HYBRID SURVEILLANCE DEVICE AND METHOD
Reference to Related Application:
The present invention claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 60/219,436, filed July 20, 2000, whose disclosure is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety into the present disclosure.
Field of the Invention:
The present invention is directed to the economical and flexible transmission and reception of dependent surveillance data using multiple automatic dependent surveillance systems.
Background Of The Invention:
At present the aviation community is developing several systems for Automatic Dependent Surveillance Broadcast (ADS-B), wherein an aircraft automatically transmits its position, velocity and other significant data by means of a radio-frequency (RF) transmitter, said data subsequently received by other nearby aircraft and ground stations with compatible RF receivers. Substantial benefits to flight safety and flight efficiency are envisioned by use of these systems. A feature of ADS-B systems in general is that the desired update rate for nearby users tends to be higher (more frequent) than the desired update rate for more distant users.
At present the FAA is considering three technologies for Automatic Dependent Surveillance: a) an extension of the Mode Select radar technology known as Mode S Extended Squitter; b) an L-band radio transceiver called Universal Access Transponder (UAT); and c) a VHF radio transceiver known as VHF Data Link Mode 4 (VDL/4). The Mode S Extended Squitter and UAT are relatively wideband systems which operate at L- band (near 1 GHz), and both rely on random transmissions at a high update rate. The high update rate is intended to overcome the possibility of overlapping transmissions, associated with the random-access nature of the systems, which can prevent error-free reception. The Mode S Extended Squitter and UAT tend to operate well at short range,
where a message can be delivered with high power that can overcome overlapping transmissions received at lower power from long range, but performance degrades at long range as overlapping transmissions increasingly hamper reception. The VDL/4 is a relatively narrow-band system which operates on multiple 25 kHz channels in the VHF portion of the radio spectrum, using a relatively low update rate with scheduled accesses. The scheduled accesses allow the system to deliver a desired level of performance without a large number of unnecessary transmissions, i.e. since unexpected overlapping transmissions are substantially avoided. The VDL/4 tends to operate well at short and long range. However, in order to deliver the desired level of performance at short range, where ADS-B systems in general need a high update rate, the VDL/4 system must increase its transmission rate to a level higher than is needed for long-range use. This consumes scarce RF spectrum resources and is undesirable.
Table 1 describes update rates for ADS-B as defined in RTCA/DO-242. The update period for reception is allowed to increase at long range. Typical ADS-B systems lmown to the prior art tend to operate for extended periods of time with a fixed transmit rate, anticipating that a percentage of the transmitted messages will be lost at any given receiver. A random-access ADS-B system, such as Mode S extended squitter or UAT, typically broadcasts at a fixed data transmission rate such as one transmission per second, and assumes that random message overlap will lead to a relatively high update rate at short range (where overlaps are relatively insignificant) and relatively lower update rate at longer range (where overlaps are relatively significant), thereby achieving the performance trend indicated in Table 1. A scheduled-access ADS-B system, such as VDL/4, delivers a relatively smaller change in received update rate versus distance since the number of overlaps is substantially reduced. Hence a transmit update rate selected to satisfy close-range requirements will lead to an excess update rate at long range, whereas a transmit update rate selected to satisfy long-range requirements will not satisfy short- range requirements.
Table 1 : ADS-B report update period requirements (reception rates)
Nominal range (mm) 3 10 20 40 90
Nominal update period (95th percentile) (sec) 3 5 7 12 12
Summary Of The Invention: The present invention is a hybrid device combining two different ADS-B systems which are non-interoperable, i.e., they are incompatible with each other's signals, in order to enhance overall performance while conserving RF spectrum.
Brief Description Of Drawings: FIG. 1 illustrates a hybrid ADS-B system according to a preferred embodiment of the current invention.
Detailed Description Of The Invention:
FIG. 1 illustrates a population of aircraft 1, 2, 3, 4 and a hybrid ADS-B system 10 installed on aircraft 1. The hybrid ADS-B system comprises an L-band random-access
ADS-B subsystem 12 operating through one or several L-band antennae 11, a VHF scheduled-access ADS-B subsystem 14 operating through one or several VHF antennae
13, and a hybrid system controller 15. Each ADS-B subsystem periodically transmits certain information comprising aircraft position, velocity, and equipment capability (such as a flag identifying the presence or absence of a functioning receiver for the associated transmitter). Each ADS-B subsystem, with a functioning receiver, can also receive information from other aircraft within radio range.
Also shown in FIG. 1 are other aircraft 2, 3, 4 which can exchange information with aircraft 1 if they are equipped with either: a) an L-band ADS-B subsystem that is functionally interoperable with 12; b) a VHF ADS-B subsystem that is functionally interoperable with 14; or c) both.
The hybrid system controller 15 can exchange data with other equipment installed onboard aircraft 1.
In the ADS-B systems known to the prior art, aircraft 1 would be equipped with either an L-band random-access ADS-B system or a VHF scheduled-access ADS-B system. The installed system would be operated with a transmit rate intended to satisfy a known set of requirements, such as those illustrated by example in Table 1. Aircraft 1 could also, according to the prior art, be equipped with both types of systems but in this case each system would operate independently without knowledge of the other, and with no change in operating parameters.
Certain ground-based systems may also broadcast surveillance data which can be received by the ADS-B systems or associated systems. These ground surveillance data broadcasts are typically referred as Traffic Information Service - Broadcast (TIS-B). In the hybrid ADS-B system according to the current invention, the operating parameters of the L-band and VHF ADS-B subsystems 12, 14 can be tailored by the hybrid controller 15 depending on the equipage of other aircraft 2, 3, 4 in the airspace, as determined by the ADS-B messages received from those aircraft or as reported in TIS-B broadcasts from the ground. Each subsystem 12, 14 reports all information received to the hybrid controller 15. Some or all of this information is relayed to other onboard equipment. The hybrid controller 15 is also informed of the current location of the aircraft 1 on which it is installed, either through the operation of one or both of the ADS- B subsystems 12, 14, or via connection to other onboard equipment. The hybrid controller 15 maintains a database of all aircraft equipped with ADS-B in its local airspace, as determined by the information it receives. This database comprises aircraft relative position, velocity, and ADS-B system equipage parameters. A benefit of the hybrid ADS-B system, relative to an L-band ADS-B system alone, is that a database record (a target track) can be initiated at relatively longer range due to the data received via the VHF system.
If all aircraft able to receive ADS-B transmissions, within its local airspace, are equipped with dual L-band and VHF ADS-B receiving subsystems, the hybrid controller adjusts the transmit update rates of the ADS-B subsystems 12, 14 in order to satisfy the receive update rate requirements of Table 1 (or similar) without a large number of excess transmissions. For example, in one preferred embodiment the L-band random-access
ADS-B subsystem parameters might be left unchanged and the VHF scheduled-access ADS-B subsystem parameters might be adjusted to accommodate only long-range requirements (i.e., relying on the L-band system to accommodate short-range requirements). In this way, VHF spectrum utilization is minimized, the number of required VHF channels is minimized, and the VHF channel resource may be used by other ADS-B transmitters or non-ADS-B applications.
If the hybrid controller 15 determines that an aircraft in its local airspace is equipped to receive ADS-B information via only one of the available ADS-B systems, it adjusts the operating parameters of that subsystem to yield high confidence that required ADS-B update rate requirements are satisfied, for that aircraft, using the available system in isolation. The hybrid controller 15 need not accommodate other aircraft in its local airspace which are not equipped to receive ADS-B information by either ADS-B system.
In another preferred embodiment, the transmit update rates for the two ADS-B subsystems are adjusted with consideration of the TIS-B broadcast parameters as well as ADS-B system parameters, since the TIS-B broadcast can partially compensate for lack of ADS-B.
When all aircraft equipped with a VHF ADS-B system are also equipped with an L-band ADS-B system, the present invention achieves a significant reduction in VHF channel utilization. In the future, simple range thresholds, as illustrated in Table 1 by example, may be replaced with more elaborate criteria.
While a preferred embodiment has been set forth above, those skilled in the art who have reviewed the present disclosure will readily appreciate that other embodiments can be realized within the scope of the invention. For example, the present invention may be extended to three or more ADS-B subsystems. Therefore, the present invention should be construed as limited only by the appended claims.