review, Adina!😊


message 3: by Flo (new)

Flo I agree with you. I think I've read the first section. It was ok, but I couldn't continue something so long that was just ok.


message 4: by Ray (new)

Ray I didn't know that there was a link to fingersmiths. I have swerved this book for ever, your review confirms this was the right thing to do


message 5: by Lynn (new)

Lynn I love the way you do reviews, you are good at expressing the mood of the book. I always have a problem with overly wordy stories.


Doris Interesting what youall say.It all dépends upon your expectations of what you want from the novel well as your penchant for the written words Victorian like long and minute descriptions Go well with their world of stability and satisfaction....Nice review all the same


Betsy Found this book to be disappointing.


Adrian Buck I loved it. Could never quite believe that Walter Hartright was a reliable narrator. Spent half my time speculating on how he had murdered poor Sir Percy and substituted Anne Catherick for Laura in order to claim Limmeridge. Marion was obviously in on the scheme.


message 9: by Pisces51 (new)

Pisces51 Educational and entertaining review.


message 10: by Fantasy boy (new)

Fantasy boy There is a classic book called The Woman in Black. Have you read it?
The Woman in White seems a chunky book for me😂 I may not read it.


message 11: by Fran (new)

Fran Hawthorne Adina, thank you for telling me about this book. This is one of those classics that I often see mentioned--I vaguely knew it was a mystery, maybe from the late 1800s? -- but that was all I knew. Now I know more! Perhaps it would read better if I skimmed the repetitive parts...


message 12: by Daphna (new)

Daphna Totally agree with you. I didn't finish it. Something I learned in my wise old age: there are so many books to read and so little time. If I don't connect with a book, I let it go with no qualms. Others will love it


message 13: by Steve (new)

Steve Payne Fine review, Adina. I used to love reading Victorian mystery/horror/gothic novels when I was younger, but my patience is no longer there for the long passages which digress from the main story, or are simply longer than they need to be. Personally I think J. Sheridan LeFanu can be the more entertaining author; Uncle Silas, The Rose And The Key and Wylder's Hand are rich in atmosphere - though again longer than need be. As has been mentioned earlier in this thread, I'm increasingly finding many modern novels also too long and rambling. I think the problem is that writers are contracted to write novels of so many words long, and all too often the novel falls short of the contracted amount and are then either padded out in the middle, or have tacked on endings which stretch the book out until well after it has come to its natural conclusion...


Adina ( back from Vacay…slowly recovering) Ken wrote: "I'm not sure, but isn't Wilkie Collins a Victorian? If so, "Too bloody long and overwritten" is not only to be expected but required! ;-)

Weirdly, I find many modern-day novels are also overwritte..."
haha, yes he was. I do not know why it bothered me here but not elsewhere.


Adina ( back from Vacay…slowly recovering) TXGAL1 wrote: "Great review, Adina!😊" Thank you.


Adina ( back from Vacay…slowly recovering) Flo wrote: "I agree with you. I think I've read the first section. It was ok, but I couldn't continue something so long that was just ok." I know. That's my problem with big books. They have to be spectacular (to me) so i can accept their size.


Adina ( back from Vacay…slowly recovering) Ray wrote: "I didn't know that there was a link to fingersmiths. I have swerved this book for ever, your review confirms this was the right thing to do" yes, but it is a spoiler for Fingersmith so I am not saying what it is.


Adina ( back from Vacay…slowly recovering) Lynn wrote: "I love the way you do reviews, you are good at expressing the mood of the book. I always have a problem with overly wordy stories." Thank you, Lynn :)


Adina ( back from Vacay…slowly recovering) Doris wrote: "Interesting what youall say.It all dépends upon your expectations of what you want from the novel well as your penchant for the written words Victorian like long and minute descriptions Go well wit..." I was expecting it but it still was too much, at some point. I've read Victorian books before so i sort of knew the deal.


Adina ( back from Vacay…slowly recovering) Betsy wrote: "Found this book to be disappointing." It was not disappointing, I was just bored at some point.


Adina ( back from Vacay…slowly recovering) Adrian wrote: "I loved it. Could never quite believe that Walter Hartright was a reliable narrator. Spent half my time speculating on how he had murdered poor Sir Percy and substituted Anne Catherick for Laura in..." You imagination is at another level :))


Adina ( back from Vacay…slowly recovering) Pisces51 wrote: "Educational and entertaining review." Thank you.


Adina ( back from Vacay…slowly recovering) fantasy fiction wrote: "There is a classic book called The Woman in Black. Have you read it?
The Woman in White seems a chunky book for me😂 I may not read it."
I haven't read that one.


Adina ( back from Vacay…slowly recovering) Fran wrote: "Adina, thank you for telling me about this book. This is one of those classics that I often see mentioned--I vaguely knew it was a mystery, maybe from the late 1800s? -- but that was all I knew. No..." I did some skipping, that'a for sure.


Adina ( back from Vacay…slowly recovering) Daphna wrote: "Totally agree with you. I didn't finish it. Something I learned in my wise old age: there are so many books to read and so little time. If I don't connect with a book, I let it go with no qualms. O..." I do the same. I learned this lesson early, I hope. It depressed me to force finish a book i did not enjoy. I read this one because I liked most of it.


Adina ( back from Vacay…slowly recovering) Steve wrote: "Fine review, Adina. I used to love reading Victorian mystery/horror/gothic novels when I was younger, but my patience is no longer there for the long passages which digress from the main story, or ..." I agree with you. I started to appreciate shorter books. Many slog in the middle. i do not understand why I am being punished as a reader for contractual decisions.


back to top