[go: up one dir, main page]

Showing posts with label Nevada geology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nevada geology. Show all posts

Monday, December 8, 2025

Geohopping across Nevada

Burners at incipient plate boundary in western Nevada. Are they waving California goodbye? (original unknown)
Many times I've crossed Nevada in the company of Frank DeCourten and Norma Biggar (hereafter called D & B). Actually I've never met either one, but I know their Roadside Geology of Nevada well. That's where I learned of the state's traumatic history—torn apart, reassembled, buried in ash and welded rock, and now being torn apart again. These stories can be hard to grasp, but I've read and reread the lengthy introduction enough to be awestruck by landscapes that many travelers find dull.

Sturdily bound, with high quality paper—my copy has survived lots of use.

Maps, diagrams and photos are abundant!
In the eight years since D & B published their book, I've often parked off the highway at their suggestion to study and photograph a geologic feature. I think of this as geohopping to geostops, rather than my usual geotripping to geosights (and later blogging about it). Now it's time to give the geostops their due.

One of my favorite stretches of highway between Laramie, Wyoming (home) and the California Central Coast (home of relatives) is US 6 across Nevada. Traffic is light, towns are few, and the geology truly is dramatic!

Geo highlights along US Highway 6, May 2025.
For example, about thirty million years ago, widespread cataclysmic destruction associated with the Great Ignimbrite Flareup (GIF) created Hell right here on Earth. Supervolcanoes erupted repeatedly across today's Nevada depositing ash thousands of feet deep, much of it welded into rock by the searing heat ("ignimbrite" means "fire cloud rock"). Trying to recreate that terrifying Flareup in my mind is one of the joys of driving across Nevada.

But it's impossible to properly imagine the GIF, in part because "no volcanic eruptions ever witnessed by humans come close to rivaling these prehistoric paroxysms." And the geologic record suggests it may be one of the largest ever. Consider this: in Nevada at least 230 supervolcanoes ejected an estimated 17,000 cubic miles of lava! Here's another way to think about it: at least 30 of these eruptions each equaled 600 Mt. St. Helens eruptions!

Blue Jay Maintenance Station on left, remnants of cataclysmic destruction behind.
About 90 miles southwest of Ely, I stopped at Palisade Mesa in the southern Pancake Range. Parking is available at a small rest area next to the Blue Jay Maintenance Station. Volcanic rocks of the GIF are nicely exposed on the steep slope to the east.
Rock pancakes stacked oldest to youngest, from bottom to top.
Palisade Mesa is one of multiple gently-tilted stacks of volcanic rock that give the Pancake Range its name. The escarpment at Blue Jay shows at least four episodes of eruption, all from the immense Central Nevada caldera complex. The pale bottom (oldest) layer is a lightly-welded tuff from an ash flow c. 31 million years ago. Next is a thin black band of glassy vitrophyre—"a flow of glowing ash that became densely welded."
Vitrophyre—beautiful memento of incandescent destruction. James St. John.
The massive brown layer above the vitrophyre is a younger tuff, about 30 million years old. Being a fan of columnar jointing, it was my favorite. The summit is a 2.75 million-year-old tuff that's sufficiently welded to provide an erosion-resistant cap.
I 💖 columnar jointing—created by contraction with cooling.
The view south beckoned.
Palisade Mesa obviously deserved a longer visit, perhaps a hike along the base and up the valley to the south. But not this time. Instead I continued west.

Those who cross the middle of Nevada (e.g. east to west) soon become aware of its extensive deformation even if they have no idea what happened. For example: When I left the Pancake Range I crossed Hot Creek Valley, then the Hot Creek Range, then Stone Cabin Valley, then the Monitor Range, and then Ralston Valley before stopping in Tonopah near the crest of the San Antonio Mountains. This is typical Nevada topography—valleys and mountain ranges one after another, all trending roughly north–south. The great pioneering geologist Clarence Dutton called them “an army of caterpillars marching north from Mexico".
Left of center, caterpillars are marching across the Basin and Range Province (NPS).
The cause of this curious pattern is east-west continental stretching, which started something like 18 million years ago and continues today. Some parts of Nevada and adjacent Utah and California have nearly doubled in width! In the process normal faulting has dropped basins, leaving adjacent land standing high, as mountain ranges.

In Tonopah, I stopped for gas and groceries as I often do. Here Hwy 6 merges with heavily-traveled Hwy 95, but at Coaldale Junction they diverge, and once again I had the highway mostly to myself. This is where I stumbled upon Radio Goldfield several years ago, broadcasting very local news and interesting country-ish, old-timey, new-to-me music. It's still going strong.
At the advice of D & B, I kept an eye out for a diatomite quarry on the left, near the junction with NV Hwy 264. The white patches were obvious. This diatomite is thought to be the same age as late eruptions of the GIF, but the setting was entirely different—a shallow freshwater lake where diatoms (microalgae) basked in the sun. Now they're diatomaceous earth, a soft crumbly rock that's 80–90% silica. Among its many uses are metal polish, toothpaste, cat litter, dynamite, thermal insulation, and bonsai soil amendments.
I would have enjoyed examining the diatomaceous earth, but wasn't clear on ownership.
Diatomaceous earth up close; scanning electron micrograph by Dawid Siodłak.
After continuing west across Montgomery Pass, I dropped into Queen Valley for the final geostop of the day, parking in a large pullout not far from California. Across the valley was the north end of the White Mountains; the snowy Sierra Nevada was visible in the far distance. It was a lovely peaceful place, or so it seemed that day. But nearby were clear signs of geologic trauma.
White Mountains rise steeply above floor of Queen Valley.
Normal faulting evidenced by triangular facets (arrows).
Across the valley at the base of the White Mountains is a normal fault just 3 million years old. This is the Queen Valley fault—a tiny piece of the immense Walker Lane. I had entered a profound but vague tectonic boundary, where the Basin and Range Province meets the great Sierra Nevada.
At Walker Lane (yellow), very different tectonic regions meet. SAFZ is San Andreas Fault Zone, a critical part of this story (Carlson et al. 2013).
Walker Lane is young—just 10 million years old at the south end, and only a few million at the north. The combination of Basin and Range extension and transverse movement of the Sierra Nevada has created a complex zone of faults that's poorly understood. Even so, Walker Lane generates a great deal of excitement among geologists. Perhaps a new plate boundary is forming! Maybe California will drift away!

Like the better known San Andreas Fault to the west, Walker Lane is contributing to the slow, incessant, contrary motions of the Pacific and North American tectonic plates, which are pulling a large part of California northward. Currently the San Andreas is responsible for about 80% of this movement but Walker Lane appears to be catching up.

Fauds & Henry (2008) predict that in another 7 to 8 million years or so, the northern part of the San Andreas will join Walker Lane, extending the Gulf of California north by hundreds of miles and turning California into a peninsula along a new plate boundary. 

If this tectonic shifting continues, as the authors think it will, California will become the island that was regularly reported by explorers hundreds of years ago! This was the "famous cartographic error that appeared on many European maps from the 16th to the 18th centuries" (David Rumsey Map Collection).
"Novissima et accuratissima totius Ameriae" by Nicolaes Visscher, 1690. Large island off the west coast of North America is California. DRMC
Peering even further into the future, we may well find that California Island has become an exotic terrane (quit snickering!). As such, it could travel far and wide before being stopped at some convergent plate boundary, thousands of miles from its origin at Walker Lane.

But Emmie ... our ephemeral lives mislead us. The Earth is far from stable.

Sources

agimark 2018. Splitting North America – The Walker Lane; Part 1 – The Tectonics; Volcano Hotspot blog. Accessed Dec 2025.

Carlson, CW, et al. 2013. Kinematics of the west-central Walker Lane ...  Geosphere 9: 1530–1551.

David Rumsey Map Collection, an unbelievably wonderful resource for fans of old maps. WARNING: it's very easy to spend a lot of time here. https://www.davidrumsey.com/

DeCourten, F, and Biggar, N. 2017. Roadside Geology of Nevada. Mountain Press.

Faulds, JE, and Henry, CD. 2008. Tectonic influences on the spatial and temporal evolution of the Walker Lane: An incipient transform fault along the evolving Pacific – North American plate boundary. Nevada Bureau of Mines and Geology, Arizona Geological Society Digest 22. The future of California is discussed on page 463. PDF

Wolterbeek, M. 2020 (Feb 18). How the burgeoning Walker Lane may split the American West; in Nevada Today, UNV Reno.

Monday, September 18, 2023

A Marine Graveyard in West-central Nevada

Eye of the Ichthyosaur
My visit to the volcanoes of eastern California last May was far too short, but there was nothing I could do. Life called. So after hiking up Panum volcano I raced east past Mono Lake, crossed into Nevada in the Bodie Hills, stopped briefly for gas and groceries in Hawthorne, and raced on. My destination was Berlin in the Shoshone Mountains.

This would be my third attempt. The first was canceled by the covid pandemic. Then the park shut down while pandemic stimulus funds were used for road improvements (still unpaved and washes out occasionally, so check before going). But this year I made it, just in time to set up camp before dark.

Looking west from Berlin across Ione Valley to the Paradise Range beyond, a fine example of the basin-and-range topography that covers much of Nevada.
Berlin is one of Nevada's many abandoned gold-mining towns. It was at its peak at the turn of the century (19th–20th), with a population of about 250 miners and their support staff: blacksmiths, woodcutters, charbonniers, a doctor, a nurse, and a prostitute. Yet by 1911 everyone was gone, a typical boom–bust story. But Berlin didn't disappear entirely. Some buildings remained intact long enough for history buffs to drum up protection.
Berlin Mill in 1910.

Two stamp batteries center bottom, for crushing ore plus water and mercury.
Several decades later Berlin experienced a revival of sorts, thanks to the many curiously-shaped stones in a draw nearby (miners supposedly used them as dinner plates!). In 1928 paleontologist Siemon Mueller of Stanford University examined them, and determined that they were fossilized bones of large marine reptiles—ichthyosaurs. But he left the fossils in place due the remoteness of the site.

In the early 1950s, amateur fossil collector Margaret Wheat visited Berlin and was astonished by what she saw. She convinced Berkeley paleontologist Charles Camp to take a look, thereby launching the excavation of what would become "the world's largest concentration of exposed fossil ichthyosaurs" (Ornduff et al. 2001).
Teeth of the Ichthyosaur
I visited Berlin during the off-season (before Memorial Day), so the Fossil Shelter was closed. Would this be yet another failure? No! This time luck was with me. A ranger cruising the campground offered to open and staff the Shelter. We agreed to meet at 10 am, and he headed off to round up others.
At the Fossil Shelter a small group had gathered in the parking lot, eight in all, a nice size. The Shelter is small and lacks the polish of well-funded visitor centers, as I was happy to discover. I felt far away from the crowds and control that have come to characterize our National Parks. The ranger opened the door, took his position at the front desk, and welcomed us in, providing laminated spiral-bound guides for our tour around a partial excavation of ichthyosaurs. At our own pace, we explored Nevada during Mesozoic time 200+ million years ago. [All quotes below are from the guide or Shelter exhibits.]
Near the front desk, Dr. Camp's reconstruction of Shonisaurus popularis hung overhead, nicely illuminated under the translucent ceiling. However, "There are some notable errors ... [this ichthyosaur] was a much more hydrodynamic predator ... Dr. Camp, however, was only going by the specimens he was excavating and can be forgiven for a few errors when one realizes he had no intact skull, and was working under very primitive and arduous conditions in what was then an extremely remote location."
Shonisaurus popularis by Charles Camp, with owl.
In 1973, Dr. Camp (in black hat below) "had his likeness preserved for posterity" with a bronze tablet installed at the Shelter by the Clampus Vitus, a group dedicated to promoting western history. In fact, Dr. Camp himself was a past Sublime Noble Grand Humbug of the order, hence the hat with C.V. hatband.
Ichthyosaurs are sometimes called sea dragons. One of the earliest collections of a sea dragon fossil was made by a 14-year old nature enthusiast in England—Mary Anning.
I walked slowly around the partially excavated bone bed, which was labeled with letters corresponding to the guide.
"R" marks ribs.
Note the miners' dinner plates (vertebrae).
Origin of this spectacular collection of bones is still debated (DeCourten & Biggar 2017). The skeletons are nearly complete, with bones roughly in proper position (articulated). Were they suddenly stranded by a very low tide? Or maybe this was a birthing area, with occasional deaths; tiny skeletons have found inside several of the larger ones (or were these ichthyosaurs cannibals?). Perhaps they died in deep water under anoxic conditions. The mystery remains.

Before leaving, I chatted once more with the ranger. He explained that visitation was booming (the new road?), and a reservation system for campsites would be available soon. I felt a little sad; probably there are changes ahead for the Fossil Shelter as well. You may want to visit soon.

Sources

DeCourten, F, and Biggar, N. 2017. Roadside Geology of Nevada. Mountain Press.

Orndorff, RL, Wieder, RW, and Filkorn, HF. 2001. Geology Underfoot in Central Nevada. Mountain Press.

Tuesday, May 10, 2022

Return to the Great Paleozoic Sea

Tiktaalik, what were you thinking?! Zina Deretsky, NSF.
In the midst of planning a tour of Paleozoic time in the Great Basin—a way to escape from this confusing disturbing world—I learned that thousands of people share my feelings. Amazing! What made the Paleozoic so alluring? It was a fish, specifically a charismatic fish that ventured onto land 375 million years ago. Tiktaalik (tic-TAH-lick) and its brethren are the progenitors of amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals. Yes, it was wandering fish—our ancestor—that got us into this mess!

Urban legend has it that Tiktaalik lived in a late Devonian paradise. The climate was mild. Stream banks, swamps, and other places where water met land were lush with delicious nutritious plants. Life was good. There was no reason to go back to the sea, at least not yet.

But life wasn't perfect. These early tretrapods most likely were stumblers rather than walkers. It probably took them all day to find enough food, and they could not escape predators. But as one paleontologist pointed out, Tiktaalik and its brethren were not burdened with self-awareness. “Everyone is, like, only barely conscious of the idea that they’re alive.” (Ben Otoo, U. Chicago grad student)

Now the Earth is occupied by creatures greatly burdened with self-awareness. Memers rage that Tiktaalik should have stayed in the ocean, thereby saving us all. Maybe those folks should return to the Paleozoic sea themselves. That's what I plan to do.
In the "desert ranges which lie to the west as far as longitude 117° 30' there is no considerable mountain body without its exposure of Palaeozoic strata" (geologist Clarence King, 1878).
Today's Great Basin is rich in remnants of the Paleozoic sea that covered much of today's Nevada and Utah. That sea was born about 700 million years ago, when the supercontinent Rodinea was breaking up. The former west half of Nevada drifted away, leaving the eastern part and adjacent Utah underwater. This was a passive continental margin, on a single tectonic plate. There was no tectonic jostling, only geological serenity (DeCourten 2003). Tens of thousands of feet of sediment accumulated on the sinking ocean floor.

Driving across northern Utah and Nevada, you can't miss the remains of that great sea. Most mountain ranges include or are even dominated by Paleozoic strata. Guidebooks make clear that this is not a monotonous stack of rock. There are nearshore carbonates in the east, and deep water siliceous rocks to the west. Quartzites tell of massive sand floods, beds of dolomite force us to confront the mysterious "dolomite problem", and there are fossils galore.
House Range in western Utah, a monstrous tilted stack of Cambrian rock; view from west, October 2021.
Lone Mountain near Eureka, Nevada, May 2021. Click to view Eureka quartzite (arrow), product of sand floods; other strata include limestone, dolomite, and shale (DeCourten & Biggar 2017).
Steeply-tilted Permian conglomerate at Tyron Gap; sediments were eroded off the now-gone Antler highland. Sulphur Springs Range, Nevada, May 2021.
Limestone and dolomite from late Devonian time, when Tiktaalik was venturing ashore; Devils Gate west of Eureka, Nevada, May, 2021.
Maybe on this trip I will find the perfect outcrop where I can rest peacefully and imagine myself in the warm shallow waters of that great Paleozoic sea, only barely conscious of being alive. This is not a childish pursuit. For all of us, pretending can make the world more magical and meaningful (Scott Hershovitz).

Sources

DeCourten, F. 2003. The Broken Land: adventures in Great Basin geology. U. Utah Press.

DeCourten, F, and Biggar, N. 2017. Roadside Geology of Nevada. Mountain Press.

Imbler, S. 2022 (Apr 29). "Started Out as a Fish. How Did It End Up Like This?" New York Times.

King, C. 1878. Systematic geology. Report of the geological exploration of the fortieth parallel, v. II. GPO.

Monday, February 28, 2022

Ruby Mountains: Island in a Paleozoic sea or metamorphic core complex?

Deformed lower crustal rocks high in the Ruby Mountains. How did this happen?!

In August of 1868, Clarence King's Survey of the Fortieth Parallel arrived in the East Humboldt Range in northeastern Nevada. The focus was geology. In fact, King was one of three geologists on board, the others being Arnold Hague and SF Emmons. They found the East Humboldts spectacular—"the most prominent uplift lying between the Sierra Nevada of California ... and the Wahsatch of Utah ... with many rugged summits reaching over 10,000 feet above sea-level" (Hague & Emmons 1877).

In the 150 years since, much has changed. The single range is now two: the East Humboldt Range to the north and the Ruby Mountains to the south, separated by today's Secret Pass (formerly Sacred Pass). A pass in the southern Rubies that used to honor explorer John Frémont is now Harrison Pass. It was here that the geologists discovered a dramatic change. To the south were thick beds of sediments deposited in a Paleozoic sea. To the north was a huge mass of seriously deformed rock.

King took it upon himself to study the area north of Frémont's Pass. He assigned the deformed rocks to the Archaean, which at that time included all Earth history before the Cambrian. King concluded these rocks had been an island in a Paleozoic sea. This was a reasonable hypothesis, not at all out of line with current thinking. But that too has changed.

Ruby Mountains and vicinity; points of interest in red (after Snoke et al. 1997).
A year earlier, 25-year-old Clarence King—young, bright, and ambitious—had persuaded Congress to fund a Geological Exploration of the Fortieth Parallel, which he would lead. His assignment was broadly defined—"a geological and topographical exploration of the territory between the Rocky Mountains and the Sierra Nevada ...".

King must have been ecstatic. This was a region poorly known geologically and ripe for discovery. He and his crew spent seven seasons in the field. The result was a large atlas of topographic and geologic maps, and seven reports, published from 1877 to 1880.

Volume II, Descriptive Geology, was the first (Hague & Emmons 1877). Arnold Hague wrote the section about the East Humboldt Range. He began with the area south of Frémont's (Harrison) Pass, in today's southern Ruby Mountains. Here were very thick beds of Paleozoic rocks, with limestone conformably overlying quartzite. "The quartzites appear a little calcareous and the limestones somewhat siliceous, but the transition is made by a rapid passage from one to the other."

North of Frémont's Pass "a change takes place in the rock ...", noted Hague laconically. In fact it was a dramatic change. The thick beds of Paleozoic sediments were replaced with deformed metamorphic rocks. Relying on King's notes, Hague described Archaean quartzites and crystalline schists extending from the crest all the way down to the valley to the west, where they disappeared under Pliocene sedimentary rocks. This situation continued to the northern end of the range. Aside from one or two small remnants, the Paleozoic limestone was gone.

Archaean quartzite, [East] Humboldt Range, Nevada (King 1878).
The next report published was Volume I, Systematic Geology (King 1878), an ambitious tome. Much of it was what we call historical geology—a challenging subject then. Some very basic geology had yet to be figured out, for example the composition of the Earth, and the origin of mountains.

Contractionists argued the Earth was a solid body that was cooling and contracting. Wrinkling of the shrinking surface created mountains. Others argued that the Earth's interior was molten; convection currents in the molten interior created volcanoes and other mountains. Clarence King leaned toward the latter hypothesis, but addressed it only briefly in his report. "I prefer to build no farther till the underlying physics are worked out ... leaving their minute discussion to a day in the near future when it can be done on a firmer physical foundation" (italics mine).

What was King thinking when he wrote "near future"? Years? Decades? In fact, it would be almost a century before geologists came up with plate tectonics, and another twenty years passed before "metamorphic core complex" was added to their vocabulary.

East Humboldt Range (Hague & Emmons 1877). Click to view geologist on an Archean "island".

King took it upon himself to discuss "the configuration and general relief of the area of the Fortieth Parallel at the close of Archaean time". It was here that he revealed his thinking about the creation of today's mountains. "Over the whole distance from the Rocky Mountains to western Nevada, in almost every prominent range, the contact may be observed between the Archaean and the Palaeozoic series. At times, Archaean summits are seen to rise above the level of the deposition of the Upper Carboniferous ..." King concluded the ancient rocks at the crests of today's mountain ranges were once part of Archaean ranges. Then the high peaks became islands in a Paleozoic sea.

The East Humboldt Range was a fine example: "The Humboldt was one of the greater Archaean ranges, and the subsequent Palaeozoic rocks are deposited unconformably, abutting against its steeply inclined flanks, leaving unsubmerged insular Archaean summits."

In the Archaean section of Systematic Geology, King included a map of Archaean rocks with a cross section. The excerpt below shows "Archaean bottom of the ocean in which Paleozoic sediments were deposited ...". Note that the high peaks of the East Humboldt Range were above sea level during deposition of the Wahsatch limestone.

 From King 1878, click to view. 
Today the Ruby Mountains/East Humboldt Range is considered a metamorphic core complex (MCC; also called core complex). MCCs are giant complicated structures, and it wasn't until the early 1980s that someone came up with a generally acceptable hypothesis.

Based on Peterson & Buddington 2014, DeCourten & Biggar 2017.
As shown above, MCCs include a dome of lower crustal metamorphic rock exposed to some extent at the surface. Above it are unmetamorphosed sedimentary rocks of the upper crust. These have been faulted, fractured, detached, and transported away from the crest of the dome. In other words, today's geologists think metamorphic rocks in the Rubies and East Humboldts came not from Archaean high peaks but from deep below the surface. This is very cool! It's not often we get to look at rocks metamorphosed by the great pressures and high temperatures of the lower crust.

The highly deformed metamorphic rocks and the undeformed sedimentary rocks are separated by a low-angle detachment fault. At the contact, the metamorphic rocks have been mylonized—highly deformed by very large shear strain. I would think giant moving chunks of rock could do just that, especially if the lower crustal rocks were a bit ductile from all the heat down there.

Mylonized (seriously scrunched) rock, East Humboldt Range. NV Highway 229 west of Secret Pass.

I first learned about MCCs on trip across the Great Basin about 15 years ago. In Broken Land (2003), Frank DeCourten described how it had taken him several decades to get up the nerve to visit one. "The complexity of these structures struck me as virtually incomprehensible." I felt the same way, but fortunately I had several guidebooks along on my trip last October.

MCCs are intimidating in part because they are so huge, too big to see. We can only glimpse bits of the various parts here and there. The best view of a MCC on my trip was not in the Rubies but the northern Snake Range. In the photo below, the very thin rock band is mylonite, marking the low angle detachment fault. Outcrops above it are fractured Paleozoic sedimentary rocks that moved eastward.

Snake Range north of US Highway 50 near turnoff to Baker, NV.
On the west side of the Ruby Mountains, the walls of Lamoille Canyon provide views of contorted metamorphic rocks of the lower crust, which domed up with formation of the MCC.

A glimpse of the interior of the Earth!
The upper canyon features a pegmatite dike–sill complex intruded into gneiss and marble.
Pegmatite in gneiss along trail to Lamoille Lake.
King thought the metamorphic rocks high in the East Humboldt Range were Archaean, equivalent to Precambrian today. He wrote, "... we have no conclusive proof of metamorphism of Palaeozoic strata to so extreme a point as to endanger a mistake between the resultant rocks and those of Archaean age." But King lived before the time of radiometric dating. Turns out most of the metamorphic rocks high in the Rubies and East Humboldts are indeed Paleozoic; only a few are older (Proterozoic).

In road cuts along Highway 229 in Secret Canyon, geogeeks can experience mylonite up close. In the photos below, the rocks midslope are Mississippian and Pennsylvanian sedimentary formations "dismembered" by serious deformation.

I collected several distinctive mementos to add to my collection at home.
Now the really hard question: What created the Ruby/East Humboldt MCC? Maybe it was extension, stretching and thinning of the crust. This is a reasonable hypothesis given that North America from central Utah to eastern California has been expanding for c. 30 million years—enough to double the distance between Reno and Salt Lake City (DeCourten & Biggar 2017). But regional extension isn't enough. Extension in the Ruby/East Humboldt MCC is extreme. Faulted and fractured Paleozoic sedimentary rocks moved as much 50 km in places. Also, MCC formation started well before regional extension.

There are other questions. How were huge chunks of rock set in motion and transported so far if the detachment fault is low angle? And why did all this happen? Did extreme extension allow the rise of lower crustal rocks, formerly buried 20 km deep or more (i.e., isostasy in response to thinning)? Or did anomalous mantle convection cause upwarp of deformed crustal rocks? MCCs seem so strange—are they real?

Maybe today's metamorphic core complexes will turn out to be historical curiosities, like Clarence King's island theory of 150 years ago. King acknowledged his hypothesis was largely speculative. But he wasn't much troubled, being satisfied to contribute "whatever value this Report may possess, either as a permanent contribution to knowledge or as a stepping-stone worthy to be built into the great stairway of science ..."
How high have we climbed on the great stairway of science?

Sources

Bartlett, RA. 1962. Great surveys of the American West. U. Oklahoma Press.

DeCourten, F, and Biggar, N. 2017. Roadside Geology of Nevada. Mountain Press.

Hague, A, and Emmons, SF. 1877. Descriptive geology. Report of the geological exploration of the fortieth parallel, v. I. GPO.

King, C. 1878. Systematic geology. Report of the geological exploration of the fortieth parallel, v. II. GPO.

Maley, TS. 2017. Metamorphic core complexes and related features, in Idaho Geology, 2nd ed. PDF.

Peterson, J., and Buddington, A. 2014. A geological study of the McKenzie Conservation Area, Spokane County, Washington. Conference Paper.

Snoke, AW, et al. 1997. The Grand Tour of the Ruby-East Humboldt Metamorphic Core Complex, Northeastern Nevada: Part 1-Introduction & Road Log. Geology Faculty Publications. 39.