
Burn, Witch, Burn!
Abraham Merritt | Corgi Books | 1963 (first published 1932) | 161 pages
Dr. Lowell, a self-proclaimed “orthodox man of medicine” struggles to find rational explanations in a mysterious case that places him in direct conflict with an ancient, “dark flame of evil wisdom”. Presented in a breathless, first-person account, Lowell details the experiences he admits would be mercilessly dismissed by his own medical community, in a story that could have alternately been named with the doctor’s own casebook title, The Dolls of Madame Mandilip.
Entering his New York City hospital late one night, Dr. Lowell is confronted by Julian Ricori, an infamous local gangster. Ricori and a group of his henchmen are delivering Peters, Ricori’s right-hand man in the organization, to the emergency room. Peters has been stricken with a mysterious malady, rendering him in a catatonic state. He was suddenly and unexpectedly crippled, debilitated with a frozen expression of horror locked on his face, unseeing eyes locked on terrors seemingly both internal and external. Recognizing Lowell as a distinguished brain specialist, Ricoli enlists his aid in treating his strangely afflicted associate, whom he suspects is the victim of foul play.
After Peters dies, his corpse exhibits a nearly supernatural onset and release of rigor mortis. In addition, his blood work shows an unusual, luminous presence in the corpuscles. Lowell reaches out to some of his distinguished colleagues in the medical profession, and discovers a rash of similar deaths throughout New York. Prompted by the vengeful Ricori, Lowell pursues a commonality among the victims, eventually discovering shared encounters with a strange downtown dollmaker.
The early chapters establish an appealingly creepy atmosphere, primarily due to Lowell’s first-person account. His inner-monologue, as he grapples with the strange agency of the assorted deaths, reads something like the voice-over narration in a bleak film noir, only with an occult tinge. Interestingly, Ricori and his gunsel, McCann, are portrayed in an unexpectedly positive light. Originally written in the thirties, the text’s empathy towards these mafiosi perhaps stems from the inherently flawed prohibition against alcohol that presumably drove their criminal enterprise.
In the subsequent decades following the book’s publication, the notion of killer dolls has descended into outrageous camp [Bride of Chucky, I’m looking at you], but here the concept is presented in all seriousness. The little details supporting the curses, from the sinister balms to the “witches ladder” of braided hair placed in the possession of the victims, serve to enhance the overall mood of malignancy.
If Madame Mandilip ultimately remains a cipher as the villain, at least she is an imposing character. A giant woman, with a huge bust and pronounced mustache, her motivations are never clearly identified beyond evil-for-the-sake-of-evil. Her mousy niece elicits some sympathy, trapped in a cycle of witchcraft that she cannot herself escape.
A final chapter avoids the pitfall of an easy, rational explanation explaining away all the horrors. This connect-all-the-dots type of conclusion arguably tarnishes such otherwise notable classics as Psycho (or, ahem, any of a dozen Scooby Doo mysteries).Lowell feigns a potential, post-hypnotic solution, but when ultimately asked if he believes in the scientific over the supernatural in this case, he responds simply, “No.”









