GB2285632A

GB2285632A - Thermal barrier coating system for superalloy components

Info

Publication number: GB2285632A
Application number: GB8520732A
Authority: GB
Inventors: Thomas Edward Strangman
Original assignee: Garrett Corp
Current assignee: Garrett Corp
Priority date: 1985-08-19
Filing date: 1985-08-19
Publication date: 1995-07-19
Anticipated expiration: 2005-08-19
Also published as: GB2285632B; FR2718464B1; GB8520732D0; FR2718464A1

Abstract

An improvement in a thermal barrier coating for superalloy turbine engine components subjected to high operating temperatures, such as turbine airfoils, e.g., vanes and blades, is disclosed which eliminates the expensive MCrAlY oxidation resistant bond coating underlayer for a columnar grained ceramic thermal barrier coating. In accordance with my present invention, a relatively low cost thermal barrier coating system for superalloy turbine components is provided which utilizes a diffusion aluminide coating layer as the oxidation resistant bonding surface for the columnar grained ceramic insulating coating.

Description

Thermal Barrier Coating System for Superalloy Components AC An improvement in a thermal barrier coating for superalloy turbine engine components subjected to high operating temperatures, such as turbine airfoils, e.g., vanes and blades, is disclosed which eliminates the expensive MCrAlY oxidation resistant bond coating underlayer for a columnar grained ceramic thermal barrier coating. In accordance with my present invention, a relatively low cost thermal barrier coating system for superalloy turbine components is provided which utilizes a diffusion aluminide coating layer as the oxidation resistant bonding surface for the columnar grained ceramic insulating coating.

BACKGROUND OP THE INVENTION Gas turbine engine fuel efficiency typically improves as turbine gas temperatures increase. Consequently, air-cooled superalloy airfoils have been developed to enhance engine performance. Purther improvements in turbine performance and component durability can be obtained by the use of protective thermal barrier coatings which insulate the component and inhibit oxidation and hot corrosion (accelerated oxidation by fuel and air Impurities such as sulfur and salt) of the superalloy.

A particular type of ceramic coating which is adherent to the metallic component but yet resistant to spalling during thermal cycling, is known as a columnar grained ceramic thermal barrier coating. The ceramic coating layer has a columnar grained microstructure and is bonded to the metal structure.

Porosity between the individual columns permits the columnar grained coating to expand and contract without developing stresses sufficient to induce spalling.

In accordance with present practice, the metallic article to be protected with the thermal barrier ceramic coating must first be coated with an adherent MCrAlY (M = Ni, Co, Be) bond coating under layer which is compositionally tailored to grow an adherent, predominately aluminum oxide scale, which inhibits oxidation of the superalloy and provides a satisfactprvniirj face for the ceramic coating layer.

The cost of the MCrAlY underlayer, which is normally applied by vapor deposition or other conventional coating techniques, adds substantially to the total cost of the thermal barrier coating system.

DISCUSSION OF ThE PRIOR ART My patents No. 4,321,311; 4,401,697 and 4,405,659 and those of Ulion and Ruckle, 4,321,310 and 4,405,660 disclose a thermal barrier coating system for a superalloy, formed by first applying a 1 to 10 mil thick MCrAlY vapor deposition coating on the superalloy substrate followed by the formation of a thin, thermally grown aluminum oxide (alumina) layer to which the columnar grain ceramic thermal barrier coating, e8. zirconia stabilized with yttria oxide, is applied.

When using thermal barrier coatings of the type described in my patent No. 4,321,311, it is common practice to also coat internal aircooling passages with a diffusion aluminide coating to inhibit oxidation at those locations.

During application of the aluminide coating to internal surfaces, external component surfaces will also be coated with a diffusion aluminide unless they are masked. Patent No. 4,005,989 teaches that an aluminide coating layer under an MCrAIY coating will increase coating durability. Consequently, my patent No. 4,321,311 also teaches that an MCrAlY coating over a diffusion aluminide coating will provide an acceptable surface for subsequent application of a columnar grained ceramic thermal barrier coating layer.

Reissue Patent No. 31,339 discloses the application of a MCrAlY bond coat to the superalloy substrate, by plasma spraying, followed by application of an aluminide coating on the MCrAlY bond coating, followed by hot isostatic pressure treatment of the assemblage.

None of the above references, however, suggest that a columnar grained ceramic thermal barrier coating will perform satisfactorily if applied directly to a diffusion aluminide coating formed on the superalloy substrate.

DISCLOSURE OP TBE MENTION In many instances, lower cost diffusion aluminide coatings are sufficient to provide required oxidation resistance to both internal and external surfaces of turbine airfoils. However, an insulative ceramic layer On the external airfoil surfaces will further improve component durability by reducing both metal temperatures and the magnitude of thermal strains in the metal. Alternatively, the benefit of a ceramic layer can be utilized to increase turbine performance by permitting cooling air requirements to be reduced or by allowing turbine inlet temperatures to be increased.

In my prior patent No. 4,321,311, I utilized an MOrAlY bond coating to both inhibit oxidation and provide a bonding surface for the ceramic layer. In most gas turbine applications, however, it is not necessary to use an expensive MCrAlY coating to inhibit oxidation. It was subsequently discovered that for several superalloys it is not necessary to utilize an MCrAIY coating layer to develop an adherent alumina scale, which is necessary for ceramic layer adhesion.In several Instances, it was discovered that a lower cost diffusion aluminide coating could thermally grow an alumina scale with sufficient adhesion for e viable bonding surface. Consequently, the cost of a thermal barrier coating can be significanUy reduced in those instances where the diffusion aluminide coating provides an edequate bonding surface.

Air-cooled turbine blades are typically aluminized on internal surfaces to inhibit oxidation. However, since the diffusion aluminizing process is multidirectional, it can provide an aluminide layer on the entire blade, in. both interior and exterior, and in many instances this diffusion aluminide coating provides adequate oxidation resistance. In accordance with my present invention, it has been found that the ceramic thermal barrier coating may be applied directly to the diffusion aluminide coating, thus eliminating the expensive MCrAlY coating layer. The ceramic thermal barrier coating, in contrast to the aluminide application process, is applied by a line-of-sight process which coats only the desired portion of the component, i.e. the exterior portion of the airfoil.

Although coatings of this invention have been thusfar developed for their thermal barrier benefits, other uses can also be anticipated. In particular, thin ceramic coatings (eg. stabilized zirconia, zircon) applied on top of diffusion aluminides have potential value in inhibiting hot corrosion attack of the component by fuel and air impurities (eg., sulfur and salt). Subsequent densification of the outer surface of the columnar ceramic layer (e.g. by laser glazing) would increase the surface density and hardness and thus provide a barrier to inhibit both hot corrosion and erosion from ingested sand or combustor produced carbon particles.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS My invention will be described hereinafter with reference to the accompanying drawings, wherein: Figure 1 is a cross sectional view of a magnified schematic drawing of the coating of the invention; Figure 2 is a photomicrograph of a superalloy substrate coated in accordance with my invention; and Pigure 3 is a photograph showing turbine blades coated in accordance with this invention.

DESCRIPTION OP TBE PREPERRED EMBODIMENT My present invention involves a thermal barrier coated turbine component which include two inter-related layers on the superalloy substrate. The base metal or substrate of my present invention may be nickel, cobalt or iron base high temperature alloys used for turbine airfoil applications, i.e. blades or vanes. My present invention is particularly applicable to hafnium and/or zirconium containing superalloys such as MAR-M247, IN-100 and MAR-M 509, the compositions of which are shown in Table 1.

TABLE I ALLOY Mo W Ta Al Ti Cr Co Hf V Zr C B Ni Mar-M247 .65 10 3.3 5.5 1.05 8.4 10 1.4 - .055 .15 .15 bal.

IN-100 3.0 - - 5.5 4.7 9.5 15.0 1.0 .06 .17 .015 bal.

Mar-M509 - 7.0 3.5 - 0.25 23.4 Bal. - - .5 .6 - 10.0 Diffusion aluminide coatings have adequate oxide scale adhesion on hafnium and/or zirconium containing superalloys. Oxide scale adhesion may be promoted for coatings of my present invention on superalloys which do not contain hafnium, or a similar element, such as La, by the use of complex diffusion aluminides; i.e. aluminide coatings containing additions of elements which promote oxide scale adhesion, such as Pt, Rh, Si, and Hf.

The diffusion aluminide coating used in connection with my present invention can be applied by standard commercially available aluminide processes whereby aluminum is reacted at the substrate surface to form an aluminum intermetallic compound which provides a reservoir for the alumina scale oxidation resistant layer. Thus the aluminide coating is predominately composed of aluminum intermetallic [eg. NiAl, CoAl, FeAl and (Ni, Co, Fe)A1 phases] formed by reacting aluminum vapor species, aluminum rich alloy powder or surface layer with the substrate elements in the outer layer of the superalloy component. This layer is typically well bonded to the substrate.Aluminiding may be accomplished by one of several conventional prior art techniques, such as, the pack cementation process, spraying, chemical vapor deposition, electrophoresis, sputtering, and slurry sintering with an aluminum rich vapor and appropriate diffusion heat treatments. The aluminiding layer may be applied at a temperature from room temperature to 21000P depending upon the particular aluminiding process employed. The aluminiding layer for my present invention, should be applied to a thickness of about 1 to 5 mils.

Other beneficial elements can also be incorporated into diffusion aluminide coatings by a variety of processes. Beneficial elements include Pt, Si, Hf and oxide particles, such as alumina, yttria, hafnia, for enhancement of alumia scale adhesion, Cr and Mn for hot corrosion resistance, Rh, Ta and Cb for diffusional stability and/or oxidation resistance and Ni, Co for increasing ductility or incipient melting limits. These elements can be added to the surface of the component prior to aluminizing by a wide range of processes including electroplating, pack cementation, chemical vapor deposition, powder metal layer deposition, thermal spray or physical vapor deposition processes.

Some methods of coating, such as slurry fusion, permit some or all of the benefical coating elements, including the aluminum, to be added concurrently. Other processes, such-as chemical vapor aepab;lL1,, Smrr pedR cementation, can be modified to concurrently apply elements such as Si and Cr with the aluminum. In addition, it is obvious to those skilled in the art that diffusion aluminide coatings will contain all elements present within the surface layer of the substrate.

In the specific case of platinum modified diffusion aluminide coating layers, the coating phases adjacent to the alumina scale will be platinum aluminide and/or nickelplatinum aluminide phases (on a Niobase superalloy).

The diffusion aluminide coating in accordance with my present invention provides aluminum rich intermetallic phase(s) at the surface of the substrate which serve as an aluminum reservoir for subsequent alumina scale growth. An alumina scale or layer is utilized in my present invention between the diffusion aluminide coating and the ceramic layer to provide both oxidation resistance and a bonding surface for the ceramic layer. The alumina layer may be formed before the ceramic thermal barrier coating is applied or formed during application of the thermal barrier columnar grained coating. The alumina scale can also be grown subsequent to the application of the ceramic coating by heating the coated article in an oxygen containing atmosphere at a temperature consistent with the temperature capability of the superalloy, or by exposure to the turbine environment.The suSmicron thick alumina scale will thicken on the aluminide surface by heating the material to normal turbine exposure conditions. The thickness of the alumina scale is preferably suSmieron (up to about one micron).

The thermal barrier coating which is applied as the final coating layer in my present invention, is a columnar grained ceramic coating which is tightly bonded to the underlying alumina film on the aluminide coating, which is applied to the substrate. The columnar grains are oriented substantially perpendicular to the surface of the substrate with interstices between the individual columns extending from the surface of the thermal barrier coating down to or near (within a few microns) the alumina film on the aluminide coating. The columnar grained structure of this type of thermal barrier coating minimizes any stresses associated with the difference in the ocoefficients of thermal expansion between the substrate and the thermal barrier coating, which would otherwise cause a failure in a derse or continuous ceramic thermal barrier coating.When he the cledThte tae expands (or contracts) at a greater rate than the ceramic thermal barrier coating. Gaps between the ceramic columnar grains permit the grains to expand and contract without producing sufficient stress to induce spilling or cracking of the thermal barrier coating. This limits the stress at the interface between the substrate and the thermal barrier coating, thus preventing fractures in the ceramic coating.

The columnar grain thermal barrier coating used in my present invention may be any of the conventional ceramic compositions used for this purpose.

Currently the strain-tolerant zirconia coatings are believed to be particularly effective as thermal barrier coatings; however, my present invention is equally applicable to other ceramic thermal barrier coatings. A preferred ceramic coating is the yttria stabilized zirconia coating. These zirconia ceramic layers have a thermal conductivity that is about 1 and one-half orders of magnitude lower than that of the typical superalloy substrate such as MAR-M247. The zirconia may be stablized with CaO, MgO, Ce02 as well as Y203. Other ceramics which are believed to be useful as the columnar type coating materials within the scope of my present invention are alumina, ceria, hafnia (yttria-stabilized), mullite, zirconium silicate and certain borides and nitrides, e.g. titanium diboride, and silicon nitride.

The columnar ceramic material may have some degree of solid solubility with the alumina scale. Also the particular ceramic material selected for use as the columnar grain thermal barrier coating should be stable in the high temperature environment of a gas turbine.

The ceramic layer may be applied by a prior art technique which provides an open columnar microstructure, preferably the electron beam evaporationphysical vapor deposition process. The thickness of the ceramic layer may vary from 1 to 1000pm but is typically in the 50 to 300pm range for typical thermal barrier applications.

The electron beam evaporation-physical vapor deposition process for applying the thermal barrier coating is a modification of the standard high-rate vapor deposition process for metallic coatings. Power to evaporate the ceramic coating material is provided by a highenergy electron beam gun. The zirconia vapor produced by evaporation of the zirconia target material, condenses onto the turbine airfoil component to form the thermal barrier coating. Zirconia coating deposition rates are typically in the range of about 0.01 to 1.0 mils per minute. The parts to be coated are preheated in a load lock by either radiant or electron beam heat sources and/or heated in the coating chamber prior to exposure to the ceramic vapor.During coating, the component temperature is typically maintained in the 1500 to 21 000F range. Since zirconia becomes somewhat oxygen deficient due to partial dissociation during evaporation in a vacuum, oxygen is also bled into the yttria-stablized zirconia vapor cloud to minimize any deviation from stoichiometry during coating.

By my present invention the ceramic thermal barrier coating is applied directly to the diffusion aluminide metallic coating.

In accordance with my present invention, ceramic coatings on turbine airfoils accommodate large strains without developing stresses of a sufficient magnitude to cause spalling. This strain tolerance is achieved by the above mentioned microstructural discontinuities within the columnar grained ceramic insulative layer, which permits the ceramic-layer strain to be accommodated with minimal stress on the ceramic to metal interface region.

Figure 1 is a schematic cross-sectional line drawing showing a coating in accordance with my present invention, wherein the aluminide coating 5 is applied to the superalloy substrate 6 and an adherent alumina scale layer 7 is formed on the aluminide coating 5. The columnar grain ceramic layer 8 overlays the alumina layer 7.

Figure 2 is a photomicrograph of a zirconia insulative layer deposited on superalloy substrate in accordance with my present invention. In this thermal barrier coating system, a diffusion aluminide oxidation resistant layer 10 was deposited directly on the Mar-M 247 superalloy substrate 12 and a yttria stabilized zirconia thermal barrier coating 14 was applied to the substrate. As may be seen from Figure 2, a thin alumina film 16 is formed between the diffusion aluminide coating and the zirconia coating. The Hf content of the superalloy substrate enhances the adhesion of the alumina layer formed on the aluminide and to which the zirconia layer is adherred.

Figure 3 is a photograph of a turboprop engine turbine showing high pressure turbine blades mounted in disc 20. Blades 22 and 24 shown as whitish, have been coated in accordance with my present invention with yttria stabilized zirconia. The blades are shown subsequent to 240 hours service in a TPE 331-10 Turbo-orop Engine.

EXAMPLE 1 TPE 331-10 turboprop engine high pressure turbine blades of IN-100 alloy were coated with a diffusion alummide plus EOPVD yttria-stabilized zirconia system. The commercially available Chromalloy RT-21 pack cementation diffusion nickel aluminide coating was applied to a nominal thickness of 2 mils.

Pollowing application of the diffusion aluminide coating layer, the yttria (approximately 20%) stabilized zirconia coating layer was applied to the surface of the aluminide coated blades, by the commercial Airco Temescal EOPVD process. The thickness of the zirconia coating was also 2 mils. The ceramic coating was applied by evaporating a yttria-stabilized zirconia ingot with power provided by a high-energy electron beam gun focused magnetically onto the zirconia target, which was the vapor source. The cloud of zirconia vapor is produced by the evaporation of the zirconia target material and vapor from this cloud condensed onto the blades at a rate of about 0.2 mil/min. to form the ceramic coating layer. Substrate temperature during coating was about 1S000F.

The coated blades were then installed in the TPE 331-10 engine and successfully tested for 240 hours of engine operating time. Pigure 3 shows the blades after the test, confirming that the blades were in good condition after the 240 hour engine test.

EXAMPLE 2 A burner rig specimen of MAR-M247 was diffusion aluminide coated with the Chromalloy RT-21 pack cementation process to a nominal thickness of 2 mils and then a 5 mil thick Y203 stabilized zirconia coating applied by a commercial Airco Temescal EB-PVD process. A second burner rig specimen was diffusion aluminide coated with Chromalloy's RT 22 process which provides a Pt-modified aluminide coating, and the same columnar grained ceramic coating applied. The burner rig specimens were subjected to a test cycle comprising 4 minutes at 21000F followed by 2 minutes of forced air cooling.

The specimens withstood 400 cycles over a 40 hour period.

EXAMPLE 3 ATF3-6 turbofan engine high pressure turbine paired-vanes of the MAR-M 509 alloy were coated with a diffusion aluminide plus EB-PVD yttria-stabilized zirconia system in accordance with this invention. The commercially available chromalloy RT-l 9 pack cememtation diffusion cobalt aluminide coating was applied to a nominal thickness of 2 mils. Following application of the diffusion aluminide coating layer, the yttria-stabilized (approximately 20%) zirconia coating layer was applied to the surface of the aluminide coated vanes by a commercially available Airco Temescal ESPVD process. The nominal thickness of the zirconia coating was 3 to 8 mils.

These thermal barrier coated paired vanes were concurrently evaluated with paired vanes coated with only the diffusion aluminide for 217 hours in an ATF 36 test engine. Post-test examination indicated that the durability of the thermal barrier coated vanes was increased relative to the vanes without the insulative zirconia coating layer.

While my present invention has been described herein with a certain degree of particularity In reference to certain specific coating and alloy compositions which were formulated and tested, it is to be understood that the scope of my invention is not limited thereto, but should be afforded the iull scope of the appended claims.

Claims

I claim as my invention:

1. A superalloy article having a ceramic thermal barrier coating, comprising: (a) a superalloy substrate, (b) an adherent diffusion aluminide bond coating applied to said substrate and forming a reservoir of aluminum for the formation of an alumina protective scale on said aluminide coated substrate, and (c) a columnar grained ceramic coating bonded to said aluminide alumina coating.

2. The article of Claim 1 wherein said diffusion aluminide coating is from 0.5 to 5 mils thick.

3. The article of Claim 1 wherein the ceramic coating is from 0.5 to 50 mils thick.

4. The article of Claim 1 wherein said diffusion aluminide coating is modified by at least one of the elements selected from the group consisting of Pt, Rh, Si, Hf, Cr, Mn, Ta, and Cb.

5. The article of Claim 1 wherein said diffusion aluminide coating is modified by dispersed particles selected from the group consisting of alumina, yttria or hafnia.

6. The article of Claim 1 having an MCrAlY overlay coating applied to the superalloy substrate under the diffusion aluminide coating.

7. The article of Claim 1 wherein an adherent alumina layer is formed between said aluminide coating and said ceramic coating.

8. The article of Claim 1 wherein said ceramic coating is yttriastabilized zirconia.

9. The article of Claim 1 wherein said ceramic coating is zirconia stabilized with at least one oxide selected from the group consisting of CaO, MgO, and CeO2.

10. The article of Claim 1 wherein said ceramic coating is selected from the group consisting of alumina, ceria, yttria stebilized hafnia, zirconium silicate or mullite.

11. The article of Claim 1 wherein said ceramic coating is selected from the group consisting of borides and nitrides.

12. The article of Claim 1 wherein up to 0.1 mil of the ceramic adjacent to the alumina scale has a denser microstructure, which may vary from equiaxed grains to columnar grains with the balance of the ceramic coating having a fully columnar grained microstructure.

13. The article of Claim 1 wherein the exterior of the ceramic coating is densified by glazing.

14. The method for producing a superalloy article having an adherent ceramic thermal barrier coating thereon, comprising the steps: (a) providing a superalloy substrate with a clean surface; (b) applying a diffusion aluminide layer to the clean superalloy substrate surface, and (c) applying a columnar grained ceramic coating to the diffusion aluminide layer on said superalloy substrate.

15. The method of Claim 14 including the step of forming an adherent alumina layer on said diffusion aluminide coating.

16. The method of Claim 15 wherein said alumina layer is formed on said aluminide coating by heat treating the ceramic coated article in an oxygen containing atmosphere at a temperature of between 1600 and 21000F.

17. The method of Claim 14 including the step of modifying the substrate surface by applying a material selected from the group consisting of h Pt, R@, Si, Hf, Cr, Ta, Cb, alumina, yttria, hafnia, or a MCrAIY surface layer, prior to aluminiding.

18. The method of Claim 14 including the step of densifying the exterior of the ceramic coating by electron beam glazing.

19. The method of Claim 14 including the step of densifying the exterior of the ceramic coating by laser glazing.

20. A method for producing a superalloy article substantially as hereinbefore described with references to the Examples.

20. The method of Claim 14 wherein said columnar grained ceramic coating is applied by vapor deposition.

Amendments to the claims have been filed as follows 1. A superalloy article having a ceramic thermal barrier coating on at least a portion of its surface, comprising: (a) a superalloy substrate, (b) an adherent diffusion aluminide coating applied to said portion of the substrate and adapted to be a reservoir of aluminum for the subsequent in situ formation by oxidation of an alumina protective scale on said aluminide coated substate; and (c) a columnar grained ceramic coating bonded directly to said aluminide coating or said subsequently formed alumina scale and adapted to allow in situ oxidation of said aluminide to alumina.

2. An article according to claim 1, wherein the diffusion aluminide coating is from 0.5 to 5 mils thick.

3. An article according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the ceramic coating is from 0.5 to 50 mils thick.

4. An article according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the diffusion aluminide coating is modified by at least one of the elements selected from the group consisting of Pt, Rh, Si, Hf, Cr, Mn, Ta, and Cb.

5. An article according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the diffusion aluminide coating is modified by dispersed particles selected from the group consisting of alumina, yttria or hafnia.

6. An article according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the ceramic coating is yttria-stabilized zirconia.

7. An article according to any one of claims 1 to 5, wherein the ceramic coating is zirconia stabilized with at least one oxide selected from the group consisting of CaO, MgO, and CeO2.

8. An article according to any one of claims 1 to 5, wherein the ceramic coating is selected from the group consisting of alumina, cera, yttria-stabilized hafnia, zirconium silicate or mullite.

9. An article according to any one of claims 1 to 5, wherein the ceramic coating is selected from the group consisting of borides and nitrides.

10. An article according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein up to 0.1 mil of the ceramic adjacent to the alumina scale has a denser microstructure, which may vary from equiaxed grains to columnar grains with the balance of the ceramic coating having a fully columnar grained microstructure.

11. An article according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the exterior of the ceramic coating is densified by glazing.

12. A method for producing a superalloy article having an adherent ceramic thermal barrier coating thereon, comprising the steps of: (a) providing a superalloy substrate with a clean surface; (b) applying a diffusion aluminide layer to at least a portion of the clean superalloy substrate surface, and (c) applying a columnar grained ceramic coating directly to the diffusion aluminide layer on said superalloy substrate.

13. A method according to claim 12, including the further step of forming, in situ, an adherent alumina layer on the diffusion aluminide coating by oxidation thereof.

14. A method according to claim 13, wherein the alumina layer is formed on the aluminide coating by heat treating the ceramic coated article in an oxygen containing atmosphere at a temperature of between 1600 and 2100-F.

15. A method according to any one of claims 12 to 14, including the step of modifying the substrate surface by applying a material selected from the group consisting of Pt, Rh, Si, Hf, Cr, Ta, Cb, alumina, yttria and hafnia prior to aluminiding.

16. A method according to any one of claims 12 to 15, including the step of densifying the exterior of the ceramic coating by electron beam glazing.

17. A method according to any one of claims 12 to 15, including the step of densifying the exterior of the ceramic coating by laser glazing.

18. A method according to any one of claims 12 to 17, wherein the columnar grained ceramic coating is applied by vapor deposition.

19. A superalloy article as hereinbefore described with references to the Examples.