[go: up one dir, main page]

Dolors's Reviews > Jayber Crow

Jayber Crow by Wendell Berry
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
18383778
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: read-in-2016, dost

Jayber Crow is an octogenarian barber who sits under the poplars that hedge in his cabin and stares at the reflections on the river water that is always running somewhere, with time floating in swirls of memories of a life fully lived and now suddenly gone, its light extinguished from within. And yet, this very same river erodes the hills and pastures that have crowned Jayber’s home since the beginning of times as if to remind him that everything changes so that the essential remains the same.

I know what you are thinking.
What can the chronicle of community life in rural Kentucky, the unfulfilled desires of a loner trying to make sense of his declining faith or the musings of a conservationist have to do with you, a modern reader? How can they add anything new? I am sure you have had your share of going over old times and that you are familiar with many authors that have addressed similar subjects.
I won’t lie to you, this book is about all that, but it is also much more.
In fact, this book is a lot of things. Not because Berry is ambitious in his vast scope, but because he remains faithful to his vision of the world.
This book is the beginning and the end, a moral voice and a confession, a ferocious criticism to technical progress or materialism that devaluates the human.
It is the definite love story that will make you weep as you’ve never done before, a hymn to friendship, a tribute to the land that breathes out the wisdom of past generations.
It is a spiritual journey towards the culmination of a life, insignificant for its achievements, but all-abiding for its ability to detect and spread beauty even after its fleeting time has ticked out.

It turns out that Jayber, our old barber, is a philosopher after all, and that his self-effacing first-person narration becomes an intimate meditation on the mysteries of existence and the retelling of his lifelong quest to overcome fear and anger and replace them with enduring love. He becomes a monk married to his ideals that takes the vote of chastity to balance out the unfairness that befalls on the wife he won’t ever have and transforms his barber shop into an unconventional church where the Coulters, the Penns, the Feltners, the Keiths and the Chantams congregate to have a haircut and to be listened to like nowhere else in town. Barbers are known to be good listeners and Jayber was born to be both.

Wendell Berry’s prose is a clear-sighted reflection of the reality his characters struggle against, sailing the turbulent waters of the quotidian. The reader gets to see them appear and recede in the dark hole of WWI and WWII, defeated by illness or consumed by their own delusions, but in spite of this constant flow of lives parading through the years, there is a strong sense of timelessness that is closely related to the physical space they inhabit.
It’s precisely in the perpetuity of the natural world, in the idea of a place that anchors aimless spirits where Jayber’s heartache finds a comforting quietude, a solace that quenches his chronic loneliness.
Heaven is right here.
Beneath the shade of double-trunked white oaks and the song of twittering birds. In silent conversation among good friends. In the dark soil that yields crops and swaying wheat. In that so much awaited smile that covers us with light. In the boat that goes with the tide to cross this river, where you will see Jayber wishing, waiting for you, sitting patiently on the other side.
103 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Jayber Crow.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 23, 2013 – Shelved
September 20, 2016 – Started Reading
September 20, 2016 –
page 121
33.33% ""It seemed to me that even if everything had been changed, I would have recognized it by the look of the sky.""
September 21, 2016 –
page 162
44.63% ""I saw that, for me, this country would always be populated with presences and absences, presences of absences, the living and the dead. The world as it is would always be a reminder of the world that was, and of the world that is to come.""
September 25, 2016 –
page 261
71.9% ""If you love somebody enough, and long enough, finally you must see yourself.""
September 28, 2016 –
page 363
100.0% ""And how many hours have I spent in watching the reflections on the water? When the air is still, then so is the surface of the river. Then it holds a perfectly silent image of the world that seems not to exist in this world.""
September 28, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 57 (57 new)


Deyanne I somehow missed that you are currently reading this book. Eager for your insights.


Dolors Deyanne wrote: "I somehow missed that you are currently reading this book. Eager for your insights."

I am relishing every second of it, Deyanne.


Deyanne I have a big smile on my face.


Cecily I've had Wendell Berry on my radar for ages, but as so often, your passionate, understated lyricism is hypnotically persuasive.

Being faithful to his vision of the world and stoically getting on with life, despite missing out on the love he really wants, and without significant outward success makes Jayber sound a little like Stoner.


message 5: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Sounds incredibly worthwhile! Thank you so much for introducing me to a new author - with a promise of quality!


message 6: by Raquel (new)

Raquel I didn't know this author either, thank you!


message 7: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Ah, Dolors, what a pleasure to read your earnest tribute to Jayber Crow this morning! As you so gracefully point out, this modest story is far far more significant than it at first appears. Wendell Berry found a great vehicle for his own philosophy in the unlikely shape of a retiring small-town barber.


message 8: by Gautam (new)

Gautam Thank you so much for introducing this new author through your brilliant review, Dolors!


Dolors Marita wrote: "Thank you for a beautiful review. Once again you tempt me to add yet another book..."

Thanks to you for reading,Marita. I hope you like this quiet chronicle if you ever decide to give it a go.


message 10: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Cecily wrote: "I've had Wendell Berry on my radar for ages, but as so often, your passionate, understated lyricism is hypnotically persuasive.

Being faithful to his vision of the world and stoically getting on ..."


Thanks Cecily. Jayber is much more selfless than Stoner, though. You get to know all the characters more than himself, because he puts his life at disposition of others in small gestures that give meaning to other people's failures. It's a compassionate, quiet story of a man who has nothing and gives much.


message 11: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Lisa wrote: "Sounds incredibly worthwhile! Thank you so much for introducing me to a new author - with a promise of quality!"

Hope you get to read Berry to compensate for Larson, Lisa! ;P


message 12: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Raquel wrote: "I didn't know this author either, thank you!"

You're welcome, Raquel. It was a discovery I am happy to have done thanks to my GR friends as well.


message 13: by Arah-Lynda (new) - added it

Arah-Lynda It always amazes me. The beauty and insight that can be found in the everyday. Everyday life, everyday man, everyday everything. A beautiful and touching review Dolors.


message 14: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Fionnuala wrote: "Ah, Dolors, what a pleasure to read your earnest tribute to Jayber Crow this morning! As you so gracefully point out, this modest story is far far more significant than it at first appears. Wendell..."

Indeed, Fionnuala. What a powerful character Berry created! How not to be moved by such compassion, such need to do good, to preserve the essence of things. I can't wait to read his poetry.
Berry reminds me of David James Duncan, glad to have a full list of new titles to read now that I've covered everything Duncan has written!


message 15: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Gautam wrote: "Thank you so much for introducing this new author through your brilliant review, Dolors!"

Thanks to you for reading and for your always supportive comments, Gautam.


message 16: by Wanda (new) - added it

Wanda Thank you, Dolors, for such a beautiful review. And, for yet another book to add to my TBR (though this one will not languish and be somehow "forgotten" as I am adding it to my Barnes & Noble wishlist from which books are purchased once every three months). Many Thanks!


Deyanne Your reviews are magnificent and this is no exception. You do justice to a marvelous read.


message 18: by Cheryl (new)

Cheryl This lyrical spin of character and landscape portrait is exquisite, Dolors. The way you write about Wendell Berry's description of the things that make us human, about the fear of losing the sweat and tears of the land, reminds me of Willa Cather's beautiful portraits. Sometimes it takes the simple, soulful stories of solitude to capture different forms of beauty.


message 19: by Henry (new)

Henry Avila Wonderful review, Dolors, must admit, never heard of this particular book. But it does looks quite interesting...


message 20: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Wanda wrote: "Thank you, Dolors, for such a beautiful review. And, for yet another book to add to my TBR (though this one will not languish and be somehow "forgotten" as I am adding it to my Barnes & Noble wishl..."

Truly honored that Jayber's book got to your to-buy list thanks to my musings, Wanda! This book touched a nerve, it's quiet, it's humble, it's moving and it's also a story of a very courageous man. Thanks for always making me feel valued and for your lush feedback, my friend.


message 21: by Dolors (last edited 27 nov. 2016 10:55) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Deyanne wrote: "Your reviews are magnificent and this is no exception. You do justice to a marvelous read."

Glad you think so, Deyanne, particularly of this book, which I know is close to your heart. Thank you.


message 22: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Cheryl wrote: "This lyrical spin of character and landscape portrait is exquisite, Dolors. The way you write about Wendell Berry's description of the things that make us human, about the fear of losing the sweat ..."

Good comparison, Cheryl. There is something of Cather's spirit certainly present in Berry's vision of the world, but Jayber embodies a different kind of stoicism than Cather's female characters. Jayber is a humble, compassionate man who threads his life without making noise, giving himself to the community without expecting anything in return.
Loneliness is not corroding when it's the path one chooses to live peacefully, without regret, without spite, without bitterness.
Much to learn from Jayber, Cheryl... thanks for reading and for teaching me some of Jayber's ideals through your marvellous reviews.


message 23: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Henry wrote: "Wonderful review, Dolors, must admit, never heard of this particular book. But it does looks quite interesting..."

Thanks, Henry! I had never heard of Berry either, but a GR friend introduced me to him. I now look forward to read his poetry...


message 24: by Anu (new) - added it

Anu Like many others on this thread, I hadn't heard of this writer either, but let me just say, your reviews are sheer poetry, Dolors! Definitely food for the soul. I love it! :)


message 25: by Carol (last edited 27 nov. 2016 15:43) (new) - added it

Carol You've written such an elegant review of this story, Dolors. I have this one to read and I'm so pleased to see your 5 stars!


message 26: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Anuradha wrote: "Like many others on this thread, I hadn't heard of this writer either, but let me just say, your reviews are sheer poetry, Dolors! Definitely food for the soul. I love it! :)"

Many thanks for your kind words, Anu. Please, keep on sharing your enthusiasm for books around...it's so contagious and refreshing! :)


message 27: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Carol wrote: "You've written such an elegant review of this story, Dolors. I have this one to read and I'm so pleased to see your 5 stars!"

Glad to hear so, Carol. Something tells me you will respond to Berry's quiet, lyrical style. I will look forward to your thoughts. Thanks for stopping by! :)


message 28: by Seemita (new)

Seemita Its nigh impossible to escape getting transported to a world that you choose to paint with such earnestness, D. Jayber Crow, wherever he found meaning, might have intended to have at least one visitor like you, so that his discovery may never disappear into oblivion. And you do that so well, my friend. In bringing us the quiet tenacity of a barber whose very nature of work makes his fingers fidgety, you tell us how rich his journey of stability can be. What a beauteous texture permeates this review!


message 29: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Seemita wrote: "Its nigh impossible to escape getting transported to a world that you choose to paint with such earnestness, D. Jayber Crow, wherever he found meaning, might have intended to have at least one visi..."

Geez Simi, everything you write is simply beautiful, in content and in form. You capture Jayber's quiet, mundane philosophy to the core, adding the perfect lyiricism that sits well with his vision of the world. Sometimes, the most resilient of people are those who receive defeat, accept it and make the most of what they have left. They don't leave space for resignation, they manage to live at peace and make others feel worthy. That's what Jayber taught me, a good dose of humility is always welcome! That, and your flowing prose...of course! :)


message 30: by Ilse (new) - added it

Ilse There is so much in your briliant and sensuous review that speaks to me, Dolors - I can hear those twittering birds and feel the light cover me. Painting that lifelong quest to overcome fear and anger and replace them with enduring love of this old barber, you gave this novel set in rural Kentucky an appealing universality, pointing in your unique poetical way to a likely gem that I would never have given a thought without your stunning review. Thank you for broadening my reading horizon again, Dolors!


message 31: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Arah-Lynda wrote: "It always amazes me. The beauty and insight that can be found in the everyday. Everyday life, everyday man, everyday everything. A beautiful and touching review Dolors."

I missed your beautiful and adept comment, Arah! You're so right. This book speaks about the beauty to be found in mundane lives. Inner peace is an attitude, and there is much to learn from Berry's stoic characters. Loved your thoughts, thanks for expressing them so touchingly.


message 32: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Ilse wrote: "There is so much in your briliant and sensuous review that speaks to me, Dolors - I can hear those twittering birds and feel the light cover me. Painting that lifelong quest to overcome fear and an..."

Thanks for your kind, generous words, Ilse. I would have never read Berry hadn't it been for some of my GR friends' enthused reviews. I felt utterly peaceful while reading this tale of quotidian hardship, Jayber's narrative irradiates a tender warmth that comforts and provides ground for quiet reflection about our life expectations. It's always good to be reminded that strength of character can go hand in hand with compassion and humility, good to have a fictional friend who will hear out our silent griefs.


message 33: by Deea (new)

Deea This review of yours made me think of two books at once: one of them was George Eliot's Romola (there is a barber there who is very nicely portrayed and he is the very opposite of this one: he is chatty and gossips a lot and he is Italian) and the second one was Stoner (now, why did I think of Stoner? I don't know... both Stoner and the character from this novel seem to be melancholic and observe their lives from afar in a melancholic way... so maybe this is why). Well-written D!


message 34: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Deea wrote: "This review of yours made me think of two books at once: one of them was George Eliot's Romola (there is a barber there who is very nicely portrayed and he is the very opposite of this one: he is c..."

Thanks for the literary references, Deea (particularly for reminding me that I need to get to Eliot the sooner the better!). You are not the first GR friend to mention Stoner, and I understand why. Both characters are stoic in dealing with the tragedies of daily life, but the main difference is their narration. Stoner focuses on his own perspective while Jayber paints a community portrait without meaning to be a protagonist in it. Jayber is humble, compassionate and selfless, something I am not ready to say about Stoner, even though I was greatly moved by his story.
Thanks for providing me the space to ponder about these issues, Deea, it's always a pleasure to talk books with you! :)


message 35: by Praj (last edited 30 nov. 2016 11:36) (new)

Praj Two things that brighten up the day here on GR , first a Dolors review and secondly, more so a 'Dolors review' that brings forth a new author to explore. Splendid ! It's intriguing but certainly not surprising when 'Stoner' is mentioned a couple times over in this 'comment' thread( coz' 'Stoner' was the very first image that came to my mind too) , for I reckon the beauty of writing or rather story-telling is how the most extraordinary tales/chronicles are unearthed from some of the humdrum lives that are easily forgotten in the course of life.

Thanks as always, D !


message 36: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Praj wrote: "Two things that brighten up the day here on GR , first a Dolors review and secondly, more so a Dolors that brings forth a new author to explore. Splendid ! It's intriguing but certainly not surpris..."

Thanks to you for making me blossom on this chilly day with your perceptive comment, Praj. The narrative voice certainly makes a difference in this tale of life and woe, but the optimistic, if also melancholic, undertone prevails in spite of the blows life bestows on the humble protagonist of this story.
The thought of introducing you to a new author makes me happy, Praj, the same way your presence on GR is like a beam of light warming us from the winter cold.


message 37: by Himanshu (new) - added it

Himanshu It's as if you have consciously placed each word after another in order to lock my eyes and get lost in that world you created. I'm sure you know it already that these kind of books are the reason I love reading, so it goes without saying that I'm already looking for a copy to get my hand on asap. But I must tell you, in India we hear a lot of stories in such setting, a barber who sits under an old banyan tree with a chair and a little mirror, and head full of stories. We have had movies made out of it too. And it's always charming, just like this beautiful review. :)


Dolors Himanshu wrote: "It's as if you have consciously placed each word after another in order to lock my eyes and get lost in that world you created. I'm sure you know it already that these kind of books are the reason ..."

Oh Himanshu, Jayber would have felt himself at home in India, then! Stories unfolding within stories, lives within lives and the comfort of a soothing voice is what the reader gets through Jayber's quiet chronicle. Everything that is good about community life is captured in Berry's books, and Jayber becomes that unconditional friend we all would want when life deals us a bad blow. I am so glad you added the book to your surely imposing to-read pile, and I will wait for the day you decide to embark on Jayber's journey with bated breath, because I Know I will relive it all through your keen, perceptive eyes! Thanks in advance, my friend! :)


message 39: by Ted (new) - added it

Ted Wonderful review, Dolors.


Dolors Ted wrote: "Wonderful review, Dolors."

Thank you, Ted.


message 41: by Agnieszka (new) - added it

Agnieszka Beautiful review , Dolors ! I loved the way you presented that old barber . He looks like a guy I should acquaint with asap . Thanks a lot for this wonderful piece of writing and the possibility to bask in your glorious writing again !


Dolors Agnieszka wrote: "Beautiful review , Dolors ! I loved the way you presented that old barber . He looks like a guy I should acquaint with asap . Thanks a lot for this wonderful piece of writing and the possibility to..."

Many, many thanks, Agna. I can't think of anybody who wouldn't be charmed by Jayber. Give him my regards if you sit to talk with him about the old times some day! ;P


message 43: by Fabian (new) - added it

Fabian  {Councillor} If I may say so, I consider this to be one of your very best reviews, Dolors. I also wasn't surprised to find out Stoner was mentioned in some of the comments, considering that he is the character I had to think of almost immediately when starting to delve into your review. Thank you yet again for a powerful review of a seemingly powerful novel! :)


Dolors Councillor wrote: "If I may say so, I consider this to be one of your very best reviews, Dolors. I also wasn't surprised to find out Stoner was mentioned in some of the comments, considering that he is the character ..."

Thanks so much for your kind, generous comment, Councillor. I am particularly fond of Jayber, so I can't tell you how grateful I am that my portrayal of him spoke to you. This is a touching story, very tender and simple, but the kind that pulls at one's heartstrings without much fuss. Hope you get to meet him some day! Thanks once more for your consistent kindness.


message 45: by Fran (new)

Fran An excellent review as always!


message 46: by Dolors (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Fran wrote: "An excellent review as always!"

Thanks a bunch, Fran! :))


message 47: by Cecily (last edited 02 juil. 2017 13:46) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cecily Dolors wrote: "Thanks Cecily. Jayber is much more selfless than Stoner, though. You get to know all the characters more than himself..."

Very true. Much as I loved Stoner (book and man), he had clear flaws, and there were occasions I want to shake him and shout at him. Not so with Jayber, who, in the hands of a lesser writer, would be too good to be true. And between the two, perhaps, is Ebenezer le Page.


message 48: by PirateSteve (new)

PirateSteve I thoroughly enjoyed reading your review here and I thank you for sharing it with us.


Dolors And I thank you for you taking the time to read it and for your kind words, PirateSteve. Berry is inspiring!:)


message 50: by Fran (new)

Fran Thank you for an awesome review as always, Dolors!


« previous 1
back to top