EP0819991B1

EP0819991B1 - Process control of an electrophotographic device

Info

Publication number: EP0819991B1
Application number: EP19970201898
Authority: EP
Inventors: Jean-Pierre Slabbaert; Robert Jansens; Dirk Broddin; Werner Heirbaut
Original assignee: Punch Graphix International NV
Current assignee: Xeikon Manufacturing NV
Priority date: 1996-07-18
Filing date: 1997-06-21
Publication date: 2006-04-19
Anticipated expiration: 2017-06-21
Also published as: EP0819991A1

Description

Field of the invention

The present invention relates to devices and methods for an image forming apparatus, such as an electrophotographic digital copying machine or digital printer with a two-component development system.

Background of the invention

One of the main factors to quantify the quality of a printed image is the tone scale representation, expressed by the optical density range and the exactness and stability of the contone rendering. In a digital printing machine, such as an electrophotographic engine, each tone of a contone image is produced by a certain spatial combination of some or all of the available tones per pixel. This process is referred to as screening. The set of tones, available in the machine, is defined by the properties of the exposure device. For instance, in an electrophotographic printer that uses a binary exposure device, only two tones (black and white) are available to the screening algorithm to reproduce a contone image. In some machines however, multiple tone levels are available to the screening process by applying area or intensity modulation on the output spot of the exposure device (see below). As screening is well-defined and, by its nature, perfectly repeatable, the image quality of the engine is largely determined by the ability to reproduce the set of tones. In an electrophotographic engine the contone density of each microdot is determined by the mass of toner per unit area transferred to paper. This toner mass, referred to as M/A and expressed in mg/cm², is a function of an almost limitless amount of parameters. Most of these parameters can be regarded as fixed by design and thus invariable during the operation of the engine. Some however are extremely variable. The most important in a two-component developer system are :

toner concentration (TC) = the ratio of the amount of toner and the amount of carrier available in the developing unit in a two-component system.
toner charge per unit of mass (Q/M), expressed in µC/g.
development potential (V_DEV), expressed in Volt = the potential difference V_E-V_B over the development gap between the developer supply roller (bias voltage V_B) and the photosensitive element (voltage after exposure V_E) upon which a latent image is present. The photosensitive element is mostly implemented as an Organic Photoconductor or OPC.
transfer efficiency (TE), expressed in % : the ratio of the amount of toner transferred to the printing medium and the amount of toner developed on the photosensitive element. This dependency can be formally expressed as : $M / A = f (T C, Q / M, V_{DEV}, T E)$

In an electrophotographic engine, the reproduction of multiple tones is highly sensitive to each of these variables. Toner concentration TC changes during engine operation due to depletion of toner caused by image development and toner addition under control of the engine. Toner charge Q/M is determined by :

the triboelectric properties of toner and carrier,
toner concentration TC,
relative humidity RH of the air in the developing unit,
agitation of developer in the developing unit.

When the developer is properly agitated, an unambiguous relationship can be found between Q/M, TC and RH. The development potential V_DEV is determined by :

the initial charge level V_C of the OPC,
the bias voltage V_B applied to the toner supply roller of the developing unit and
the intensity E_EXP of the image dependent illumination of the photosensitive element.

Transfer efficiency TE on its turn is, amongst other factors, determined by :

toner charge Q/M,
amount of toner on the photosensitive element and
the value of the electric field in the transfer zone.

Present electrophotographic machines maintain the optical density of their produced tones by keeping toner concentration TC at a constant level. For this purpose they use a toner concentration sensor in the developing unit, or a density sensor that measures the density D_OPC developed on the OPC, or both. Changes of the toner charge Q/M, due to relative humidity RH or variations of RH are compensated for by changing the development potential V_DEV and the value of the transfer electric field. Disadvantages of this technique are :

extremely low toner charge Q/M at high relative humidity RH, leading to an increase in dust production, fogging and possibly inconsistent transfer quality over the whole tone scale.
extremely high toner charge at low relative humidity, decreasing the developability of the toner. This requires large electric fields in the developing stage and consequently implies more powerful engine hardware.

Furthermore, it can be shown that for a two-component developing system, the development of the latent image is almost purely driven by toner charge Q/M. Therefore toner charge Q/M would be a valuable input to any process control system for steering the electrophotographic process. Generally, online toner charge measurement Q/M can not be implemented easily without the need for high precision measurement hardware, which leads to an increase in system variable cost. As stated before, producing several tones in an electrophotographic engine can be done by area modulation or by intensity modulation of the light beam of the exposure device (or by any combination of both). In this way, a set of microscopic tones at the pixel or microdot level are created. These form a microscopic gradation that has to be kept constant for the contone rendering, handled by the screening process, to be repeatable. US-A-4,026,643 discloses and apparatus and method wherein the toner charge Q/M is determined by combining a measurement of the difference between the photoreceptor potential in the presence and in the absence of charged toner particles with a measurement of a difference in optical reflectance in the presence and in the absence of charged toner particles. The measurement of the difference in the electrostatic potential of the photoreceptor provides a quantity proportional to the toner particle charged per unit area. The measurement of the difference in optical reflectance provides a quantity related to the toner mass per unit area, a quantity that is linear for low particle densities. Combining the two difference measurements provides a value proportional to the Q/M of the toner.
EP-A-510 325 describes an image forming apparatus, a measuring unit for measuring the optical density of an image and control unit for determining an operation condition of the image forming unit based on the measurement.
EP-A-276 107 describes an electrographic image forming apparatus in which image forming conditions, e.g. exposure conditions, are regulated according to the ambient conditions, such as humidity, detected by suitable sensors.

Objects of the invention

It is therefore a first object of the present invention to provide a process control method that maintains quality contone rendering and at the same time avoids negative effects such as excessive dust creation, fogging, deteriorated transfer on paper and necessity of strong electric fields.
It is a further object of the invention to provide a method of measuring toner charge Q/M, online in the engine, without the need for any extra external hardware in the form of sensors or other measuring devices.
Further objects and advantages of the invention will become apparent from the description hereinafter.

Summary of the invention

The above mentioned objects are realised by the specific features according to claim 1. Preferred features of the invention are set out in the dependent claims.
These objects can be accomplished according to the present invention by an electrophotographic image forming apparatus as shown in Fig. 3. This apparatus comprises a charging device 2, such as a scorotron, that charges a photosensitive element 1, such as an Organic Photo conductor (OPC). The charged photoconductor 1 is exposed by an exposure device 3, such as a LASER, an LED-array, a spatial light modulator (like a DMD : deflective mirror device) etc., to form a latent image. The latent image is developed by a two-component developing system to form a toner image. The toner image is transferred to an output medium 22 such as paper or transparency and fused by applying heat and/or mechanical pressure. The apparatus preferentially comprises a densitometer 6 that measures the optical density D of the image developed on the OPC, preferably to correct the developing process for possible deviations. The apparatus contains a contact-less electrostatic voltage sensor 4 that measures the surface potential of the OPC 1. The apparatus preferably also contains a toner concentration sensor 16, preferentially located in the developing system 5. The developability and transferability of the toner particles are maintained over the complete range of environmental conditions, developer lifetime, etc. by keeping the charge of the toner, Q/M, within a narrow range. This range is defined by the unambiguous relationship between Q/M, TC and RH and the range for TC that can be allowed without penalizing developer lifetime. By changing the toner concentration TC by means of toner addition or toner depletion during operation of the engine, toner charge Q/M can be maintained at its required level. Toner charge Q/M may be indirectly measured, based upon the unambiguous relationship that exists between M/A, Q/M and V_DEV, for that range of M/A where development is not limited by toner supply (low- and midtones).

Detailed description of the invention

The invention is described hereinafter by way of examples with reference to the accompanying figures wherein :

Fig. 1: is a graph representing measured points of developability curves typical for a two-component developer for various toner concentration values TC and different relative humidity values RH ;
Fig. 2: is a graph representing the toner charge per unit of mass Q/M of the toner in a two-component developer system as a function of the toner concentration TC, with relative humidity RH as parameter ;
Fig. 3: represents an electrophotographic engine suitable for the current invention ;
Fig. 4: represents a closed loop control system for regulating toner charge Q/M ;
Fig. 5a: represents the discharge potential V_E after exposure of the photosensitive element 1 by the exposure device 3, as a function of the amount of exposure energy E_EXP, along with a reference to the bias potential V_B = -200 V and the charge potential V_C = - 300 V ;
Fig. 5b: represents the development potential V_DEV = V_E - V_B as a function of the exposure energy E_EXP for a charge potential V_C = - 300 V ;
Fig. 5c: represents the transmission density D_TRANS as a function of the exposure energy E_EXP for a charge potential V_C = - 300 V.
Fig. 5d: represents the discharge potential V_E after exposure of the photosensitive element 1 by the exposure device 3, as a function of the amount of exposure energy E_EXP, along with a reference to the bias potential V_B = - 400 V and the charge potential V_C = - 500 V ;
Fig. 5e: represents the development potential V_DEV = V_E - V_B as a function of the exposure energy E_EXP for a charge potential V_C = - 500 V ;
Fig. 5f: represents the transmission density D_TRANS as a function of the exposure energy E_EXP for a charge potential V_C = - 500 V ;
Fig. 6: shows the density D_OPC of 10 patches, as recorded with a densitometer, in a 10 step wedge with respect to relative exposure energy E_EXP/(E_EXP)_MAX ;

While the present invention will hereinafter be described in connection with preferred embodiments thereof, it will be understood that it is not intended to limit the invention to those embodiments. On the contrary, it is intended to cover all alternatives, modifications, and equivalents which are included within the scope of the invention as defined by the appending claims.

Electrophotographic engine

The most important components of an electrophotographic imaging apparatus suitable for the current invention are shown in Fig. 3. A photosensitive element 1, such as an OPC, is charged by a charging device 2 (such as a scorotron) and exposed by an exposure device 3 (laser scan system, LED-array, DMD, etc.). The exposure device 3 is capable of generating more than one exposure energy level E_EXP per pixel. For instance a binary device can image two levels (0 and some other level different from 0), a 16-level (4 bit/pixel information) exposure device can generate 16 distinguishable levels per pixel (including 0), etc. The exposure device 3 receives image data 33 from an image processing unit 14, generally called a RIP or Raster Image Processor, which translates image data, presented in a page description language, to a bitmap. The bitmap contains the required exposure tone level I for each pixel in the image. Inside the exposure device 3 there is preferably a translation table 15 (look-up-table or LUT) to translate the data in the bitmap to physical exposure energy levels E_EXP. The effect of charging to a charge voltage V_C and subsequently discharging by exposure E_EXP can be measured by a contact-less electrostatic voltage sensor 4. The resultant latent image is developed by a two-component developing system 5. Charged toner particles are transferred from the magnetic brush 8 to the OPC surface by the force of the electric field V_DEV present between the OPC surface at potential V_E and the surface of the magnetic roller at potential V_B. The density D _OPC 31 of the developed image can be measured with a densitometer 6 focused on the OPC surface. The engine comprises a toner container 12 from which toner can be added to the developing unit 5 through a control means 13. The developing unit 5 further preferably contains a toner concentration sensor 16 which is merely used as a watchdog for detecting extreme toner concentration values. The toner image is transferred to a medium 7 (paper, transparency, etc.). The engine also contains an environmental sensor 9 (referred to as RH/T sensor) that senses both relative humidity RH and temperature T. Toner particles that are not transferred to the medium 7 are scraped from the OPC by a cleaner system 11 and dumped into the toner waste box 10.

Definitions of terms (see Fig. 3)

The charge potential (V_C 23) of the OPC is defined as the surface voltage with respect to ground after charging the OPC by means of a charging device 2 such as a scorotron and in absence of any exposure to light. The charge potential may be measured by a contact-less electrostatic voltage sensor such as a TREK™ model 856.
The potential after exposure or discharge potential (V_E 27) is defined as the surface voltage of the OPC with respect to ground after charging the OPC followed by exposure E_EXP. The potential after exposure may be measured by a contact-less electrostatic voltage sensor such as a TREK™ model 856
The bias potential (V_B 29) is the voltage of the sleeve of the magnetic roller 8 of the developing unit 5, with respect to ground.
The development potential (V_DEV 30) is the difference V_DEV = V_E - V_B between the potential after exposure V_E 27 and the bias potential V_B 29. When this value is negative, it is regarded as 'not-developing' and considered as set to a value of 0.
The cleaning potential (V_CL) is the difference V_CL = V_B - V_C between the bias potential V_B and the charge potential V_C and is preferentially regarded as a fixed value.
the saturation potential (V_SAT) is the residual potential on the OPC, after a charge cycle followed by exposure with a limitless intensity value E_EXP. For every charge potential V_C there is a constant value for V_SAT.
toner supply (TS) : the amount of toner supplied to the developing gap 28 per second. TS is dependent on toner concentration TC, doctor blade distance, speed of the magnetic roller 8, etc.
toner concentration (TC) : ratio of amount of toner to amount of carrier in the developing unit 5.
PID controller : Proportional, Integral and Differential controller, referring to a general control method, incorporating one, two or three of these techniques, as described in 'Modern Control Engineering' by K. Ogata, Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey.

Measuring Q/M

As described above, the density D_OPC of the developed image on the OPC can be measured online by a densitometer 6. The development potential V_DEV may be measured by a contact-less electrostatic voltage sensor 4. The graph in Fig. 1 represents a set of values for deposited toner mass M/A in a small, rectangular image or patch, homogeneously exposed over its complete area i.e. full density patch. This deposited toner mass M/A is measured for different toner concentrations TC and different relative humidity RH, for a range of values of the development potential V_DEV, divided by the actual toner charge Q/M at which development took place. All data are experimental. From Fig. 1 it can be seen that for low deposited toner mass M/A values (below approximately 0.4 mg/cm²), the toner mass M/A is, to a certain extent, independent of toner concentration TC or relative humidity RH. As a consequence, by developing a full density patch with a M/A within the range of e.g. 0.1 to 0.4 i.e. the linear part of the developability curve, and by measuring both the development potential V_DEV - indirectly by measuring V_E - and the toner mass M/A, the almost linear relationship between M/A and V_DEV / (Q/M), allows to easily extract charge information with a reasonable accuracy i.e. better than 10%. This is regarded as being sufficient.

Stabilizing developability

Fig. 2 shows the toner charge per unit of mass Q/M as a function of toner concentration TC for different values of the relative humidity RH.

Curve 36 represents Q/M = f(TC) for RH = 70 % ;
curve 37 represents Q/M = f(TC) for RH = 50 % ;
curve 38 represents Q/M = f(TC) for RH = 30 %.

As stated earlier, both the developing process and the transfer process benefit from a stable charge level Q/M of the toner. It is the aim of the process control to maintain toner charge Q/M at one level for all environmental conditions. The applied method will be explained below.
From Fig. 2, it can be seen that maintaining toner charge Q/M at one level would require a very wide range of toner concentration TC values to operate in. For instance, keeping the charge at 10 µC/g on the vertical Q/M axis, requires an operative range of 3% to 6% in TC on the horizontal axis. Extreme toner concentration values lead to negative effects on the quality of the developer, for instance shorter lifetime, which have to be avoided. Therefore, the target value of the toner charge Q/M is preferably made dependent on the actual relative humidity of the environment. The relative humidity RH is preferably measured by the environmental RH/T sensor 9 : ${(Q / M)}_{target} = a + b . R H$

where a and b are constants to be chosen based on the actual characteristics of the developer. So, by measuring the toner charge Q/M in the way described earlier and calculating the target value (Q/M)_target based on the environmental relative humidity RH, a closed loop control system can be devised as depicted in Fig. 4. The actual toner charge (Q/M)_actual is calculated by the block 43. The target Q/M is calculated by the block 44. The target and actual toner charge are compared by the comparator 41. Through a control algorithm 42 such as a PID controller, the process control decides on which corrective action to take :

add toner to increase toner concentration TC ; or,
deplete toner to decrease the toner concentration TC. This can be achieved by developing a dummy image and dumping the toner into the toner waste box 10, or - which is the preferred method - not adding toner while images are being made.

Stabilization of microscopic gradation

The figures 5a to 5f present the relationship between exposure energy E_EXP and the discharge potential V_E, development potential V_DEV and density D_TRANS on paper for two different values of the charge potential V_C=-300 V, -500 V.
The relationship is shown between exposure energy E_EXP and :

Charge potential V_C, bias potential V_B, potential after exposure V_E in Fig. 5a for V_C = - 300 V and in Fig. 5d for V_C = - 500 V ;
development potential V_DEV = V_E - V_B for V_C = - 300 V in Fig. 5b and for V_C = - 500 V in Fig. 5e ;
transmission density of an evenly exposed patch D_TRANS for V_C = - 300 V in Fig. 5c and for V_C = - 500 V in Fig. 5f.

From the graphs it becomes very clear that the relationship between exposure energy E_EXP and the resulting transmission density D_TRANS changes drastically :

The minimum exposure energy E_MIN, shown in Fig. 5b and Fig. 5e, that will cause toner to be transferred to the OPC moves from a value of about 3 mJ/m² (Fig. 5b and Fig. 5c) to less than 2 mJ/m² (Fig. 5e and Fig. 5f)
an exposure energy E_EXP of 10 mJ/m² on the OPC results in a density of 0.8 (Fig. 5c) while in the graph of Fig. 5f resulting from the same exposure level E_EXP = 10 mJ/m² but starting from another charge potential V_C = - 500 V the density is about 1.7.

This means that, as the charging potential V_C is being changed in order to maintain the required density D_TRANS as the toner charge Q/M and toner supply TS change, the exposure energy levels E_EXPi that correspond to each of the microscopic tones I_i have to be redefined, in order for the microscopic gradation to remain the same. Several methods can be used for redefining the exposure levels. A first way to do this is to develop a wedge of, for instance, 10 patches, each patch being homogeneously exposed by a different exposure energy E_EXPi, I = 1..10. E_EXPi may be expressed in % of the available range E_MAX for a certain exposure device. The number of patches does not have to correspond to the number of bits/pixel that the engine can produce. The number of patches may be freely chosen depending on the required accuracy of the microscopic gradation calibration. The higher the number the higher the accuracy of the procedure, as described. The wedge may be preferentially measured online by the densitometer 6. The results of such measurement are presented in a graph in Fig. 6. The wedge can be generated at start-up, at regular time intervals after start-up, or after a certain number of prints, or when operating points of the engine have changed significantly, or any combination of these criteria, whatever is appropriate according to the stability of the engine's components. At factory calibration of the engine, a table is preferentially stored in the memory of the controlling microprocessor. This table contains the required output values (D_OPCi)_RQ of the densitometer 6 for each of the microscopic density levels. For instance, in a 4 bit/pixel engine, 16 microscopic density levels (D_OPCi)_RQ can be produced (including density 0). By taking the inverse function of the graph presented in Fig. 6, it is possible to calculate for each entry D_OPCi in the table the corresponding exposure energy E_EXPi, as shown graphically for one value in Fig. 6. On the vertical D_OPC axis the required target density value D _OPC 17 is indicated. Via the sensitometric curve 19 in Fig. 6 D_OPC = f(E_EXP/E_MAX), one can find the corresponding required exposure energy level 18 to achieve the target density D _OPC 17. The exposure level is given as a percentage with respect to E_MAX : the maximum exposure energy level. These values may then be stored in the look-up table (LUT) 15, located in the control electronics of the exposure device.
A second way to re-calibrate the microscopic gradation, is to expose for i = 0 .. 15 to E_EXPi but not develop a similar wedge as the one described above. By means of the electrostatic voltage sensor 4 the development potentials V_DEVi for each of the patches i can be recorded. This allows to construct a graph similar to the one described in Fig. 6.
Preferably, again at factory calibration of the engine, the required development potentials V_DEVi are stored in a table resident in the memory of the controlling microprocessor. By taking the inverse of the recorded function, the required exposure energy level E_EXPi for each of the entries in the table can be found and stored in a LUT 15 inside the exposure device.
Having described in detail preferred embodiments of the current invention, it will now be apparent to those skilled in the art that numerous modifications can be made therein without departing from the scope of the invention as defined in the following claims.

Claims

A method for controlling output density in an electrophotographic device with a two-component development system, said device having a photosensitive element and a toner supply means, said method comprising the following steps:
- establishing a relation between optical density (D_OPC) of applied toner, development voltage (V_DEV) and toner charge (Q/M) of applied toner, the development voltage being the difference between the surface potential on the photosensitive element after an exposure but before toner development and a bias potential on the toner supply means;

- generating on said photosensitive element an electrostatic patch corresponding to medium optical density;

- measuring the development voltage (V_DEV) on said electrostatic patch;

- developing said electrostatic patch by application of toner, giving a toner patch on said photosensitive element;

- measuring the optical density (D_OPC) of said toner patch;

- computing, using said relation, from said development voltage and said optical density, the toner charge (Q/M); and

- modifying toner concentration (TC) in correspondence with said computed toner charge (Q/M).
Method according to claim 1, wherein modification of said toner concentration TC comprises the steps of increasing or decreasing toner supply TS.
Method according to any of the preceding claims, wherein measuring the development voltage V_DEV comprises the steps of :
- measuring potential after exposure V_E of said electrostatic patch ;

- finding bias potential V_B of said toner supply means ;

- making the difference between v_E and V_B.
Method according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the step of modifying said toner concentration TC is based on a target toner charge (Q/M)_TARGET.
Method according to claim 4, wherein said target toner charge (Q/M)_TARGET is computed comprising the following steps :
- establishing a second relation between relative humidity RH and target toner charge ;

- measuring a relative humidity RH ;

- computing using said second relation, from said measured relative humidity, the target toner charge (Q/M)_TARGET.
Method according to claims 4 or 5, comprising the steps of :
- regularly computing the Q/M and (Q/M)_TARGET values ;

- using these values in a PID system to compute the required TC change.
Method according to any of claims 1 to 6, comprising the step of exposing a plurality of patches on said photoconductive element to different exposure levels E_EXPi, constant within each patch.
Method according to claim 7, further comprising the steps of :
- developing said patches by application of toner ;

- measuring the optical density of each patch by a densitometer ;

- establishing a conversion table giving exposure level as a function of required optical density, based on said measured optical density.
Method according to claim 7, further comprising the steps of :
- measuring the voltage level of said exposed patches ;

- establishing a conversion table giving exposure level as a function of required optical density, based on said measured voltage level.
An electrophotographic image forming device with a two component development system comprising:
- a photosensitive member (1);

- a charging device (2) for charging the photosensitive member (1);

- an exposure device (3) for exposing the photosensitive member including exposing a patch thereon;

- a contact-less electrostatic voltage sensor (4) for measuring a discharge potential of the patch, the discharge potential being the surface voltage after exposure but before toner development;

- toner supply means (5) for applying toner to the photosensitive member (1) including applying toner to the patch to develop a toner patch;

- a densitometer (6) for measuring the optical density of the toner patch; and

- a closed-loop control system for computing the toner charge (Q/M) from a predetermined relationship and for modifying toner concentration (TC) in accordance with the computed toner charge (Q/M),
characterised in that said predetermined relationship is between the development voltage of the patch, the optical density of the toner patch and the toner charge (Q/M), the development voltage of the patch being the difference between the discharge potential of the patch and a bias potential on the toner supply means (5).
The electrophotographic image forming device according to claim 10, characterised in that the closed-loop control system includes a calculator (44) for calculating a target toner charge (Q/M_TARGET), and a comparator (41) for comparing the computed toner charge (Q/M) of the toner patch with the target toner charge (Q/M_TARGET).
The electrophotographic image forming device according to claim 11, further characterised by an environment relative humidity sensor (9) and wherein the calculator (44) is adapted to calculate the target toner charge (Q/M_TARGET) based on the environment relative humidity.
The electrophotographic image forming device according to claim 11 or 12, characterised in that the closed-loop control system includes a process controller (42) for controlling the toner concentration (TC) in accordance with the output of the comparator (41).