[go: up one dir, main page]

US20140348981A1 - Food products with yogurt whey - Google Patents

Food products with yogurt whey Download PDF

Info

Publication number
US20140348981A1
US20140348981A1 US14/138,608 US201314138608A US2014348981A1 US 20140348981 A1 US20140348981 A1 US 20140348981A1 US 201314138608 A US201314138608 A US 201314138608A US 2014348981 A1 US2014348981 A1 US 2014348981A1
Authority
US
United States
Prior art keywords
whey
yogurt
product
food product
yogurt whey
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Abandoned
Application number
US14/138,608
Inventor
Erika B. Smith
Wenyi Wang
Vikramaditya Ghosh
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
General Mills Inc
Original Assignee
General Mills Inc
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Priority claimed from PCT/US2013/042576 external-priority patent/WO2014189519A1/en
Application filed by General Mills Inc filed Critical General Mills Inc
Priority to US14/138,608 priority Critical patent/US20140348981A1/en
Assigned to GENERAL MILLS, INC. reassignment GENERAL MILLS, INC. ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST (SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS). Assignors: GHOSH, VIKRAMADITYA, SMITH, ERIKA B., WANG, WENYI
Assigned to GENERAL MILLS, INC. reassignment GENERAL MILLS, INC. CORRECTIVE ASSIGNMENT TO CORRECT THE EXECUTION DATE OF WENYI WANG SHOULD BE 12-02-2013 PREVIOUSLY RECORDED ON REEL 031850 FRAME 0495. ASSIGNOR(S) HEREBY CONFIRMS THE VIA ASSIGNMENT FILED 12/26/2013. Assignors: GHOSH, VIKRAMADITYA, SMITH, ERIKA B., WANG, WENYI
Publication of US20140348981A1 publication Critical patent/US20140348981A1/en
Abandoned legal-status Critical Current

Links

Classifications

    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A23FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
    • A23CDAIRY PRODUCTS, e.g. MILK, BUTTER OR CHEESE; MILK OR CHEESE SUBSTITUTES; MAKING OR TREATMENT THEREOF
    • A23C21/00Whey; Whey preparations
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A21BAKING; EDIBLE DOUGHS
    • A21DTREATMENT OF FLOUR OR DOUGH FOR BAKING, e.g. BY ADDITION OF MATERIALS; BAKING; BAKERY PRODUCTS
    • A21D13/00Finished or partly finished bakery products
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A21BAKING; EDIBLE DOUGHS
    • A21DTREATMENT OF FLOUR OR DOUGH FOR BAKING, e.g. BY ADDITION OF MATERIALS; BAKING; BAKERY PRODUCTS
    • A21D2/00Treatment of flour or dough by adding materials thereto before or during baking
    • A21D2/08Treatment of flour or dough by adding materials thereto before or during baking by adding organic substances
    • A21D2/24Organic nitrogen compounds
    • A21D2/26Proteins
    • A21D2/261Animal proteins
    • A21D2/263Animal proteins from dairy products
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A23FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
    • A23CDAIRY PRODUCTS, e.g. MILK, BUTTER OR CHEESE; MILK OR CHEESE SUBSTITUTES; MAKING OR TREATMENT THEREOF
    • A23C19/00Cheese; Cheese preparations; Making thereof
    • A23C19/06Treating cheese curd after whey separation; Products obtained thereby
    • A23C19/09Other cheese preparations; Mixtures of cheese with other foodstuffs
    • A23C19/0917Addition, to cheese or curd, of whey, whey components, substances recovered from separated whey, isolated or concentrated proteins from milk
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A23FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
    • A23CDAIRY PRODUCTS, e.g. MILK, BUTTER OR CHEESE; MILK OR CHEESE SUBSTITUTES; MAKING OR TREATMENT THEREOF
    • A23C21/00Whey; Whey preparations
    • A23C21/02Whey; Whey preparations containing, or treated with, microorganisms or enzymes
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A23FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
    • A23CDAIRY PRODUCTS, e.g. MILK, BUTTER OR CHEESE; MILK OR CHEESE SUBSTITUTES; MAKING OR TREATMENT THEREOF
    • A23C21/00Whey; Whey preparations
    • A23C21/02Whey; Whey preparations containing, or treated with, microorganisms or enzymes
    • A23C21/026Whey; Whey preparations containing, or treated with, microorganisms or enzymes containing, or treated only with, lactic acid producing bacteria, bifidobacteria or propionic acid bacteria
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A23FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
    • A23CDAIRY PRODUCTS, e.g. MILK, BUTTER OR CHEESE; MILK OR CHEESE SUBSTITUTES; MAKING OR TREATMENT THEREOF
    • A23C21/00Whey; Whey preparations
    • A23C21/06Mixtures of whey with milk products or milk components
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A23FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
    • A23CDAIRY PRODUCTS, e.g. MILK, BUTTER OR CHEESE; MILK OR CHEESE SUBSTITUTES; MAKING OR TREATMENT THEREOF
    • A23C9/00Milk preparations; Milk powder or milk powder preparations
    • A23C9/12Fermented milk preparations; Treatment using microorganisms or enzymes
    • A23C9/13Fermented milk preparations; Treatment using microorganisms or enzymes using additives
    • A23C9/1307Milk products or derivatives; Fruit or vegetable juices; Sugars, sugar alcohols, sweeteners; Oligosaccharides; Organic acids or salts thereof or acidifying agents; Flavours, dyes or pigments; Inert or aerosol gases; Carbonation methods
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A23FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
    • A23GCOCOA; COCOA PRODUCTS, e.g. CHOCOLATE; SUBSTITUTES FOR COCOA OR COCOA PRODUCTS; CONFECTIONERY; CHEWING GUM; ICE-CREAM; PREPARATION THEREOF
    • A23G3/00Sweetmeats; Confectionery; Marzipan; Coated or filled products
    • A23G3/34Sweetmeats, confectionery or marzipan; Processes for the preparation thereof
    • A23G3/36Sweetmeats, confectionery or marzipan; Processes for the preparation thereof characterised by the composition containing organic or inorganic compounds
    • A23G3/46Sweetmeats, confectionery or marzipan; Processes for the preparation thereof characterised by the composition containing organic or inorganic compounds containing dairy products
    • A23L1/10
    • A23L1/39
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A23FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
    • A23LFOODS, FOODSTUFFS OR NON-ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR; PREPARATION OR TREATMENT THEREOF
    • A23L2/00Non-alcoholic beverages; Dry compositions or concentrates therefor; Preparation or treatment thereof
    • A23L2/52Adding ingredients
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A23FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
    • A23LFOODS, FOODSTUFFS OR NON-ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR; PREPARATION OR TREATMENT THEREOF
    • A23L23/00Soups; Sauces; Preparation or treatment thereof
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A23FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
    • A23LFOODS, FOODSTUFFS OR NON-ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR; PREPARATION OR TREATMENT THEREOF
    • A23L23/00Soups; Sauces; Preparation or treatment thereof
    • A23L23/10Soup concentrates, e.g. powders or cakes
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A23FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
    • A23LFOODS, FOODSTUFFS OR NON-ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR; PREPARATION OR TREATMENT THEREOF
    • A23L33/00Modifying nutritive qualities of foods; Dietetic products; Preparation or treatment thereof
    • A23L33/10Modifying nutritive qualities of foods; Dietetic products; Preparation or treatment thereof using additives
    • A23L33/17Amino acids, peptides or proteins
    • A23L33/19Dairy proteins
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A23FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
    • A23LFOODS, FOODSTUFFS OR NON-ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES, NOT OTHERWISE PROVIDED FOR; PREPARATION OR TREATMENT THEREOF
    • A23L7/00Cereal-derived products; Malt products; Preparation or treatment thereof
    • A23L7/10Cereal-derived products
    • A23L7/101Addition of antibiotics, vitamins, amino-acids, or minerals

Definitions

  • Acid whey is produced during the production of acid types of cheese such as cottage cheese, and contains a higher solids content than yogurt whey.
  • yogurt whey is used as an agricultural liquid fertilizer. This liquid yogurt whey does not have suitable characteristics for use in processed foods and animal feed, like other whey by-products.
  • a food product includes neutralized yogurt whey.
  • the neutralized yogurt whey has the following composition: a pH of 6.0 or greater; at least 100 mg calcium per 100 grams of yogurt whey; at least 1% wt galactose; and at least 6% wt solids.
  • the yogurt whey in the food product has the following composition: a pH of 6.2 or greater; at least 3% wt calcium; at least 5% wt galactose; at least 95% wt solids; and less than 5% wt protein.
  • neutralized yogurt whey refers to yogurt whey that has been neutralized with a basic material to raise the pH of the yogurt whey.
  • a “food product” is a food produced by combining two or more edible ingredients.
  • the present disclosure relates to a food product including a neutralized yogurt whey.
  • the food product can be a bakery product, a beverage product, a snack product, a confectionery product, a soup product, a dry meal product, or a dairy product, for example.
  • the neutralized yogurt whey can be provided in the food product in any useful level.
  • the neutralized yogurt whey is a free flowing solid having a moisture content of less than 5% wt or less than 3% wt.
  • the neutralized yogurt whey is liquid flowing material having a solids % in a range from about 20% wt to 90% wt. While the present disclosure is not so limited, an appreciation of various aspects of the disclosure will be gained through a discussion of the examples provided below.
  • Acid whey or yogurt whey is generated in the food industry as a by-product of the traditional method to make Greek yogurt which involves a whey separation process.
  • the resulting whey by-product is a dilute, high acid liquid containing lactose and milk minerals and is referred to herein as “yogurt whey”.
  • Greek yogurt is produced by the fermentation of milk with yogurt cultures. Three pounds of milk produces one pound of Greek Yogurt and two pounds of acid or yogurt whey. Greek yogurt is separated from yogurt whey and the Greek yogurt is then packaged into containers or further processed.
  • This disclosure describes a neutralized and dry yogurt whey concentrate or powder that can be utilized in a food product.
  • the neutralized and dry yogurt whey concentrate or powder can be utilized as a bulking agent, sweetening agent or a mineral fortificant (calcium and phosphorus) for food products.
  • a mineral fortificant calcium and phosphorus
  • the neutralized liquid or powder concentrate product can replace sweet whey in food products, for example.
  • Applicant has discovered no significant sensory differences between 10% w/w solutions of dried sweet whey and the neutralized yogurt whey.
  • the color of neutralized yogurt whey was more similar to sweet whey than whey permeate.
  • Sweet whey and neutralized yogurt whey have similar opacity and whiteness.
  • Yogurt whey has a pH that is more acidic than whey produced from cheese (i.e., sweet whey).
  • the pH of yogurt whey can be less than 5.0 or less than 4.8 or 4.5 or less.
  • the pH of yogurt whey can be in a range from 4.0 to 5.0 or from 4.3 to 4.7 or from 4.4 to 4.6.
  • Another way to describe acidity is “titratable acidity” or TA which refers to a total acidity and is expressed as %.
  • Titratable acidity can be determined for yogurt whey by titration with a 0.1 N NaOH solution to a 8.2-8.4 pH using phenolphthalein indicator.
  • Yogurt whey has a TA that is greater than a TA of sweet whey.
  • the TA of yogurt whey is at least about 0.2% or at least 0.3% or at least 0.4%.
  • the TA of yogurt whey can be in a range from 0.2 to 0.5% or from 0.3 to 0.5%.
  • Yogurt whey that has just been separated from Greek yogurt has a solids content of less than 10% wt or less than 8% wt or about 6% wt.
  • Yogurt whey can have a solids wt % in a range from 3 to 9% wt or from 4 to 8% wt or from 5 to 6% wt.
  • Yogurt whey has a wt % of protein that is less than whey produced from cheese (i.e., sweet whey).
  • Sweet whey can have about 0.8% wt protein.
  • Yogurt whey has less than 0.5% wt or less than 0.4% wt or about 0.3% wt protein.
  • Yogurt whey can have a protein wt % in a range from 0.1 to 0.5% wt or from 0.2 to 0.4% wt.
  • Yogurt whey has galactose while sweet whey typically does not contain galactose.
  • Yogurt whey can have at least 0.4% wt galactose or at least 0.5% wt galactose.
  • Yogurt whey contains an amount of lactose that is similar to sweet whey.
  • Yogurt whey and sweet whey contains about 70% wt lactose on a dry basis or is in a range from 50 to 75% wt lactose on a dry basis.
  • yogurt whey is pasteurized, concentrated and neutralized with a basic material.
  • These processing steps can be performed in any order.
  • the yogurt whey can be first pasteurized, then concentrated and then neutralized and optionally further dried to a powder.
  • the yogurt whey can be first neutralized, then pasteurized and then concentrated and optionally further dried to a powder.
  • the yogurt whey can be first concentrated, then neutralized and then pasteurized and optionally further dried to a powder.
  • Neutralizing the yogurt whey is accomplished with an addition of a basic material to form a neutralized yogurt whey.
  • the neutralized yogurt whey has a pH that is greater than 5.0 or greater than 5.5 or greater than 6.0 or greater than 6.2. In many embodiments the neutralized yogurt whey has a pH in a range from about 6.0 to 6.5.
  • the basic material can be any useful basic material.
  • the basic material is a hydroxide such as alkali metal hydroxides or alkali earth metal hydroxides.
  • Alkali metal hydroxides include sodium and potassium hydroxide.
  • Alkali earth metal hydroxides include calcium and magnesium hydroxide.
  • the basic material is a carbonate such as sodium bicarbonate.
  • Yogurt whey can be concentrated by removing water to any useful solids % or moisture content.
  • the concentrated yogurt whey can be a liquid concentrate or a powder concentrate depending on the amount of water removed from the yogurt whey.
  • Water can be removed by any useful method such as filtration or evaporation. In some embodiments water is removed by membrane separation techniques such as reverse osmosis, nanofiltration or ultrafiltration, for example.
  • Yogurt whey concentrates can have a solids % in a range from about 20% wt to 90% wt.
  • Yogurt whey concentrates can be pumped or transported in some embodiments have been neutralized (having a pH of greater than 5.0 or greater than 5.5 or greater than 6.0) and in other embodiments have not been neutralized (having a pH of less than 5.0).
  • neutralized yogurt whey or powdered compositions have a pH of 6.0 or greater, at least 2% wt calcium, at least 1% wt galactose and at least 6% wt solids or a pH of 6.2 or greater, at least 3% wt calcium, at least 5% wt galactose and less than 5% protein.
  • yogurt whey powdered compositions have at least 2% wt calcium, at least 5% wt galactose, less than 5% wt protein and a moisture content of 5% wt or less or 3% wt or less. In many embodiments, yogurt whey powdered compositions have at least 3% wt calcium, at least 5% wt galactose, less than 5% wt protein and a moisture content of 5% wt or less or 3% wt or less.
  • Yogurt whey and sweet whey contains about 70% wt lactose on a dry basis or is in a range from 50 to 75% wt lactose on a dry basis.
  • the concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can be incorporated into a food product.
  • the neutralized and concentrated yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can replace all or a portion of the sweet whey in products such as food products, for example.
  • the concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can be utilized as food product bulking agent, sweetening agent and nutrient fortificant.
  • the concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can be utilized as a sweetening agent and replace all or a portion of typical sweetening agents that are added to food products.
  • the concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can be utilized as a sweetening agent and replace all or a portion of dextrose that is added to food products such as beverage, bakery or snack products, for example.
  • Other food products include cereal and cereal coatings.
  • the concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can be utilized to replace all or a portion of milk permeate, skim milk powder or non-fat dry milk that are added to food products.
  • the concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can be utilized as a nutrient fortificant.
  • the concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder contains calcium at useful fortificant levels.
  • the concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can contain 3% wt or greater of calcium, on a dry basis.
  • the food product can be a bakery product, a beverage product, a snack product, a confectionery product, a soup product, a dry meal product, a cereal or a dairy product, for example.
  • the neutralized yogurt whey can be provided in the food product in any useful level.
  • the neutralized yogurt whey is a free flowing solid having a moisture content of less than 5% wt or less than 3% wt.
  • the neutralized yogurt whey is liquid flowing material having a solids % in a range from about 20% wt to 90% wt.
  • Examples of food products that may incorporate the neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey described herein include a confectionary, a confectionary coating, a gum, a bakery product, an ice cream, a dairy product, a fruit snack, a chip or crisp, an extruded snack, a tortilla chip or corn chip, a popcorn, a pretzel, a nut, a snack bar, a meal replacement, a ready meal, a soup, a pasta, a canned food, a frozen processed food, a dried processed food, an instant noodle, a chilled processed food, an oil or fat, a sauce dressing or condiment, a dip, a pickled product, a seasoning, a baby food, a spread, a chip or a crisp such as chips or crisps comprising potato, corn, rice, vegetable (including raw, pickled, cooked and dried vegetables), a fruit, a grain, a soup, a seasoning, a ready-to-eat breakfast cereal, hot cereal or dough, or an ice cream such as
  • the neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey described herein can be included in a baking product.
  • the baking product can be in the form of a dry mix, refrigerated or frozen dough or baked product that is refrigerated, frozen or kept at room temperature.
  • Exemplary baking products include pie shells, pancake mixes and biscuit mixes and dough and baked products, sweet rolls and the like.
  • the neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey described herein are incorporated into a nutritional supplement, a vitamin supplement, an infant formula product, a medicinal or pharmaceutical product, or the like.
  • a food product is a processed food product.
  • Food processing includes the transformation of raw ingredients into food or transforming forms of food into other forms of food.
  • Food processing often includes using harvested crops or animal products to produce marketable and often long shelf-life products.
  • Processed food products include products for which additional processing by a consumer may be desired prior to consumption.
  • a food product for which heating, cooking, baking, or the like, may be desired by a consumer prior to consumption may be a processed food product despite not being in its final form (e.g., being unheated, uncooked, unbaked, etc.) prior to delivery to a consumer.
  • Yogurt whey from the production of Greek yogurt was characterized and compared to a typical sweet whey product as described in Dried Dairy Handbook, WI Center for Dairy Research, Smith, Karen. The results of this analysis is shown in the table below.
  • This yogurt whey was concentrated to about 35% wt solids in an evaporator and then pasteurized and neutralized with a 10% solution of calcium hydroxide (Ca(OH) 2 ) to pH targets of 5.5, 6.0, 6.25 and 6.5. Each of these samples were then dried to less than 3% wt moisture. The samples that were neutralized to a pH of 6.0, 6.25 and 6.5 were found to be free flowing powders. It was surprising that the samples that were neutralized to a pH of 6.0, 6.25 and 6.5 were found to be free flowing powders while the sample neutralized to a pH of 5.5 was not a free flowing powder.
  • Ca(OH) 2 calcium hydroxide
  • Yogurt Whey The 6.5 pH sample (referred to as “Yogurt Whey”) was characterized against typical sweet whey and typical whey permeate. The results of this characterization is illustrated in Table 2 below.

Landscapes

  • Life Sciences & Earth Sciences (AREA)
  • Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Food Science & Technology (AREA)
  • Chemical & Material Sciences (AREA)
  • Polymers & Plastics (AREA)
  • Nutrition Science (AREA)
  • Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
  • Microbiology (AREA)
  • Inorganic Chemistry (AREA)
  • Proteomics, Peptides & Aminoacids (AREA)
  • Mycology (AREA)
  • Zoology (AREA)
  • Dairy Products (AREA)

Abstract

A food product comprising a neutralized yogurt whey.

Description

    RELATED APPLICATION
  • The present application is a continuation application of International Application No. PCT/US2013/042579, titled FOOD PRODUCTS WITH YOGURT WHEY, filed on May 24, 2013, which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
  • BACKGROUND
  • Separated yogurt production produces about two pounds of whey for every pound of yogurt produced. The whey by-product produced from yogurt is a relatively new by-product resulting from the recent popularity of separated yogurt quite often referred to as “Greek” yogurt. Traditional yogurt production via cup set or stirred-style vat set processes does not produce a yogurt whey by-product stream. Additionally, yogurt whey is unlike whey produced from cheese manufacturing. Yogurt whey contains less solids and is more acidic than whey produced from the production of cheese. In contrast, sweet whey is manufactured during the production of rennet types of hard cheese like cheddar or Swiss cheese and has a higher solids content and lower acidity. Acid whey is produced during the production of acid types of cheese such as cottage cheese, and contains a higher solids content than yogurt whey. Currently, yogurt whey is used as an agricultural liquid fertilizer. This liquid yogurt whey does not have suitable characteristics for use in processed foods and animal feed, like other whey by-products.
  • SUMMARY
  • The present disclosure relates to a food product including a neutralized yogurt whey. The food product can be bakery product, a beverage product, a snack product, a confectionery product, a soup product, a dry meal product, a cereal or a dairy product, for example.
  • In many embodiments, a food product includes neutralized yogurt whey. The neutralized yogurt whey has the following composition: a pH of 6.0 or greater; at least 100 mg calcium per 100 grams of yogurt whey; at least 1% wt galactose; and at least 6% wt solids.
  • In some embodiments, the yogurt whey in the food product has the following composition: a pH of 6.2 or greater; at least 3% wt calcium; at least 5% wt galactose; at least 95% wt solids; and less than 5% wt protein.
  • These and various other features and advantages will be apparent from a reading of the following detailed description.
  • DETAILED DESCRIPTION
  • Unless otherwise indicated, all numbers expressing feature sizes, amounts, and physical properties used in the specification and claims are to be understood as being modified in all instances by the term “about.” Accordingly, unless indicated to the contrary, the numerical parameters set forth in the foregoing specification and attached claims are approximations that can vary depending upon the properties sought to be obtained by those skilled in the art utilizing the teachings disclosed herein.
  • The recitation of numerical ranges by endpoints includes all numbers subsumed within that range (e.g. 1 to 5 includes 1, 1.5, 2, 2.75, 3, 3.80, 4, and 5) and any range within that range.
  • As used in this specification and the appended claims, the singular forms “a”, “an”, and “the” encompass embodiments having plural referents, unless the content clearly dictates otherwise. As used in this specification and the appended claims, the term “or” is generally employed in its sense including “and/or” unless the content clearly dictates otherwise.
  • “Include,” “including,” or like terms means encompassing but not limited to, that is, including and not exclusive.
  • The term “yogurt whey” refers to the acid whey separation byproduct generated from the traditional method of making Greek yogurt. Yogurt whey is a dilute, acidic liquid containing carbohydrates, milk minerals, protein and cultures.
  • The term “neutralized yogurt whey” refers to yogurt whey that has been neutralized with a basic material to raise the pH of the yogurt whey.
  • As used herein, a “food product” is a food produced by combining two or more edible ingredients.
  • The present disclosure relates to a food product including a neutralized yogurt whey. The food product can be a bakery product, a beverage product, a snack product, a confectionery product, a soup product, a dry meal product, or a dairy product, for example. The neutralized yogurt whey can be provided in the food product in any useful level. In many embodiments the neutralized yogurt whey is a free flowing solid having a moisture content of less than 5% wt or less than 3% wt. In some embodiments the neutralized yogurt whey is liquid flowing material having a solids % in a range from about 20% wt to 90% wt. While the present disclosure is not so limited, an appreciation of various aspects of the disclosure will be gained through a discussion of the examples provided below.
  • Acid whey or yogurt whey is generated in the food industry as a by-product of the traditional method to make Greek yogurt which involves a whey separation process. The resulting whey by-product is a dilute, high acid liquid containing lactose and milk minerals and is referred to herein as “yogurt whey”. Greek yogurt is produced by the fermentation of milk with yogurt cultures. Three pounds of milk produces one pound of Greek Yogurt and two pounds of acid or yogurt whey. Greek yogurt is separated from yogurt whey and the Greek yogurt is then packaged into containers or further processed.
  • This disclosure describes a neutralized and dry yogurt whey concentrate or powder that can be utilized in a food product. The neutralized and dry yogurt whey concentrate or powder can be utilized as a bulking agent, sweetening agent or a mineral fortificant (calcium and phosphorus) for food products. To accomplish this, the separated yogurt whey is pasteurized, concentrated and neutralized with a basic material.
  • In some embodiments the neutralized liquid or powder concentrate product can replace sweet whey in food products, for example. Applicant has discovered no significant sensory differences between 10% w/w solutions of dried sweet whey and the neutralized yogurt whey. In addition, the color of neutralized yogurt whey was more similar to sweet whey than whey permeate. Sweet whey and neutralized yogurt whey have similar opacity and whiteness.
  • Yogurt whey that is separated from Greek yogurt includes a relatively large number of yogurt cultures or colony forming units of yogurt cultures. The yogurt cultures used to form Greek yogurt are Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus and Streptococcus thermophilus bacteria, among others. In many embodiments, yogurt cultures are present in the yogurt whey.
  • Yogurt whey has a pH that is more acidic than whey produced from cheese (i.e., sweet whey). The pH of yogurt whey can be less than 5.0 or less than 4.8 or 4.5 or less. The pH of yogurt whey can be in a range from 4.0 to 5.0 or from 4.3 to 4.7 or from 4.4 to 4.6. Another way to describe acidity is “titratable acidity” or TA which refers to a total acidity and is expressed as %. Titratable acidity can be determined for yogurt whey by titration with a 0.1 N NaOH solution to a 8.2-8.4 pH using phenolphthalein indicator. Yogurt whey has a TA that is greater than a TA of sweet whey. The TA of yogurt whey is at least about 0.2% or at least 0.3% or at least 0.4%. The TA of yogurt whey can be in a range from 0.2 to 0.5% or from 0.3 to 0.5%.
  • Yogurt whey that has just been separated from Greek yogurt has a solids content of less than 10% wt or less than 8% wt or about 6% wt. Yogurt whey can have a solids wt % in a range from 3 to 9% wt or from 4 to 8% wt or from 5 to 6% wt.
  • Yogurt whey has a wt % of protein that is less than whey produced from cheese (i.e., sweet whey). Sweet whey can have about 0.8% wt protein. Yogurt whey has less than 0.5% wt or less than 0.4% wt or about 0.3% wt protein. Yogurt whey can have a protein wt % in a range from 0.1 to 0.5% wt or from 0.2 to 0.4% wt.
  • Yogurt whey has more calcium than whey produced from cheese (i.e., sweet whey). Yogurt whey has at least two times or at least three times or at least 4 times the amount of calcium as sweet whey. Yogurt whey can have about 100 mg/100 g or more of calcium. Yogurt whey contains calcium in a range from 100 to 150 mg/100 g.
  • Yogurt whey has galactose while sweet whey typically does not contain galactose. Yogurt whey can have at least 0.4% wt galactose or at least 0.5% wt galactose. Yogurt whey contains an amount of lactose that is similar to sweet whey. Yogurt whey and sweet whey contains about 70% wt lactose on a dry basis or is in a range from 50 to 75% wt lactose on a dry basis.
  • To be utilized in products such as food products, yogurt whey is pasteurized, concentrated and neutralized with a basic material. These processing steps can be performed in any order. For example the yogurt whey can be first pasteurized, then concentrated and then neutralized and optionally further dried to a powder. In other embodiments, the yogurt whey can be first neutralized, then pasteurized and then concentrated and optionally further dried to a powder. In some embodiments, the yogurt whey can be first concentrated, then neutralized and then pasteurized and optionally further dried to a powder.
  • Neutralizing the yogurt whey is accomplished with an addition of a basic material to form a neutralized yogurt whey. The neutralized yogurt whey has a pH that is greater than 5.0 or greater than 5.5 or greater than 6.0 or greater than 6.2. In many embodiments the neutralized yogurt whey has a pH in a range from about 6.0 to 6.5. The basic material can be any useful basic material. In many embodiments the basic material is a hydroxide such as alkali metal hydroxides or alkali earth metal hydroxides. Alkali metal hydroxides include sodium and potassium hydroxide. Alkali earth metal hydroxides include calcium and magnesium hydroxide. In some embodiments the basic material is a carbonate such as sodium bicarbonate.
  • Yogurt whey can be concentrated by removing water to any useful solids % or moisture content. The concentrated yogurt whey can be a liquid concentrate or a powder concentrate depending on the amount of water removed from the yogurt whey. Water can be removed by any useful method such as filtration or evaporation. In some embodiments water is removed by membrane separation techniques such as reverse osmosis, nanofiltration or ultrafiltration, for example. Yogurt whey concentrates can have a solids % in a range from about 20% wt to 90% wt. Yogurt whey concentrates can be pumped or transported in some embodiments have been neutralized (having a pH of greater than 5.0 or greater than 5.5 or greater than 6.0) and in other embodiments have not been neutralized (having a pH of less than 5.0).
  • Concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey can be dried utilizing any useful drying method. In many embodiments the yogurt whey can be dried with a drum dryer, an oven dryer, a freeze dryer, or any other known drying equipment or process. In many embodiments the dried yogurt whey is a yogurt whey powder having a moisture content of 5% wt or less, or 3% wt or less.
  • In embodiments, the concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey can be dried utilizing spray drying. Surprisingly it is found that when the concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey has a pH of about 6 or greater, the spray dried neutralized yogurt whey forms a free flowing powder.
  • In many embodiments, neutralized yogurt whey or powdered compositions have a pH of 6.0 or greater, at least 2% wt calcium, at least 1% wt galactose and at least 6% wt solids or a pH of 6.2 or greater, at least 3% wt calcium, at least 5% wt galactose and less than 5% protein.
  • In many embodiments, yogurt whey powdered compositions have at least 2% wt calcium, at least 5% wt galactose, less than 5% wt protein and a moisture content of 5% wt or less or 3% wt or less. In many embodiments, yogurt whey powdered compositions have at least 3% wt calcium, at least 5% wt galactose, less than 5% wt protein and a moisture content of 5% wt or less or 3% wt or less. Yogurt whey and sweet whey contains about 70% wt lactose on a dry basis or is in a range from 50 to 75% wt lactose on a dry basis.
  • The concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can be incorporated into a food product. The neutralized and concentrated yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can replace all or a portion of the sweet whey in products such as food products, for example. The concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can be utilized as food product bulking agent, sweetening agent and nutrient fortificant.
  • The concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can be utilized as food product bulking agent and replace all or a portion of sweet whey that is added as a bulking agent. The concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can be utilized as food product bulking agent and replace all or a portion of maltodextrin that is added as a bulking agent to food products. These food products include cereals, soups, yogurts, frostings, fillings, dry cheeses or dry spice mixes, cake mixes and other baking products or meal products.
  • The concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can be utilized as a sweetening agent and replace all or a portion of typical sweetening agents that are added to food products. The concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can be utilized as a sweetening agent and replace all or a portion of dextrose that is added to food products such as beverage, bakery or snack products, for example. Other food products include cereal and cereal coatings.
  • The concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can be utilized to replace all or a portion of milk permeate, skim milk powder or non-fat dry milk that are added to food products.
  • The concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can be utilized as a nutrient fortificant. The concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder contains calcium at useful fortificant levels. For example, the concentrated and neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey powder can contain 3% wt or greater of calcium, on a dry basis.
  • Food products described herein incorporate the neutralized yogurt whey. The food product can be a bakery product, a beverage product, a snack product, a confectionery product, a soup product, a dry meal product, a cereal or a dairy product, for example. The neutralized yogurt whey can be provided in the food product in any useful level. In many embodiments the neutralized yogurt whey is a free flowing solid having a moisture content of less than 5% wt or less than 3% wt. In some embodiments the neutralized yogurt whey is liquid flowing material having a solids % in a range from about 20% wt to 90% wt.
  • Examples of food products that may incorporate the neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey described herein include a confectionary, a confectionary coating, a gum, a bakery product, an ice cream, a dairy product, a fruit snack, a chip or crisp, an extruded snack, a tortilla chip or corn chip, a popcorn, a pretzel, a nut, a snack bar, a meal replacement, a ready meal, a soup, a pasta, a canned food, a frozen processed food, a dried processed food, an instant noodle, a chilled processed food, an oil or fat, a sauce dressing or condiment, a dip, a pickled product, a seasoning, a baby food, a spread, a chip or a crisp such as chips or crisps comprising potato, corn, rice, vegetable (including raw, pickled, cooked and dried vegetables), a fruit, a grain, a soup, a seasoning, a ready-to-eat breakfast cereal, hot cereal or dough, or an ice cream such as a frozen yogurt, a dairy products such as a yogurt or cheese or cheese powders, ready meal, a soup, a pasta, a canned food, a frozen processed food, a dried processed food, an instant noodle, or a chilled processed food, a beverage including beverages that include fiber or protein, energy drinks, or dairy beverages. Further useful products for the inclusion of the neutralized yogurt whey include pet food, an animal product, and a medical food.
  • In embodiments, the neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey described herein can be included in a baking product. The baking product can be in the form of a dry mix, refrigerated or frozen dough or baked product that is refrigerated, frozen or kept at room temperature. Exemplary baking products include pie shells, pancake mixes and biscuit mixes and dough and baked products, sweet rolls and the like.
  • In embodiments, the neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey described herein are incorporated into a nutritional supplement, a vitamin supplement, an infant formula product, a medicinal or pharmaceutical product, or the like.
  • In embodiments, a food product is a processed food product. Food processing includes the transformation of raw ingredients into food or transforming forms of food into other forms of food. Food processing often includes using harvested crops or animal products to produce marketable and often long shelf-life products. Processed food products include products for which additional processing by a consumer may be desired prior to consumption. For example, a food product for which heating, cooking, baking, or the like, may be desired by a consumer prior to consumption may be a processed food product despite not being in its final form (e.g., being unheated, uncooked, unbaked, etc.) prior to delivery to a consumer.
  • Particularly suitable food products including soup, meal kits, grain products such as ready-to-eat cereals, snacks, bars and baked dough, and dairy products such as ice cream, yogurt and cheese. For the purposes of the present disclosure “grain” includes grain and pseudograin. Examples of food grains include corn; sorghum; fonio; millet such as pearl millet, proso millet, finger millet, foxtail millet, Japanese millet, kodo millet and the like; Job's tears; wheat; rice; rye; barley; oat; tritacle; wild rice; teff; amaranth; quinoa; buckwheat; and the like. The neutralized yogurt whey or yogurt whey described herein can also be used in connection with soup, broth, sauce (such as basting sauce), various seasoning sauces, ketchup, dressings, and other like foods.
  • EXAMPLES
  • Yogurt whey from the production of Greek yogurt was characterized and compared to a typical sweet whey product as described in Dried Dairy Handbook, WI Center for Dairy Research, Smith, Karen. The results of this analysis is shown in the table below.
  • TABLE 1
    Sweet Whey Yogurt Whey
    12.5% solids 5.5% solids
    pH 6.2 4.5
    Fat % 0.3 0.03
    Protein % 0.8 0.11
    Carbs % 4.8 3.9
    Moisture % 3.8 1.6
    Ash % 0.5 0.64
    Lactose % 4.8 3.4
    Galactose % 0 0.5
    Ca mg/100 g 45 120
    P mg/100 g 45 61
    Total Acidity 0.10
  • This yogurt whey was concentrated to about 35% wt solids in an evaporator and then pasteurized and neutralized with a 10% solution of calcium hydroxide (Ca(OH)2) to pH targets of 5.5, 6.0, 6.25 and 6.5. Each of these samples were then dried to less than 3% wt moisture. The samples that were neutralized to a pH of 6.0, 6.25 and 6.5 were found to be free flowing powders. It was surprising that the samples that were neutralized to a pH of 6.0, 6.25 and 6.5 were found to be free flowing powders while the sample neutralized to a pH of 5.5 was not a free flowing powder.
  • The 6.5 pH sample (referred to as “Yogurt Whey”) was characterized against typical sweet whey and typical whey permeate. The results of this characterization is illustrated in Table 2 below.
  • TABLE 2
    Sweet Whey Whey Permeate Yogurt Whey
    pH 6.0 6.0 6.5
    Fat % 1.0 0.10 0.26
    Protein % 12 3.6 4.2
    Carbs % 73 86 77
    Moisture % 3.8 1.6 2.8
    Ash % 7.3 8.2 16
    Lactose % 65 87 53
    Galactose % 0 0 7.0
    Ca % 0.58 0.36 3.5
    P % 0.63 0.57 1.1
  • Thus, embodiments of FOOD PRODUCTS WITH YOGURT WHEY are disclosed. The implementations described above and other implementations are within the scope of the following claims. One skilled in the art will appreciate that the present disclosure can be practiced with embodiments other than those disclosed. The disclosed embodiments are presented for purposes of illustration and not limitation.

Claims (20)

What is claimed is:
1. A food product comprising a neutralized yogurt whey.
2. The food product according to claim 1, wherein the food product is a bakery product.
3. The food product according to claim 1, wherein the food product is a beverage product.
4. The food product according to claim 1, wherein the food product is a snack product.
5. The food product according to claim 1, wherein the food product is a confectionery product.
6. The food product according to claim 1, wherein the food product is a soup product.
7. The food product according to claim 1, wherein the food product is dry meal product.
8. The food product according to claim 1, wherein the food product is a dairy product.
9. A food product comprising yogurt whey, the yogurt whey comprising:
a pH of 6.0 or greater;
at least 100 mg calcium per 100 grams of yogurt whey;
at least 0.5% wt galactose; and
at least 10% wt solids.
10. The food product according to claim 9, wherein the yogurt whey comprises:
a pH of 6.2 or greater;
at least 3% wt calcium;
at least 5% wt galactose;
at least 95% wt solids; and
less than 5% wt protein.
11. The food product according to claim 10, wherein the food product is a bakery product.
12. The food product according to claim 9, wherein the food product is a beverage product.
13. The food product according to claim 10, wherein the food product is a snack product.
14. The food product according to claim 9, wherein the food product is a confectionery product.
15. The food product according to claim 9, wherein the food product is a soup product.
16. The food product according to claim 10, wherein the food product is a dry meal product.
17. The food product according to claim 9, wherein the food product is a dairy product.
18. The food product according to claim 10, wherein the food product is a cereal product.
19. The food product according to claim 9, wherein the yogurt whey comprises yogurt cultures.
20. The food product according to claim 10, wherein the wherein the yogurt whey comprises yogurt cultures.
US14/138,608 2013-05-24 2013-12-23 Food products with yogurt whey Abandoned US20140348981A1 (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
US14/138,608 US20140348981A1 (en) 2013-05-24 2013-12-23 Food products with yogurt whey

Applications Claiming Priority (2)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
PCT/US2013/042576 WO2014189519A1 (en) 2013-05-24 2013-05-24 Yogurt whey and method
US14/138,608 US20140348981A1 (en) 2013-05-24 2013-12-23 Food products with yogurt whey

Related Parent Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
PCT/US2013/042576 Continuation WO2014189519A1 (en) 2013-05-24 2013-05-24 Yogurt whey and method

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
US20140348981A1 true US20140348981A1 (en) 2014-11-27

Family

ID=51935545

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
US14/138,608 Abandoned US20140348981A1 (en) 2013-05-24 2013-12-23 Food products with yogurt whey

Country Status (1)

Country Link
US (1) US20140348981A1 (en)

Cited By (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
WO2017132707A1 (en) * 2016-01-27 2017-08-03 Mcintosh Karen Frozen dessert based on whey proteins
CN108094569A (en) * 2017-12-14 2018-06-01 光明乳业股份有限公司 A kind of processing method of acid whey and the food prepared using this method
EP3351110A1 (en) * 2017-01-22 2018-07-25 DMK Deutsches Milchkontor GmbH Process for coupled production of sweet whey and lactic acid from acid whey
US10440971B2 (en) 2013-08-23 2019-10-15 Keller Technologies, Inc. System for drying acid whey

Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
GB2293825A (en) * 1994-10-05 1996-04-10 Waterford Creamery Ltd Manufacture of acid whey powder
US5580592A (en) * 1993-04-09 1996-12-03 Kraft General Foods R & D Inc. Spray drying of acid whey, acid permeate and mixtures thereof
CA2481023A1 (en) * 2002-03-04 2003-09-18 Keller Technologies, Inc. Process for drying high-lactose aqueous fluids

Patent Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US5580592A (en) * 1993-04-09 1996-12-03 Kraft General Foods R & D Inc. Spray drying of acid whey, acid permeate and mixtures thereof
GB2293825A (en) * 1994-10-05 1996-04-10 Waterford Creamery Ltd Manufacture of acid whey powder
CA2481023A1 (en) * 2002-03-04 2003-09-18 Keller Technologies, Inc. Process for drying high-lactose aqueous fluids

Non-Patent Citations (2)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Title
Asada et al. "Acceleration of Hericium erinaceum mycelial growth in submerged culture using yogurt whey as an alternative nitrogen source" Advances in Bioscience and Biotechnology Vol. 3 No. 7 2012 *
Salad in a Jar "18 Ways to Use Whey-a By- Product of Greek Yogurt" https://web.archive.org/web/20110925011413/http://www.salad-in-a-jar.com/recipes-with-yogurt/18-ways-to-use-whey-a-by-product-of-greek-yogurt.6 pages *

Cited By (5)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US10440971B2 (en) 2013-08-23 2019-10-15 Keller Technologies, Inc. System for drying acid whey
WO2017132707A1 (en) * 2016-01-27 2017-08-03 Mcintosh Karen Frozen dessert based on whey proteins
EP3351110A1 (en) * 2017-01-22 2018-07-25 DMK Deutsches Milchkontor GmbH Process for coupled production of sweet whey and lactic acid from acid whey
US10611717B2 (en) 2017-01-22 2020-04-07 Dmk Deutsches Milchkontor Gmbh Process for the coupled production of sweet whey and lactic acid from acid whey
CN108094569A (en) * 2017-12-14 2018-06-01 光明乳业股份有限公司 A kind of processing method of acid whey and the food prepared using this method

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
Aktaş et al. Influence of rice bran and corn bran addition on the selected properties of tarhana, a fermented cereal based food product
Das et al. Production of pumpkin powder and its utilization in bakery products development: a review
US20080057158A1 (en) Lactase-containing comestibles and related methods
US20080160117A1 (en) Composition, a food, and a beverage having an anti-obesity action
Devani et al. Study on quality of white bread enriched with finger millet flour
US20140348981A1 (en) Food products with yogurt whey
JP6696835B2 (en) Fermented flavor liquid manufacturing method and food manufacturing method
AU2017101745A4 (en) Applications of oat syrups
Rai et al. Quality characteristics of biscuits produced from composite flour of wheat, maize and sesame seed
US11116235B2 (en) Food products with yogurt whey
WO2019130264A1 (en) Carbohydrate composition, process for producing the composition and feed and food products comprising such a composition
CN102475242A (en) Fig corn vegetable combined wheaten food
Sadeghi et al. The role of water alternatives in bread formulation and its quality; an emerging source of sustainable and cost-effective bakery improvers
Mustafa et al. Drying of sweet whey using drum dryer technique and utilization of the produced powder in French-type bread and butter cookies
WO2017127769A1 (en) High-protein compositions and methods of their making and use
Mallik et al. Quality of rusks prepared by incorporation of concentrated whey
Bukhovets et al. New production technology for nutritionally enhanced bakery products.
Selvamuthukumaran Spray drying of dairy and cereal food products
Gaddam et al. Complementary health food rich in micronutrients
Singh et al. Cereals, their processing and cereal based dairy and non-dairy products
Hassan et al. Utilization of the permeate as replace sugar to improve biscuits quality
El-Nimer Organoleptic properties and some minerals of junket (a sweet dessert) fortified with husk tomato seeds powder
Adubofuor et al. Sensory evaluation and proximate composition of rock buns and cakes prepared from partially-dried ripe pawpaw pulp incorporated into wheat flour
Mitra et al. Development of Whey Choco Ball and Its Characterization
MA et al. Effect of replacement of water by acid whey at different levels on quality characteristics of flat bread (balady) and fino bread

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
AS Assignment

Owner name: GENERAL MILLS, INC., MINNESOTA

Free format text: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST;ASSIGNORS:SMITH, ERIKA B.;WANG, WENYI;GHOSH, VIKRAMADITYA;SIGNING DATES FROM 20131203 TO 20131217;REEL/FRAME:031850/0495

AS Assignment

Owner name: GENERAL MILLS, INC., MINNESOTA

Free format text: CORRECTIVE ASSIGNMENT TO CORRECT THE EXECUTION DATE OF WENYI WANG SHOULD BE 12-02-2013 PREVIOUSLY RECORDED ON REEL 031850 FRAME 0495. ASSIGNOR(S) HEREBY CONFIRMS THE VIA ASSIGNMENT FILED 12/26/2013;ASSIGNORS:SMITH, ERIKA B.;WANG, WENYI;GHOSH, VIKRAMADITYA;SIGNING DATES FROM 20131202 TO 20131217;REEL/FRAME:032149/0651

STCB Information on status: application discontinuation

Free format text: ABANDONED -- AFTER EXAMINER'S ANSWER OR BOARD OF APPEALS DECISION