[go: up one dir, main page]

AU2025204532A1 - Electronic trading systems and methods - Google Patents

Electronic trading systems and methods

Info

Publication number
AU2025204532A1
AU2025204532A1 AU2025204532A AU2025204532A AU2025204532A1 AU 2025204532 A1 AU2025204532 A1 AU 2025204532A1 AU 2025204532 A AU2025204532 A AU 2025204532A AU 2025204532 A AU2025204532 A AU 2025204532A AU 2025204532 A1 AU2025204532 A1 AU 2025204532A1
Authority
AU
Australia
Prior art keywords
order
firm
participant
orders
matching
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Pending
Application number
AU2025204532A
Inventor
Dean P. Alderucci
Andrew Fishkind
Kevin Foley
Brian L. Gay
Howard W. Lutnick
Philip Marber
Mark A. Miller
Charles Plott
Bill Rice
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
CFPH LLC
Original Assignee
CFPH LLC
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Priority claimed from AU2008322494A external-priority patent/AU2008322494B2/en
Priority claimed from AU2016203638A external-priority patent/AU2016203638A1/en
Application filed by CFPH LLC filed Critical CFPH LLC
Priority to AU2025204532A priority Critical patent/AU2025204532A1/en
Publication of AU2025204532A1 publication Critical patent/AU2025204532A1/en
Pending legal-status Critical Current

Links

Landscapes

  • Electrochromic Elements, Electrophoresis, Or Variable Reflection Or Absorption Elements (AREA)
  • Management, Administration, Business Operations System, And Electronic Commerce (AREA)
  • Information Retrieval, Db Structures And Fs Structures Therefor (AREA)

Abstract

#$%^&*AU2025204532A120250710.pdf##### ABSTRACT A trading platform and trading method that allows access to additional pools of liquidity is described. Other embodiments are also described. ABSTRACT A trading platform and trading method that allows access to additional pools of liquidity is described. Other embodiments are also described. 20 25 20 45 32 18 J un 2 02 5 A B S T R A C T 1 8 J u n 2 0 2 5 A t r a d i n g p l a t f o r m a n d t r a d i n g m e t h o d t h a t a l l o w s a c c e s s t o a d d i t i o n a l p o o l s o f l i q u i d i t y i s d e s c r i b e d . O t h e r e m b o d i m e n t s a r e a l s o d e s c r i b e d . 2 0 2 5 2 0 4 5 3 2

Description

ELECTRONIC TRADING SYSTEMS AND METHODS Cross-Reference to Related Applications
[001] This application claims the benefit of priority of each of the
following applications: U.S. Provisional Application Serial No. 60/988,426 filed
November 15, 2007, entitled "TRADING SYSTEM PRODUCTS AND 2025204532
PROCESSES"; U.S. Application Serial No. 12/015,990 filed January, 17 2008,
entitled "TRADING SYSTEM PRODUCTS AND PROCESSES"; U.S. Application Serial No. 12/204,403 filed September 4, 2008, entitled "NON-FIRM
ORDERS IN ELECTRONIC MARKETPLACES"; U.S. Application Serial No. 12/237,941, filed September 25, 2008, entitled "SUBSTITUTABILITY OF
FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS"; U.S. Application Serial No. 12/237,958, filed
September 25, 2008, entitled "GENERATING RISK POOLS"; U.S. Application
Serial No. 12/237,976 filed September 25, 2008, entitled "TRADING RELATED
TO FUND COMPOSITIONS"; U.S. Application Serial No. 12/204,341, filed
September 4, 2008, entitled "CANCELLATION TIMING IN AN ELECTRONIC MARKETPLACE'; U.S. Application Serial No. 12/135,479, filed June 9, 2008,
entitled "TRADING SYSTEM PRODUCTS AND PROCESSES"; U.S. Application Serial No. 12/239,803, filed September 28, 2008, entitled
"INTERACTION WITH TRADING SYSTEMS"; U.S. Application Serial No.
12/239,804, filed September 28, 2008, entitled "TRADING SYSTEM
ACCESSIBILITY"; and U.S. Application Serial No. 12/257,499, filed October 24,
2008, entitled "ORDER CANCELLATION." Each of these applications is hereby
incorporated herein by reference.
Brief Description of the Drawings
[002] Figure 1 illustrates an example computer system;
[003] Figure 2 illustrates an example trading system configured to
perform one or more trades;
[004] Figure 3 illustrates an example process that may be performed by
one or more trading systems;
[005] Figure 4 illustrates an example process that may be performed by a
participant of a trading system;
[006] Figure 5 illustrates an example process that may be used to query a
participant;
[007] Figure 6 illustrates an example process that may be used in
responding to queries; 2025204532
[008] Figure 7 illustrates an example process that may be used for order
entry;
[009] Figure 8 illustrates an example order entry interface;
[010] Figure 9 illustrates an example process that may be used to present
order query information; and
[011] Figure 10 illustrates an example interface for presenting order query
information; and
[012] Figure 11 illustrates an example process that may be used in some
embodiments involving non-firm orders;
[013] Figure 12 illustrates an example system involving alternative
trading systems;
[014] Figure 13 illustrates an example process that involves orders from
alternative trading systems; and
[015] Figure 14 illustrates an example process that may be performed by
an alternative trading system.
Detailed Description
[016] The following sections I - X provide a guide to interpreting the
present application.
I. Terms
[017] The term "product" means any machine, manufacture and / or
composition of matter, unless expressly specified otherwise.
[018] The term "process" means any process, algorithm, method or the
like, unless expressly specified otherwise.
[019] Each process (whether called a method, algorithm or otherwise)
inherently includes one or more steps, and therefore all references to a "step" or
"steps" of a process have an inherent antecedent basis in the mere recitation of the
term 'process' or a like term. Accordingly, any reference in a claim to a 'step' or
'steps' of a process has sufficient antecedent basis.
[020] The term "invention" and the like mean "the one or more inventions
disclosed in this application" unless expressly specified otherwise.
[021] The terms "an embodiment", "embodimen" "embodiments", "the 2025204532
embodiment", "the embodiments", "one or more embodiments", "some
embodiments", "certain embodiments", "one embodiment", "another embodiment"
and the like mean "one or more (but not all) embodiments of the disclosed
invention(s)", unless expressly specified otherwise.
[022] The term "variation" of an invention means an embodiment of the
invention, unless expressly specified otherwise.
[023] A reference to "another embodiment" in describing an embodiment
does not imply that the referenced embodiment is mutually exclusive with another
embodiment (e.g., an embodiment described before the referenced embodiment),
unless expressly specified otherwise.
[024] The terms "including", "comprising" and variations thereof mean
"including but not limited to", unless expressly specified otherwise.
[025] The terms "a", "an" and "the" mean "one or more", unless expressly
specified otherwise.
[026] The term "plurality" means "two or more", unless expressly
specified otherwise.
[027] The term "herein" means "in the present application, including
anything which may be incorporated by reference", unless expressly specified
otherwise.
[028] The phrase "at least one of", when such phrase modifies a plurality
of things (such as an enumerated list of things) means any combination of one or
more of those things, unless expressly specified otherwise. For example, the
phrase "at least one of a widget, a car and a wheel" means either (i) a widget, (ii) a
car, (iii) a wheel, (iv) a widget and a car, (v) a widget and a wheel, (vi) a car and a
wheel, or (vii) a widget, a car and a wheel. The phrase "at least one of", when such
phrase modifies a plurality of things does not mean "one of each of" the plurality
of things.
[029] Numerical terms such as "one", "two", etc. when used as cardinal
numbers to indicate quantity of something (e.g., one widget, two widgets), mean
the quantity indicated by that numerical term, but do not mean at least the quantity
indicated by that numerical term. For example, the phrase "one widget" does not 2025204532
mean "at least one widget", and therefore the phrase "one widget" does not cover,
e.g., two widgets.
[030] The phrase "based on" does not mean "based only on", unless
expressly specified otherwise. In other words, the phrase "based on" describes
both "based only on" and "based at least on". The phrase "based at least on" is
equivalent to the phrase "based at least in part on".
[031] The term "represent" and like terms are not exclusive, unless
expressly specified otherwise. For example, the term "represents" do not mean
"represents only", unless expressly specified otherwise. In other words, the phrase
"the data represents a credit card number" describes both "the data represents only
a credit card number" and "the data represents a credit card number and the data
also represents something else".
[032] The term "whereby" is used herein only to precede a clause or other
set of words that express only the intended result, objective or consequence of
something that is previously and explicitly recited. Thus, when the term
"whereby" is used in a claim, the clause or other words that the term "whereby"
modifies do not establish specific further limitations of the claim or otherwise
restricts the meaning or scope of the claim.
[033] The term "e.g." and like terms mean "for example", and thus does
not limit the term or phrase it explains. For example, in the sentence "the
computer sends data (e.g., instructions, a data structure) over the Internet", the term
"e.g." explains that "instructions" are an example of "data" that the computer may
send over the Internet, and also explains that "a data structure" is an example of
"data" that the computer may send over the Internet. However, both "instructions"
and "a data structure" are merely examples of "data", and other things besides
"instructions" and "a data structure" can be "data".
[034] The term "respective" and like terms mean "taken individually".
Thus if two or more things have "respective" characteristics, then each such thing
has its own characteristic, and these characteristics can be different from each other
but need not be. For example, the phrase "each of two machines has a respective
function" means that the first such machine has a function and the second such
machine has a function as well. The function of the first machine may or may not 2025204532
be the same as the function of the second machine.
[035] The term "i.e." and like terms mean "that is", and thus limits the
term or phrase it explains. For example, in the sentence "the computer sends data
(i.e., instructions) over the Internet", the term "i.e." explains that "instructions" are
the "data" that the computer sends over the Internet.
[036] Any given numerical range shall include whole and fractions of
numbers within the range. For example, the range "1 to 10" shall be interpreted to
specifically include whole numbers between 1 and 10 (e.g., 1, 2, 3, 4, 9) and
non-whole numbers (e.g., , 1.1, 1.2, 1.9).
[037] Where two or more terms or phrases are synonymous (e.g., because
of an explicit statement that the terms or phrases are synonymous), instances of
one such term / phrase does not mean instances of another such term / phrase must
have a different meaning. For example, where a statement renders the meaning of
"including" to be synonymous with "including but not limited to", the mere usage
of the phrase "including but not limited to" does not mean that the term "including"
means something other than "including but not limited to".
[038] The term "facilitating" and like terms may include any action or set
of actions which help to bring about a result. Throughout this disclosure, examples
of facilitation may be given. Such examples should be interpreted as non-limiting
examples only.
[039] An order query should be understood to include information that,
when interpreted by a computer module, identifies an order for which a trade
related action is desired. Such information may be interpreted by the computer
module for use in querying stored information such as a database of stored order
information.
[040] A query should be understood to include information form which a
question may be determined.
[041] A computer module should be understood to include any
combination of hardware and/or software.
[042] A firm order should be understood to include an order for a
financial instrument, for which a system will execute a trade with a matching order 2025204532
without additional intervening authorization from an originator of the firm order.
[043] A financial instrument should be understood to include an
instrument that evinces ownership of dept or equity, and/or any derivative thereof,
including equities, stocks, fixed income instruments, bonds, debentures, certificates
of interest or deposit, warrants, options, futures, forwards, swaps, or generally any
security.
[044] Although some embodiments are described with reference to Order
Management Systems, which are understood in the art, it should be understood that
other embodiments may include an order information system. An order
information system should be understood any system through which information
about orders to purchase and/or sell financial instruments is stored, including, for
example, order management systems.
[045] Two things should be understood to match if they share one or more
properties. The exact properties shared may be different among various
embodiments. Some example properties may include, a type of financial
instrument (e.g., industry, capitalization, risk, etc.), a security identifier (e.g., stock
symbol, etc.), an amount of shares, a price, etc.
[046] A representation of a thing includes any indication from which a
part of an underlying thing may be derived.
[047] Enabling should be understood to include allowing an action to
occur. An action may be enabled by, for example, providing/activating a
mechanism (e.g., a button or other control) through which the action may be
performed (e.g., by clicking a button or otherwise activating another control).
[048] Binding acceptance of an order should be understood to include an
acceptance of a trade fulfilling at least part of the order that does not allow for
further intervention in the execution of the trade and without the ability to revoke
the acceptance (e.g., without the ability to revoke the acceptance in any way,
without the ability to revoke the acceptance without a penalty).
[049] An acceptance of an order should be understood to include an
agreement to participate in a trade fulfilling at least part of the order.
[050] Suppressing evidence should be understood to include attempting to
prevent others from discovering evidence. Suppressing evidence of a situation or 2025204532
action may include not disseminating information about the situation or action,
disseminating false or misleading information about the situation or action,
disseminating false or mislead information at other times to obscure the
dissemination of information about the situation or action, and/or any other desired
actions.
[051] Facilitating execution of a trade should be understood to include
performing any actions that help to bring about the execution of a trade. The
actions may include, for example, actually executing the trade, transmitting a
request for the execution of the trade, transmitting any information that helps to
bring about the trade, and/or any other actions.
[052] A marketplace should be understood to include a platform through
which at least the following actions are performed: order execution is facilitated,
indications of orders are accepted, and matches for the orders are sought.
[053] Applying a filter to a set of things should be understood to include
generating a subset of the set of things in which each thing in the subset has one or
more desired properties.
[054] A trade should be understood to fulfill part of an order for one or
more things if the trade includes transfers of ownership of at least a portion of the
one of more thing in accordance with the order. Fulfilling may include bringing a
trade into effect.
[055] A participant system should be understood to include any system
that allows an order management system to interface with a marketplace.
II. Determining
[056] The term "determining" and grammatical variants thereof (e.g., to
determine a price, determining a value, determine an object which meets a certain
criterion) is used in an extremely broad sense. The term "determining"
encompasses a wide variety of actions and therefore "determining" can include
calculating, computing, processing, deriving, investigating, looking up (e.g.,
looking up in a table, a database or another data structure), ascertaining and the 2025204532
like. Also, "determining" can include receiving (e.g., receiving information),
accessing (e.g., accessing data in a memory) and the like. Also, "determining" can
include resolving, selecting, choosing, establishing, and the like.
[057] The term "determining" does not imply certainty or absolute
precision, and therefore "determining" can include estimating, extrapolating,
predicting, guessing and the like.
[058] The term "determining" does not imply that mathematical
processing must be performed, and does not imply that numerical methods must be
used, and does not imply that an algorithm or process is used.
[059] The term "determining" does not imply that any particular device
must be used. For example, a computer need not necessarily perform the
determining.
III. Forms of Sentences
[060] Where a limitation of a first claim would cover one of a feature as
well as more than one of a feature (e.g., a limitation such as "at least one widget"
covers one widget as well as more than one widget), and where in a second claim
that depends on the first claim, the second claim uses a definite article "the" to
refer to the limitation (e.g., "the widget"), this does not imply that the first claim
covers only one of the feature, and this does not imply that the second claim covers
only one of the feature (e.g., "the widget" can cover both one widget and more than
one widget).
[061] When an ordinal number (such as "first", "second", "third" and SO
on) is used as an adjective before a term, that ordinal number is used (unless
expressly specified otherwise) merely to indicate a particular feature, such as to
distinguish that particular feature from another feature that is described by the
same term or by a similar term. For example, a "first widget" may be SO named
merely to distinguish it from, e.g., a "second widget". Thus, the mere usage of the
ordinal numbers "first" and "second" before the term "widget" does not indicate
any other relationship between the two widgets, and likewise does not indicate any
other characteristics of either or both widgets. For example, the mere usage of the 2025204532
ordinal numbers "first" and "second" before the term "widget" (1) does not indicate
that either widget comes before or after any other in order or location; (2) does not
indicate that either widget occurs or acts before or after any other in time; and (3)
does not indicate that either widget ranks above or below any other, as in
importance or quality. In addition, the mere usage of ordinal numbers does not
define a numerical limit to the features identified with the ordinal numbers. For
example, the mere usage of the ordinal numbers "first" and "second" before the
term "widget" does not indicate that there must be no more than two widgets.
[062] When a single device, article or other product is described herein,
more than one device / article (whether or not they cooperate) may alternatively be
used in place of the single device / article that is described. Accordingly, the
functionality that is described as being possessed by a device may alternatively be
possessed by more than one device / article (whether or not they cooperate).
[063] Similarly, where more than one device, article or other product is
described herein (whether or not they cooperate), a single device / article may
alternatively be used in place of the more than one device or article that is
described. For example, a plurality of computer-based devices may be substituted
with a single computer-based device. Accordingly, the various functionality that is
described as being possessed by more than one device or article may alternatively
be possessed by a single device / article.
[064] The functionality and / or the features of a single device that is
described may be alternatively embodied by one or more other devices which are
described but are not explicitly described as having such functionality / features.
Thus, other embodiments need not include the described device itself, but rather
can include the one or more other devices which would, in those other
embodiments, have such functionality / features.
IV. Disclosed Examples and Terminology Are Not Limiting
[065] Neither the Title (set forth at the beginning of the first page of the
present application) nor the Abstract (set forth at the end of the present application)
is to be taken as limiting in any way as the scope of the disclosed invention(s). An 2025204532
Abstract has been included in this application merely because an Abstract of not
more than 150 words is required under 37 C.F.R. ยง 1.72(b).
[066] The title of the present application and headings of sections
provided in the present application are for convenience only, and are not to be
taken as limiting the disclosure in any way.
[067] Numerous embodiments are described in the present application,
and are presented for illustrative purposes only. The described embodiments are
not, and are not intended to be, limiting in any sense. The presently disclosed
invention(s) are widely applicable to numerous embodiments, as is readily
apparent from the disclosure. One of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that
the disclosed invention(s) may be practiced with various modifications and
alterations, such as structural, logical, software, and electrical modifications.
Although particular features of the disclosed invention(s) may be described with
reference to one or more particular embodiments and / or drawings, it should be
understood that such features are not limited to usage in the one or more particular
embodiments or drawings with reference to which they are described, unless
expressly specified otherwise.
[068] No embodiment of method steps or product elements described in
the present application constitutes the invention claimed herein, or is essential to
the invention claimed herein, or is coextensive with the invention claimed herein,
except where it is either expressly stated to be SO in this specification or expressly
recited in a claim.
[069] The preambles of the claims that follow recite purposes, benefits
and possible uses of the claimed invention only and do not limit the claimed
invention.
[070] The present disclosure is not a literal description of all embodiments
of the invention(s). Also, the present disclosure is not a listing of features of the
invention(s) which must be present in all embodiments.
[071] Devices that are described as in communication with each other
need not be in continuous communication with each other, unless expressly
specified otherwise. On the contrary, such devices need only transmit to each 2025204532
other as necessary or desirable, and may actually refrain from exchanging data
most of the time. For example, a machine in communication with another machine
via the Internet may not transmit data to the other machine for long period of time
(e.g. weeks at a time). In addition, devices that are in communication with each
other may communicate directly or indirectly through one or more intermediaries.
[072] A description of an embodiment with several components or
features does not imply that all or even any of such components / features are
required. On the contrary, a variety of optional components are described to
illustrate the wide variety of possible embodiments of the present invention(s).
Unless otherwise specified explicitly, no component/feature is essential or
required.
[073] Although process steps, algorithms or the like may be described or
claimed in a particular sequential order, such processes may be configured to work
in different orders. In other words, any sequence or order of steps that may be
explicitly described or claimed does not necessarily indicate a requirement that the
steps be performed in that order. The steps of processes described herein may be
performed in any order possible. Further, some steps may be performed
simultaneously despite being described or implied as occurring non-simultaneously
(e.g., because one step is described after the other step). Moreover, the illustration
of a process by its depiction in a drawing does not imply that the illustrated process
is exclusive of other variations and modifications thereto, does not imply that the
illustrated process or any of its steps are necessary to the invention(s), and does not
imply that the illustrated process is preferred.
[074] Although a process may be described as including a plurality of
steps, that does not imply that all or any of the steps are preferred, essential or
required. Various other embodiments within the scope of the described
invention(s) include other processes that omit some or all of the described steps.
Unless otherwise specified explicitly, no step is essential or required.
[075] Although a process may be described singly or without reference to
other products or methods, in an embodiment the process may interact with other
products or methods. For example, such interaction may include linking one
business model to another business model. Such interaction may be provided to 2025204532
enhance the flexibility or desirability of the process.
[076] Although a product may be described as including a plurality of
components, aspects, qualities, characteristics and / or features, that does not
indicate that any or all of the plurality are preferred, essential or required. Various
other embodiments within the scope of the described invention(s) include other
products that omit some or all of the described plurality.
[077] An enumerated list of items (which may or may not be numbered)
does not imply that any or all of the items are mutually exclusive, unless expressly
specified otherwise. Likewise, an enumerated list of items (which may or may not
be numbered) does not imply that any or all of the items are comprehensive of any
category, unless expressly specified otherwise. For example, the enumerated list
"a computer, a laptop, a PDA" does not imply that any or all of the three items of
that list are mutually exclusive and does not imply that any or all of the three items
of that list are comprehensive of any category.
[078] An enumerated list of items (which may or may not be numbered)
does not imply that any or all of the items are equivalent to each other or readily
substituted for each other.
[079] All embodiments are illustrative, and do not imply that the
invention or any embodiments were made or performed, as the case may be.
V. Computing
[080] It will be readily apparent to one of ordinary skill in the art that the
various processes described herein may be implemented by, e.g., appropriately
programmed general purpose computers, special purpose computers and
computing devices. One or more such computers or computing devices may be
referred to as a computer system. Figure 1 illustrates an example computer system.
The computer system comprises a plurality of server computers 101 and client
computers 103. Typically a processor 105 (e.g., one or more microprocessors, one
or more microcontrollers, one or more digital signal processors) will receive
instructions (e.g., from a memory 107 or like device), and execute those
instructions, thereby performing one or more processes defined by those 2025204532
instructions. Instructions may be embodied in, e.g., one or more computer
programs, one or more scripts.
[081] A "processor" means one or more microprocessors, central
processing units (CPUs), computing devices, microcontrollers, digital signal
processors, or like devices or any combination thereof, regardless of the
architecture (e.g., chip-level multiprocessing/multi-core, RISC, CISC,
Microprocessor without Interlocked Pipeline Stages, pipelining configuration,
simultaneous multithreading).
[082] Thus a description of a process is likewise a description of an
apparatus for performing the process. The apparatus that performs the process can
include, e.g., a processor and those input devices and output devices that are
appropriate to perform the process.
[083] Further, programs that implement such methods (as well as other
types of data) may be stored and transmitted using a variety of media (e.g.,
computer readable media) in a number of manners. In some embodiments, hard-
wired circuitry or custom hardware may be used in place of, or in combination
with, some or all of the software instructions that can implement the processes of
various embodiments. Thus, various combinations of hardware and software may
be used instead of software only.
[084] The term "computer-readable medium" refers to any medium, a
plurality of the same, or a combination of different media, which participate in
providing data (e.g., instructions, data structures) which may be read by a
computer, a processor or a like device. Such a medium may take many forms,
including but not limited to, non-volatile media, volatile media, and transmission
media. Non-volatile media include, for example, optical or magnetic disks 109 and
other persistent memory. Volatile media include dynamic random access memory
(DRAM) 111, which typically constitutes the main memory. Transmission media
include coaxial cables, copper wire and fiber optics, including the wires that
comprise a system bus coupled to the processor. Transmission media may include
or convey acoustic waves, light waves and electromagnetic emissions, such as
those generated during radio frequency (RF) and infrared (IR) data
communications. Common forms of computer-readable media include, for 2025204532
example, a floppy disk, a flexible disk, hard disk, magnetic tape, any other
magnetic medium, a CD-ROM, DVD, any other optical medium, punch cards,
paper tape, any other physical medium with patterns of holes, a RAM, a PROM, an
EPROM, a FLASH-EEPROM, any other memory chip or cartridge, a carrier wave
as described hereinafter, or any other medium from which a computer can read.
[085] Various forms of computer readable media may be involved in
carrying data (e.g. sequences of instructions) to a processor. For example, data
may be (i) delivered from RAM to a processor; (ii) carried over a wireless
transmission medium; (iii) formatted and or transmitted according to numerous
formats, standards or protocols, such as Ethernet (or IEEE 802.3), SAP, ATP,
Bluetooth , and TCP/IP, TDMA, CDMA, and 3G; and / or (iv) encrypted to
ensure privacy or prevent fraud in any of a variety of ways well known in the art.
[086] Thus a description of a process is likewise a description of a
computer-readable medium storing a program for performing the process. The
computer-readable medium can store (in any appropriate format) those program
elements which are appropriate to perform the method.
[087] Just as the description of various steps in a process does not indicate
that all the described steps are required, embodiments of an apparatus include a
computer / computing device operable to perform some (but not necessarily all) of
the described process.
[088] Likewise, just as the description of various steps in a process does
not indicate that all the described steps are required, embodiments of a computer-
readable medium storing a program or data structure include a computer-readable
medium storing a program that, when executed, can cause a processor to perform
some (but not necessarily all) of the described process.
[089] A computer system may also include one or more input / output
devices 113. Such input / output devices may include monitors, keyboards, mice,
and r any other desired devices.
[090] Some computer systems may include transmission medium 115,
which may be referred to as a communication network, that couples various
internal components of the computer system. Such a communication network may 2025204532
also be referred to in some implementations as a computer bus. Some computer
systems may include a specialized input/output device 117 configured to connect
to an external communication network. Such a device may be referred to as a
network interface. The external communication network may include a LAN 119
and / or the Internet 121. In some implementations, an edge routing device 123
may operate between a LAN and another network like the Internet 121. Such a
device may include a firewall and / or any other desired security mechanism.
[091] Where databases are described, it will be understood by one of
ordinary skill in the art that (i) alternative database structures to those described
may be readily employed, and (ii) other memory structures besides databases may
be readily employed. Any illustrations or descriptions of any sample databases
presented herein are illustrative arrangements for stored representations of
information. Any number of other arrangements may be employed besides those
suggested by, e.g., tables illustrated in drawings or elsewhere. Similarly, any
illustrated entries of the databases represent exemplary information only; one of
ordinary skill in the art will understand that the number and content of the entries
can be different from those described herein. Further, despite any depiction of the
databases as tables, other formats (including relational databases, object-based
models and / or distributed databases) could be used to store and manipulate the
data types described herein. Likewise, object methods or behaviors of a database
can be used to implement various processes, such as the described herein. In
addition, the databases may, in a known manner, be stored locally or remotely
from a device which accesses data in such a database.
[092] Various embodiments can be configured to work in a network
environment including a computer that is in communication (e.g., via a
communications network) with one or more devices. The computer may
communicate with the devices directly or indirectly, via any wired or wireless
medium (e.g. the Internet, LAN, WAN or Ethernet, Token Ring, a telephone line, a
cable line, a radio channel, an optical communications line, commercial on-line
service providers, bulletin board systems, a satellite communications link, a combination of any of the above). Each of the devices may themselves comprise
computers or other computing devices, such as those based on the Intelยฎ 2025204532
Pentiumยฎ, Core, or CentrinoTM processor, that are adapted to communicate with
the computer. Any number and type of devices may be in communication with the
computer.
[093] In an embodiment, a server computer or centralized authority may
not be necessary or desirable. For example, the present invention may, in an
embodiment, be practiced on one or more devices without a central authority. In
such an embodiment, any functions described herein as performed by the server
computer or data described as stored on the server computer may instead be
performed by or stored on one or more such devices.
[094] Where a process is described, in an embodiment the process may
operate without any user intervention. In another embodiment, the process
includes some human intervention (e.g., a step is performed by or with the
assistance of a human).
VI. Continuing Applications
[095] The present disclosure provides, to one of ordinary skill in the art,
an enabling description of several embodiments and / or inventions. Some of these
embodiments and / or inventions may not be claimed in the present application, but
may nevertheless be claimed in one or more continuing applications that claim the
benefit of priority of the present application.
[096] Applicants intend to file additional applications to pursue patents
for subject matter that has been disclosed and enabled but not claimed in the
present application.
VII. 35 U.S.C. ยง 112, paragraph 6
[097] In a claim, a limitation of the claim which includes the phrase
"means for" or the phrase "step for" means that 35 U.S.C. ยง 112, paragraph 6,
applies to that limitation.
[098] In a claim, a limitation of the claim which does not include the
phrase "means for" or the phrase "step for" means that 35 U.S.C. ยง 112, paragraph
6 does not apply to that limitation, regardless of whether that limitation recites a 2025204532
function without recitation of structure, material or acts for performing that
function. For example, in a claim, the mere use of the phrase "step of" or the
phrase "steps of" in referring to one or more steps of the claim or of another claim
does not mean that 35 U.S.C. ยง 112, paragraph 6, applies to that step(s).
[099] With respect to a means or a step for performing a specified
function in accordance with 35 U.S.C. ยง 112, paragraph 6, the corresponding
structure, material or acts described in the specification, and equivalents thereof,
may perform additional functions as well as the specified function.
[0100] Computers, processors, computing devices and like products are
structures that can perform a wide variety of functions. Such products can be
operable to perform a specified function by executing one or more programs, such
as a program stored in a memory device of that product or in a memory device
which that product accesses. Unless expressly specified otherwise, such a program
need not be based on any particular algorithm, such as any particular algorithm that
might be disclosed in the present application. It is well known to one of ordinary
skill in the art that a specified function may be implemented via different
algorithms, and any of a number of different algorithms would be a mere design
choice for carrying out the specified function.
[0101] Therefore, with respect to a means or a step for performing a
specified function in accordance with 35 U.S.C. ยง 112, paragraph 6, structure
corresponding to a specified function includes any product programmed to perform
the specified function. Such structure includes programmed products which
perform the function, regardless of whether such product is programmed with (i) a
disclosed algorithm for performing the function, (ii) an algorithm that is similar to
a disclosed algorithm, or (iii) a different algorithm for performing the function.
[0102] Where there is recited a means for performing a function hat is a
method, one structure for performing this method includes a computing device
(e.g., a general purpose computer) that is programmed and / or configured with
appropriate hardware to perform that function.
Also includes a computing device (e.g., a general purpose computer) that is
programmed and / or configured with appropriate hardware to perform that 2025204532
function via other algorithms as would be understood by one of ordinary skill in
the art.
VIII. Disclaimer
[0103] Numerous references to a particular embodiment does not indicate a
disclaimer or disavowal of additional, different embodiments, and similarly
references to the description of embodiments which all include a particular feature
does not indicate a disclaimer or disavowal of embodiments which do not include
that particular feature. A clear disclaimer or disavowal in the present application
shall be prefaced by the phrase "does not include" or by the phrase "cannot
perform".
IX. Incorporation By Reference
[0104] Any patent, patent application or other document referred to herein
is incorporated by reference into this patent application as part of the present
disclosure, but only for purposes of written description in accordance with 35
U.S.C. ยง 112, paragraph 1 and enablement in accordance with 35 U.S.C. ยง 112,
paragraph 1, and should in no way be used to limit, define, or otherwise construe
any term of the present application where the present application, without such
incorporation by reference, would not have failed to provide an ascertainable
meaning, but rather would have allowed an ascertainable meaning for such term to
be provided. Thus, the person of ordinary skill in the art need not have been in any
way limited by any embodiments provided in the reference
[0105] Any incorporation by reference does not, in and of itself, imply any
endorsement of, ratification of or acquiescence in any statements, opinions,
arguments or characterizations contained in any incorporated patent, patent
application or other document, unless explicitly specified otherwise in this patent
application.
X. Prosecution History 2025204532
[0106] In interpreting the present application (which includes the claims),
one of ordinary skill in the art shall refer to the prosecution history of the present
application, but not to the prosecution history of any other patent or patent
application, regardless of whether there are other patent applications that are
considered related to the present application, and regardless of whether there are
other patent applications that share a claim of priority with the present application.
XI. Sample Embodiments
[0107] Information about orders for good or service may be tracked by an
order management system (OMS). An order management system may include data
regarding desired, contemplated, open, completed, considered, ongoing and / or
other order. One typical order management system used in securities trading
includes the Fidessa Order Management System. Although this order management
system and embodiments below focus largely on the trading of securities (e.g.,
stocks, bonds, futures, options, derivatives, etc.), it should be recognized that other
embodiments may be used in connection with the trading of any goods and or
services whether tangible (e.g., food, oil, collectibles, etc.) or intangible
(intellectual property rights, contract performance, etc.).
[0108] Information that is stored by an OMS may identify a specific
security that is desired (e.g., by a user of the OMS, by a client of the user of the
OMS, etc.), a type or class of security that is desired, an amount or range of
amounts of a security that is desired, a desired price, price range, and / or pricing
method to be used to buy the security, a limit on a desired price associated with a
limit order for the security, a security to be sold, a price, price range, and / or
pricing method to be used to sell a security, a security desired or available to be
sold (e.g., long and / or short sale), an amount of a security to be sold, contingent
buying and / or selling information (e.g., information identifying a purchase to be
made if some contingent event occurs, information setting amounts based on a
contingent price, etc.), and / or any other information.
[0109] Pricing policies may include any desired pricing policy supported
by a trading system. In some embodiments, such a pricing policy may include, for
example, midpoint pricing in which prices are based on a midpoint between a 2025204532
national best offer and national best bid, limit pricing in which a maximum or
minimum price level cannot be passed, midpoint pricing subject to such a limit,
volume weighted average pricing in which the weighted average price over a
trading period is the bases of the price. Any other methods or combinations of
pricing policies may be used.
[0110] Market liquidity, a measure a securities ability to be bought and / or
sold readily through a market, is recognized as a factor that may affect prices at
which securities are traded. For example, one may have a more difficult time
selling an illiquid security because potential buyers may fear they will be unable to
resell the security after purchase. Such fear may artificially lower the price of the
sale of the security from the true market value of the security to help alleviate the
fears of such potential buyers. Accordingly, a more liquid market may facilitate
trading of securities at their fair market values or closer to their fair market values
than they would be traded at in a less liquid market.
[0111] In some markets, information identifying orders (e.g., bids, offers,
etc.) that is stored by order management systems, or otherwise stored internally by
a trading organization or trader, have not traditionally been thought of as liquidity
available to the market. Rather, such orders typically add to the liquidity of those
markets only when they are made public to the market SO other traders in the
market may act against those orders. Such secret orders may be referred to as
"dark pools" or "dark books" of liquidity because they remain unseen by such
markets.
[0112] It is recognized that enabling trading to take place using such orders
may improve the liquidity of a market and thereby allow more trades to occur
through a market and / or allow trades to occur at a price closer to or at a fair
market value.
[0113] It is recognized that one problem that may be associated with using
such orders in a market includes a potential that information associated with the
existence of otherwise secret orders may be used to influence a market and / or to
diminish an advantage attributable to the originator of the information (e.g., some
insight, knowledge, trading algorithm, etc.). In typical markets, when bids and
offers match, a negotiation may take place between a buyer and a seller before any 2025204532
transaction is finalized. Such negotiations typically include revealing the existence
of a matching party, information about a matching order associated with the
matching party, and / or the identity of the matching party to both parties involved
in the negotiation. By revealing this information, the potential to "game the
market" (e.g., artificially affect a market using knowledge of the existence of
orders of other people) is increased and the possibly secret knowledge embodied
by the orders may be made public. For example, a trader may end a negotiation by
refusing an order in a negotiation. The trader may subsequently use the knowledge
that the matching party is interested in a transaction related to the security to
increase or decrease the price of the security by entering one or more other orders
at higher or lower prices and / or use the knowledge embodied by the order to
adjust otherwise adjust a trading strategy.
[0114] It is recognized that as the size of orders increases, the chances that
a trader associated with such orders is trying to game the market may decrease.
Accordingly, it is recognized that trading large blocks of liquidity may decrease the
probability that gaming is occurring. It is also recognized that if a trader agrees to
have an order executed without a negotiation, without receiving notification before
the execution, and / or otherwise automatically, the chance that the trader is trying
to game the market is also decrease. Furthermore, it is recognized that if
anonymity of trading partners is maintained for part or all of a trading exchange,
the chances of gaming the market are also reduced. Accordingly, participants in
securities markets, such as buy and / or sell side participants) may be more willing
to participate in markets with one or more such characteristics. Further, such
participants may be more willing to allow orders present in OMS to add liquidity
to such markets. Markets with such characteristics may, for example, allow large
blocks of securities to be moved relatively quietly compared to traditional trading
mechanisms.
[0115] It is recognized that in some markets, such as typical
securities markets, participants exist in an asymmetrical relationship. For example,
participants known as sell side firms in securities markets generally act as retail
brokers and researchers for investors. Participants known as buy side firms in 2025204532
securities markets generally include investment institutions that tend to buy and /
or sell large amounts of securities for money-management purposes and keep
information about their trading intentions secret. Accordingly, the desires of these
participants may not be identical. Some embodiments may be configured to treat
differently participants with different characteristics in an attempt to balance
desires of the different participants.
[0116] Some embodiments of a trading system may allow access to what
might be traditionally untapped pools of liquidity (e.g., orders in OMS systems).
Such systems may provide asymmetric access rules to such information to
accommodate desires and / or preferences of market participants. Such systems
may include anonymity policies, order size restrictions, incentives, filtering
policies, and / or automatic execution of types of orders to encourage participation.
[0117] Some embodiments may read information from an OMS or other
source of orders associated with a buy side market participant. Information
regarding such orders may be used to match information from other market
participants with one or more element of anonymity, automatic order execution,
and / or order size policy implementations. In some embodiments, the information
may be narrowcast to potential counter parties for matching with orders associated
with the OMS of those parties. Accordingly, market participants, such as sell side
participants and buy side participants can submit orders, both firm orders and OMS
orders that add liquidity to a market, with a degree of privacy and / or a security
that the market is not being gamed by other participants. A participant may
include a person and/or machine that interfaces in some way with a marketplace to
engage in trading. A participant may include an OMS, a computer that interfaces
with an OMS, and/or any other type of computer or trading-related apparatus.
[0118] In some embodiments, firm orders (i.e., orders for which
participants agree to automatic order execution with matching orders) may be
viewed anonymously by those unlikely to abuse the information, and / or by
nobody at all. In some implementations, such participants may include buy side
participants who may view information about firm orders if a matching order exists
in an OMS associated with a respective buy side participant. In some 2025204532
implementations, such participants may include participants for which matching
firm orders exist (e.g., have been submitted to a trading system). By limiting the
viewing of such information, trading of high quality block liquidity using pools of
liquidity currently not available may be encouraged.
[0119] In some embodiments, control over one or more aspects of
disclosing information about orders in an OMS may reside with buy side
originators of the orders. In some embodiments, sell side participants or other buy
side participants that enter a firm order matching an order in a buy side
participant's OMS may only be notified of the existence of such a matching order
if the buy side participant with the order in its OMS agrees to such notification,
and / or agrees to an execution of a trade. In some embodiments, the sell side
participants or other buy side participants may not be notified of the identity of the
buy side participant at all, but rather only be notified that some matching order was
found and / or executed.
Example Structures
[0120] Figure 2 illustrates one example trading system configured to
perform one or more trades. As illustrated, the trading system may include a
plurality of computer systems at one or more locations. The illustrated
embodiment includes a central system along with a plurality of remote computer
systems. Other embodiments may include different numbers, arrangements and /
or types of computer systems. For example, some embodiments may include
fewer or no remote computer systems. Some other embodiments may include a
more distributed or fully distributed system such as one without any central system
or with a limited central system.
[0121] The central system 201 or a place at which orders are executed may
be called a "marketplace". In some embodiments, various actions, such as firm
order querying, firm order matching, providing indications of firm orders firm
order matches, receipt of indications that firm order queries / firm order matches
exist and / or any other desired actions may occur, for example, upstream from
such a marketplace. 2025204532
[0122] As illustrated, the trading system may include a central system 201.
The central system 201 may include one or more computer systems, each
configured to perform one or more processes. Such computer systems may
receive, transmit, and / or process information as desired. In some
implementations, the central system 201 may be configured to perform actions
including receiving information relating to orders (e.g., firm orders), matching firm
orders, executing trades, facilitating the execution of trades, clearing orders,
facilitating the clearing of orders, communicating with remote systems, settling
orders, reporting trades, querying remote systems to determine if matching order
exist, querying processes or databases to determine if matching orders exist, and /
or any other desired actions.
[0123] In some embodiments, the central system 201 may be distributed
among a plurality of regional hubs. Such distribution may allow a trading system
to span a very large geographic area through which a very large number of trades
may be routed. Such regional hubs may include duplication and / or distribution of
functionality.
[0124] In some embodiments, the central system 201 may be responsible
for facilitating one or more functions typically referred to as "back office"
functions. For example, the central system 201 may facilitate clearing of trades,
settling of trades, reporting of trades, credit checking of participants, other
functions required for compliance with rules and regulations, and / or any other
desired functions.
[0125] In some embodiments, the central system 201 may include a firm
order matching system. Such a system may be configured to determine if firm
orders match other firm orders and / or perform other functions related to such firm
order matching. In some embodiments, the central system may include an order
router matching module. Such a module may be configured to route order queries
to one or more participants and / or perform any desired actions associated with
OMS orders. In some embodiments, the central system may include a regulation
NMS system. Such a system may interface with one or more other securities
markets to find better pricing options for an order. Such action may be required in
some embodiments because of securities regulations. 2025204532
[0126] In some embodiments, the central system may be coupled to one or
more remote systems by a communication network 203. The communication
network 203 may include the Internet, one or more local area networks, and / or
any other desired communication medium. The communication network 203 may
allow the central system to transmit and / or receive information to and / or from
remote systems, such as computer systems associated with market participants. In
some embodiments, communication between systems, modules, processes, and / or
programs may include the use of Financial Information eXchange messaging.
Such messaging may be encrypted or not as desired. In some embodiments, one or
more firewalls or other security device may be included in the communication
network 203.
[0127] In some embodiments, system 200 may include one or more sell
side computer systems, each indicated by 205. The sell side systems 205 may
include one or more trading computers configured to accept information regarding
security offers (e.g., firm orders to buy and / or sell securities). The sell side
systems 205 may be configured to receive, send, and / or processes information. In
some embodiments, the sell side systems 205 may be configured to transmit one or
more indications of such orders to the central system 201 over the communication
network 203. In some distributed embodiments, the sell side systems 205 may be
configure to transfer information to one or more other sell side systems 205 and /
or buy side systems 207. In some embodiments, the sell side systems 205 may be
configured to receive information identifying a completed order execution (e.g.,
from the central system 201) and may provide an indication of such an indication
to a user (e.g., through a trading interface). In some embodiments, the sell side
systems 205 may be configured to interact with the central system 201 or an
otherwise distributed system. In some embodiments, a separate computer system
may act as an interface between the central system 201 or otherwise distributed
system and the rest of the sell side system 205. Although the sell side systems 205
are shown as a single system, it should be recognized that any number of
computers may be used to perform any desired functions of a sell side system.
[0128] Some embodiments may include one or more buy side systems,
each indicated at 207. In some embodiments, all or part of the buy side systems 2025204532
207 may be located with a buy side market participant. In some embodiments, all
or part of the buy side systems 207 may be distributed or located at a central
location, such as with central system 201.
[0129] In some embodiments, the buy side systems 207 may include one or
more trader systems, each indicated at block 209. The trader systems 209 may
provide an interface to one or more traders through which information may be
obtained or provided. Traders, for example, may enter order information and / or
receive indications associated with orders through a trader systems 209.
[0130] In some embodiments, the buy side systems 207 may include one or
more OMS systems 211. The OMS systems 211 may perform one or more
functions typically performed by an OMS. Such functions may include storing
order information, providing order information to trader computers, and / or any
other desired functions. As mentioned above, one example OMS system includes
the Fidessa OMS system.
[0131] In some embodiments, the buy side systems 207 may include one or
more participant systems 213. In some embodiments, the participant systems 213
may act as an interface between the central system 201 or an otherwise distributed
system and the rest of the buy side system 207. In some embodiments, the
participant system may perform function related to trading, such as storing order
information, receiving firm order queries, executing orders, facilitating execution
of orders, clearing orders, facilitating clearing of orders, transmitting order
information, determining if matching orders exist, providing indication regarding
order queries, searching existing orders, determining if an order is a firm order or a
OMS order, and / or any other desired functions. Participant systems may enhance
the functionality of traditional OMS systems by allowing otherwise unavailable
pools of liquidity to become available to a market. In various embodiments,
participant systems may query an OMS for updated information (pull information
from the OMS), may receive updates from the OMS as information in the OMS
changes (information may be pushed from the OMS), and/or synchronize with an
OMS in any desired way.
[0132] In some embodiments, participant systems 213 may query (e.g.,
periodically, randomly, etc.) OMS systems 211 to generate a copy of an OMS 2025204532
database. In some embodiments, the OMS systems 211 may send information to
the participant systems 213 in response to such queries and / or without any
querying taking place. Such information may include indications of orders in the
OMS database (e.g., updates of prior orders, changes to orders, deletions of orders,
new orders, complete database copies, etc.) In some embodiments, a participant
system 213 may directly access the OMS database (e.g., without the need to make
a copy) of the OMS system 211, such as by querying the database. In still other
embodiments, the OMs system and participant system may be a single system, and
such distinctions may not be relevant.
[0133] In some embodiments, buy side order information may be
maintained in confidence on buy side systems, which may be located on respective
buy side participants' premises. By SO maintaining the information, buy side
participants may feel more secure about the use of such information for trading and
be less worried about potential information leakage.
[0134] In some embodiments, one or more software modules may act as
part of an OMS system 211 to provide some or all buy side functionality. Such
modules may exist in addition to and / or as an alternative to the participant system
213. For example, the module may include an update to an OMS software or a
companion program to an OMS software program.
[0135] Although Figure 2 shows OMS systems, participant systems and
trading systems as separate systems, it should be understood that any configuration
of systems may be used. For example a single system may operate as all or part of
any other systems (e.g., a single system may act as an OMS system and a
participant system, etc.) Furthermore, various systems may share information and
/ or distribute the performance of functions. For example, an OMS system may
maintain an order database that may be read by one or more or a trading system, a
participant system, and / or any other desired system.
[0136] In some embodiments, one or more of the buy side or sell side
systems may include mobile devices. Such mobile devices may include laptop
computers, PDAs, cellular telephones, and / or any other desired mobile device.
[0137] In some embodiments one or more software modules may act as 2025204532
companions and / or replacements to trading interface software and / or OMS
software. Such companion or replacement software may include additional and
or different options from traditional interface and / or OMS software.
[0138] Although Figure 2 shows buy side systems 207 and sell side
systems 205 as connected to separate parts of communication network 203, it
should be understood that such systems may be connected to a same network such
as the Internet or any other communication network.
[0139] In some embodiments, one or more participants may use a virtual
OMS rather than a traditional OMS. It should be understood that reference to an
OMS includes reference to such a virtual OMS. A virtual OMS may include a
system that acts as a dedicated OMS for a plurality of participants, but in reality is
a shared system. For example, in some implementations, a virtual OMs may
include a system that is remote from a participant and accessed over the Internet.
The system may include a separate database for each such participant for tracking
typical OMS information. It should be understood that some systems may include
a single database with a participant identifier, and/or any other method of storing
information that may be used in providing virtual OMS services to participants.
The use of a virtual OMS may provide a participant with OMS services without the
need to maintain and/or purchase a dedicated OMS system.
Example System Processes
[0140] Figure 3 illustrates an example process 300 that may begin at block
301. In some embodiments, process 300 may be performed by the central system
201. In other embodiments, process 300 may be performed by one or more
distributed computer systems.
[0141] As indicated at block 303, process 300 may include receiving an
indication of an order. In some implementations, the order may be a firm order. In
some embodiments, such an indication may be considered a binding indication on
the part of the firm order submitter. For example, central system 201 may receive
an indication of such an order from a buy side system (e.g., 207) and / or a sell side
system (e.g., 205). Such orders may be entered, for example by a trader using a 2025204532
trading interface at a buy or sell side firm. The indication of the firm order may
identify that an originator of the order is committed to a transaction (e.g., a bid,
offer, etc.). In some embodiments, an indication of an order may indicate an
amount of a security to buy or sell, a time for a firm order to remain open, a price
at or around which to buy the security, a limit price, a pricing method, an order
identifier, and / or any other information. The order may define a side of a trade
for a financial instrument. A side of a trade for a financial instrument may include
one of a desire to buy a financial instrument and a desire to sell a financial
instrument.
[0142] As indicated at block 305, process 300 may include determining if
any matching firm orders are available. A matching order may include an order
that includes complementary terms to the firm order. Such terms may include a
security, an amount, a price, a time frame, and / or any other desired information.
For example, the firm order may indicate that 10,000 shares of eSpeed stock
should be purchased at an average price of $100.00 per share. A prior firm order
may have been received that indicates 10,000 shares of eSpeed stock should be
sold at an average price of $100.00 per share. The prior eSpeed order may be
determined to match the later eSpeed order in such a situation. In some
embodiments, orders within a price range, below a maximum price, above a
minimum price, and / or matching in any other desired ways may also be
determined to be matching. In some embodiments, orders for a larger number of
smaller number of shares may be determined to be matching. In some
embodiments, an indication of a firm order may identify a minimum and / or
maximum order size / percentages for which other firm orders may be determined
to be matching.
[0143] In some embodiments, multiple orders may be determined to be
matching according to some priority mechanism SO that a total number of shares of
all matching orders sums to at least as much as a number indicated by the firm
order indication. In some embodiments, in which multiple orders are determined
to be matching, a priority may be assigned to some of the orders based one or more
characteristics of the orders, an originator of the orders, and / or any other 2025204532
characteristic.
[0144] In some embodiments, a matching firm order may have been
received from a buy or sell side system. Such a matching order may have been
stored on a machine readable medium (e.g., a disk drive of the central system 201).
Determining if a matching firm order has previously been received may include
searching a database or other listing of previously received firm orders. Such a
database may be keyed to allow quick lookup, such as by security identifier (e.g.,
stock symbol).
[0145] Some embodiments may include maintaining a listing of firm
orders. Such a listing may include a database. Maintaining the listing may include
adding newly received firm orders to the listing, deleting fulfilled firm orders from
the listing, deleting expired firm orders from the listing, and / or any other desired
actions.
[0146] As indicated at block 307, if one or more matching firm order is
determined to exist, the execution of some or all of those matching firm orders may
be facilitated to fulfill the received firm order. Each such matching orders may
fully or partially fulfill the received firm order. Facilitating the execution may
include performing an exchange of money for a security, clearing such an
exchange, transmitting information to a remote execution and / or clearing service,
notifying participants, and / or any other desired action. A trade may be facilitated
at a price and/or with a quantity that may be identified from a query.
[0147] In some embodiments in which multiple matching orders exist, the
matching orders may be matched to the received firm order based on any desired
prioritizing mechanism. Such prioritizing mechanism may include prioritizing
based on price of security, first come first serve, priority given to older and / or
most active originators of orders, large orders may be matched first, priority given
to closest match in price and / or size, a round robin system, and / or any other
desired prioritizing method. In some embodiments, multiple orders may be
combined together to fully fulfill as many existing offers as possible. In some
embodiments, part of each matching order may be fulfilled. The part may
correspond to some characteristic of the order or order originator, such as order
size, loyalty of originator, activeness of originator, actual price compared to 2025204532
desired price, etc.
[0148] In some embodiments, process 300 may end at block 309 if a
matching firm order is found. In some embodiments, if one or more matching firm
orders exist but do not completely fulfill the received firm order, execution of the
matching firm order may be facilitated, and a remaining balance of the firm order
may be treated as if no matching firm order had been found (e.g., may continue as
described below with a firm order that includes only the left over order amount).
[0149] In some embodiments, as indicated at block 311, process 300 may
include querying one or more participants to find a matching order. In some
embodiments, querying the participants may include transmitting one or more
requests from a central system (e.g., 201) to a buy side system (e.g., 207). In other
embodiments, querying the participants may include transmitting requests from a
computer of a distributed system to another computer of the distributed system,
such as from one buy side participant to another, or one sell side participant to a
buy side participant, etc. In some embodiments, such querying may continue from
one participant to another participant in a tree like fashion in which one or more
participants queries one or more further participants which may themselves
continue querying further participants and SO on. Such action may be taken if no
matching firm order was found or an incomplete set of matching firm orders was
previously found as described above. In still other embodiments, querying may
include transmitting requests to other processes, threads, memory locations,
portion of a computer program, etc. executing by a single system, such as central
system 201 or multiple systems, such as a distributed system.
[0150] Systems associated with market participants (e.g., buy side system
207, participant systems 205, 207) may be configured to accept requests and
determine if matching OMS orders exist. In some situations, which are discussed
in more detail below, some such systems may respond to a query indicating that a
match exists. In some implementations such a response may include an indication
that the trade has already been executed and / or cleared (e.g., by a remote system
to which a request was transmitted, some other system, etc.).
[0151] In some embodiments, the act of querying and / or some or all
response that may be received may be concealed and / or otherwise suppressed 2025204532
from an originator of the firm order and / or any other individual. For example, if a
negative response is received, such a response may not be revealed to the
originator of the firm order. In some embodiments, as discussed below, only a
positive response may be revealed. In some embodiments, negative response may
be eliminated or otherwise suppressed. By limiting responses, actions may be kept
secret from originators of the order and the participants may be granted an
additional level of anonymity, thereby encouraging them to participate in the
trading system because the opportunity and / or chances to game the market may
be reduced.
[0152] As indicated at block 313, process 300 may include receiving
additional firm orders from various other firm order sources such as buy side and
or sell side participants. Such receipt of new firm orders may occur substantially
simultaneously as the querying of participants. Such new firm orders may be
compared with the received firm order from block 303 to determine if they are
matching, similar to the description above with respect to block 305.
[0153] As indicated at block 315, process 300 may include determining if a
matching order is found. Finding a matching order may include receiving a new
firm order from another source and / or receiving a response from a participant that
a matching order exists.
[0154] If no matching order is determined to exist, process 300 may loop
back to block 311. In various embodiments, the participants may be queried
periodically. The period may be any length, such as 30 seconds, 30 minutes, a
random length, a length based on some characteristic of a trader and / or order, etc.
In various embodiments, participants may be queried until either a match is found,
a matching firm order is received, a time period associated with the firm order
expires, the firm order is revoked, and / or any other desired length of time.
[0155] If one or more matching orders is determined to exist, process 300
may include facilitating execution of a trade fulfilling the firm order and the one or
more matching orders as indicated at block 317. In some embodiments, facilitating
may include executing a trade, clearing a trade, transmitting indications that
execution or clearing of a trade should be performed by a remote system, and / or
any other desired actions. In some embodiments, execution of the trade may occur 2025204532
at a remote server, such as one or more servers at which a firm order match is
found (e.g., a buy side system, etc.), and / or a central system, such as central
system 201
[0156] In some embodiments, a matching order may not fulfill a whole
firm order. In such situations, process 300 may continue to search for matching
orders, e.g., by querying remote servers and awaiting new firm orders in a loop to
block 311.
[0157] In some embodiments, multiple matching orders may be found
within a relatively short period of time. For example, multiple firm orders may be
received and / or multiple OMS orders may be found at participants within a
relatively short period of time. Such a time period may be any amount of time
desired, such as 1 second, 1 minute, etc.
[0158] In various embodiments, order execution with such matching orders
found within such a short period of time may be based on some desired set of
priorities. In such embodiments, matching orders found with in the short period of
time may be treated as if they were found simultaneously and executed based on
some other priority mechanism. For example, firm orders may be executed first, or
orders found through querying participants may be executed first, first entered
orders may be executed first, larger orders may be executed first, smaller orders
may be executed first, older orders may be executed first, newer orders may be
executed first, best customers may have their orders executed first, highest ranked
customers may have their orders executed first, customers willing to be charged a
fee may have their orders executed first, and / or any other method may be used to
determine execution order. In other embodiments, order execution may be based
strictly on the order in which the matching order is found.
[0159] Process 300 may end at block 319 after facilitation of the execution
of the orders is complete. In some embodiments, one or more participants, such as
originators of the orders may be notified of execution. In some embodiments, the
order of acts may not be the same is indicated in process 300. In some
embodiments, process 300 may include additional actions, fewer actions, and / or
different actions. Process 300 or a similar process may be performed by any 2025204532
computer system or systems in a centralized and / or distributed manner.
Example Participant Processes
[0160] Figure 4 illustrates an example process 400 that begins at block 401
and that may be performed by a participant (e.g., by buy side system 207). In other
embodiments, some or all of process 400 may be performed at a centralized
location, such as by central system 201, or a distributed location, such as by sell
side systems or buy side systems. Process 400 may, in part, be performed to
facilitate responses to queries and / or to provide indications of firm orders, as
those described above with respect to process 300. In some embodiments, process
400 may be performed by an OMS system, a separate participant system, a buy
side or sell side trader's computer, or any other computer system such as one
configured to receive and process orders.
[0161] As indicated at block 403, process 400 may include receiving an
indication of an order. Such an indication may be received, for example, from a
trader entering information about desired trades through a trading interface. The
indication may include an identification of a price, an amount of a security to buy
or sell, a time for an order to remain open, a price at or around which to buy the
security, a limit price, a pricing method, an order identifier, and / or any other
information.
[0162] As indicated at block 405, process 400 may include determining if
the order is a firm order. A firm order, as described above, may indicate that an
order should be executed substantially automatically. A OMS order, may indicate
that the information about the order is to remain secret from other market
participants and / or should not be automatically executed against. Some
embodiments may not include a separate act of determining a type of order. For
example, in some embodiments, different processes, threads, and / or systems may
receive the different types of orders, SO that the act of receiving the order itself
identifies the type of order. For example, a trader may use one interface to submit
an OMS order (e.g., to an OMS system, to a participant system, etc.) and use a
different interface to submit a firm order (e.g., to a central system, etc.). In some 2025204532
embodiments, a single program may be used to submit the different order types,
and the program may make the determination (e.g., based on different buttons
pressed, based on different checkboxes selected, etc.).
[0163] As indicated at block 407, if the order is a firm order, process 400
may include providing the indication of the order for firm order execution. Such
providing may include transmitting information about the order to the central
system 201, or a distributed system. Such an order may be received by such
system, which may attempt to execute the order substantially automatically (e.g.,
using a process similar to process 300). In some embodiments, such providing
may include providing the information to a processing thread or program executed
by one or more computing devices. Process 400 may end at block 409 if the order
is a firm order. In other embodiments process 400 may continue to provide
updated information about the execution of the firm order, such as through an
interface of a trading computer.
[0164] As indicated at block 411, if the order is not a firm order, process
400 may include an act of storing information about the order. Storing the
information may include storing the information on a machine readable medium,
such as in RAM, on a hard disk, etc. The medium may be part of / associated with
one or more of an OMS system and / or a participant system. The information may
be stored in one or more database tables configured to store information about
orders. Such a database table may be arranged for easy searching of orders to
determining if an incoming order request matches any of the ordered stored in the
database. For example, in some embodiments, the database may be keyed by a
name of a security.
[0165] Some embodiments may include maintaining stored information.
Such information may be maintained similar to the maintenance of order
information in a typical OMS system. In some embodiments, maintenance may
include the actions of an OMS and / or a participant system. Maintenance may
include updating orders executed in connection with matching firm order queries.
For example, order information may be removed/updated when an order is fully
or partially fulfilled, an order expires, an order is explicitly removed or updated by
a trader, and / or for any other desired reason. 2025204532
[0166] As indicated at block 413, process 400 may include receive
incoming firm order queries. An incoming firm order query may indicate an
identification of a price, an amount of a security to buy or sell, a time for an order
to remain open, a price at or around which to buy the security, a limit price, a
pricing method, an order identifier, and / or any other information. In some
embodiments, such firm order queries may be received from one or more computer
systems performing a process similar to that shown in process 300. In some
embodiments, the firm order queries may include orders that would fulfill part or
all of the OMS order. Such queries may be received at a participant system, an
OMS system configured to perform some or all of the action of process 400, and /
or any other desired location.
[0167] As indicated at block 415, process 400 may include determining
that a firm order query matches the order. For example, a result from a database
query that includes terms identified by the firm order query (e.g., security
identifier, price, quantity, etc.) may return a positive result.
[0168] As indicated at block 417, process 400 may include attempting to
facilitate execution of a trade with the matching firm order query. Facilitating
execution of a trade may include, for example, displaying an indication of the firm
order to a trader through one or more trading interfaces, as discussed in more detail
below, raising an alarm or other audible alert for such a trader, and / or any other
desired action. In some such embodiments, the trader may be asked to accept the
matching order or reject the matching order. If the trader, in some embodiments,
acceptance of the order, the system may execute a trade, forward information for
the trade to be executed and / or cleared by another system, and / or perform any
other desired action to further facilitate execution of the trade.
[0169] In some embodiments, by keeping the OMS orders secret from
other trading participants, a trading system performing process 400 may encourage
traders to allow pools of liquidity that would typically remain inaccessible, such as
orders in OMS systems, to be used to match against firm orders. This
encouragement may be particularly important to buy side participants who may
typically be protective of their order information. Such use of OMS orders may 2025204532
increase liquidity in a market using such a process.
[0170] Process 400 may end at block 419, after facilitating execution of the
trade. In some embodiments, one or more participants, such as originators of the
orders may be notified of execution. In some embodiments, stored information
regarding the orders may be updated to reflect the order execution. In some
embodiments, in which only part of the OMS order is fulfilled by the matching
firm order, process 400 may include receiving additional firm order queries and
facilitating execution of those orders.
In some embodiments, the order of acts in process 400 may not be the same
is indicated in Figure 4. In some embodiments, process 400 may include
additional actions, fewer actions, and / or different actions. Process 400 or a
similar process may be performed by any computer system or systems in a
centralized and / or distributed manner. For example, process 400 may be
performed by the participant systems 205, 207, by an OMS system configured to
perform one or more parts of process 400, and / or by any other system. In some
embodiments, process 400 may be performed only in connection with a buy side
participant.
Example Querying Processes
[0171] Figure 5 illustrates an example process 500 that begins at block 501
and may be used, in some embodiments, to perform, in part, querying of
participants, as indicated by block 311 of process 300 above. Process 500 may be
performed by a central computer system to query participants for matching orders,
may be performed in a distributed fashion by a plurality of computer systems, and /
or may be performed by any other computer systems. In some embodiments, such
a process may be performed, in part or in whole, in a tree like distributed fashion in
which some participants may query one or more child participants to search for
matching orders.
[0172] As indicated at block 503, process 500 may include identifying one
or more participants. Participants may include one or more remote servers, one or
more computer processes, threads, or programs. For example, in some 2025204532
embodiments, participants may include buy side systems. In other embodiments,
participants may include sell side systems, and / or other systems. Identifying
participants may include querying potential participants in a list of participants,
(e.g., pinging IP addresses, making function calls, etc.). In some embodiments,
identifying participants may include placing one or more items in a predefined
memory location, querying a predefined memory location for information about
participants, accessing a database or other listing of participants, receiving an
indication that a participant exists (e.g., from the participant, from an
administrator, etc.) and / or any other actions desired. In some embodiments, the
identified participants may include child participants of a tree-like participant
structure.
[0173] As indicated at block 505, process 500 may include receiving an
indication of a firm order. Such a firm order may be substantially similar to the
firm order received at block 303 in process 300.
[0174] As indicated at block 507, process 500 may include transmitting
requests to the identified servers. Such requests may be substantially similar to
those discussed above with respect to block 311 in process 300. In some
embodiments, as discussed above with respect to process 300, the received firm
orders may be matched against other locally stored firm orders instead of or in
addition to querying of participants as discussed with respect to process 300.
[0175] In some embodiments, participants may be arranged in a distributed
fashion. For example in one embodiment, participants may be arranged in a tree-
like fashion. In such an embodiment, a first participant may query one or more
other participants. The other participants may determine if matches exist locally.
If matches exist, the participants may return a positive indication (e.g., to the
originating participant, the originator of the firm order, a marketplace, etc.). If no
match is found locally, the further participants may query additional participants.
The order of querying may be established based on any desired priority mechanism
(e.g., largest customers are queried first, premium customers queried first, highest
ranked customers queried first, etc.). In some embodiments, a participant may
query additional participants regardless of whether a match is found locally.
[0176] As indicated at block 509, process 500 may include determining if a 2025204532
response was received from a queried participant. In some embodiments,
determining if a response was received may include querying a port or socket
through which communication may be received from a communication network.
In other embodiments, determining if a response is received may include querying
a register, memory location, process, thread, program, function and / or any other
action.
[0177] In some embodiments, if no responses is received, process 500 may
loop back to block 507 to send one or more additional requests. Any number of
requests may be sent any number of times. Any period of time may pass between
transmission of requests (random, periodic, etc.). Process 500 may continue to
loop until a response is received, a matching firm order is found otherwise, a time
period expires, and / or any other event occurs.
[0178] In some embodiments, the participants queried at each loop may be
the same or different. For example, in some embodiments, an initial group of
participants may be queried first (e.g., a premium group of participants, a group of
good customers, a group of high volume customers, etc), and then after some
period of time a second group of participants may be queried. Any number of such
subgroups may be queried in such order.
[0179] As indicated at block 511, process 500 may include facilitating
execution of a trade fulfilling a matching order in the response. Facilitating may
include executing a trade, clearing a trade, forwarding information requests and /
or any other desired action. In other embodiments, a response may indicate that a
trade has been or will be executed and / or cleared (e.g., by a remote system).
[0180] In some embodiments, a response may only be received if a match
exists and / or a trader desires to execute a trade. Limiting response to positive
responses may encourage participation because less information is revealed from
the participants. This may incentivize participants to make orders available to a
market to a great extent than in traditional markets, thereby increasing the liquidity
of the market.
[0181] Other embodiments may include receiving negative response when
no matching order exists and / or a trader does not desire to execute a trade.
[0182] In some embodiments, a response may be received for a trade that 2025204532
does not completely fulfill the firm order. In some implementations, after
execution of such an order, process 500 may loop back to block 507 to query
participants again. Future queries of participants may include an updated order
with a requested amount decreased by the previous order. In other embodiments,
such facilitation of order execution may be limited to complete orders (e.g., based
on preferences indicated by an originator of the order, based on preferences of a
trading system, etc.).
[0183] In some embodiments, multiple responses may be received at the
same time or within a relatively short time period. Orders received as such may be
treated as if they were received at the same time. A priority mechanism may be
used to determine which of such orders is to be executed first. For example, an
order associated with a high volume customer, a premium customer, a long term
customer, or a customer with any other desired characteristic may be given higher
or lower priority compared with other orders. In some embodiments, largest or
smallest orders may be given priority. In other embodiments, any desired priority
mechanism may be used.
[0184] In some embodiments, process 500 may end at block 513. In some
embodiments, process 500 may include notifying one or more traders of the
execution. In some embodiments, process 500 may include additional actions,
fewer actions, and / or different actions. Process 500 or a similar process may be
performed by any computer system or systems in a centralized and / or distributed
manner.
Example Passive Order Processes
[0185] Process 600 of Figure 6 which begins at block 601 illustrates
an example process that may be performed by one or more participants. Process
600 may include actions similar to process 400 described above. In some
embodiments, process 600 may be performed only by one or more buy side
participants.
[0186] As indicated at block 603, process 600 may include receiving one or 2025204532
more indication of one or more orders. Such orders may include OMS orders as
discussed above with respect to process 400. The orders may be stored
accordingly, as discussed with respect to block 411 SO that queries may be matched
against them.
[0187] As indicated at block 605, process 600 may include receiving an
indication of one or more firm order queries. Such firm order queries may be
transmitted, for example, by an entity performing a process similar to process 500
and / or process 300 as discussed above.
[0188] As indicated at block 607, process 600 may include filtering firm
order queries. Firm order queries may be filtered based on characteristics of the
order (e.g., price, security, amount (e.g., minimum amount, maximum amount),
etc.), characteristics of the originator of the order (e.g., a rating of the originator, a
type of the originator, specific originators, etc.), and / or orders queries may be
filtered according to any other desired characteristics. In some embodiments,
different filters may be applied to different types of securities. For example, large
capitalization securities may have one set of filters applied and small capitalization
securities may have a different set of filters applied. In some embodiments,
specific securities (e.g., identified by stock symbol) may be filtered out or have a
specific set of filters applied.
[0189] In some embodiments, filtering may allow a participant to filter
queries received from or sent to other participants. Filtering may be performed
based on any desired characteristics. Such characteristics may include
characteristics that make the order less likely to be an order associated with gaming
of the market. For example, in one implementations, a filter may block firm orders
that do not meet a minimum size requirement, a minimum total dollar amount
requirement, and / or any other desired characteristics.
[0190] In some embodiments, as another example, a participant may only
desire to consider orders associated with originators with certain characteristics.
Such characteristics may include characteristics that make an order less likely to be
an order associated with gaming of the market. For example, in one
implementations, a filter may block orders that are from a particular class of
traders (e.g., hedge funds, etc.), that are associated with a particular trader that has 2025204532
been identified by the participant as being involved with gaming the market, that
are not from a particular trusted set of participants, a from a set of participants that
were rated poorly by other participants, are from a participant without a history of
trading, etc.
[0191] In some embodiments, a firm order submitter may desire to filter
the participants that receive queries regarding their firm orders. Such a filter may
filter the participants based on characteristics of the participants, behavior of the
participants, and SO on. For example, in some implementations, a filter may be
established based on a response pattern of participants (e.g., how participants have
responded to queries in the past). As an example, a firm order submitter may only
desire their orders to be transmitted to participants that have a history of accepting
firm order queries (e.g., all firm order queries, firm order queries from a type of
trader, firm order queries for a particular financial instrument, firm order queries
for a class of financial instruments, firm order queries for a quantity range of
financial instruments, firm order queries from the submitter, and SO on). Such
filtering may prevent information about the firm order from being sent to
participants that are unlikely to respond positively to the order. In one
implementations, firm order submitters may choose from one or more ranges of
response rates (i.e., number of queries accepted/number of queries received),
which may be referred to as risk pools, with which participants must be associated
to receive a query (e.g.,, choose from among participants with positive response
rates of1-50%, 51-70%, 71-90%, and/or 91-100%).
[0192] Some embodiments may include receiving an indication of desired
filters. The indication may be received from one or more traders, participant
systems, or any other desired source. The indication may identify any desired
characteristics, combination of characteristics, exceptions to filters, and / or any
other information related to the filters.
[0193] The filters may be applied in a centralized fashions and / or a
distributed fashion. For example, in some implementations, filters may be applied
before requests are transmitted (e.g., by a central system, by a distributed system,
etc.). Applying the filters before transmitting requests may decrease the amount of 2025204532
traffic associated with performing process 600. Conversely, performing such
filtering before transmitting may increase the amount of processing performed
before transmitting and may involve a participant revealing filtering preference
they may not desire to reveal to anyone, even a trading system administrator. In
other embodiments, filtering may occur locally to a participant. By performing
such filtering locally, more traffic may be generated by a trading system, more
processing may take place at participants, and filtering options may remain private.
[0194] In some embodiments, participants may be filtered from receiving
requests based on the desires of a firm order submitter (e.g., by a central system or
other participant submitting queries, etc.). Such participants may be filtered by
identity, order availability, and or any other desired characteristic. Such filtering
may occur for example, by the participants themselves (e.g., by a participant
system configured to perform such filtering in addition to, before, or otherwise in
connection with other participant functions), by a central system, by a submitting
system, and / or by any other desired system. In some embodiments, for example,
a participant may not be provided with a query if they do not have a matching firm
order to fulfill a minimum percentage of a firm order. In other embodiments, such
information may not be known until after a query is sent, and in such
embodiments, a match may only be determined to exist if the match meets the
minimum percentage. Filtering before transmitting queries may decrease an
amount of traffic (e.g., TCP/IP packets) transmitted which may be snooped to
reveal trading information, however, a malicious user may snoop such queries in
an attempt to determine a filter setting.
[0195] In some embodiments, participant systems may transmit filtering
information to a central system. Such information may be used to perform the
filtering at the central system. Such information may also be used to provide
information to users entering firm orders, as described below.
[0196] A trading system that allows such filtering may enable a participant
to open traditionally untapped pools of liquidity only to a certain subset of traders.
By allowing such limitations, the participant opening that pool of liquidity (e.g., a
set of orders in an OMS) may be more confident that the traders gaining access to 2025204532
those pools are not going to use the pools of liquidity for malicious purposes (e.g.,
gaming the market).
[0197] As indicated at block 609, process 600 may include determining if a
matching order for the firm order query exists. Such determination may include
searching one or more database or other listings of OMS orders. The
determination may be made at a same or different location as the filtering.
Determining may include searching a listing of orders in an OMS of a buy side
participant. Such a listing may include all listed orders, a subset of listed orders
identified as searchable by a trader, and / or any other orders.
[0198] As indicated at block 611, and 613, process 600 may end if it is
determined that no matching order exists. Some embodiments may end without
providing any indication that no order exists. By not providing specifically
identifying that no order exists, others (e.g., other traders, participants, people
snooping packets, etc.) may be unable to determine if no order exists or no such
response was sent for some other reason (e.g., because a trader indicated that no
trader should occur as discussed below, because a trade was filtered out, as
discussed above, etc.). In some embodiments, no indication that the query was
received may be presented to a trader or trading system associated with the
participant that received the query. By keeping such information secret, receivers
of queries may be prevented from using the information that the firm order exists
to game the market.
[0199] As indicated at blocks 611 and 615, if a firm order is determined to
exist, process 600 may include providing an indication that a firm order has been
received. Providing such an indication may include transmitting information over
one or more networks from one computer system to another computer system.
Providing such an indication may include presenting a user (e.g., a buy side trader
associated with the OMS order matched) with one or more interfaces or icon
identifying the firm order. Such an interface may include options to accept a firm
order, reject a firm order, ignore a firm order, ignore all firm orders (e.g., for a
desire period of time), and / or any other desired options. Such an indication may
be considered a non-binding indication from the point of view of the participant
associated with the OMS in SO much as a recipient (e.g., a participant associated 2025204532
with the matching OMS order) is not bound to fulfill any order based on the
indication. However, an originator of the firm order may still be bound to fulfill
the order if the recipient of the indication chooses to accept the order.
[0200] In some embodiments, ignoring a firm order may result in a
participant opting out of receiving/matching using firm order queries for a
minimum amount of time. Such an opt out time may encourage participants to
accept firm order queries. The time may vary based on characteristics of the order
and / or participants.
[0201] In some embodiments, a user may select various options
regarding ignoring future indications. For example, a user may select that
indications should be ignored unless a price associated with the firm order is at a
certain level, a firm order has some desired characteristic, ignore until a certain
time, ignore for a certain amount of time, ignore until the end of the day, etc.
[0202] In some embodiments, evidence that a user has selected to
ignore an indication may be suppressed. For example, the information may
maintained in confidence at a participant system, may be kept in confidence at a
central system, or may otherwise be kept secret. In implementations where
different options for ignoring an indication may selected, evidence regarding some
or all of the information regarding the options may also be suppressed.
[0203] As indicated at block 617, process 600 may include awaiting a
response from such an indication. Some implementations may include receiving a
response and determining if the response is a positive or negative response. In
other implementations a response may not be received or may only be received if
the response is a positive response. In some embodiments, the amount of time to
be awaited may be indicated to a trader. In some embodiments, the amount of time
may vary based on one or more desired characteristics of a security, a participant,
an originator and / or other desired entity.
[0204] As indicated at block 619, process 600 may include determining if a
positive response is received. Determining if a response is a positive response may
include determining which if any mouse buttons were pressed, which if any
keyboard buttons were pressed, which interface control if any was selected, and / 2025204532
or any other determination of a possible entry of intent, if any.
[0205] As indicated in block 621, process 600 may end if a positive
response is not received. In some embodiments after a period of awaiting, a
presumptive default response may be entered. In some implementations such a
default response may include a negative response. In some embodiments, an
operator of an interface (e.g., a trader, an administrator, etc.) may determine the
appropriate amount of time and / or the appropriate default command.
[0206] As indicated at block 623, if a positive response is received, process
600 may include facilitating a trade fulfilling at least part of the matching order
and at least part of the firm order. Facilitating the trade may include executing the
trade, clear the trade, transmitting information SO that the trade is executed and
cleared remotely and / or any other desired actions. In some implementations,
facilitating may include providing a positive response (e.g., to a central server, to a
buy side and / or sell side participant, etc.). The recipient of the positive response
may further facilitate the execution of the trade if a trade fulfilling the firm order
has not already been executed. Transmission of a positive response may be
considered a binding indication of a trade in SO much as the participant associated
with the OMs order may be bound to fulfill the matching firm order by the
indication. In some embodiments, the binding may be conditioned on the firm
order not having been fulfilled previously, not on actions of the participant.
[0207] In some implementations, process 600 may include receiving an
update regarding the facilitation of the execution, such an update may include
receiving an indication that the execution was completed or that the execution was
not completed. In some implementations, a trade may be partially completed and
an update may indicate that the trade was partially completed. For example, a
trade may be partially completed if when the positive response is received, only
part of the firm order is still awaiting execution, and the OMS order includes a
larger volume for trade. In such a situation, a trade may be cancelled in some
embodiments, in other embodiments, a the OMS order may be executed to the
extent that the firm order remains, and in indication to that extent may be
transmitted to the participants, in still other embodiments, an originator of the
OMS order may be contacted with the updated firm order information, and / or any 2025204532
other action may be taken.
[0208] Process 600 may end at block 625. Process 600 may include
notifying one or more participants of a result of the facilitation of the execution of
the trade. In some embodiments, process 600 may include additional actions,
fewer actions, and / or different actions. Process 600 or a similar process may be
performed by any computer system or systems in a centralized and / or distributed
manner. Process 600 may be performed by one or more computer systems in a
centralized and / or distributed fashion.
[0209] It should be understood that the process of querying
participants is given as one example process only. In various embodiments other
methods of pulling order information from one or more OMS may be used. In still
other embodiments, order information may be pushed from one or more OMS to a
central system or other system through which order matching occurs rather than
the pulling of order information described in process 600. In such
implementations, an OMS and/or participant system may be configured to provide
OMS order information and updates to a trusted system for order matching to take
place without the need for querying.
Example Order Entry Processes
[0210] Figure 7 illustrates an example process 700 that begins at block 701
and that may involve interfaces used in some embodiments. Process 700 may be
performed in part, for example, by an OMS, a trading terminal, and / or any other
computer system.
[0211] As indicated at block 703, process 700 may include providing an
interface through which one or more of a firm order and / or a OMS order may be
entered. Such an interface may allow a user to enter information identifying a
security, a pricing policy, a price, an amount, and / or any other information about
a desired trade.
[0212] Figures 8 illustrate one example interface through which a user may
enter order information. Through such an interface a user may be able to enter
order types, a security desired, a pricing policy, a time in force, a limit, a minimum 2025204532
fill amount, a increment fill amount, an amount, and / or any other desired options.
In some embodiments a same or similar interface may be used for entry of one or
more of firm order and OMS order information.
[0213] Such a trading interface may illustrate information about a
percentage / number of participants that may view a firm order query associated
with an entered order as indicated at 801. This information may be based on filters
established by the participants to filter out orders as described above. Such
information may be collected by a central system (e.g., from participant systems).
One characteristic that may be frequently used to filter orders includes size of the
order. The percentage / number of participants may reflect the total number of
participants willing to accept orders with all characteristics except size and the
number willing to accept with the size characteristic. Accordingly, order
originators may adjust their order size to increase or decrease the number of
participants queried.
[0214] As indicated in block 705, process 700 may include receiving
information about an entered order. The information may include information
entered through the provided interface and / or any other information (e.g., default
information, identification information, etc.).
[0215] As indicated at block 707 process 700 may include determining if
the order is a firm order. Determining if the order is a firm order may include
determining characteristics of an input signal, an interface control, and / or any
other information. Some implementations may not include such a determination,
but rather an interface, program, computer, etc. at which the indication is received
or through which information related to the indication is entered may identify the
type without a separate action being taken.
[0216] As indicated at block 709, if the order is a firm order, process 700
may include transmitting (e.g., to a central system, a distributed system, etc.) an
indication of the firm order for automatic execution against matching orders (e.g.,
matching firm orders previously or later submitted, OMS orders, etc.). Process
700 may then end at block 711. In some implementation, process 700 may also
include receiving information about a matching order and displaying that 2025204532
information through one or more interfaces.
[0217] As indicated at block 713, if the order is determined not to be a firm
order, process 700 may include transmitting a representation of the order to be
matched against incoming order queries e.g., by a process such as process 400.
Transmitting may include providing to a different process, thread, memory
location, etc. In other embodiments, a same program thread server may perform
query matching, providing interfaces, receiving order information, and or any
other desired acts. As indicated at block 715, process 700 may then end.
[0218] In some embodiments, process 700 may include receiving
information about the order, such as whether matching queries are received, etc. In
some implementations, process 700 may be performed, for example by a trading
computer, an OMS system, a central system, and / or a participant server. In some
embodiments, process 700 may include additional actions, fewer actions, and / or
different actions. Process 700 or a similar process may be performed by any
computer system or systems in a centralized and / or distributed manner. Process
700 may be performed by one or more computer systems in a centralized and / or
distributed fashion. In some embodiments, entering OMS orders in such a process
may be limited to buy side participants of a market.
Example Passive Order Query Processes
[0219] Figure 9 illustrates an example process 900 that begins at block 901.
Process 900 may be performed, for example, by a buy side system, sell side
system, and or any other computer system. In some implementations, a
participant server, a trader's computer, an OMS, and / or any other computer
system may perform one or more actions associated with process 900 and / or a
similar process.
[0220] As indicated at block 903, process 900 may include receiving an
indication that a firm order matches a OMS order. Such an indication may be
received from one or more OMS systems, participant servers, central servers, buy
side systems, sell side systems, computer programs, computer processes, computer 2025204532
threads, memory locations, network interfaces, and / or other desired sources.
[0221] As indicated at block 905, process 900 may include providing an
interface, icon and / or other indication that a matching order exists. Figure 10
illustrates an example interface that may be used as such an indication in some
embodiments. Such an interface, as illustrated, may display some details of a
matching order. Such an interface may allow a trader to indicate a positive
response to the order or a negative response to the order (e.g., by operating a
control, such as a button).
[0222] Process 900 as indicated at block 907 may include determining if a
positive response is received with some time period. In some embodiments, the
period of time may include a default time period, an amount of time according to a
user profile, an amount of time according to terms of the firm order, an amount of
time determined in part by a size and / or dollar value of the order, and or any
other desired amount of time. In some implementations, receiving a positive
response may include receiving an indication that a control was selected. If a
positive response is not received, process 900 may end at block 909.
[0223] As indicated at block 911, if a positive response is received, process
900 may include transmitting a request to execute a trade fulfilling at least part of
the firm order and at least part of the matching order. Other embodiments may
include otherwise facilitating the execution of such a trade (e.g., executing the
trade, clearing the trade, etc.)
[0224] Process 900 may end at block 913. Other embodiments of process
900 may include receiving information about the execution of the trade, displaying
information about such execution, displaying terms associated with a trade,
displaying information about an originator of a firm order, updating / maintaining
stored order information and / or any other desired actions.
[0225] In some embodiments, multiple firm orders may match a OMS
order. In such embodiments, an indication of each such matching order may be
provided. In some embodiments, the indications may be ordered according to a
preference mechanism. Such preference mechanism may include ordering based
on preferences of an order originator, an indication receiver, a computer system
administrator, and / or any other preferences of any individual regarding any 2025204532
characteristics of an order, computer system, trade, etc. In some implementations,
rather than providing separate indications, indications may be pooled into a single
indication. Such pooling may include combining multiple firm orders according to
some preference mechanism SO that the firm orders fulfill the matching order. If
additional firm orders exist, some implementations may separately provide
information about such firm orders. In some implementations, even if indications
are pooled, an interface may be provided that allows a user to access information
and enter information (e.g., acceptance of orders) about individual orders.
[0226] In some embodiments, process 900 may include additional actions,
fewer actions, and / or different actions. Process 900 or a similar process may be
performed by any computer system or systems in a centralized and / or distributed
manner. Process 900 may be performed by one or more computer systems in a
centralized and / or distributed fashion. In some embodiments, only buy side
participants may receive firm order queries for matching against OMS orders.
[0227] Processes 300-700 and 900 are arranged to provide convenient
illustration of concepts disclosed herein. It should be recognized that no such
processes need be performed at all.
Encryption
[0228] In various embodiments, some or all communication may be
encrypted. In various embodiments, some or all information stored in various
media may be encrypted. In some embodiments, comparisons among information
may be made in an encrypted form. In other embodiments, encrypted data may be
unencrypted before a comparison occurs.
[0229] In some embodiments, an encryption algorithm such as the well-
known PGP, RSA encryption method may be used for communication among
participants, computer systems, etc. Advances in quantum computing may make
such encryption less secure in the future. Some embodiments, therefore may
include use of quantum key encryption algorithms designed to overcome such
vulnerability and or other future proof encryption algorithms. 2025204532
User types
[0230] In some embodiments, different users of a system (e.g., central
system, buy side system, sell side system, trader computer, etc.) may have access
to different options. Because a market may be asymmetrical, providing
asymmetrical options to such user types may best capture a dynamic of the market.
For example, in a security trading market, participants may be divided into four
example categories which may include hedge funds, investors, brokers, and
verified naturals. It should be recognized that other embodiments may include
different, additional, alternative, fewer, and / or no categories of users.
[0231] Referring to the example four category embodiment,
investors may include traders that trade on behalf of their own accounts (e.g.,
individuals). Hedge funds may include organizations exempt from standard
securities regulation that typically seek high returns for accredited investors.
Brokers may include originations that may trade on behalf of others as regulated by
standard securities laws. Verified naturals may include brokers that are not acting
one behalf of their own proprietary accounts. To become a verified natural, a
broker may be required to provide proof that they are not trading on behalf of their
own proprietary accounts. In some implementations, a single user may act as more
than one type of user at various times. For example, a broker may act as a broker
in some situations and a verified natural in other situations. Options and treatment
given to such different categories may reflect a likelihood that the participants may
be gaming the market.
[0232] In some embodiments, information provided to users may
depend upon a category or type of user. For example, users may be limited to
receiving certain firm order queries, accepting certain firm order matches, etc.
based on their category. In one implementation, for example, only buy side
participants only may receive firm order queries. In such situations, information
about possible trade executions with OMS orders may not be provided to sell side
participants until and unless a trade is accepted by a buy side participant and / or
executed. 2025204532
[0233] In some embodiments, as discussed above, rebates and charges may
be given. In some embodiments, such rebates and / or charges may depend on a
category of participant. For example, in some implementations, investors may be
given a rebate for submitting firm orders. In other implementations, anyone
submitting a firm order may be given a rebate. In some implementations, brokers
may be charged a fee for each time a OMS order matches a firm order query. In
some implementations, brokers can opt out of having their firm orders matched
against other brokers firm orders because of pricing rebate that allows brokers to
be paid for submitting firm orders.
[0234] In some embodiments, size or other characteristics of a participant
may affect a participants options. Some implementations, for example, may be
limited to large participants, others to small participants, others may allow all sized
participants.
Possible negotiation
[0235] Although some embodiments described above execute trades
without a negotiation between participants in the trade (e.g., with only a buy or
reject / ignore option presented to participants with matching OMS orders), some
embodiments may include a negotiation. Such negotiation may be limited in some
embodiments to preserve anonymity, encourage entering of OMS orders, and / or
limit the possibility of gaming the market.
[0236] In some embodiments, for example, where there are multiple
matching orders, a negotiation to determine the counter party that is willing to
adjust their offer the most may be performed.
[0237] In some embodiments, if user accepts a matching firm order found
from a query, the user and / or the originator of the firm order may be presented
with an option to trade more of the security. By selecting a control in an interface
that activates such an option, a negotiation may begin between the two
participants. Such a negotiation may include asking if the other party agrees to
trade more, the terms of such a trade, etc. Such negotiation may limit the 2025204532
probability of gaming the market since the participants may already be aware of
each other from the prior trade.
Rebate
[0238] Some embodiments may include providing rebates or charging fees
to trade participants. Such fees and / or rebates may be arranged to incentivize
participation in certain aspects of a trading system. For example, in some
embodiments, when an order is executed based on a firm order matched with a
OMS order, the participant that submitted the firm order may receive a rebate, and
the participant associated with the OMS order may be charged a fee.
Types of trades
[0239] Some embodiments may support various types of trades. Such
trades may include buying securities, selling securities, short selling securities, and
/ or any other desired types of trades. In some embodiments in which a short sell
of a security is performed, a location of a purchased / borrowed security may be
required before a short sell order may be completed.
Tracking users
[0240] Some embodiments may include tracking information about one or
more participants. For example, a trade history, a number of trades, a type of
trades, characteristics of trades, etc. may be tracked for buy and / or sell side
participants. In some information, a participant may view some or all of such
information about itself and / or about other participants. In some embodiments,
such information may be used to generate a rating of a participant. Such a rating
may be used, for example, as a filter of participants querying a participant server.
[0241] It should be recognized that while embodiments described
herein generally included a computer-human interactions (e.g., through an
interface), other embodiments may be performed completely though a computer
(e.g., a computer may respond to firm order queries, etc.). 2025204532
[0242] It should also be recognized that while embodiments
described herein generally included various securities trading, other embodiments
may be used to trade any desired goods or services.
Some information revealed
[0243] In some embodiments, one or more participants may be given some,
but not all, information about pending orders. Such information may be provided,
for example, as a way of incentivizing the participant to submit an order, and/or
take some action. In some implementations, the pending orders may include firm
orders, and the participants may include participants with orders in an OMS. In
other implementations, the pending orders may include orders in an OMS and the
participants may include any participant (e.g., a participant inquiring about present
orders, a participant with OMS orders, a participant with firm orders, etc.). In
some implementations, the participants that are told such information may include
buy side participants. In such implementations, buy side participants may be given
the information, for example, without having to submit orders of their own, after
submitting OMS orders related to the pending orders, after submitting firm orders
related to the pending orders, and/or after any other desired event.
[0244] In some implementations, the some information may include
information about one or more pending orders that does not include all the
information about the pending orders. For example, the information may include
the fact that one or more orders for a financial instrument are pending. The
information may, for example, withhold which side the orders are for, who the
orders were submitted by, the quantity of the orders, the price of the orders, and/or
any other information. In other implementations, some or all of such information
may be provided and other information may be withheld. In some
implementations, the information may be sufficient to entice a participant who may
be interested in a trade involving the pending orders to perform one or more
actions but may be limited SO that an effect on behavior of other participants is
limited to legitimate trading activity (e.g., limit gaming of the market).
[0245] In some implementations, if the participant that was shown the 2025204532
information takes one or more specific actions, additional information about the
pending orders may be provided. For example, if an order is submitted for the
financial instrument, if an OMS order is converted to a firm order, if a positive
response to an OMS query is guaranteed, etc., then the remaining information
about the pending orders may be provided. Such a method of providing some but
not all information before an action is taken may be used to incentive a participant
to take a particular action to obtain the remained of information (e.g., if the initial
information was enticing). In some implementations, orders in an OMS, order
histories, and/or any other information about a participant may be tracked and used
to determine if providing some information may encourage the one or more
actions. In some implementations, market conditions may be tracked to determine
that the one or more actions may provide needed liquidity to a market (e.g., may
encourage submission of firm orders when they are lacking).
Non-Firm Orders
[0246] Figure 11 illustrates another embodiment. In some
embodiments, an indication of a non-firm order may be received (e.g., over a
communication network, etc.) from a first participant as indicated at block 1101.
The non-firm order may define a side of a trade (e.g., a desire to buy, a desire to
sell). Such an indication may be received from an order submitter (e.g., a sell side
trader, etc.). In some embodiments, the receipt of such an indication may be
similar to the receipt of an order (e.g., as described with respect to process 300. In
some embodiments, a non-firm order may be treated similar to a firm order, as
described above with respect to process 300. In some embodiments, a process
similar to process 300 may be performed with the addition of an act of confirming
a trade with a submitter of the non-firm order before facilitating execution of the
trade. In some embodiments, such a process may differ from process 300 in any
number of ways. In some implementations, a non-firm order may include an order
to buy or sell a financial instrument that is contingent on a confirmation before a trade fulfilling the order is facilitated.
[0247] In some embodiments, an indication of a non-firm order may be 2025204532
received and in response, a search for matching orders may be performed. If a
matching order is found, instead of facilitating execution in response to finding the
matching order the non-firm order may be confirmed before such facilitation is
performed. If such confirmation is received, execution of the trade may be
facilitated.
[0248] Some embodiments may include determining whether a matching
order to the non-firm order is stored in an order management system and whether
an offer to enter into a trade that fulfills at least a portion of each of the non-firm
order and the matching order is accepted. As described below such determining
may include, for example, transmitting one or more queries, receiving responses,
and any other actions. In other implementations, such determining may include
other actions, such as searching one or more databases, and SO on.
[0249] In some embodiments, after the indication of the non-firm
order is received, one or more queries may be transmitted (e.g., using a querying
process such as those described above, if a matching firm order is not found, in
parallel with a search for matching firm orders, etc.). The queries may ask if a
matching order to the non-firm order is stored in an order management system
(e.g., similar to process 500) as indicated at block 1103 and/or if an offer to enter
into a trade that fulfills at least a portion of each of the non-firm order and the
matching order is accepted as indicated at block 1105. In some implementations, a
single query may be transmitted, for example, to a computer system configured to
interpret the single query as asking if the matching order is stored in the order
management system and, if the matching order is stored in the order management
system, if the offer is accepted (e.g., by a trader associated with the order
management system. In some implementations, transmitting a query may include
transmitting a query to a system configured to determine if a matching order is
stored in the order management system, determine if an offer to enter into a trade
regarding that order is accepted, and respond to the query only if the matching
order is stored in the order management system and the offer is accepted (e.g., a
participant system as described above).
[0250] In some implementations, such querying may include identifying
that the order is a non-firm order (e.g., by color coding an indication provided to a 2025204532
trader, by including a text description in an indication provided to a trader, by
including an icon in an indication provided to a trader, by including a flag or other
indicator in data transmitted, etc.). In other implementations, such querying may
include treating a non-firm order as if it were a firm order (e.g., by not identifying
that the non-firm order is not a firm order, by identifying that the non-firm order is
a firm order, by not providing any distinction between firm orders and non-firm
orders, etc).
[0251] In some implementations, an indication of an acceptance of the non-
form order may be received (e.g., from a participant that was queried) as indicated
at block 1107. The acceptance of the non-firm order may identify that a trader
agrees to enter into a trade fulfilling at least part of the firm order and at least part
of a matching order stored in an order management system. The acceptance may
indicate that the trader agrees to enter into the trade (e.g., without any further
negotiation, etc.).
[0252] In response to receiving the indication of the acceptance or
otherwise making a determination, a request for confirmation of the non-firm order
may be transmitted to a submitter of the non-firm order as indicated at block 1109.
A request for confirmation may include a request to respond, a request to not
respond, a request for information identifying whether the submitter is obligated to
confirm, a request for information identifying circumstances that overcome an
obligation to confirm, and SO on. In some implementations, a request to confirm
may be similar to a request to accept a firm order in which the firm order includes
the matching order.
[0253] In some embodiments, an indication of a confirmation of the non-
firm order may be received as indicated at block 1111. The indication may include
for example, an indication that the trade should occur, an indication that the non-
firm order is still available, an indication that the submitter of the non-firm order
agrees to make the non-firm order firm, an indication that one or more events has
or has not happened, an indication of an acceptance of the matching order, and/or
any other indications. In some implementations, a confirmation may be similar to
an acceptance of a firm order, in which the firm order includes the matching order.
It should be recognized that in some implementations, a non-firm order may be 2025204532
considered confirmed if an indication to the opposite is not received. A
confirmation may include an agreement to enter into a trade that relates to the non-
firm order.
[0254] In some embodiments, if such confirmation is received, execution
of the trade may be facilitated as indicated at block 1113. If such confirmation is
not received, the participant may be notified that the trade will not be executed.
[0255] In some embodiments, those participants that are queried
may not desire to respond to non-firm order queries because of a possibility that
the submitter of the non-firm order may reject the trade and use the information
about the acceptance by the participant to affect the market. In some
embodiments, not all traders may be able to submit non-firm orders. For example,
in some embodiments, non-firm orders may be submitted that meet one or more
desired characteristics. Such characteristics may reflect the likelihood that the
submitter will game the market and/or will confirm an accepted matching order.
Some example characteristics may include that the submitter trades on behalf of
others, that the submitter does not trade based for proprietary purposes, that the
trader agrees to one or more restrictions, and SO on. In some embodiments, all
traders may be able to submit non-firm orders, and participants may be able to
establish filters to block queries from some types of submitters of non-firm orders
and/or only allow queries from some types of submitters of non-firm orders.
[0256] In some embodiments, a submitter of a non-firm order may
be asked/required to agree to one or more restrictions regarding the non-firm
orders. Such restrictions, for example, may affect the circumstances of when a
submitter of a non-firm order may confirm and/or not-confirm a non-firm order
and/or any other aspect of the confirmation process. In some implementations, a
submitter of a non-firm order may be asked and/or required to agree to confirm an
order unless the at least one of the order is cancelled and at least a part of the order
is fulfilled SO that the matching order (or a portion of it that is accepted in response
to a query) is no longer available before at least one the transmission of and the
receipt of the request for confirmation. Some implementations may include
receiving an indication of such an agreement from a submitter of the non-firm
order before the submitter is allowed to submit the non-firm order. In other 2025204532
implementations, other restrictions regarding when a non-firm order submitter may
not confirm a non-firm order may be established. In some implementations, such
restrictions may only apply for a limited time after submission and/or receipt of the
non-firm order. For example, in some implementations, such restrictions may only
apply for an initial 30 seconds. In some implementations, the time period may be
similar to a time period for a shot clock, as described below. In other
implementations, there may be no such time period limitation.
[0257] Some implementations may include determining whether
one or more restrictions are met. Such determining may include receiving
information identifying circumstances that meet such restrictions or identify that
such restrictions are met. For example, in some implementations, a determination
as to whether or not a non-firm order is cancelled may be made based, on
information received about the cancellation of the non-firm order. A non-firm
order may be cancelled for example if at least one of a request to cancel the non-
firm order is received from an originator of the non-firm order by the submitter of
the non-firm order, a request to cancel the non-firm order is processed by the
submitter of the non-firm order, a time period during which the non-firm order is
scheduled to remain active expires, and SO on. As another example, a
determination as to whether or not at least a part of the non-firm has been fulfilled.
The part of the non-firm order may be fulfilled if at least one of an agreement to
execute a trade fulfilling the at least the part of the non-firm order and another
order has been entered into, a trade fulfilling the at least the part of the non-firm
order has been executed, an act entering the submitter into a trade fulfilling the at
least part of the non-firm order and another order has occurred, and SO on.
[0258] In some implementations, a submitter of a firm order may be
prevented from making a change to a price and or quantity related to a trade. In
some implementations, a trade may be facilitated without a negotiation regarding
the price and or quantity. In some implementations the price and/or quantity may
be determined, at least in part, based on information in a non-firm order indication,
a market, a machining order, a query, and/or nay other information.
[0259] In some embodiments, a non-firm order submitter may be asked
required to respond to confirmation requests within a limited time period. Such a 2025204532
time period may include, for example 5 seconds, half a second, 50 milliseconds,
etc. In some implementations, such a time period may be too small for a human to
effectively confirm an order. In such implementations, the confirmation process
may be computerized (e.g., a computer may determine if the order has been
cancelled by an originator or was fulfilled otherwise, and if not may confirm the
order). In some implementations the time period may begin when a request for
confirmation is transmitted, received, and/or at any other time. In some
implementations the time period may include between about 10 milliseconds and
about 1 second. A time period may include a period of time having a beginning
and an end point. In some implementations, a confirmation may be received
within the time period, transmitted in the time period, and SO on.
[0260] In some embodiments, a non-firm order submitter may be asked /
required to abide by a set of procedures for treatment of non-firm order
confirmation requests. For example, a confirmation requests transmitted to and/or
received by non-firm order submitters may have privacy policies applied to it. For
example, in some implementations, no humans may be allowed to view such
confirmation, but rather the process of responding to confirmation requests may be
computerized. Some implementations may include receiving an indication of an
agreement to prevent humans from obtaining information regarding confirmation
of non-firm orders unless the non-firm order is confirmed. In some
implementations, restrictions on the storage of confirmation requests may be
imposed. For example, in some implementations, computer systems that respond
to confirmation requests and/or otherwise process portions of such requests may be
restricted from storing information about the request, from displaying information
about the request, from transmitting information about the request, and SO on.
[0261] In some embodiments, information regarding rejections of
confirmation requests may be provided by a non-firm order submitter. Such
information, for example, may include documentary proof that one or more
circumstances in which a rejection is allowed had occurred (e.g., a document
showing that an order was cancelled at a certain time, a document showing that an
order was fulfilled at a certain time, etc.). Such information may be used for 2025204532
auditing purposes to ensure that the non-firm order submitter is complying with
restrictions established for the submission of non-firm orders in some
implementations. In some implementations, if the non-firm order submitter
violates such restrictions a number of times, a fine may be assessed, the non-firm
order submitter maybe restricted from submitting non-firm orders, and/or any other
penalty may be provided. In some implementations, privacy policies may apply to
such information. Such policies may include preventing humans from viewing the
information, removing stored information from one or more computer systems,
preventing information from being stored one or more computer systems and SO
on.
[0262] In some embodiments, when a query is made to a participant
to determine if a matching order is available (e.g., stored in an OMS), the query
may only present a portion of a quantity of a non-firm order. For example, because
there may be a chance that part of the non-firm order may be fulfilled otherwise
(e.g., through another exchange, etc.), the quantity associated by the firm order
may be reduced to reflect a quantity that is likely not to be otherwise fulfilled
within a desired period of time. Accordingly, an offer to enter into a trade
represented by a query may include an offer to enter into a trade that fulfills only a
portion of the non-firm order. Some implementations may include determining the
portion to be presented. As a specific example, in one implementation, if a non-
firm order for 100 shares of X stock is received, it may be determined that there is
a 99% chance that the submitter of the order will still be looking for 90 shares of X
stock in 30 seconds, SO one or more queries maybe transmitted to one or more
participants for 90 shares of X stock. In various implementations, the percentage
of confidence, the amount of time, and other characteristics may be altered. In
some implementations, such a determination may be made based on historic data
regarding the liquidity of a financial instrument, based on current market
conditions, based on open orders on other exchanges, and SO on. In some
implementations, if the remaining portion of a non-firm order is left unfulfilled
when a confirmation request is sent to the non-firm order submitter, one or more
parties to the trade may be given an option to present the other party with an offer
to trade the remaining portion. In some implementations, one or more algorithms 2025204532
that include any number of variable inputs, some of which are mentioned above,
may be used to determine a portion to be presented. In some implementations, a
portion presented may include a portion that is expected to be confirmed by a
submitter of the non-firm order. The portion expected to be confirmed may
include a portion that is likely to be available at a future time (e.g., based on an
algorithm, based on historic information, based on a guess, and SO on).
[0263] Some embodiments may include one or more systems
interacting with a system configured to perform a method such as one described
above. Some implementations may include, for example, transmitting an
indication of a non-firm order (e.g., after entry into an interface, receipt from an
originator, etc,). Some implementations may include receiving, an indication
defining a matching firm order to the non-firm order. The indication may be
received from a system configured to find matching orders in the content of a
plurality of order management systems, as described above. Some
implementations may include determining if the non-firm order is available for a
tread involving the matching firm order (e.g., has not been canceled or otherwise
fulfilled). If the order is available, some implementations may include transmitting
a confirmation (e.g., within a time period, according to various restrictions that
have been agreed to, etc.). The confirmation may include an indication that a trade
should take place without a negotiation about a price and/or quantity. In some
implementations, an interface or system may prevent a negotiation from taking
place by blocking one or more communication medium, during the time period, for
example.
Trading System Interaction
[0264] Some embodiments may include interaction with one or
more trading systems. In some implementations, such trading systems may include
alternative trading systems. An alternative trading system may include a non-
exchange trading venue. A non-exchange trading venue may include, for example,
a trading venue in which only secondary trading of financial instruments occurs.
An ATS may keep a book of orders, determine matches among orders in the book, 2025204532
and execute trades. In some embodiments, an ATS may include a system that
operates in accordance with Securities and Exchange Commission regulation ATS
and/or 242 Code of federal Regulations 300-303. Figure 12 illustrates an example
embodiment that may include interaction with one or more ATS. Although
examples are described with respect to alternative trading systems, it should be
recognized that other embodiments may include any trading system, including
exchanges. An exchange may allow primary and secondary trading of financial
instruments. Similar to an ATS, an exchange may keep any number of order books
regarding any number of financial instruments and/or orders. As illustrated in
Figure 11, a trading system 1201 (e.g., an alternative trading system) may be
coupled to one or more participants 1203 through one or more communication
networks 1205. Such coupling is discussed above. Operation of example
participants and example trading systems are also discussed above. In some
embodiments, as illustrated, the trading system may be coupled to one or more
alternative trading systems 1207 through one or more communication networks
1209. Each alternative trading system 1207 may store information about an order
book 1211 associated with the alternative trading system 1207. An order book
may include a collection of pending orders for one or more financial instruments.
An order book may include a queue of orders ordered based on some priority, a
database of orders keyed based on some priority, and/or any other collection of
orders with any other ordering or lack of ordering. Each alternative trading system
may be coupled to one or more customers 1213 through one or more
communication networks 1215. The customers may submit information about
orders and/or receive information about orders from the alternative trading systems
1207 related to orders that may be and/or are stored in an order book 1211. The
customers may include computer systems, people, and/or any other entity that may
participate in trading. Communication networks 1205, 1209, and/or 1215 may
include the same or different communication networks. An order book includes at
least one of a database, a queue, a list, and a collection.
[0265] Figure 13 illustrates an example method 1300 that may be
performed in some embodiments. Method 1300 may be performed by one or more
computers, such as computers of trading system 1201. 2025204532
[0266] As indicated at block 1301, method 1300 may include
receiving an indication of order that is pending in an order book (e.g., 1211) of an
alternative trading system (e.g., 1207). The indication may be received from the
alternative trading system (e.g., 1207) through a communication network (e.g.,
1209). The order may define a financial instrument, a side of a trade, a quantity, a
price, and/or any other desired information. In some implementations, an order
may be pending in an order book of an alternative trading system if the order is
stored in the order book. In some implementations, an order may be pending in an
order book of an alternative trading system if the order has not been cancelled or
otherwise fulfilled after it has been received by the alternative trading system.
[0267] In some implementations, the indication of the order may
include an indication that the order is pending in the order book of the alternative
trading system. In some implementations, such an indication may be treated
similarly to a non-firm order as described above. For example, in some
implementations, the indication may be an indication that if the trading system
identifies a matching order, the matching order may be fulfilled if the order has not
been cancelled or otherwise fulfilled by another order. In other implementations,
the indication may include an indication that the order is firm with respect to the
trading system (e.g., 1201). For example, in such implementations, if a matching
order is identified by the trading system, a trade fulfilling the order and the
matching order may be facilitated without regard for matching orders pending on
the alternative trading system.
[0268] As indicated at block 1303, method 1300 may include
determining that a matching order to the order is stored in an order management
system and that an offer to enter into a trade that fulfills at least a portion of each
of the order and the matching order is accepted. The matching order may define an
opposite side of the trade for the financial instrument. Such a determination may
be similar to such determination discussed above (e.g., with respect to non-firm
order).
[0269] In some embodiments, making such a determination may include
transmitting a first query asking if a matching order to the order is stored in an
order management system, and transmitting a second query asking if an offer to 2025204532
enter into a trade that fulfills at least a portion of each of the order and the
matching order is accepted. Such querying may be similar to the querying
discussed above with respect to non-firm orders. Such querying may include
transmitting a single query as discussed above. In some implementations, such
querying may include identifying that the order may not be executed by the trading
system. In some implementations, such querying may include identifying tat the
order is associated with the alternative trading system. In some implementations,
such querying may include identifying that the order is not a firm order. In some
implementations, such querying may include treating the order as if it were a firm
order received from a participant (e.g., not making any identification otherwise).
[0270] In some embodiments, making such a determination may include
receiving an indication of an acceptance of the offer from a participant. Receiving
such an indication may be similar to receiving an indication as discussed above
with respect to non-firm orders.
[0271] In some embodiments, the indication of the order may identify a
quantity of a financial instrument to be trading. Determination may include
determining if a matching order with a smaller quantity is available. Similar to the
non-firm orders discussed above, determining the availability of orders for only a
portion of the quantity may result in fewer instances of an offer being accepted, but
a trade not being executed. In some implementations, a determination of the
portion may be made. Such a determination may be made based on a likelihood of
a quantity of financial instruments related to the order being available, as discussed
above with respect to non-firm orders. In some implementations, the portion may
be based on an expected amount of time to communicate with the alternative
trading system. For example, if the time is a long time, the opportunity that a
cancellation or other fulfillment of the order occurs during transmission may be
greater, SO the portion may be smaller. If the time is a short time, the opportunity
that a cancellation or other fulfillment of the order occurs during transmission may
be less, SO the portion may be larger. The time may be based on a speed of
communication networks, a number of hops between source and destination of
transmission, a protocol's requirements for confirmation, and/or any other
information. Because alternative trading systems generally operate at a much 2025204532
faster rate and with much more bandwidth than typical computer systems, the
portion may be larger than in some non-firm order embodiments discussed above.
Other characteristics may be used to determine the portion and some
implementations may include a full quantity.
[0272] As indicated at block 1305, method 1300 may include transmitting
an indication that the trade should be executed to the alternative trading system.
Such an indication may be transmitted through a communication network to the
alternative trading system. Such an indication may identify that a trade that fulfills
at least a part of the order pending in the order book and at least part of the
matching order should be executed. In some implementations, such an indication
may be transmitted in response to receiving the indication of the acceptance as
discussed above.
[0273] In some implementations, the alternative trading system may
execute the trade or otherwise facilitate execution of the trade if the order is still
available (e.g., if the order has not been cancelled or otherwise fulfilled). In some
implementations, the alternative trading system may provide a information about
the execution of the trade to the trading system and/or to the participant taking part
in the trade. Such information may identify whether the trade has been executed or
not.
[0274] Some embodiments may include receiving orders from a plurality of
different alternative trading systems. Some embodiments may include determining
that respective matching orders are stored in respective order management systems
and that offers to enter into respective trades for the orders are accepted. Some
embodiments may include transmitting respective indications that respective trades
should be executed to respective alternative trading systems for each order. Such
transmission may occur in response to a determination regarding the respective
matching order.
[0275] Figure 13 illustrates an example method 1400 that may be
performed by one or more alternative trading systems in some embodiments. Such
a method, for example, may be performed by an alternative trading system that
interacts with a trading system performing a method similar to method 1300 or any 2025204532
other desired method or system.
[0276] As indicated at block 1401, method 1400 may include receiving an
indication of one or more orders. An order may define a side of a trade for a
financial instrument. The indication may be received, for example, from a
customer 1213 of the alternative trading system. Such a customer may include a
sell side trader, any other person or system that desires to trade a financial
instrument using the alternative trading system, and/or any other entity. The
indication may be received through a communication network (e.g., 1215).
[0277] As indicated at block 1403, method 1400 may include storing
information about the one or more orders in an order book of an alternative trading
system. Storing such information may include placing the information in a
database, a list, a queue, and/or any other structure in which order information may
be stored. In some implementations, storing such information may include placing
the information in a queue of orders for the financial instrument. In some
implementations, if a matching order is received by the alternative trading system,
the next order in the queue of orders may used to trade against the matching order.
Such an order book may be associated with a matching engine that determines if
matching orders are pending and facilitates the execution of such orders. A
matching engine may include software and/or hardware that facilitates
determinations of matches between orders for a financial instrument.
[0278] As indicated at block 1405, method 1400 may include transmitting
an indication of an order to a trading system (e.g., 1201). Such an indication may
be transmitted through a communication network (e.g., 1209). The indication may
be similar to the indication received at block 1301 as discussed above.
[0279] As indicated at block 1407, method 1400 may include receiving an
indication of an acceptance of an offer to enter into a trade that fulfills at least part
of the order. The indication may be received from the trading system. Such an
indication be similar to the indication transmitted at block 1305 discussed above.
The indication may identify information about a matching order sufficient to allow
the alternative trading system to execute a trade involving the order and the
matching order. The indication may indicate that the trade should be executed.
The indication may indicate that the trade should be executed if one or more 2025204532
conditions are met. In some implementations, such conditions may include that the
order is available. In some implementations, such conditions may include that the
order has not been cancelled and/or that the order has not been previously fulfilled.
In some implementations, the matching order may fulfill only a portion of the
order. In other implementations, the matching order may fulfill the entire order.
[0280] As indicated at block 1409, method 1400 may include determining
if the order is available. In some implementations, determining if the order is
available may include determining if the order is in the order book (e.g.,. by
searching the order book). In some implementations, determining if the order is
available may include determining if the order has been cancelled. In some
implementations, determining if the order is available may include determining if
the order has been otherwise fulfilled (e.g., by a previous order that was identified
by the alternative trading system). An order may have been otherwise fulfilled, for
example, if another matching order was previously submitted to the alternative
trading system before the matching order was identified by the trading system.
[0281] Some embodiments may include determining if an acceptance is
identified by the trading system before a matching order is identified by the
alternative trading system. Some embodiments may include determining if an
acceptance is identified by the alternative trading system before a matching order
is identified by the trading system. Identifying an order or an acceptance may
include ant action that makes the existence of the order or the acceptance
consequential. For example, a matching order may be identified when an
indication of the matching order is received by the first alternative trading system,
the matching order is stored in the order book, a matching engine of the first
alternative trading system identifies that the matching order and the first order
match, the first order is removed from the order book, the matching order is
processed by the first alternative trading system, and/or any other desired action
occurs. As another example, an acceptance may be identified when an indication
of the acceptance is received by the second alternative trading system, an
indication of the acceptance is transmitted from the second alternative trading
system to the first alternative trading system, an indication of thee acceptance is
received by the first alternative trading system, the indication of the acceptance is 2025204532
processed by the first alternative trading system, and/or any other desired action
occurs.
[0282] In some embodiments, if an acceptance of an offer to enter
into a trade that fulfills at least part of the order is identified by the trading system
before a matching order to the order is identified by the alternative trading system,
the trade may be executed. In some embodiments, if the matching order to the
order is identified by the alternative trading system before the acceptance is
identified by the trading system, a trade that fulfills at least part of the matching
order and the order may be executed. In some embodiments, if a cancelation is
identified before either the acceptance or the matching order, neither trade may be
executed.
[0283] As indicated at block 1411, method 1400 may include facilitating
execution of the trade that fulfills at least part of the order if it is determined that
the order is available. Various examples of facilitating execution are discussed
herein. In some implementations, the alternative trading system may execute the
trade.
[0284] Some embodiments may include providing information about the
execution to one or more customers, participants, the trading system, and/or any
other entity.
[0285] Some embodiments of a trading system (e.g., 1201), may require
and/or ask an operator of an alternative trading system to accept certain restrictions
before participating in a method such as method 1300 and/or method 1400. In
some such implementations, the restrictions may include, for example, that if an
acceptance of a trade related to an order is identified through the trading system
before either an order is cancelled or otherwise fulfilled, that the trade will be
executed. The restriction may include that the alternative trading system is used
for non-proprietary trading (e.g., at least some, primarily, to some degree,
exclusively, etc.). Some implementations may be limited to alternative trading
systems that meet some or all such requirements. Some implementations of an
alternative trading system may include providing an indication of an agreement to
such restrictions. Some implementations of a trading system may include
receiving such an indication. Similar indications are discussed above with respect 2025204532
to non-firm orders.
[0286] In some embodiments, an alternative trading system may transmit
information about all orders to a trading system, some orders to a trading system,
orders that meet certain characteristics to the trading system and/or any other set or
subset of orders associated with the alternative trading system to the trading
system. For example, in some implementations, an alternative trading system may
transmit indication about orders that are for financial instruments that are not
traded frequently through the alternative trading system to the trading system. In
other implementations, an alternative trading system may transmit indication about
orders over a particular size to the trading system. In still other implementations,
an alternative trading system may transmit indications about orders for financial
instruments for which there are over a certain number of orders pending in the
alternative trading system to the trading system. In other implementations, any set
of characteristics may be used to determine if any, all, and/or which orders should
be transmitted to a trading system. In some implementations, an operator of the
alternative trading system may establish such characteristics and may control the
alternative trading system to provide only such desired information.
[0287] In some implementations, a trading system may have direct
and/or semi direct access to an order book of an alternative trading system. Such
access may include for example access to a copy of the order book, access to a
database or other representation of the order book, and/or any other access to the
order book and/or a copy of the order book. The trading system may obtain
information about orders in the order book using such access. In such
implementations, the trading system may not wait for indications from the
alternative trading system, but may proactively search the order book for order
information. Such searching may be performed for example, by querying a
database, querying a copy of an order book, transmitting a query to an alternative
trading system, and/or performing any other actions. In some implementations, an
alternative trading system may receive and process a query. Processing a query
may be part of a process for responding to queries. In some implementations, an
operator of an alternative trading system may establish characteristics related to
order that may be obtained from the order book by the trading system, similar to 2025204532
the characteristics discussed above. The trading system may follow such
characteristics in determining which orders in the order book to obtain.
[0288] In some implementations, access to an order book may be
provide through an SSL link. In some implementations, access to an order book
may involve authentication to a trading system that maintains the order book.
Such authentication may include authentication using a password, an IP address, a
username, and/or any other information.
[0289] In some embodiments, trading system may be coupled to a
plurality of other trading systems. The trading system may allow the other trading
systems to access orders received by the trading system (e.g., accessing an order
book, transmitting information about orders in an order book, etc.). In some
implementations, such a trading system may determine which of the plurality of
trading systems first identifies a matching order to an order (e.g., base don
information received from one or more of the trading systems). Based on such a
determination, the trading system may execute a trade that fulfills at least part of
the order. The trade may also fulfill at least part of a matching order that was
identified first by a trading system (e.g., one of the plurality and/or the trading
system).
[0290] It should be recognized that Figures 12, 13, and 14 are provided as
examples only and that other embodiments may include different methods and/or
systems.
Shot Clock
[0291] In some embodiments, a firm order submitter may have
restrictions placed on their actions during a period of time after transmission and/or
receipt of such orders. For example, for a period of time after an indication of a
firm order defining a side of a trade is received, the submitter of the firm order may
be constrained from cancelling the firm order for a first period of time. The
amount of time may include an amount of time that may allow a participant to be
queried and respond. In some implementations, such time may include, for
example, between about 20 seconds and about 1 minute, about 5 seconds, and SO 2025204532
on.
[0292] In some implementations, if the firm order, during that first time
period, is accepted, a trade fulfilling at least a portion of the order may be
facilitated, even if a request to cancel the order has been received before the
acceptance. If queries are rejected during that time, the firm order may still not be
cancelled until the time period ends.
[0293] In some embodiments, after the first time period, cancellation of the
firm order may be allowed if a matching order is not determined to be stored in an
order management system and/or if a participant is nor determined to accept the
order before the first time period expired (i.e., ends).
[0294] In some implementations, constraining may include limiting the
ability to perform an act of cancellation. For example, constraining may include
not allowing an action to occur in a time period (e.g., preventing an action from
occurring). Constraining may include imposing a penalty for taking an action.
Some implementations, for example may fine a participant for cancelling in the
first time period. Some implementations may prevent a cancellation in the first
time period completely. Some implementations may place restrictions on
cancellation in the first time period that are not placed after the first time period.
In some implementations, if a request to cancel is received during the first time
period, for example, it may be ignored. In some implementations if a request to
cancel is received during the first time period, the request may be queued until the
first time period ends and may be processed at the end of the first time period (e.g.,
the order may be cancelled if it was not accepted before the end of the first time
period). In some implementations, cancellation may include cancelling an order,
revoking an order, invalidating an order, and SO on. In some implementations,
allowing may include letting an act happen with a penalty or without a constraint.
[0295] In some implementations, by constraining cancellation of
the firm order during the time period, information leakage about orders pending in
an OMS may be prevented. For example, in other implementations, a firm order
may be cancelled after either (a) it is determined that no matching orders are
present with any participants or (b) all queries sent to participants with matching
orders are negatively responded to or a time period passes. In some 2025204532
implementations, option (a) may take a short a mount of time (e.g., less than a
second) and option (b) may take a variable amount of time depending on how
quickly the participants respond to queries. Accordingly, if option (a) occurs, then
the firm order submitter will be able to cancel orders quickly, but if option (b)
occurs then the firm order submitter will not be able to cancel orders until some
time longer amount of time passes. By tracking such time, the firm order submitter
may be able to tell whether there were matching orders pending or not based on
how long the wait to cancel was. By requiring a standard level (e.g., 20 seconds, 1
minute, etc.) before cancelation is allowed, firm order submitters may not be able
to tell the difference between these different situations and therefore less
information about the contents of OMS may be leaked to firm order submitters.
An indication of a remainder of the time period may be shown to a submitter (e.g.,
though an interface). An indication of the end of the time period may be shown to
a submitter (e.g., through an interface). In some implementations, a standard time
period determined before an indication of an order is received may be used as the
first time period.
[0296] In some embodiments, a time period during which cancellation is
constrained may be randomly determined for one or more firm orders. Such
random time period may simulate a time period for reply of a participant. In some
implementations, the time period may be randomly determined between a
minimum and maximum period of time (e.g., between 5 seconds and 20 seconds, 1
minute, etc.). In some implementations, such time period may be shown to the
submitter of the firm order (e.g., through an interface, as a counting down clock,
etc.). In some implementations, an indication that the end of the period is reached
may be sent to the submitter (e.g., in addition to the time period, instead of the time
period, by changing a color, by playing a tone, through an interface, and SO on).
[0297] In some embodiments, an indication of an amount of time
remaining in the first time period and/or whether the first time period has passed
may be transmitted to one or more participants. In some embodiments, the amount
of time remaining in the time period before the order may be cancelled may be
shown to a recipient of a query (e.g., a clock may be shown in an interface
window, a query may include the indication, etc.). In some implementations, an 2025204532
indication that the time period has ended may be shown to the recipient of a query
(e.g., a window may change colors, an icon may be shown, an amount of time
remaining may be shown, etc.). In some implementations, an indication of the
query may be removed from an interface after the end of the time period (e.g., a
window may be closed or removed from an interface). In some implementations,
the recipient may respond to the query after the time period, but the firm order may
be cancelled before such response is processed. In some implementations, if the
firm order is cancelled, an indication of the query may be removed (e.g., removed
from an interface, a window may be closed, etc.).
[0298] In some embodiments, an indication of whether the first
time period has passed may be provided to a submitter of the firm order. Such an
indication may include an amount of time until the time period ends, an indication
that the time period has not passed, an indication that a time period has changed,
and SO on.
[0299] Some implementations may include a system configured to
interface with a system such as those describe above. In some implementations,
for example, information about a firm order may be accepted (e.g., through an
interface). In some implementations, an indication of the firm order may be
transmitted (e.g., to a system configured to find matching orders to firm orders in
the content of a plurality of order management systems). Some implementations
may include providing an indication of a time period during which the firm order
may not be cancelled (e.g., through an interface, to a trader that submitted
information about the firm order, and SO on). Some implementations may include
receiving an indication of the time period (e.g., from a system to which the order
was submitted, etc.). In some implementations the indication may include a color
coding of an interface, an indication of an amount of time remaining in the first
time period, and SO on.
[0300] In some embodiments, a cancellation of an order may be
constrained as discussed above and/or in any other way. When an order is
submitted, some embodiments may determine whether cancellation should be
constrained for that order. Determining whether cancellation should be 2025204532
constrained may include determining whether a number of orders has been
submitted prior to the order. The number of orders ay include orders that meet
certain criteria, some of which are discussed below. In other implementations, a
determination about cancellation constraining may be randomly made. For
example, each order may have a 10% chance of having cancellation constrained.
A random number generator or other method of random selection may determine
that the order should or should not have cancellation constrained. It should be
recognized that any method of making such a determination may be used and that
examples are non-limiting.
[0301] In some implementations that constrain cancellation of an order
after a number of orders have been submitted may keep a count of orders
submitted. For example, such embodiments may constrain cancellation of every
20th order submitted. In some implementations, Cancellation of the other (e.g., non
20th orders) orders may not be constrained. In some implementations, cancellation
of the other orders may not be constrained unless a matching order to the other
orders has been identified (e.g., in an order management system). Such
constraining for the other orders may be for a period of time that gives the
participant associated with the order management system a chance to accept or
reject the order. Cancellation of the order (e.g., the 20th order) may be constrained
even if a matching order is not identified. Accordingly, a submitter of the order
may not know whether a match is found based on whether cancellation is
constrained.
[0302] In some implementations, a number of other orders may be
submitted. The other orders may be treated as described elsewhere herein. In
some implementations, the number may be any desired number. For example, the
number may be 20 orders. In some implementations, the number may be a random
number. The number may be determined periodically. The number may be
determined randomly. The number may be determined to simulate random market
actions.
[0303] In some implementations, the other orders may all be
submitted from a same submitter (e.g., the same submitter as the order (e.g., the
20th order)). Each submitter may be tracked to determine whether the number has 2025204532
been submitted by the submitter. In other implementations, the number may be
submitted from different submitters.
[0304] In some implementations, the other orders may include all
orders submitted (e.g., by one submitter, by many submitters). In other
implementations, the other orders may include orders that meet one or more
criteria. For example, in some implementations, the other orders may include only
orders that have not been fulfilled (e.g., within a time period after submission). In
some implementations, the other orders may include orders for which at least one
of (i) no matching order has been found in an order management system and (ii) no
offer to enter into a trade for the order was accepted.
[0305] Some embodiments may include determining that no
matching order is stored in the order management system associated with any of
the plurality of participants for one or more of the other orders. In such an
implementation, each of such other orders may not have their cancellation
constrained. In some such implementations, each of such other orders may have
their cancellation constrained only until the determination is made but not past that
point. Such a determination may take about 100 milliseconds or less.
[0306] In some implementations, a determination of whether a
matching order is stored in an order management system may be made. In some
implementations, a database of orders may be searched to make such a
determination. In some implementation, such a determination may be made, for
example, based on whether an indication that a matching order is stored in the
order management system has been received. In some implementations, a
participant may be queried as discussed elsewhere herein. In some
implementations, the participant may be configured to transmit an indication that a
matching order is stored in an order management system. Such an indication may
be sent regardless of whether an offer has been accepted, unlike some
embodiments discussed herein.
[0307] In some embodiments, all orders may have cancellation
constrained for an initial determination to be made. The time to make the
determination may be minimal (e.g., less than about 100 ms). In some
implementations, to make the determination, participants may be queried. Each 2025204532
participant may respond with an indication that a matching order is or is not stored
in an order management system associated with the respective participant. In some
implementations, a lack of response may be an indication of a default value (e.g.,
no response before the end of some initial period means no matching order is
stored). In some implementations, if a determination is made that any of the
participants has a matching order stored in an order management system,
cancellation of the order may be constrained for a period of tie to allow the
participant to accept the order if desired. If a determination is made that no
matching orders are stored, then cancellation ay be allowed after that determination
is made. In some implementations, that cancellation may be constrained as if the
determination that the matching order was stored was made in some circumstances
(e.g., if such a constraining decision is made as described above, if a number of
prior orders have been submitted, etc.). Such constraining may make it difficult
for a submitter to determine whether a matching order was found or not.
[0308] As mentioned above, in some embodiments, if it is determined that
an order is stored in an order management system of a participant, cancellation
may be constrained for a time period SO that the participants may respond to an
offer. The time period may be about 5 seconds. In some embodiments, if it is
determined that no such order is stored in the order management system, then
cancellation may not be constrained except under certain circumstances, as
discussed herein.
[0309] Some embodiments may include determining that none of the
plurality of participants accepts an offer to enter into the respective first trade
defined by one or more of the number of orders. Such a determination may be
made based on whether an indication that such an acceptance to an offer has been
received (e.g., from a participant as discussed above).
[0310] In some embodiments, the other orders may be limited to orders
with one set of criteria or more than one set of criteria in any combination. For
example, in some embodiments, the number may be accepted orders, order without
matching orders, and orders with matching orders that are unaccepted. In other
implementations, the orders may be any subset or other set of such orders. Orders
that do not meet such criteria, in some implementations, may not be included in a 2025204532
count of orders to determine if a constraint should be made to cancellation of the
order.
[0311] As discussed above, if cancellation is determined to be constrained,
cancellation may be constrained during a first time period and allowed after the
first time period. As discussed above, the time period may be a random time
period. In other implementations, the time period may be a fixed time period (e.g.,
about 5 seconds).
[0312] In some implementations, a determination that no orders matching
orders are stored in order management systems associated with a plurality of
participants may be made before an end of the first time period. Such a
determination may have no affect on the ending of the time period. Rather, in
some implementations, the constraining may continue despite there being no
matching orders available for the order.
[0313] It should be recognized that various examples above are non-
limiting and other methods of constraining orders may be used. Such constraining
may limit an order submitter's ability to determine whether a matching order exists
based on his or her ability to cancel an order.
Fund Participants
[0314] In some embodiments, one or more funds (e.g., mutual funds, bond
funds, stock funds, index funds, actively managed funds, commodities funds,
exchange traded funds, etc.) may participate.
[0315] Some such funds may use OMS systems and may participate in a
similar way as other participants with OMS systems, as described above (e.g., buy
side participants). Other fund participants may not use such OMS systems and/or
may not want to provide access to such OMS systems. In some embodiments, a
publication of a fund composition may be used to determine what types of queries
and/or other information to transmit to fund participant.
[0316] In some embodiments, an indication of a composition of a
fund may be received (e.g., over a communication network, as a printed
publication of a fund prospectus, and SO on). The composition of the fund may 2025204532
include a plurality of financial instruments that are owned by a fund (e.g., a listing
of stocks owned by a mutual fund, and SO on). The composition may include an
amount of each financial instrument owned or desired to be owned by the fund.
The composition may include a target percentage of the fund made up of each
financial instrument. The composition may include a snap shot view of the fund at
a particular time, at a desired future time, and SO on.
[0317] The indication of the composition may include any information
from which at least a portion of a composition of a fund may be determined. For
example, a composition of a fund may include a written statement of the desired
composition of the target composition of the fund, such as may be found in a
published prospectus. In some embodiments, an indication of a composition may
be obtained directly from an operator of a fund, from a website that tracks fund
information, from a third party, and SO on. The indication may include information
from a plurality of sources that taken together identify the composition.
[0318] An interest in trading related to a particular financial instrument
may be approximated/determined based on the composition of the fund and/or any
other information (e.g., price changes). For example, in some implementations,
one or more orders to buy or sell a financial instrument may be received. For one
or more such orders, a determination may be made if the financial instrument
defined by the order is part of the composition of the fund. Such a determination
may include comparing the financial instrument to the composition (e.g., searching
the composition for the financial instrument, searching a database, and SO on). If
the financial instrument is part of the composition of the fund, a query may be
transmitted asking if a fund operator (e.g., anything or one that has the capacity to
enter into trades on behalf of the fund) desires to enter into a trade fulfilling the
order and a matching order for the financial instrument. Transmitting the query
may in some implementations include querying an order management system of
the fund as described above, transmitting a query to a trader or machine operated
by a trader, and/or soliciting an acceptance in any other way.
[0319] In some implementations, queries may only be sent to a fund if the
composition indicates that the fund holds a certain amount of a financial
instrument. For example, a query asking if the fund is interested in a trade to sell a 2025204532
financial instrument may only be sent to the fund if the composition indicates that
the fund holds enough of the financial instrument to fulfill the order. In some
implementations, a query may only be sent if the fund holds some other threshold
amount of the financial instrument (e.g., a million shares), holds some minimum
percentage of the threshold instrument (e.g., 10% of the makeup of the fund is the
financial instrument), the financial instrument is one of the top number of financial
instruments that make up the fund (e.g., 1 of the top 10 constituents of the fund),
and/or any other set of filters may be used.
[0320] In some implementations, changes in price of one or more
financial instruments in the composition of a fund may be used to determine
whether to query a fund regarding a trade. For example, in some embodiments, a
change to a price of a financial instrument defined by an order may be determined.
Such a change in price may be based on the time when the composition was
received, a time that the composition identifies and SO on. Such a change may be
determined based on historic and current information about a price of the financial
instrument (e.g., such information may be received from a third party such as a
stock tracker, a marketplace, and SO on).
[0321] In some embodiments, based on a determined change in price, a
determination of whether an operator of a fund is likely to be interested in a trade
that matches the trade defined by a received order may be made. The operator may
be likely to be interested if a current situation indicates that there is a heightened
chance that an operator would accept an offer for a trade. Operators may attempt
to keep a fund close to or at the composition levels based on value of the holding
of each financial instrument in the composition, SO when a price increases or
decreases the relative value of the holdings of that financial instrument may be
changed and a sale may be desired to return the composition to the target level.
Determining if the operator is likely to be interested in the opposite side of the
trade for the financial instrument includes determining if the price change includes
an increase or a decrease in price. For example, if a price change includes an
increase in price, then the operator may be determined to likely be interested if the
order includes a sale of the financial instrument. If the price change includes a
decrease in price, then the operator may be determined to be likely to be interested 2025204532
if the order includes a buy of the financial instrument. Some implementations may
take into account changes in the prices of other financial instruments in the
composition with respect to the financial instrument. Some implementations may
take into account a relative change in price of the financial instrument with respect
to changes in price of other financial instruments in the composition (e.g., to
determine if a sale or purchase may be needed to return a composition to a target
level).
[0322] If the operator of the fund accepts an order, an indication of an
acceptance may be transmitted from the fund. The acceptance may be received by
some embodiments. As described above, a trade may be facilitated in response to
receiving the acceptance.
Risk Pools
[0323] Some embodiments may perform/allow filtering of participants
based on the participants' prior actions. For example, in some embodiments, when
a participant is queried regarding an order, the response of the participant may be
tracked. Participants may be arranged into groups based on the frequency of
positive responses to queries. For example, participants may be arranged into
groups as follows: participants with 100% to 75% positive response rate,
participants with 75% to 50% positive responses, and participants with less than
50% positive responses. It should be recognized that these groups are given as an
example only, and that other embodiments may include any number of groups and
any arrangement of groups. Such groups may be referred to as risk pools.
Submitters of orders may indicate that queries regarding the orders should be sent
to participants in one or more of the groups and/or not to participants in one or
more of the groups. Because sending a query to a participant reveals information
about an order, the submitter of the order may use the response rate to limit
exposure of that information to participants that are historically likely to respond
positively.
[0324] In some embodiments, a plurality of sets of queries may be
transmitted to a plurality of participants. Each set of queries may ask the plurality 2025204532
of participants about a respective order. Each query of each set of queries may ask
a respective participant if a respective matching order to the respective order is
stored in a respective order management system associated with the respective
participant and if the respective participant accepts a respective offer to enter into a
respective trade that fulfills at least a portion of each of the order and the respective
matching order. If the participant accepts the offer, a positive response/indication
of the acceptance may be received. In some implementations, if the matching
order is stored in the order management system, an indication of that storage may
be received. Accordingly, in some implementations, it may be determined from
this information if the matching order is stored in the order management system,
and if it is stored, whether or not it was rejected or accepted. If the order is
accepted, some implementations may include facilitating execution of the trade. In
other embodiments, as described above, queries to order management systems may
not be used, but rather databases may be searched or any other methods may be
used.
[0325] In some embodiments, the plurality of participants may be assigned
to one or more risk pools based on the results of the querying. Each risk pool may
correspond to at least one rate of positive responses to offers to enter into trades.
The rate of positive responses may, for example, include a comparison (e.g., a
ratio, a percentage, etc.) between a number of positive responses and a number of
offers (e.g., offers with a characteristic, offers associated with a submitter, and SO
on). Such a rate, for example, may correspond to offers made to participants if the
matching order is stored in the order management system, to all queries sent to
participants, and/or to queries/orders having one or more characteristics. In some
implementations, a rate of positive responses includes a rate of positive responses
to all offers to enter into a trade when a matching order is stored in an order
management system. In some implementations, a rate of positive responses
includes a rate of positive responses to offers to enter into a trade when a matching
order is stored in an order management system and a query is associated with the
submitter. In some implementations, a rate of positive responses includes a rate of
positive responses to offers to enter into a trade when a matching order is stored in
an order management system and associated with an order having at least one 2025204532
similar characteristic to the order. In some implementations, such a characteristic
may include a financial instrument, a quantity range, a price range, a market
capitalization, an industry, and a financial instrument type.
[0326] In some embodiments, a submitter of an order may be allowed to
identify one or more risk pools to which queries regarding the order should and/or
should not be transmitted. For example, a submitter may use an interface to
identify such information, may transmit an electronic message identifying such
information, may establish default risk pools that identify such information, and/or
may identify such information in any other way. Some implementations may
include providing an interface through which the one or more risk pools may be
selected. Queries regarding the order may subsequently be made to participants in
accordance with such information.
[0327] Some embodiments, may include submitting one or more
orders and/or indications identifying risk pools. Some embodiments may include
receiving an indication of a plurality of risk pools. Such an indication may be
presented to a person though an interface to allow selection from among the
plurality of risk pools. Some implementations may include receiving a selection of
at least one risk pool (e.g., through an interface, through an electronic message,
etc.). Some implementations may include transmitting an indication that
participants associated with the at least one selected risk pool should be queried
regarding an order (e.g., through an electronic message, etc.). Some
implementations may include receiving an indication that execution of a trade
fulfilling an order has been facilitated. Some implementations may include
providing an indication of such a facilitation(e.g., as a display on an interface to a
person, as an electronic message, etc.).
[0328] It should be recognized that risk pools may be combined
with any other implementations and/or concepts described herein and that any
methods and/or apparatus may be used in various embodiments.
Substitutability 2025204532
[0329] In some embodiments, one financial instrument may be
substitute for another financial instrument. A substitutable financial instrument
may include an instrument that is replaceable for another instrument (e.g., fulfills a
same reason for existence, has similar characteristics, and SO on). For example, if
an order is for a first financial instrument, a second financial instrument may be
used to fulfill the order instead of the first financial instrument. The order may be
an order pending in an order management system, an order submitted by a sell side
participant, and/or any other type of order. For example, a participant that desires
to buy stock in a soda company may enter an order for Coca-Cola; however, the
order may be fulfilled with stock for PepsiCo that fulfills the desire to buy stock in
a soda company, bonds in Coca-Cola, derivatives related to Coca-Cola, a futures
contract for soda, and SO on. Various criteria/tests may be used to establish if one
financial instrument is substitutable for another financial instrument. Participants
may identify which financial instruments are substitutable for each other.
Exchange rates between financial instruments may be established based on prices
and/or desires of the various participants.
[0330] As described above, some embodiments may include
receiving an indication of an order. The order may define a side of a trade for a
first financial instrument. The indication may include an identification of one or
more other financial instruments that may be substituted for the first financial
instrument to fulfill the order. The identification may include identification of
characteristics of such other financial instruments (e.g., market cap, industry, type
of instrument, etc.), a specific enumeration of the other financial instruments,
and/or any other information from which such other financial instruments may be
determined. In some implementations, such characteristics may include an
industry, a type of financial instrument, and a market capitalization, a company,
and/or any other characteristics.
[0331] As discussed above, some embodiments may include
determining if a matching order is stored in an order management system
associated with a participant. As described above, such determination may include
transmitting one or more queries. The matching order may be for the first financial 2025204532
instrument or may be for another financial instrument. For example, in some
implementations, the matching order may be for a different financial instrument
that is substitutable for the first financial instrument. The order management
system may identify what financial instruments are substitutable for the financial
instrument for which the matching order is for. For example, the first financial
instrument may be stock in Coca-Cola and the matching order may be for stock in
PepsiCo. The order management system may identify that Coca-Cola is
substitutable for PepsiCo. Such identification may be made directly through a list
of substitutable instruments, may be made through asset of characteristics that
identify substitutable instruments, and/or in any other way.
[0332] In some implementations, if an order is for a quantity of a
first financial instrument, and a trade fulfilling the order is for a substitutable
financial instrument, the quantity of instruments traded and/or the price at which
the instruments are traded may not be the same as those identified by the order for
the first financial instrument. For example, an order for 100 shares of Coca-Cola
may be fulfilled by a trade for 50 shares of PepsiCo. The quantity and/or price at
which a trade takes place may be identified by an order management system (e.g.,
the OMs may identify a set of exchange rates between the financial instruments).
The quantity and/or price at which the trade takes place may be identified from a
market price (e.g., the market price of the two financial instruments may be used to
determine an exchange rate between them, the most recent trade price, a current
bid and/or offer, a midpoint price, etc.). The price and/or quantity may be
determined in any other way.
[0333] As discussed above, a trader may be presented with an offer
to enter into a trade. The trade may include a trade for the first financial
instrument even if the matching order is for a different financial instrument. In
other implementations, the trade may include the other financial instrument even if
the order is for the first financial instrument. The trader may accept or reject such
an offer.
[0334] In some embodiments, an acceptance of the order may be
received (e.g., if the trader accepts the offer). The acceptance may indicate that a
trade fulfilling an order should be executed. In response to receiving the 2025204532
acceptance, execution of a trade fulfilling an order may be facilitated.
[0335] From the point of view of a participant with an order in an
order management system, an indication may be received for an order for a first
financial instrument. A determination may be made that a matching order for a
second financial instrument that is substitutable for the first financial instrument is
stored in the order management system. A trader may be solicited for a binding
acceptance to enter into a trade that fulfills the order and the matching order.
Some implementations may include providing an interface through which the
binding acceptance may be requested, transmitting a request for the binding
acceptance (e.g., through an electronic message, and/or any other method of
soliciting a binding acceptance. The trade may be for the first financial instrument
even though the matching order is for a different financial instrument. In other
implementations, the trade may be for the other financial instrument even though
the order is for the first financial instrument. Only if an acceptance is received
(e.g., though an interface, from the trader, etc.) execution of the trade may be
[0336] It should be recognized that substitutability may be
combined with any other implementations and/or concepts described herein and
that any methods and/or apparatus may be used in various embodiments.
XII. Miscellaneous Information 1
[0337] Numbering of elements in the below section may not match to
numbering of elements in the previous sections. This section provides additional
disclosure of relevant material, and should not be interpreted to limit any prior
disclosures. For example, no definitions below should be applied to disclosure
above unless explicitly stated otherwise and descriptions of preference do not
apply to above disclosed embodiments.
[0338] Although computers are heavily used to facilitate trading of
securities, manual intervention may still be required at certain steps in the trading
process. For example, most traders at institutional investment management firms
record their orders to purchase or sell securities in computerized order management 2025204532
systems (OMS's). However, one or more traders at each firm may manually review
the orders in the OMS and attempt to fill the orders by contacting one or more
market intermediaries. Typically, the traders transmit the orders in the OMS by
telephone or separate data entry links to registered broker-dealers for the securities,
to electronic marketplaces that trade the securities, or to other market
intermediaries. Accordingly, manual effort is often required to actually execute the
orders in the OMS.
[0339] One problem arising from this manual effort is that institutional
traders may be unable to execute trades involving large quantities of securities
without adversely affecting the market price of the securities. For example,
institutional traders often need to trade large quantities of securities due to the
continuing need of investment managers to respond to changes in market
conditions by altering the contents of their investment portfolios. As these
portfolios increase in size due to increased investor activity, the corresponding
quantity of securities to be traded in order to achieve a similar portfolio balance
also increases. Market impact costs, or adverse costs resulting from the
institutional traders' activities, rise in such circumstances because locating parties
with whom to trade such large quantities of securities becomes more difficult for
the market intermediaries.
[0340] Moreover, if the market intermediaries become aware that an
institutional firm wants to, say, sell a large block of a particular equity security,
this awareness is likely to lower the sale price that the institutional firm can obtain
due to the normal processes of supply and demand. The effect is also likely to be
exacerbated by speculation from others with knowledge of the order as to why the
particular investor wishes to sell such a large quantity of the security. Similarly, if
market intermediaries become aware of the fact than an institutional firm wants to
buy a large block of a particular equity security, this awareness will likely increase
the purchase price that the institutional firm will have to pay. This adverse effect
on price is further exacerbated by the fact that traditional market intermediaries
trade for their own accounts.
[0341] One strategy commonly employed by institutional traders to offset
market impact costs is to spread out trade orders for a large quantity of a security 2025204532
into small orders each handled by a different market intermediary, sometimes over
several trading days. Of course, this strategy brings about its own problems in that
the market price can change significantly during this extended trading period due
to the unforeseeable activities of others.
[0342] Another strategy that may be employed is to spread the orders for
the security among one or more electronic marketplaces. However, the traders may
need to manually transmit each order to the electronic marketplaces using a
telephone or a separate data entry link. The fact that the traders may need to
perform these extra steps, which include duplicate entry of basic order data already
recorded in the OMS, causes many traders to use these electronic marketplaces
infrequently, and to supply the marketplaces with only a small subset of the total
orders. As a result, these electronic marketplaces often lack the liquidity required
by a trader to timely execute orders.
[0343] The lack of integration between the OMS and the electronic
marketplaces also poses problems when an institutional trader wishes to trade a
particular security simultaneously within an electronic marketplace and, for
example, over the telephone with a traditional broker. For example, some
electronic marketplaces attempt to find matches at only specific time intervals. If a
trader wishes to buy 100,000 shares of IBM, and has placed an order for half that
amount in an electronic marketplace, the trader will not know how much, if any,
IBM stock was purchased until after the next scheduled match attempt. In the
meantime, the trader potentially could have purchased more than 50,000 shares
from a broker over the phone at a better price.
[0344] Therefore, there is a need in the art for an electronic trading
marketplace that does not require a significant amount of manual intervention by
traders or other parties, offers anonymity, and offers a high amount of liquidity.
[0345] Some embodiments address the above need by providing for the
automated transmission of orders (i.e., without manual trader intervention) from
the various order management systems (OMS's) used by investment management
firms or other entities having trading systems to an electronic trading marketplace
(ETM). A firm with a trading system stores information about orders in an OMS to
manage its order flow, to monitor the initiation, placement, and execution of 2025204532
orders, and for related purposes. Software providing the functionality of an OMS is
well known in the art.
[0346] OMS interfacing modules (OIMs) at the firms may automatically
transmit orders from the OMS's to the ETM and preferably update the OMS's in
response to orders executed at the ETM. Traders can communicate with the ETM
to anonymously negotiate trades of securities. As used herein, a "security" is an
ownership or creditorship interest, such as a stock certificate, bond, or any other
financial instrument, contract or transaction, such as a forward, futures, option, put,
call, collar, swap, or currency contract on any security. This description uses the
term "security" for convenience but it should be understood that the term covers
financial instruments generally. It should also be understood that other
embodiments may be used for trading of other goods and/or services.
[0347] The ETM may include an OMS data integration module (ODIM)
for receiving and processing data representative of orders received from the OIMs.
In a preferred embodiment, the data from the OIMs are provided to the ETM in a
standardized format that requires little processing by the ODIM. The orders
processed by the ODIM may be stored in an ETM database.
[0348] A negotiation module in the ETM may support negotiations
between traders. In one embodiment, an indications module transmits orders
received by the ETM among the traders based upon filtering criteria established by
the traders and/or the ETM. These orders are transmitted among the traders in the
form of non-binding indications. Based upon these indications, traders at one
institution can enter into negotiations with traders at other institutions, through the
negotiation module of the ETM. In one embodiment, at least parts of the
negotiations are conducted anonymously.
[0349] A trader authentication module may authorize and/or authenticate
traders who log into the ETM in order to perform trading negotiations and/or other
functions. A transaction history module may record transactions performed by the
ETM in the ETM database. The transaction history module also preferably records
other data processed by the ETM including, for example, the orders received from
and sent to the trading systems and the conducted negotiations. 2025204532
[0350] A typical trading system at an investment management firm or other
entity at which trading is performed includes a number of workstations coupled to
an OMS server via a network, with a trader at each workstation. Each workstation
preferably executes a trader OMS interaction module (TOIM) for facilitating
interactions between the trader's workstation and the OMS server. In one
embodiment of the present invention, the TOIM allows a trader to add, delete, or
modify open or contemplated orders stored in the OMS database. The OMS, which
includes the OMS server, OMS database, and TOIM, is typically provided by an
OMS vendor, though some firms have developed their own OMS's.
[0351] In connection with the present invention, each workstation also
preferably executes an ETM interaction module (EIM) for facilitating interactions
with the ETM. The EIM allows a trader to send information to the ETM and view
and respond to information received from the ETM. Typically, this information
includes information about the trader's indications, information about other traders'
indications, and orders transmitted to and received by a trader during a negotiation.
[0352] The OMS database holds data representative of open, contemplated,
and/or completed orders to buy and/or sell securities by traders using the trading
system. The OIM is in communication with the OMS database and the ETM. An
OMS database integration module in the OIM may read data records stored in the
OMS database and, in a preferred embodiment, also creates and modifies data
records stored in the OMS database upon execution of a trade through the ETM. In
one embodiment, the OMS database interaction module directly accesses the OMS
database and in another embodiment it sends commands to an application
programming interface (API) in the OMS for accessing the database.
[0353] The OIM may include an ETM communication module for
communicating with the ETM. In one embodiment, the ETM communication
module provides selected data records in the OMS database to the ETM and, in a
preferred embodiment, receives data and/or instructions from the ETM regarding
changes to make to the OMS database. In addition, the OIM preferably includes a
data record conversion module for modifying the format of data records sent to the
ETM and/or received from the ETM. The OIM also preferably includes a filtering
module for filtering out specified orders by security type, security name, order 2025204532
type, order price, order quantity, or other category, SO that those orders are not
transmitted to the ETM.
[0354] In some embodiments, the OIM or some other component may
include a reasoning module. Such a reasoning module may determine why a
particular order is present in an OMS database (e.g., by asking a trader entering the
order, by receiving such information from a trader, by searching strategy
information that also may be stored by an OMS, by analyzing trading behavior, by
receiving information from a risk model associated with a trader, etc.). In some
embodiments, the reasoning module may be used to suggest and/or enter orders for
securities that fulfill reasons for other orders being present. Such functionality may
be useful if an order would otherwise go unfulfilled and a reasonable alternative
security is available.
[0355] Preferably, the OIM transmits to the ETM data records in the OMS
database relating to a trader's orders when the trader logs on to the ETM. Once the
OIM determines that the trader has logged on to the ETM, the OIM retrieves data
records about that trader's orders suitable for transmission to the ETM from the
OMS database. In one embodiment, the OIM converts the data records retrieved
from the OMS database into a standardized format understood by the ETM. In
another embodiment, this functionality is part of the ETM.
[0356] After a trader has logged on to the ETM, the OIM determines
whether the contents of the OMS database have changed. If the OMS database has
changed, the OIM determines whether the change should be transmitted to the
ETM. In one embodiment, the OIM continues to determine whether the contents of
the OMS database have changed between the time that a trader logs on to the ETM
and the time that the ETM commences trading. In another embodiment, the OIM
does not commence making this determination until the time that the ETM
commences trading.
[0357] Because typical OMS's are complex and multi-featured, and
because securities of types not handled by the ETM may be traded using the OMS,
some changes to the OMS database do not necessitate a transmission of updated
data to the ETM. The OIM preferably transmits changes to the database to the 2025204532
ETM if the changes represent new or modified orders.
[0358] The OIM preferably updates the database in response to information
received from the ETM indicating executed trades or other information. In a
preferred embodiment, if an execution occurred in the ETM involving an order in
the OMS associated with the OIM, the OIM receives information from the ETM
describing the execution. This information includes, for example, the type, amount,
and price of securities traded, the time of execution, and/or information identifying
the original order in the OMS database on which the execution was based. The
OIM converts the received information about the execution into the format used by
the OMS and updates the OMS database accordingly. As a result of these steps, the
OMS is updated automatically and transparently to reflect executions performed at
the ETM. The executions appear to the OMS as typical trades conducted at another
broker, SO no special functionality needs to be added to the OMS in order to
interact with the ETM beyond that functionality described herein.
[0359] Although several embodiments may be described as involving
"traders" it should be recognized that other embodiments may not involve traders
in all the same ways as described or at all. Rather than involving traders in
negotiations, entering of trades in an OMS, and/or other actions, some
embodiments may be automated through a trading algorithm. Such a trading
algorithm may control the entry of traders, the negotiation of deals, and/or any
other actions that would traditionally be controlled by one or more traders at a
trading institution.
[0360] FIG. 15 is a high-level block diagram illustrating an electronic
trading marketplace (ETM) environment according to an embodiment of the
present invention;
[0361] FIG. 16 is a high-level block diagram illustrating more details of the
ETM;
[0362] FIG. 17 is a lower-level block diagram illustrating a trading system
like those illustrated in FIG. 15;
[0363] FIG. 18 is a diagram illustrating a data record stored in the order
management system (OMS) database to identify an order according to one 2025204532
embodiment of the present invention;
[0364] FIG. 19 is a diagram illustrating a placement record preferably
stored in the OMS database to indicate a placement of an order at a particular
venue;
[0365] FIG. 20 is a diagram illustrating an execution record preferably
stored in the OMS database to indicate the execution of an order;
[0366] FIG. 21 is a flow diagram illustrating actions performed by an
embodiment of the present invention when a trader logs on to the ETM;
[0367] FIG. 22 is a flow diagram illustrating actions performed by an
embodiment of the present invention after a trader has logged on to the ETM; and
[0368] FIG. 23 is a flow diagram illustrating actions performed by a
preferred embodiment of the present invention when the OMS database is updated
in response to a trade executed by the ETM.
[0369] U.S. patent number 7,136,834 to Merrin (hereinafter, "Merrin"), et
al. is hereby incorporated herein by reference in its entirety, including, the
specification of Merrin, the prosecution file history of Merrin, and any other
material that provides meaning to any portion of the patent. Accordingly, terms
that have a meaning in Merrin (e.g., based on the specification, based on the
prosecution file history, based on other material that provides a meaning to the any
portion of the patent, etc.) are intended to have the same meaning herein. Thus, the
person of ordinary skill in the art would understand terms used in Merrin and used
herein to have the same meaning.
[0370] FIG. 15 is a high-level block diagram illustrating an electronic
trading marketplace (ETM) environment according to an embodiment of the
present invention. An ETM 110 is in communication with three trading systems
112A, 112B, 112C. Although only three trading systems 112 are illustrated,
embodiments of the present invention can have many more (or fewer) trading
systems 112 in communication with the ETM 110. FIG. 15 illustrates only three
trading systems 112 in order to enhance the clarity of this description.
[0371] In some embodiments, an ETM may be configured to couple to
other ETMs and / or other marketplaces. For example, one particular ETM may be
configured to facilitate trades between traders coupled to the particular ETM. That 2025204532
particular ETM may, in some circumstances (e.g., if no counter parties for a
particular order is available at the particular ETM) may transmit information about
orders to another ETM to try to find counter parties through that other ETM.
Accordingly, one ETM may be able to avail itself of orders/traders associated with
other ETMs. Transmitting order information to other ETMs may be performed
after asking a trader associated with a particular order if such transmission is
acceptable and / or according to a previously established trading preference of a
particular trader. In some embodiments, different ETMs may be configured to
trade different things. For example, one ETM may be configured to trade stocks,
and another ETM may be configured to trade derivatives. The coupling of such
ETMs configured to trade different things may be particularly useful in
embodiments configured to offer additional products and / or services to traders
based on knowledge regarding orders submitted by traders, as discussed in more
detail below.
[0372] The trading systems 112A, 112B, 112C are used by investment
management firms or other entities that have established a relationship with the
ETM 110. The trading systems 112 communicate with the ETM 110 to facilitate
the trading of securities. As used herein, a "security" is any ownership or
creditorship interest, such as a stock certificate or bond, or any other financial
instrument, contract, or transaction, such as a forward, futures, option, put, call,
collar, swap, or currency contract. This definition includes, for example, any note,
stock, bond, debenture, certificate of interest or participation in any profit-sharing
agreement or in any oil, gas, or other mineral royalty or lease, any collateral trust
certificate, investment contract, voting-trust certificate, certificate of deposit, any
put, call, straddle, option, or privilege on any of the foregoing, or group or index of
securities (including any interest therein or based on the value thereof). This list is
not all-inclusive. For purposes of clarity, this description will describe the trading
of stock.
[0373] Within each trading system 112 is a database 114A, 114B, 114C
associated with an order management system (OMS). Each OMS database 114
holds data representative of open, contemplated, and/or completed orders to buy
and/or sell securities (collectively referred to herein as "orders for securities") by 2025204532
traders using the trading system 112. For example, assume that the database 114A
of trading system 112A contains orders to sell 50,000 shares of DELL and 75,000
shares of MSFT and orders to buy 25,000 shares of CPQ and 100,000 shares of
IBM. Also assume that the database 114B of trading system 112B contains orders
to sell 30,000 shares of CPQ and buy 62,000 shares of T.
[0374] The orders in the OMS databases 114 may be automatically
transmitted to the ETM 110. Likewise, any changes in the orders, such as
modifications and/or withdrawals, may be automatically transmitted to the ETM
110. As used herein, the term "automatically" means that the associated action is
performed without any human or manual intervention. Thus, there is no need for
traders to specifically request that individual orders in the OMS databases 114 are
transmitted to the ETM 110; orders in the databases are sent to the ETM 110
without the traders' input (subject to filtering criteria).
[0375] In some embodiments, orders in OMS databases may not be
automatically transmitted to the ETM 110. Rather, traders may individually select
orders from an OMS database to be transmitted to the ETM 110. Because some
trading firms may fear that information about some of the orders stored within their
OMS databases may be used maliciously if that information is revealed, using such
selective transmission rather than automatic transmission may enable trading firms
to keep particularly sensitive order information from being transmitted while
allowing less sensitive order information to be transmitted.
[0376] Preferably, the ETM 110 anonymously transmits information about
a trader's orders to other traders using the ETM, subject to filtering in accordance
with filtering criteria established by the traders and/or the ETM. Moreover, the
ETM 110 preferably manages anonymous negotiations between traders using the
trading systems 112 for the purpose of executing the orders and sends data about
the completed trades to the OMS's of the traders involved in the transaction.
[0377] Thus, one embodiment of the present invention selectively
broadcasts information about the orders received by the ETM 110 from the
database 114A of trading system 112A to the other trading systems 112B, 112C.
Likewise, the ETM 110 selectively broadcasts information about the orders 2025204532
received from the database 114B of trading system 112B to the other trading
systems 112A, 112C. If the traders desire such a trade, the ETM 110 will facilitate
the anonymous negotiation and sale of 25,000 shares of CPQ from a trader using
trading system 112B to a trader using trading system 112A.
[0378] In some embodiments, an order from a first trader may be
narrowcast to potential counter parties. To determine which other traders are
potential counter parties, the ETM may match the order from the first trader with
orders received from other traders (e.g., by security name, type, order size, price,
etc.). If matching orders are available from other traders, those traders may be
identified as potential counter parties and information about the order from the first
trader may be transmitted to those traders.
[0379] Data may be communicated between the trading systems 112 and
the ETM 110 using interfacing links 116A, 116B, 116C. Any known interfacing
technologies can be used to effectuate these links, including, but not limited to,
transmission control protocol/Internet protocol (TCP/IP), satellite, cellular, and/or
radio frequency (RF) links, or some combination thereof. The links may pass
through one or more intermediate data processing systems, such as telephone
switches or Internet servers, before reaching the ETM 110 or a trading system 112.
In embodiments where data travels over shared links, such as embodiments where
data travels over the public Internet, the data is preferably encrypted using a secure
protocol, such as the secure sockets layer (SSL).
[0380] FIG. 16 is a high-level block diagram illustrating more details of the
ETM 110. Those of skill in the art will recognize that FIG. 16 illustrates only one
possible embodiment of the ETM 110. Obviously, different combinations of
hardware and software can be used to provide the functionality of the ETM 110
described herein.
[0381] Data received by the ETM 110 from the trading systems 112 over
the interfacing links 116 may be received by a firewall 210. As is known in the art,
the firewall 210 preferably prevents unauthorized users from gaining access to the
rest of the ETM 110 and monitors transfers of data to and from the network.
[0382] Data that pass through the firewall 210 may be received by one or
more modules that perform the functionality of the ETM 110. As used herein, the 2025204532
term "module" refers to machine-executable code and/or data, but may also include
associated circuitry, such as processing circuitry, as well as data storage areas,
and/or any other software or hardware. Thus, it will be appreciated that one or a
combination of hardware and software, such as a computer system executing
software for performing the functionality of the modules, may implement each of
the modules shown in FIG. 16. It will also be appreciated by those skilled in the art
that the ETM 110 may comprise one or more other types of modules, circuitry,
etc., not shown in FIG. 16 in order to avoid unnecessarily obscuring understanding
of the invention. For instance, the ETM 110 may include one or more
microprocessors, network connection circuitry, and/or data storage areas, such as
read-only memory (ROM), random-access memory (RAM), CDROM, DVD, tape
drive, hard disk (HD), and/or other types of storage areas. It will also be
appreciated that the functionality of multiple modules described herein can be
combined into a single module and the functionality of a single module can be split
or shared among multiple modules. Moreover, alternative embodiments of the
present invention can lack one or more of the modules described herein and/or
have modules not described herein.
[0383] The ETM 110 preferably includes an OMS data integration module
(ODIM) 212. The ODIM 212 receives and processes data representative of orders
received from the OMS databases 114 in the trading systems 112. In a preferred
embodiment, the data from the OMS databases 114 are provided to the ETM 110
in a standardized format that requires little processing by the ODIM 212. In an
alternative embodiment, the data from the OMS databases 114 are provided to the
ETM 110 in one or more different formats depending upon factors such as the type
of OMS used by the trading systems 112, the types of interfacing links supplying
the data to the ETM, the type of security or orders to which the data pertains, and
the like. In this latter embodiment, the ODIM 212 preferably converts the data into
a standardized format for use by other modules in the ETM 110.
[0384] The orders processed by the ODIM 212 may be stored in an ETM
database 214. Data in the database 214 are preferably accessible to the other
modules in the ETM 110. In addition, the other modules in the ETM 110 can store
other data in the illustrated database 214 or other databases as may be required 2025204532
during normal operation.
[0385] In a preferred embodiment, an indications module 216 transmits
information about orders received by the ETM 110 among the various traders
based upon filtering criteria established by the traders and/or the ETM. This
information is transmitted among the traders in the form of non-binding
indications.
[0386] Based upon these indications, traders may be able to enter into
negotiations with other traders through a negotiation module 218. The negotiation
module 218 may facilitate negotiations between traders using trading systems and
having contra interests. In one embodiment, at least parts of the negotiations are
conducted anonymously, in order to limit the spread of information about the
traders' activities.
[0387] A market data module 220 may receive real-time and/or other
market data from an input 222. The market data module 220 may provide the
market data to the negotiation module 218 and/or to the traders. The traders
preferably use the market data during the negotiations to determining market prices
for the securities.
[0388] A transaction history module 224 may record transactions
performed by the ETM 110 in the database 214. The transaction history module
224 also preferably records other data processed by the ETM 110 including, for
example, information about orders received from and sent to the trading systems
112 and the negotiations conducted (successful or not). This module 224 is
preferably used to audit the transactions conducted on the ETM 110.
[0389] In some embodiments, the transaction history module may record
transaction information as well as information about orders that were placed but
unfulfilled. Such information may be used to provide products, and/or services to
traders. For example, information about a frequency of orders placed for a
particular security may be recorded and used to inform traders about how liquid a
market for the security has been historically and/or how long an order may take to
be fulfilled based on historic trades. As another example, information about
fulfilled transactions for a particular trader may be used to provide information
about other goods or services that the trader may desire, such as hedging 2025204532
opportunities related to the trades (e.g., available futures trades on a same or
different ETM that may be used to hedge an equity purchase, etc.). As yet another
example, some embodiments may use recorded information to determine that
major changes in a trading pattern of a security (e.g., a major price drop, a major
change in liquidity, etc.) has occurred, and use such information to adjust
performance (e.g., prepare for a major increase in trading activity, offload orders to
a different market, pause acceptance of orders temporarily until trading has
stabilized, etc.) trade on a security (e.g., for an account/fund associated with an
ETM operator) and/or provide such information to traders.
[0390] A trader authentication module 226 may authorize and/or
authenticate traders who log into the ETM 110 in order to perform trading
negotiations and/or other functions. In one embodiment, the trader authentication
module 226 stores authentication information, such as a login ID/password pair in
the database 214. The trader authentication module 226 also preferably stores
profiles for the registered traders.
[0391] Other modules that may be present in the ETM 110 include load
monitoring modules for monitoring the load on various servers comprising the
ETM, fault tolerance modules for providing fault tolerance to the ETM, security
modules for preventing and detecting security violations on the ETM, and back
office modules for providing back office functionality. These modules are not
shown in FIG. 16 in order to avoid unnecessarily complicating the figure.
[0392] FIG. 17 is a lower-level block diagram illustrating a trading system
112 like those illustrated in FIG. 15. Those of ordinary skill in the art will
recognize that FIG. 17 illustrates only one possible embodiment of a trading
system 112 and alternative embodiments of the trading system exist. FIG. 17
illustrates three workstations 310A, 310B, 310C coupled to an OMS server 312 via
a network 314. The workstations 310 are preferably general- or specific-purpose
computer systems executing specialized software for facilitating trading of
securities. Although only three workstations 310 are illustrated, a trading system
112 can have any practical number of workstations.
[0393] In a typical trading system that interacts with the ETM 110, each
workstation 310 executes a trader OMS interaction module 316 (TOIM) for 2025204532
facilitating interactions with the OMS server 312. In this typical trading system,
the TOIM 316 allows a trader to add, delete, or modify open or contemplated
orders stored in the OMS database 114. Contemplated orders may be stored in the
OMS database 114, for example, because the trader intends to execute certain
transactions in stages, or because the contemplated transactions are desirable only
if the market prices of the securities to be traded are within a certain range (e.g.,
limit orders). Therefore, such orders serve as placeholders indicating the total
quantity of a security that a trader wishes to transact and conditions for transacting
other orders; other data in the database 114 indicate the quantity of the security that
has been transacted to date.
[0394] Each workstation 310 may execute an ETM interaction module 318
(EIM) for facilitating interactions with the ETM 110. In alternative embodiments
of the present invention, the EIM 318 is incorporated into the TOIM 316 or other
modules on the workstation 310. The EIM 318 allows a trader to send information
to the ETM 110 and view and respond to information received from the ETM 110.
Typically, the received information includes information about orders (through the
indications module 216) and orders (through the negotiation module 218) that the
ETM 110 receives from other traders or trading institutions. The trader uses the
EIM 318 to enter into and transact negotiations to buy and/or sell securities
through the ETM 110.
[0395] The network 314 connects the workstations 310 to the OMS 312
and to external networks such as the network in communication with the ETM 110.
The network 314 can utilize any networking technology that supports bi-
directional transfer of data among the OMS 312, workstations 310, and external
networks. In a typical embodiment, the network 314 is a private local area network
(LAN) installed at a financial institution and interfacing with one or more external
gateways. In alternate embodiments, the network may be wireless, connect devices
over a wide area, and/or at least partially carry data over a public network (such as
the Internet). Other network components, such as a firewall, may also be present.
Those of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that many different types of
networks can perform the functionality described herein.
[0396] The OMS 312 is preferably comprised of one or more computer 2025204532
systems for executing and maintaining an order management system. The OMS
312 receives instructions from the workstations to create, modify, and/or delete
orders and updates the database 114 accordingly. Software providing the
functionality of the OMS 312 is well known in the art. Commercial OMS software
packages are available from The MacGregor Group, Eze Castle Software, Advent
Software, and Decalog, to name but a few. In addition, some trading institutions
utilize custom OMS software.
[0397] As described above, the database 114 may hold data representative
of open, contemplated, and/or completed orders to buy and/or sell securities. FIG.
18 is a diagram illustrating a data record 400 stored in the database 114 to identify
an order according to one embodiment of the present invention. Different OMS
systems utilize different order data records and, therefore, it should be understood
that FIG. 18 illustrates only one possible data record. However, many OMS
systems store the same general information and the illustrated order data record
400 is intended to represent a typical order data record for an OMS system.
[0398] The order data record 400 has multiple fields, each field holding
different information about an order. The Order ID field 410 preferably holds a
value uniquely identifying the order associated with the data record 400. Similarly,
the Trader ID field 412 preferably holds a value uniquely identifying the trader or
other person who placed the order. The Order Status field 414 identifies whether
the order is open, contemplated, completed, canceled, or any other possible status.
The next field, Order Last Update Time 416, preferably holds a timestamp that
identifies the last time that the data record 400 was modified in any way. This field
416 is useful for determining whether the most recent version of the data record
400 has been considered.
[0399] The Transaction Type field 418 preferably indicates whether the
data record 400 corresponds to an order to buy or sell a security. The Security
Symbol field 420 preferably uniquely identifies the security to be transacted. The
Security Symbol field 420 can hold, for example, a Committee on Uniform
Securities Identification Procedures (CUSIP) number, a ticker symbol, or any other
identifier of the security. The Security Type field 422 is preferably used to 2025204532
interpret the other data in the data record 400 according to the given security type.
For example, treasury bills are priced in terms of a discount to face value; inherent
in the pricing formula is the yield that would be obtained if the bill were held to
maturity. In contrast, equity securities are priced in actual per-share values. The
information in the Security Type field 422 can also be used to filter out certain
types of securities.
[0400] The Order Type field 424 preferably indicates whether the order is a
market or a limit order, although the field can also indicate other order types. If the
order is a limit order, the Limit Price Field 426 preferably identifies the price set
by the trader.
[0401] The Total Order Size field 428 preferably identifies the actual
number of shares that the trader desires to transact. The Quantity Placed Elsewhere
field 430 is a value either equal to or less than the value in the Total Order Size
field 428. In an embodiment of the present invention, the ETM 110 uses the values
of these two fields 428, 430 to determine a quantity of a security, if any, that are
available to be transacted by the ETM.
[0402] Preferably, the OMS 312 allows for the possibility that trading a
large quantity of a given security may occur over several days at several different
venues. For example, to fill an order to buy 1,000,000 shares of IBM, a trader may
need to place an order for 300,000 shares with one broker, and record numerous
executions of portions thereof until the full 300,000 shares placed with that broker
are purchased. If the broker cannot provide additional shares at a suitable price, the
trader may then place an additional quantity, up to the 700,000 shares remaining to
be purchased, via another broker, electronic marketplace, or other venue.
Preferably, the broker enters a placement record into the OMS database 114 to
indicate that the trader anticipates executing a portion of the order through the
second venue. This second venue may also fill the quantity it was asked to provide
in several executions. Thus, an order can have one or more placements and each
placement can have one or more executions associated with it.
[0403] FIG. 19 is a diagram illustrating a placement record 500 preferably
stored in the OMS database 114 to indicate a placement of an order at a particular
venue. The Order ID field 510 preferably holds a value that uniquely identifies the 2025204532
order associated with the placement. The Order ID field 510 ties the placement
information to the overall order. Thus, all placements for the same order preferably
have the same value in this field 510. The Broker field 512 preferably contains an
alphanumeric value identifying the venue associated with the placement record.
Lastly, the Quantity Placed with Broker field 514 preferably lists the portion of the
total order size that is placed for fulfillment through the venue.
[0404] When a transaction is executed in a specified venue, such as the
ETM 110, a corresponding execution record is preferably stored in the OMS
database 114. FIG. 20 is a diagram illustrating an execution record 600 according
to an embodiment of the present invention. An execution ID field 608 preferably
holds a value identifying the particular execution. As before, the Order ID field
610 preferably holds a value that uniquely identifies the order associated with the
execution and all executions for the same order preferably have the same value in
this field 610. The Broker field 612 preferably contains an alphanumeric value
identifying the venue that performed the execution. The Quantity Executed field
614 preferably specifies the number of securities transacted in this execution while
the Price field 616 specifies the price at which the securities were executed. The
Timestamp field 618 preferably records the time at which the execution took place.
[0405] The OMS interfacing module (OIM) 320 may be in communication
with the OMS database 114 via the network 314 or a direct connection. In
alternative embodiments, the OIM 320 is in communication with the OMS 312
and/or the workstations 310. The OIM 320 may also be in communication with the
ETM 110 via an external gateway or some other form of network connection. In
another alternative embodiment, the OIM 320 is integrated into the ETM 110 and
is remote from the OMS 312, although some functionality is present at the OMS in
order to provide OMS data to the OIM.
[0406] In a preferred embodiment, the OIM 320 includes a computer
system storing and executing software for performing the functionality described
herein. In an alternative embodiment, the OIM 320 executes on the same computer
system as the OMS 312. In one embodiment, the OIM 320 includes an OMS
database interaction module 322 for interacting with the OMS database 114. The
OMS database interaction module 322 reads records stored in the OMS database 2025204532
114 and, in a preferred embodiment, creates and modifies data records stored in the
OMS database 114. In one embodiment, the OMS database interaction module 322
directly accesses the OMS database 114 and in another embodiment it sends
commands to an applications programming interface (API) in the OMS 312 for
accessing the database.
[0407] The OIM 320 also preferably includes an ETM communication
module 324 for communicating with the ETM 110. In one embodiment, the ETM
communication module 324 automatically provides selected data records in the
OMS database 114 to the ETM 110 and, in a preferred embodiment, receives data
and/or instructions from the ETM. In addition, the OIM 320 also preferably
includes a data record conversion module 326 for modifying the format of the data
records sent to and/or received from the ETM 110 and a filtering module 238 for
filtering out specified orders by security type, security name, order type, order
quantity, order price, or some other factor or category, SO that filtered orders are
not transmitted to the ETM.
[0408] FIG. 21 is a flow diagram illustrating actions performed by an
embodiment of the present invention when a trader logs on to the ETM 110.
Although the actions of FIG. 21 and subsequent figures are attributed herein to the
OIM 320, one of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that all or some of the
actions can be carried out by other entities.
[0409] Preferably, the OIM 320 waits 710 until a trader logs on to the OMS
312 before transmitting data records for that trader to the ETM 110. In one
embodiment, the ETM 110 sends a message to the OIM 320 when a trader at the
institution in which the OIM 320 resides logs into the ETM. The OIM 320
interprets this message as a sign to commence receiving orders. In other
embodiments of the present invention, the OIM 320 uses other techniques, such as
querying the OMS database 114 for specific entries, listening for an inter-process
message sent by the OMS 312, polling individual trader workstations 310, or
implementing a timer-based algorithm, to determine that a trader has logged on to
the OMS 312.
[0410] Once a determination 710 is made that a trader has logged on to the
OMS 312 the OIM 320 may retrieve 712 data records about orders suitable for 2025204532
transmission to the ETM from the OMS database 114. In one embodiment of the
present invention, all open orders are suitable for transmission to the ETM 110. In
other embodiments of the present invention, the OIM 320, through the filtering
module 328, makes the determination of suitable orders based on other criteria,
such as the security type (e.g., stock or bond), security name (e.g., IBM or T),
order type (e.g., market or limit order), order quantity, and/or order price. In still
other embodiments, only orders selected by a trading firm (e.g., by the trader)
associated with the OMS may be suitable for transmission.
[0411] If necessary, the data record conversion module 326 within the OIM
320 preferably converts 714 the data records retrieved from the OMS database 114
into a standardized format understood by the ETM 110. As described above, the
functionality of the data record conversion module 326 can also be performed by
the ODIM 212 in the ETM 110. Alternative embodiments of the present invention
may send the data records individually or in multiple batches. The data transmitted
to the ETM 110 depend on factors such as the types of securities being traded,
and/or the fields required in order to accurately trade such securities.
[0412] FIG. 22 is a flow diagram illustrating the actions performed by an
embodiment of the present invention after a trader has logged on to the OMS
during the trading day. The actions of FIG. 22 are preferably automatically
performed multiple times during the trading day. Initially, the OIM 320 may
determine 810 whether the contents of the OMS database 114 have changed. The
OIM 320 can perform this step by, for example, polling the database 114 at
regular, near-real-time intervals, querying the database for contents of specified
fields such as timestamps, and/or listening for network or specific interprocess
communication message traffic.
[0413] If the database has changed, the OIM 320 preferably determines
whether the change should be transmitted to the ETM 110. Because typical OMS's
are complex and multi-featured, and because securities of types not handled by the
ETM 110 may be traded using the OMS 312, some changes to the OMS database
114 may not necessitate a transmission of updated data to the ETM 110. Thus, the
OIM 320 may determine 812 whether the change to the database 114 reflects a 2025204532
new order of a type that is traded in the ETM 110 (and in some embodiments, other
ETMs and/or marketplaces coupled to the ETM 110). If so, then the OIM 320 may
retrieve 816 the pertinent data for the order from the database 114. If the change
does not reflect a new order, then the OIM 320 preferably determines 814 whether
the database change pertains to a modification of an existing order that has already
been sent to the ETM 110. If so, the OIM 320 may retrieve 818 the data records
corresponding to the modified order from the database 114. Once the appropriate
data records, if any, are retrieved from the database, the OIM 320 preferably
converts 820 the data records into the appropriate format and transmits the records
to the ETM 110 as described above with respect to FIG. 21.
[0414] FIG. 23 is a flow diagram illustrating the actions performed by an
embodiment of the present invention when the OMS database 114 is updated in
response to a trade executed by the ETM 110. The illustrated steps can be
performed each time a trade is executed, or in batch. However, the steps are
preferably performed frequently enough SO that the OMS database 114 is updated
in substantially real-time.
[0415] The OIM 320 initially may determine 910 whether an execution
occurred in the ETM 110 involving an order in the OMS 312 associated with the
OIM. The step may be performed, for example, by receiving a message from the
ETM 110 identifying a particular execution that occurred at the ETM, by filtering a
list of all executions or other data from the ETM for executions listed in the OMS
312, or by periodically polling the ETM for performed executions.
[0416] If an execution occurred in the ETM 110 involving an order in the
OMS 312 associated with the OIM 320, the OIM receives 912 information from
the ETM describing the execution. This information includes, for example, the
type, amount, and price of securities traded, the time of execution, and/or
information identifying the original order in the OMS database 114 on which the
execution was based. The OIM 320 may convert 914 the received information
about the execution into the format used by the OMS 312. Then, the OIM 320 may
update 916 the OMS database 114 with the converted execution data. As a result of
these steps, the OMS 312 may be updated automatically and transparently to
reflect executions performed at the ETM 110. The executions appear to the OMS 2025204532
312 as typical trades conducted at another broker.
[0417] In some embodiments information about orders in an OMS database
and/or any other information about a trading institution may be used to provide
additional (e.g., complimentary, alternative) products and/or services to traders.
The information about the orders may include the existence of the orders, the
existence of counter orders, the lack of counter orders, historical data about similar
orders, historical data about counter orders, knowledge that an order was
unfulfilled (e.g., for some time period, was removed from the system in an
unfulfilled state, etc.), knowledge about a broader trading plan that may be
embodied by specific orders (e.g., knowledge that a particular order is present
because of a desire to trade in a particular industry, market capitalization, etc.),
knowledge that an order was fulfilled, knowledge that an order is now inactive
(e.g., was fulfilled, expired, was unfulfilled, etc.) information about a risk model,
and/or any other information. In some embodiments, such features may be
available to premium users of an ETM (e.g., users willing to pay a fee). The
additional products and/or service may be available through a single ETM and/or
additional ETMs.
[0418] In some embodiments, an ETM, OIM, OMS, and/or other
component may track (e.g., determine when an order becomes inactive and store
information about it) unfulfilled orders (e.g., expired orders and/or orders that were
removed (e.g., removed from an OMS, removed from consideration by the ETM,
etc.)). The knowledge that an order was once placed and was not fulfilled may
reveal that a trader associated with the order may desire a trade in a security
associated with the order in the future. When new orders are received, there may
be no available counter parties currently trading in a security identified by the
order. The existence of counter parties may be determined by searching (e.g.,
through a listing maintained in a database of the ETM) for matching offers
received from a plurality of other traders using an ETM. In some implementations,
if no such parties are available, unfulfilled orders may be used to find such parties.
Such use of unfulfilled orders may occur after a new order has been active (e.g.,
near an expiration time of the order, after an indication that the order is being
otherwise removed from the system is received, etc.). 2025204532
[0419] The use of such unfulfilled orders may include querying a party
associated with the unfilled order (or any other inactive order). Such query may
ask if the party is still interested in a trade related to the security and/or identify
that a matching counter order is now available. The party may then reenter an
order, enter into negotiations with the party associated with the new order, ignore
the request, and/or take any other desired actions.
[0420] In some embodiments, before such unfulfilled orders are used, a
party associated with the new order may be asked if such use is desired. To
encourage the use of such orders for matching, the party associated with the new
order may be provided with statistics related to the usefulness of such orders. The
statistics may be gathered by a transactional history module of an ETM and may
include, for example, a percentage of times when such orders have successfully
fulfilled an order, and/or any other desired information. The information may be
selected at a degree of abstraction that is most convincing (e.g., overall securities,
securities in a related industry, a specific security, a specific counter party, etc.).
[0421] In some embodiments in which multiple unfulfilled orders exist,
priority may be given according to any desired priority mechanism. For example,
possible counter parties associated with larger orders may be queried first, possible
counter parties associated with most recently expired orders may be queried first,
etc.
[0422] In some embodiments, counter party identities may be kept
anonymous during part or all of a querying process associated with the use of
unfulfilled orders. Also, size of orders, and/or any other information related to
new and/or inactive unfulfilled orders may be kept confidential during the process
until the counterparties choose to reveal such information.
[0423] Any number of unfulfilled orders may be tracked for any desired
time period. For example, in some embodiments some number of the most
recently expired orders may be tracked. In some embodiments, all unfulfilled
orders may be tracked for some desired period. In some embodiments, the tracking
may relate to characteristics of the security. For example, orders associated with a
less liquid security may be tracked for a longer time than orders associated with a 2025204532
more liquid security.
[0424] Fulfilled orders, may be tracked for use in fulfilling future orders, in
a substantially similar method to tracking unfulfilled orders described above. This
may be useful because a trader that has previously traded in a security may be
more likely to trade in that security again. The fulfilled orders may be fulfilled
through the ETM and/or through some other method (e.g., a different marketplace).
[0425] In some embodiments, if it is determined that no matching counter
parties (e.g., counter parties with orders matching the order in their OMS's) are
available (e.g., a counter party is not found for an order (e.g., after some time
period, near an expiration time for an order, etc.)) alternative products and/or
services may be offered to a trader. The alternative products and/or services may
be based, at least in part, on a characteristic of an order entered by the trader. The
desired characteristics may include, for example, market capitalization, geographic
area, industry, risk level, profit to loss ratio, volume of trades, profit level, sales
level, cash on hand amount, analyst recommendation, and/or any other
information. For example, derivatives based on the security may be offered (e.g.,
from other orders available to the ETM, from another market, etc.), other securities
may be offered (e.g., securities with similar profiles such as capitalization,
industry, etc., securities that were purchased by other traders who also placed
similar orders (e.g., after a similar order went unfulfilled), securities that fulfill a
desire associated with the order (e.g., a desire to adjust a portfolio to include a
particular industry, etc.)). In some embodiments, information about how long an
order may take to be fulfilled based on historical trading trends may be provided.
Such information may encourage a trader to take an alternative to the order if the
time is too long or wait for order fulfillment if the time is short.
[0426] In some embodiments, an alternative product and/or service may
include a trade that is based on a reason for the order in the trader's OMS database.
For example, an ETM may receive information about the reason that the order is
present in the OMS (e.g., a desire to own a security in a particular industry), and
based on that reason may determine that an alternative available order may fulfill
the same reason and offer that order as an alternative. In some embodiments a 2025204532
reason may be part of a broader trading strategy and/or risk model that may be
shared with the ETM, SO that the ETM may offer alternatives that more closely
fulfill reasons embodied by the order and that fits into the broader trading strategy
and/or risk model.
[0427] In some embodiments, if a matching order is found for an order,
additional (e.g., complementary) products and/or services may be offered. For
example, the fact that an order has been, at least partly, fulfilled may be
determined, and in response, an additional product and/or service may be offered.
The order may be fulfilled through the ETM and/or through some other method
and identified as fulfilled to the ETM (e.g., through a status change in an OMS).
The product and/or service may be offered from a marketplace operator, a
participant of a marketplace, and/or any other source. For example, a trader may be
offered a hedging opportunity after an order for a security is fulfilled. Such a
hedging opportunity may include a future related to the security. The hedging
opportunity may be available through a different counter party on the same ETM
(e.g., may be found in similar fashion to finding an original counter party) and/or
through another marketplace.
[0428] In some embodiments, historical data about previous orders may be
used to recommend additional products and/or services. For example, if a trader
has a trade go unfulfilled, the trader may be presented with an available order that
was often entered by traders that also had similar orders go unfulfilled.
[0429] In some embodiments, historical information may be used to adjust
treatment of new orders. For example, if an order is entered for a historically
illiquid security, additional avenues may be used to find a matching order, such as
prior traders who had entered orders for the security, other marketplaces, etc. In
some embodiments, other traders may be information of the existence of an order
for an illiquid security. Traders may be encouraged to enter counter orders for
illiquid securities through any desired incentivizing method. For example, traders
may be offered priority in liquid orders if they enter an order for an illiquid
security, traders may be offered rebates for entering such orders, and/or traders
may be offered any desired incentive for entering such orders.
[0430] In various embodiments, trades may be related to any desired 2025204532
currency or country (e.g., stocks of U.S. companies, stocks of Chinese companies,
British savings bonds, etc.). In some embodiments, a trader in one country may
enter into a trade involving another country and/or the currency of another country
(e.g., a U.S. trader may purchase debt of a Japanese company).
[0431] In some such embodiments, additional products or services may be
offered based on the knowledge of a currency associated with a trade. For
example, one or more currency trade contracts may be offered to a trader involved
in such trading. A currency trade contract may act as a hedging instrument against
volatility in currency markets. Such a contract may allow a trader to exchange the
contract for some cash value if the currency associated with the trade changes in
value compared to the trader's native currency. In some embodiments, the
availability of such contracts may be included as a negotiation option between
traders when negotiating a trade. In some embodiments, traders may trade in such
contracts among each other independently of any other trade (e.g., through the
ETM and/or some other marketplace). In some embodiments, a trader may be
offered such a contract as a service from a marketplace (e.g., the operator of the
ETM may offer such contracts for a fee as a service to users of the ETM).
[0432] Some embodiments may include participants from different time
zones. Such participants may not always be active at the same time due, in part, to
the differences in the time zones. Accordingly, one or more mechanisms may be
used to address these time zone differences.
[0433] For example, in some embodiments, participants may be able to
establish automatic trading profiles that can be used to automatically negotiate,
accept, and/or reject trades during times when the participants are not active (e.g.,
at night, on holidays, etc.). Such profiles, for example may indicate that orders for
securities in a certain price range should always be accepted, and/or any other
desired actions should be taken.
[0434] In some embodiments, active trading times may be tied to a
particular market (e.g., the New York Stock Exchange). By limiting trading to
hours similar to a particular market, participants may be sure that they can
participate in trades by being present during that period of time. 2025204532
[0435] In some embodiments, a marketplace (e.g., the ETM) may
determine if a participant is active and involve active participants in potential
trades with some level of preference. Such determining may include monitoring a
level of activity at a computer terminal, presenting a query through a computer
interface, and/or any other desired action. In some embodiments, if a participant is
not active (e.g., has gone home for the day), the participant may not be eligible to
be part of a trade until the participant becomes active again. In other
embodiments, active participants may be given preference over inactive
participants, but inactive participants may still be offered an opportunity to be
involved in trades.
[0436] In some embodiments, if a matching order involves an active trader
and an inactive trader, a negotiation may be started between the two traders. The
active trader may be informed that the inactive trader is inactive. The active trader
may be given an estimate of when the inactive trader may be active (e.g., an
indication of a time zone difference, historic data, etc.). While waiting for the
inactive trader to become active to enter into a negotiation, the order associated
with the active trader may still be used to search for other matches (e.g., with other
active traders). When the inactive trader returns to active status, the previously
inactive trader may enter into a negotiation about the trade with the previously
active trader. The previously active trader may have gone inactive by the time the
previously inactive trader becomes active. Because such a problems may occur
due to time difference, a negotiation may take a long time to complete. In some
embodiments, one or more sides of the negotiation may enter information to
automate the negotiation (e.g., preferences, limit prices, etc.), SO that the
negotiation may complete in a shorter time.
[0437] Some embodiments may be limited to buy side trading participants
(i.e., investing institutions that tend to buy large portions of securities for money-
management purposes). Other embodiments may include buy side participants and
sell side participants (e.g., brokers, retail analysts, etc.). Buy side participants are
typically protective of revealing trading intentions because of a fear of malicious
market manipulation and a fear of revealing proprietary trading strategies. Some 2025204532
embodiments which allow sell side participation may include mechanisms to
address such fears of buy side participants.
[0438] For example, in some embodiments, buy side participants may be
able to opt out of trading with sell side participants. In some embodiments, buy
side participants may be able to establish filters that allow only some sell side
participant orders to be traded with the buy side participants. For example, filters
may allow sell side participant orders for a sufficient amount of a security, if the
sell side agrees to a non-negotiated fulfillment of the order (e.g., according to a
standard price such as the most recent traded price, etc.) and/or if the sell side
and/or the sell side participant's order meets any other desired criteria of the buy
side participant.
[0439] In some embodiments, indications of one or more criteria for use in
filtering orders may be received. The criteria may be used to establish appropriate
filters SO that orders not meeting the criteria are filtered. If orders do meet the
criteria, the orders may be presented to the market participant that established the
criteria. In some embodiments, the criteria may include a time related criteria
(e.g., when the order is received, when the order may be presented to the market
participant (e.g., orders for XXX security may only be presented between noon and
2pm, etc.), etc.). In some embodiments, the criteria may include quantity-related
criteria, an identification criteria, a price-related criteria, a type-related criteria, an
industry-related criteria, and/or any other criteria.
[0440] Some embodiments may limit options available to sell side
participants. For example, sell side participants may only be able to enter binding
orders. If a sell side participant's order finds a counter party in a buy side
participant, the sell side participant may be bound to fulfill the order. In some
embodiments, even though a sell side participant is bound to fulfill an order, a
negotiation for price and/or quantity may still occur between a buy side participant
and a sell side participant. In other embodiments, no negotiation may be started,
but, rather, a trade may be facilitated without a negotiation (e.g., if the buy side
accepts the offer, the trade may occur automatically, according to a standard
pricing mechanism, for a quantity of securities identified in the sell side order,
etc.). 2025204532
[0441] In some embodiments, a request for acceptance of an order may be
transmitted to one or more market participants (e.g., buy side participants). In
some embodiments, such participants may receive the requests for acceptance of
an order. In some embodiments, the market participants may be allowed to
respond to the request for acceptance within a limited amount of time. If the
participant responds affirmatively to the request for acceptance within the limited
time, then an indication of acceptance may be transmitted and/or an execution of a
trade fulfilling at least a portion of an order may be facilitated.
[0442] In some embodiments, a sell side participant may be required to
enter a quantity of a security to be traded when entering an order. A sell side
participant may be bound to that quantity if an order from a buy side participant
matches the sell side order. In some embodiments, the sell side participant may
negotiate to increase the quantity, but may be limited to the quantity as a
minimum. In some embodiments, a sell side participant may only enter orders
above a threshold minimum quantity.
[0443] In some embodiments, to avoid negotiations between sell side and
buy side participants, sell side participants may be bound to have their orders
fulfilled according to a standard pricing mechanism. Such a pricing mechanism
may include fulfilling the order based on a well-known midpoint pricing policy
and/or any other desired mechanism.
[0444] In some embodiments, when two sell side participants become
counter parties to a trade, they may not be restricted in the same manner as when a
sell side participant is a counter party to a buy side participant. For example, if
two sell side participants enter a negotiation, both may enter negotiations for price
and/or quantity even if such negotiations are limited or not allowed at all when a
sell side participant and a buy side participant are counter parties.
[0445] In some embodiments, parties with matching orders may enter into
a limited negotiation. For example, execution of a trade fulfilling matching orders
may include a negotiation that does not include a negotiation about price and/or a
negotiation about quantity. A price, for example, may be determined using a
VWAP, midpoint, and/or any other desired pricing policy. A quantity may be
determined based on quantities defined by the matching orders. If there are any 2025204532
other issues to be negotiated, some embodiments may allow a negotiation for those
issues (e.g., time of execution, platform to use for execution, etc.).
[0446] In some embodiments, evidence of actions/things may be
suppressed from one or more parties. For example, in some embodiments, when a
determination is made that one order matches another order, any evidence of that
determination may be suppressed from one or more parties associated with the
orders and/or any other parties; when a criteria for a filter is established, any
evidence of the criteria and/or the establishment of the filter may be suppressed;
when a determination about whether an order meets criteria of a filter is made,
evidence of that determination may be suppressed. Such suppression of evidence
may occur until some action occurs and/or for some amount of time. For example,
in one implementation, evidence that a first party's order matches a second party's
order may be suppressed from the first party until and unless the second party
decides to proceed with the order and/or until the execution of the order is
facilitated.
[0447] In some embodiments, suppressing evidence of an event may
include performing any action or not performing any action SO that an observer is
led to believe that the event did not occur. For example, suppressing evidence may
include performing one or more actions that would occur if the event did not occur
(e.g., transmitting requests, transmitting indications that the event did not occur,
etc.), transmitting misleading information regarding the event (e.g., transmitting
indications that the event did not occur, transmitting indications that another event
occurred, transmitting information before the event and/or after the event that
obscure the occurrence of the event (e.g., indications that the event happened
earlier and/or later SO that the actually occurrence of the vent is obscured)), not
transmitting information that the event occurred, transmitting imitations
information to mislead observers, encrypting information transmissions, using
onion routing techniques, obscuring a source of transmissions, obscuring a
destination of transmissions, obscuring the timing of events, and/or any other
actions.
[0448] In some embodiments, an order may include an order to purchase or
sell a quantity of a financial instrument. The side of the order may refer to whether 2025204532
the order is for a purchase or a sale of a financial instrument. Two orders may
match if the orders are for the same financial instrument and are for opposite side
of a trade for that financial instrument. Other criteria, such as quantity, price, etc.,
may also be sued to determine if orders match each other.
[0449] In some implementations, an order may indicate a price range in
which a execution of a trade fulfilling at least part of the order is agreed. In such
implementations, a first order may match a second order if the two orders are for
opposite sides of a trade for a single financial instrument and the two orders have
at least partially overlapping price ranges. In some implementations, an actual
price of a trade may be determined according to a VWAP and/or midpoint pricing
model.
[0450] In some embodiments, facilitating execution of a trade may include
taking any actions which help to bring about the execution of a trade. In some
implementations, facilitating execution may include, for example, executing the
trade, beginning a negotiation between the first market participant and the second
market participant that does not involve the price of the trade and does not involve
the quantity of financial instruments in the trade, transmitting information about
the trade to a third party to execute the trade, and/or any other actions. Such
actions may include centralized actions and/or distributed actions.
[0451] In some embodiments, one or more market participants may be
charged a fee for use of a trading system. For example, if matching orders are
found and/or facilitation of order execution is performed, a fee may be charged to
the parties related to the matching orders. In some embodiments, some parties may
be incentivized to use a trading system by providing a financial incentive regarding
such fees. For example, in some embodiments, some participants may not be
charged a fee, orders meeting certain criteria may not be charged a fee, some
participants may be given a payment to submit orders, and SO on. Such
incentivizing may help to increase liquidity in a market where certain participants
may be otherwise unwilling to provide such liquidity.
[0452] In some implementations, for example, a portion of a fee charged to
a first participant may be provided to a second participant. In some
implementations, providing the portion of the fee to the second participant may 2025204532
include paying at least part of a second fee for the second participant (e.g.,
discounting the fee of the second participant by the portion). In some
implementations, providing the portion may include crediting an account of the
second participant (e.g., providing a payment to a financial account). In some
implementations, buy side participants may be given a discount and/or a payment
for use and sell side participants may be charged a fee. The fee charged to sell side
participants may be sued to pay the discount or payment given to buy side
participants. In some implementations when two buy side participants interact, no
discount, no fee, and/or no payment may be made to either party. In some
implementations, the first party to submit an order may be given a discount and/or
payment.
[0453] In some embodiments, various actions taken by traders and/or
information presented to traders may be taken/presented through one or more user
interfaces of computing devices. For example, indications of orders, negotiations,
etc. may be facilitated by user interfaces through which traders may interact.
Traders may enter order information, accept order requests, establish criteria for
filters, etc. through suitable user interfaces of computing devices. In other
embodiments, such user interfaces may not be used and/or needed to perform all of
some of such actions (e.g., computers may perform such actions without user
interfaces, etc.).
[0454] In summary, the present invention includes an electronic trading
marketplace that generates liquidity, at least in part, by receiving order information
directly from the databases of OMS systems at trading institutions. Since orders are
extracted from the OMS databases automatically, and information about executed
orders is inserted into the databases automatically, the OMS databases "see" the
marketplace as "just another market intermediary." Moreover, traders are able to
conduct trades in the electronic marketplace without any duplicative manual
efforts.
[0455] The above description is included to illustrate the operation of the
preferred embodiments and is not meant to limit the scope of the invention. The
scope of the invention is to be limited only by the following claims. From the
above discussion, many variations will be apparent to one skilled in the relevant art 2025204532
that would yet be encompassed by the spirit and scope of the invention.
[0456] The following should be interpreted as embodiments, and not as
claims:
A. A computer-implemented method comprising:
receiving a non-binding indication of an order in a database of an order
management system; determining if a currently matching counter party for the order exists by
searching a listing of active orders of an electronic marketplace; and
if no currently matching counter party is determined to exist, determining if
an previously matching counter party exists by querying at least one potential
counter party who is associated with a matching inactive order.
A.1. The method of claim A, in which the matching inactive order includes an
order that was previously fulfilled.
A.2. The method of claim A, in which the matching inactive order includes an
order that was previously unfulfilled.
A.2.1. The method of claim A, in which the matching inactive order includes
an expired order.
A.3. The method of claim A, in which the listing of active orders includes a
plurality of orders received from a plurality of potential counter parties.
A.3.1. The method of claim A.3, in which the plurality of active orders
includes active orders in respective databases of respective order management
systems of the plurality of potential counter parties.
A.4. The method of claim A, further comprising: determining that an active
order has become inactive; and storing information about the now inactive 2025204532
order that may be used to identify the at least one potential counter party.
B. A computer-implemented method comprising:
accessing, by an electronic marketplace, records of open orders in a
database of an order management system;
determining that at least one of the open orders from the database of the
order management system has been, at least partly, fulfilled;
in response to determining that the at least one of the open order has been,
at least partly, fulfilled, providing an indication of at least one of a
complementary service and a complementary product available through the
marketplace.
B.1. The method of claim B, in which the at least one of the complementary
service and the complementary product includes a hedging opportunity.
B.2. The method of claim B, in which the at least one of the complementary
service and the complementary product includes a money contract.
B.2.1. the method of claim B.2, in which the money contract involves a first
currency native to a trading institution associated with the at least one of the
open orders and a second currency with which the at least one of the open
orders is associated.
B.2.2. The method of claim B.2, in which the money contract is offered by an
operator of the marketplace.
B.2.3. The method of claim B.2, in which the money contract is available from
a participant of the marketplace.
B.3. The method of claim B, in which the at least one of the complementary
service and the complementary product includes a futures contract related to
the at least one of the open orders. 2025204532
B.3.1. The method of claim B.3, in which the futures contract is offered by at
least one of operator of the marketplace and a participant of the marketplace.
B.4. The method of claim B, in which the at least one of the complementary
service and the complementary product is available through a second electronic
marketplace.
B.5. The method of claim B, further comprising determining the at least one of
the complementary service and the complementary product based on a history
of previous orders.
C. A computer-implemented method comprising:
receiving by an electronic marketplace, an indication of a record of an order
in a database of an order management system;
determining that the electronic marketplace includes no matching counter
parties for the order; and
providing an indication of an alternative trade based, at least in part, on a
characteristic of the order.
C.1. The method of claim C.1, in which the alternative trade involves an order
with a desired characteristic in common with the order.
C.1.1. The method of claim C.1, in which the desired characteristic includes at
least one of an industry, a market capitalization, a geographic region, a risk
level, a profit to loss ratio, a volume of trades, a profit level, a sales level, a
cash on hand amount, and an analyst recommendation.
C.2. The method of claim C, in which the alternative trade includes a trade of a
derivative based at least in part on a security underlying the order. 2025204532
C.3. The method of claim C, further comprising: receiving an indication of a
trading strategy, and in which the alternative trade fulfills a part of the trading
strategy embodied by the order in the trading strategy.
C.4. The method of claim C, further comprising: receiving an indication of a
reason for the order being placed, and in which the alternative trade fulfills at
least part of the reason.
C.5. The method of claim C, in which the alternative trade is available through
a second electronic marketplace.
C.6. The method of claim C, further comprising determining the alternative
trade based on a history of previous orders.
D. A computer system comprising:
a microprocessor operable to:
receive a first order from a first market participant,
receive a second order from a second market participant, in which the
second order is received from an OMS module of the second market
participant,
determine that the first order matches the second order,
transmit a request for acceptance of the first order to the second market
participant, and
only if the second market participant accepts the request, facilitate an
execution of a trade fulfilling at least part of the first order and at least part of
the second order, in which facilitating the execution includes facilitating the
execution without a negotiation between the first market participant and the
second market participant about a price of the trade and without a negotiation
between the first market participant and the second market participant about a
quantity of financial instruments in the trade.
D.1. The system of claim D, in which the OMS module includes at least one of 2025204532
an order management system, and a system configured to interface an order
management system with a marketplace
D.2. The system of claim D, in which the microprocessor is further operable to
suppress, from the first market participant, evidence of the determination that
the first order matches the second order, at least until the facilitation of the
execution of the trade.
D.2.1. The system of claim D.2, in which suppressing evidence includes at
least one of: performing at least some actions as if the determination were not
made, transmitting misleading information regarding the determination,
transmitting no information regarding the determination, and transmitting an
imitation request for acceptance if the determination were not made.
D.3. The system of claim D, in which the first order includes an indication of a
price range in which the first market participant agrees to execution of the
trade.
D.4. The system of claim D, in which the execution of the trade includes an
execution at a price determined by at least one of a midpoint pricing model and
a volume weighted average pricing model.
D.5. The system of claim D, in which the request includes a request that is
available for a limited amount of time, in which the second market participant
may only accept the request during the limited amount of time.
D.6. The system of claim D, in which receiving the first order from the first
market participant includes receiving the first order from an electronic device
operated by the first market participant.
D.6.1. The system of claim D.6, in which the electronic device is configured to
allow the first market participant to enter information defining the first order 2025204532
through a user interface,
D.7. The system of claim D, in which receiving the second order from the
OMS module includes receiving the second order from the OMS module
through a communication network.
D.8. The system of claim D, in which receiving the first order from the first
market participant includes receiving the first order from an OMS module of
the first market participant.
D.9. The system of claim D, in which the first order matches the second order
if the first order and the second order are for opposite sides of a trade for the
same financial instrument.
D.9.1. The system of claim D.9, in which the first order includes an order for at
least one of a purchase and a sale of a first quantity of the financial instrument,
and the second order includes an order for a respective at least one of a sale and
a purchase of a second quantity of the financial instrument.
D.10. The system of claim D, in which the microprocessor is part of a
marketplace.
D.11. The system of claim D, in which the first order identifies a financial
instrument to be traded, a first quantity of the financial instrument to be traded,
and a side of a trade of the financial instrument, and in which the second order
identifies the financial instrument to be traded, a second quantity of the
financial instrument to be traded, and an opposite side of the trade of the
financial instrument.
D.12. The system of claim D, in which facilitating execution includes at least
one of: executing the trade, beginning a negotiation between the first market
participant and the second market participant that does not involve the price of 2025204532
the trade and does not involve the quantity of financial instruments in the trade,
and transmitting information about the trade to a third party to execute the
trade.
E. A computer system comprising:
a microprocessor operable to:
accept an indication of one or more criteria to use for filtering orders
directed to a first market participant, in which the first market participant is
associated with a plurality of first orders in an OMS,
accept a second order from a second market participant, in which the
second order matches at least one first order of the plurality of first orders,
determine if the second order meets the one or more criteria,
only if the second order meets the one or more criteria, direct a request
for acceptance of the second order to the first market participant, and
only if the first market participant accepts the request, facilitate an
execution of a trade fulfilling at least part of the at least one first order and at
least part of the second order, in which facilitating the execution includes
facilitating the execution without a negotiation between the first market
participant and the second market participant about a price of the trade and
without a negotiation between the first market participant and the second
market participant about a quantity of financial instruments in the trade.
E.1. The system of claim E, in which the microprocessor is further operable to
suppress, from the second market participant, evidence of the one or more
criteria.
E.1.1. The system of claim E.1, in which suppressing evidence includes at least
one of: performing at least some actions as if the indication of the one or more
criteria were not received, transmitting misleading information regarding the
one or more criteria, transmitting no information regarding the receipt of the
indication of the one or more criteria, and transmitting an imitation request for
acceptance if the second order does not match the criteria. 2025204532
E.2. The system of claim E, in which the microprocessor is further operable to
suppress, from the second market participant, evidence of the determination of
whether the second order meets the one or more criteria.
E.2.1. The system of claim E.2, in which suppressing evidence includes at least
one of: performing at least one action as if the determination was not made,
transmitting misleading information regarding the determination, transmitting
no information regarding the determination, and transmitting an imitation
request if a third order does not match the criteria.
E.3. The system of claim E, in which the second order includes an indication of
a price range in which the second market participant agrees to execution of the
trade.
E.4. The system of claim E, in which the execution of the trade includes an
execution at a price determined by at least one of a midpoint pricing model and
a volume weighted average pricing model.
E.5. The system of claim E, in which the request includes a request that is
available for a limited amount of time, in which the first market participant
may only accept the request during the limited amount of time.
E.6. The system of claim E, in which the first order matches the second order if
the at least one first order and the second order are for opposite sides of a trade
for the same financial instrument.
E.6.1. The system of claim E.6, in which the first order includes an order for at
least one of a purchase and a sale of a first quantity of the financial instrument,
and the second order includes an order for a respective at least one of a sale and
a purchase of a second quantity of the financial instrument. 2025204532
E.7. The system of claim E, in which the one or more criteria includes a time-
related criteria.
E.8. The system of claim E, in which the one or more criteria includes at least
one of a quantity-related criteria, an identification criteria, a price-related
criteria, a type-related criteria, and an industry-related criteria.
E.9. The system of claim E, in which the microprocessor is part of a
marketplace.
E.10. The system of claim E, in which second order is submitted through a user
interface of an electronic device.
E.11. The system of claim E, in which the first order identifies a financial
instrument to be traded, a first quantity of the financial instrument to be traded,
and a side of a trade of the financial instrument, and in which the second order
identifies the financial instrument to be traded, a second quantity of the
financial instrument to be traded, and an opposite side of the trade of the
financial instrument.
E.12. The system of claim E, in which facilitating execution includes at least
one of: executing the trade, beginning a negotiation between the first market
participant and the second market participant that does not involve the price of
the trade and does not involve the quantity of financial instruments in the trade,
and transmitting information about the trade to a third party to execute the
trade.
F. A computer system comprising:
a microprocessor operable to:
receive a first order from a first market participant,
receive a second order from a second market participant, in which the
second order is received from an OMS module of the second market 2025204532
participant, and in which the second order matches the first order,
only if the second market participant accepts a request for acceptance of
the first order, facilitate an execution of a trade fulfilling at least part of the first
order and at least part of the second order, in which facilitating the execution
includes facilitating the execution without a negotiation between the first
market participant and the second market participant about a price of the trade
and without a negotiation between the first market participant and the second
market participant about a quantity of financial instruments in the trade,
charge a first fee to the first market participant, and
provide at least a portion of the first fee to the second market
participant.
F.1. The system of claim F, in which the first market participant is a sell-side
participant and the second market participant is a buy-side participant.
F.2. The system of claim F, in which the microprocessor is further operable to
charge a second fee to the second market participant, and in which providing
the at least the portion of the first fee to the second participant includes paying
at least a portion of the second fee.
F.3. The system of claim F, in which providing the at least the portion of the
first fee to the second market participant includes crediting an account of the
second market participant.
F.4. The system of claim F, in which the first order matches the second order if
the first order and the second order are for opposite sides of a trade for the
same financial instrument.
F.4.1. The system of claim F.4, in which the first order includes an order for at
least one of a purchase and a sale of a first quantity of the financial instrument, 2025204532
and the second order includes an order for a respective at least one of a sale and
a purchase of a second quantity of the financial instrument.
F.5. The system of claim F, in which the first order includes an indication of a
price range in which the first market participant agrees to execution of the
trade.
F.6. The system of claim F, in which the execution of the trade includes an
execution at a price determined by at least one of a midpoint pricing model and
a volume weighted average pricing model.
F.7. The system of claim F, in which the request includes a request that is
available for a limited amount of time, in which the second market participant
may only accept the request during the limited amount of time.
F.8. The system of claim F, in which receiving the first order from the first
market participant includes receiving the first order from an electronic device
operated by the first market participant.
F.8.1. The system of claim F.8, in which the electronic device is configured to
allow the first market participant to enter information defining the first order
through a user interface.
F.9. The system of claim F, in which receiving the second order from the OMS
module includes receiving the second order from the OMS module through a
communication network.
F.10. The system of claim F, in which receiving the first order from the first
market participant includes receiving the first order from an OMS module of
the first market participant.
F.11. The system of claim F, in which the microprocessor is part of a 2025204532
marketplace.
F.12. The system of claim F, in which the first order identifies a financial
instrument to be traded, a first quantity of the financial instrument to be traded,
and a side of a trade of the financial instrument, and in which the second order
identifies the financial instrument to be traded, a second quantity of the
financial instrument to be traded, and an opposite side of the trade of the
financial instrument.
F.13. The system of claim F, in which facilitating execution includes at least
one of: executing the trade, beginning a negotiation between the first market
participant and the second market participant that does not involve the price of
the trade and does not involve the quantity of financial instruments in the trade,
and transmitting information about the trade to a third party to execute the
trade.
XXIII. Miscellaneous Information 1
[0457] Numbering of elements in the below section may not match to
numbering of elements in the previous sections. This section provides additional
disclosure of relevant material, and should not be interpreted to limit any prior
disclosures. For example, no definitions below should be applied to disclosure
above unless explicitly stated otherwise and descriptions of preference do not
apply to above disclosed embodiments.
[0458] FIG. 24 is a schematic diagram depicting a preferred embodiment of
the subject invention.
[0459] FIG. 25 is a schematic diagram depicting a preferred system for
targeted dissemination of confidential information regarding trading interests.
[0460] FIG. 26 is a flowchart illustrating steps of a preferred method of
targeted dissemination of confidential information regarding trading interests.
[0461] FIG. 27 is a flowchart showing steps of a preferred method of
matching interests identified by targeted dissemination in an auction execution. 2025204532
[0462] The subject invention relates to a method for managing certified
trading information to direct and execute confidential trading interests over a
computer network such as the Internet.
[0463] The term "trading interest" is used herein to describe any expressed
interest in trading a given security or securities, and the term "certified trading
interest" is used herein to describe a trading interest that has been verified as
genuine and certified as such by some trusted third party. One example of a
genuine trading interest is an order that has been placed on a securities market
automatic matching system. A second example of a genuine trading interest is a
trading interest expressed by a party with a documented history of aggressive
trading. An example of a trading interest that would not be certified is an
undocumented indication of interest (known in the art as an IOI).
[0464] In public securities markets, market mechanics and trading
psychology create barriers to efficient information dissemination and price
discovery. A market participant's decision to reveal information regarding a large
trading interest typically represents a tradeoff between confidentiality and
liquidity. By publicly revealing the details of a significant active buying interest,
for example, a market participant assumes the risk of adverse price action. Other
market participants with legitimate selling interests and market makers can "fade"
their offers (become much less aggressive sellers). There is also an empirically
demonstrable risk of adverse price action due to "front running" (buying activity by
market participants in anticipation of price movement resulting from the large
revealed order). Confidentiality can be maintained by splitting the large order up
into many small orders to avoid arousing interest, but this is inefficient and will fail
to attract substantial natural contra-interests. An economically efficient transaction
is therefore avoided because the trading costs associated with disseminating
information are too high. Also, the common practice of splitting large interests into
smaller orders affects all price discovery. When confronting each order, a market
participant must incorporate the possibility that the order is only a small part of a
much larger interest, because it is often impossible for the market participant to
verify that many such orders are not being sent simultaneously.
[0465] Another serious obstacle to efficient dissemination of trading 2025204532
interests and price discovery is the lack of validated information about trading
interests. The validated trading interest information which does exist (e.g.,
displayed executable orders) is often of little assistance. Displayed orders are
miniscule compared to undisclosed interest, and typically equate to no more than
one or two minutes of trading in a liquid stock in the U.S. market. Displayed orders
can therefore be easily manipulated, for example, to indicate excess buying interest
when sellers are in fact abundant. In addition, non-validated misinformation is
often created and disseminated by unscrupulous market participants to manipulate
market prices. Voluntarily disseminated trading interests can be false or misleading
if they are not verified either by proof of a current executable order, actual trades
executed, or canceled orders which were at one point executable at risk in the
market. Because there is often no way for a market participant to verify an
expressed trading interest or to know which other market participants have a
history of unscrupulous trading behavior, all prices must incorporate the possibility
of such behavior.
[0466] One known approach to voluntary selective dissemination of non-
validated trading interests and activity in public equity markets is used by the
AutEx+.RTM. system. This is an electronic database and online network that
provides users with the ability to voluntarily publicly indicate trading interests and
executed trades. AutEx+.RTM. users can limit the recipients of a message
regarding a trading interest by inclusion (a user-defined list) or exclusion (blocking
specific named market participants). Users can also limit by name the securities on
which they receive information and the other users from whom they receive
information.
[0467] In the AutEx+.RTM. system the expressed trading interests and
reported trades are not certified, however, and this creates the opportunity for
deceptive dissemination. In addition, users of the system are not obligated to report
all trades, which offers further opportunities to create false impressions of trading
interests. Significantly, this approach does not enable the use of analysis of
certified trading interests (CTI) to limit information dissemination to those market
participants likely to have a contra-interest. It also does not enable using such CTI
analysis to permit market participants to limit the trading interest indications 2025204532
received. It also does not provide the ability to initiate an auction based on
disseminated CTI analysis information. It also does not enable the monitoring of
user trading activity to generate a rating of the accuracy of disclosures or the
correlation of trading activity to inappropriate trading practices.
[0468] One known approach to matching trading interests and executing
trades while limiting information dissemination is employed by the POSIT.RTM.
matching system. The POSIT.RTM. system allows trading interests to accumulate
and initiates a matching sequence at set intervals. Market participants place
confidential orders in the system and are unaware of the amount or aggressiveness
of other orders on the same or contra side until the matching is released. This
approach does not enable targeted communication of trading interests based on
analysis of verified executable interests and trading activity, and does not provide
the ability to initiate private auctions based on this analysis. It also does not enable
granting the auction initiator any exclusivity over contra-orders entered in response
to the targeted dissemination.
[0469] In this environment, there is an acute need for efficient
dissemination of confidential information regarding trading interests. Market
participants with large confidential trading interests wish to notify only those other
market participants likely to have a significant contra-interest. Other market
participants wish to be notified of confidential certified trading interests to which
they are likely to have a contra-interest. Both groups wish to have a place to
transact a trade once they have been connected through analysis of their certified
trading interests. Market participants also desire certified information regarding the
trading behavior of other market participants and a means of certifying expressed
trading information.
[0470] Preferred embodiments of the subject invention overcome the
limitations of known trading interest dissemination and execution systems by (1)
enabling market participants to limit dissemination of trading interests to only
those other market participants likely to have a significant contra-interest, (2)
enabling market participants to ensure that other market participants' disseminated
trading interests are legitimate, and (3) enabling auctions among trading interests 2025204532
targeted and validated in this manner. Software of a preferred embodiment
identifies likely contra-interests by analyzing information from various sources
regarding certified trading interests.
[0471] A preferred embodiment comprises a method of managing market
information, comprising the steps of: electronically receiving data including
confidential information regarding market participants; electronically storing said
received data regarding market participants; electronically receiving information
from a first market participant computer; electronically storing said information
received from said first market participant computer; producing a targeted
dissemination list of market participants based on said stored data regarding market
participants and said information received from said first market participant
computer; and electronically transmitting to the market participants on said
targeted dissemination list data based on said information received from said first
market participant computer.
[0472] Advantageously, this is done without revealing the confidential
information of the market participants to the first market participant. In one
embodiment, the identity of the first market participant is not revealed to the other
participants.
[0473] Further embodiments are described below.
[0474] FIG. 24 illustrates a system configuration of a preferred
embodiment of the subject invention that comprises a certified trading interest
(CTI) manager 10 connected to various users 20 via a communication network 30.
CTI manager 10 is a computer comprising a processor, a memory, and input/output
including a communications interface. Computer programs stored in the memory
operate the CTI manager in accordance with the invention. In the preferred
embodiment, communication network 30 is the Internet, but alternate embodiments
can employ dedicated communication networks, as is well known in the art. In the
preferred embodiment, communication between users and the CTI manager is
secured, because of the confidential nature of the information communicated. The
CTI manager 10 is also connected to various external data sources 40, a CTI user
database 50, and an auction server 60.
[0475] External data sources 40 provide information regarding positions 2025204532
held, trades executed, and active orders for the users 20. This enables the CTI
manager to identify and verify users' historical and current trading interests. In an
alternate embodiment, the CTI manager does not receive external data, but only
uses data generated within the system. In a preferred embodiment applied to the
U.S. equity market, the external data sources 40 include various electronic
communication networks (ECNs) such as Instinet. TM., public markets such as
NASDAQ.TM., stock exchanges, matching networks such as POSIT.RTM., and
publicly available data such as the published holdings of various institutional
investors. In a preferred embodiment, the data regarding market participants used
by the CTI manager comprises confidential information. For example, the identity
of an executable order on an ECN is not typically available. Since the confidential
information is not publicly available, the CTI system must obtain permission from
the users 20 to utilize it. In the preferred embodiment users 20 agree to release this
confidential information to the CTI system, with the understanding that the secure
CTI system will use the information only for supplying the user with valuable
confidential trading interests of others. In other words, the confidential information
with which users 20 entrust the CTI manager 10 gives them access to more
information (in particular, certified trading interests), but the confidential
information provided by users 20 does not leak out to third parties.
[0476] In a preferred embodiment, the CTI manager 10 communicates in
real time with external data sources 40 via the Internet. Alternate embodiments
employ dedicated communication networks as is well known in the art. Also,
alternate embodiments store information from external data sources 40 in a
database and update the information periodically rather than in real time. For
example, an alternate embodiment receives information regarding the published
holdings of various institutional investors, stores the information in a database, and
updates the information from the news service source only as frequently as new
information is published. As will be apparent to those skilled in the art, the subject
invention could also be used to direct confidential information in markets other
than U.S. equities, since virtually all markets for fungible items of value pose the
same informational inefficiencies.
[0477] In a preferred embodiment, the CTI user database 50 contains user 2025204532
data such as security and contact information, CTI notification parameters, and an
activity history. The preferred embodiment maintains an activity history for each
user that includes auctions initiated and their outcome (e.g., whether the auction
was canceled, unsuccessful in locating a contra-interest, or resulted in a partial or
full execution of the initiating interest). The activity history also includes the CTI
notifications received, the orders placed in response, and their outcome (whether
the responding order was canceled, unsuccessful, or resulted in a partial or full
execution of the response order). In an alternate preferred embodiment, the CTI
user database 50 simply maintains overall statistics regarding this activity history
for each user.
[0478] The CTI notification parameters specify the circumstances in which
CTI information is to be received and can be different for different securities and
different users. For example, some users may limit CTI notifications to initiating
interests over 100,000 shares for certain securities and 500,000 shares for others. In
a preferred embodiment the notification parameters can be modified by the user at
any time, and can be on the basis of order size, security, identity of initiating user,
or statistics regarding the initiating user's activity history.
[0479] In an alternate preferred embodiment, the CTI user database 50 also
contains information regarding inappropriate trading behavior such as peg gaming
and front running. Peg gaming is possible when an auction sets the execution price
to be the market midpoint at a specific time. An auction participant with a large
buy order might sell actively in the market to pull the midpoint price down. Front
running is possible in this context if, for example, a recipient of a notification of a
large buy order starts buying CTI trades actively before the auction in anticipation
of price action caused by the large CTI. The CTI manager of this embodiment will
monitor the trading activity of all auction participants and note any suspected peg
gaming or front running in the CTI user database, either as raw data or as a rating
of trading behavior. An alternate embodiment maintains similar data and/or ratings
in the CTI user database 50 regarding the accuracy of the market participants' non-
certified disclosures on external systems such as AutEx+.RTM.. A further
embodiment maintains similar data and/or ratings in the CTI user database 50
regarding the market participants' adherence to self-imposed trading limits set 2025204532
during negotiations. This list is not intended to be exhaustive; other embodiments
will be apparent to those skilled in the art.
[0480] The auction server 60 manages the process of accumulating market
participant (MP) contra-orders in response to a CTI notification and executing a
matching auction. In an alternate embodiment, there is no auction server and the
CTI system functions as a targeted information dissemination mechanism. FIG. 25
depicts the information management function of a preferred embodiment of the
subject invention. An initiating user 210 communicates to the CTI manager a
trading interest and parameters that limit the dissemination of the information. The
CTI manager uses these parameters and CTI information 230 to determine which
market participants 240 should receive the information. Also, each MP
communicates his own parameters to the CTI manager delineating the trading
interest information that the MP desires to receive. The CTI manager therefore acts
as a bilateral CTI information filter 220. It limits dissemination of the initiating
user's confidential information to those MPs 240 for which (1) the MP fits the
initiating user's dissemination parameters, and (2) the initiating interest fits the
MP's notification parameters. In an alternate embodiment, the CTI manager is only
a unilateral information filter in which the system targets MPs to notify but does
not allow the MP to similarly filter notifications. Comparing FIG. 24 and FIG. 25,
in a preferred embodiment both the initiating user 210 and the market participants
240 are users 20 of the system, the bilateral CTI information filter 220 is the CTI
manager 10, and the CTI information 230 is supplied by the external data sources
40 and the CTI user database.
[0481] FIG. 26 is a flow diagram of the operation of an information
management function of a preferred embodiment. In step 310, a user
communicates an initiating interest to the CTI manager. In the preferred
embodiment, the initiating interest is a live executable order submitted to the CTI
system to initiate an auction, but in alternate embodiments the initiating interest
can be other information that the CTI system must then certify. For example, the
user may wish to selectively disseminate the existence of a large executable order
that a user has placed in another market or auction system such as an ECN or
POSIT.RTM.. The user would submit information regarding the order, and the CTI 2025204532
system would then verify the existence of the claimed order, SO that all market
participants subsequently notified of the order can rely on the truthfulness of the
dissemination. Similarly, the user can submit an indication of interest, which the
system then certifies from verified information regarding current executable
orders, recent trading history, and/or canceled orders which were once executable
but were not filled. Once again, all market participants subsequently notified of the
interest can rely on the truthfulness of the dissemination. In an alternate
embodiment, the user can submit a non-certified trading interest, but this lack of
certification is indicated to all market participants subsequently notified.
[0482] In a preferred embodiment, the initiating interest includes a price
limit, which can be a nominal value (e.g., $1121/2) or pegged to a market price
when the price is set (e.g., market midpoint set at the termination of the auction).
Alternate embodiments enable the initiating user to peg the price limit to a yet-to-
be-determined market value or index. For example, in an alternate embodiment the
user can peg the price limit to the daily volume weighted average price (VWAP) as
will be calculated at the end of the trading session. In the preferred embodiment,
the initiating interest includes auction parameters such as the length of the
accumulation period.
[0483] In step 320, the user communicates the desired dissemination
parameters. In the preferred embodiment, there are many dissemination parameters
available to the user, the most important being various measures of certified
contra-interest. In the preferred embodiment, the user can specify certified contra-
interest from (1) live executable orders; (2) past executed trades; or (3) canceled
orders that were once executable but were not filled. Examples of CTI-based
filtering of dissemination of an interest to buy 500,000 shares of a certain stock
include limiting dissemination to (1) MPs or other system users presently offering
10,000 or more shares of that stock in the marketplace; (2) MPs or other system
users who have sold over 25,000 shares of that stock in the current trading session;
(3) MPs or other system users who have offered blocks of over 10,000 shares of
that stock in the current trading session; or (4) MPs or other system users who have
bought at or above the National market Best Offer in the current trading session.
The quantities and time horizons in these parameters are all selectable by the user. 2025204532
[0484] In a preferred embodiment, there are many other parameters
available to the user that employ market information from the external data sources
40 and the CTI user database 50 to more accurately target dissemination to desired
market participants. For example, the user can choose to notify only those market
participants with certain response or initiation statistics (e.g., directing the CTI
manager to notify only market participants who have responded to 10% of CTI
notifications received in a certain time frame or to a certain total number of CTI
notifications). In addition, the preferred embodiment enables the user to target MPs
with certain known holdings in the security of interest. The preferred embodiment
also enables users to exclude MPs from notification on the basis of their history of
trade breaks (e.g., preventing CTI information from reaching any MP who has
broken some quantity of trades in some period of time). The preferred embodiment
also enables users to include or exclude specific MPs from notification by name or
identification number.
[0485] In an alternate preferred embodiment, the user can also target MPs
based on more sophisticated analysis performed by the CTI manager on the trading
patterns of various users to identify certain correlations or pattern recognition (e.g.,
buyer of technology stocks, sector rotation, etc.). In another preferred embodiment,
the user can exclude MPs based on any identified inappropriate trading behavior
such as front running and peg gaming stored in the CTI user database 50. In
another alternate embodiment, the dissemination parameters are system-defined
and not selectable by the user. In yet another alternate embodiment, the user can
choose between defining some or all of the dissemination parameters and using
system-defined default parameters.
[0486] Referring back to FIG. 26, at step 330 the CTI manager accesses the
necessary CTI information from the external data sources 40 and the CTI user
database 50 to perform the CTI filtering analysis. At step 340, the CTI manager
analyzes CTI information using the dissemination parameters and produces a list of
MPs to notify. At step 350, the CTI manager further reduces the MP notification
list using the MP notification parameters stored in the CTI user database 50. At
step 360, the CTI manager sends notification of the confidential initiating CTI to
those MPs for which (1) the MP fits the initiating user's dissemination parameters, 2025204532
and (2) the initiating interest fits the MP's notification parameters. In an alternate
embodiment, the notification includes statistics regarding the initiating user's past
auctions (e.g., proportion filled, cancel rate, frequency of trade breaks, etc.).
[0487] In an alternate preferred embodiment, after step 350 the initiating
user is shown a summary of the results of this analysis and is given the option of
modifying the dissemination parameters given in step 320 to more accurately
tailor/limit the dissemination of confidential CTI. For example, a user can modify
dissemination parameters that are too inclusive (e.g., too many MPs have sold
10,000 or more shares of the relevant security today) or exclusive (e.g., there are
no MPs who currently have a live order to sell over 50,000 shares). The production
of the MP notification list is an iterative process in this embodiment, as the
embodiment repeats steps 330-350 until the user is satisfied with the output of the
dissemination analysis. The user interaction in this iterative process is performed
through interface means that are well known in the art.
[0488] FIG. 27 is a flow diagram of the operation of the CTI management
system in executing an auction based on the disseminated initiating interest. At
step 405, notification of an auction initiated by a CTI is disseminated to targeted
MPs in the process depicted in FIG. 26. At step 410, the notified MPs have the
option of responding to the notification. In the preferred embodiment, this response
is an executable price-limited contra-order sent to the auction server. As with the
initiating interest, in the preferred embodiment the price limit can be either a
nominal value or pegged to a market price. Alternate embodiments enable the
responding MP to peg the price limit to a yet to be determined market value or
index. For example, in an alternate embodiment the MP can peg the price limit to
the end of day VWAP.
[0489] An alternate embodiment enables the notified MPs to
simultaneously submit a trading interest and send a message to the initiating user to
directly negotiate a trade. Another alternate embodiment enables the notified MPs
to respond via a private chat session to directly negotiate a trade. Alternate
preferred embodiments also enable the MP to respond in a semi-private negotiation
chat session with the initiating user and some or all of the other notified MPs. The 2025204532
system provides the chat and messaging functionality using interactive
communication technology as is well known in the art. Alternate preferred
embodiments also provide the notified MPs with the initiating user's phone number
and/or e-mail address to provide other channels of direct communication.
[0490] In step 420, the auction server 60 accumulates orders from the
notified MPs. In the preferred embodiment, the duration of the accumulation
period is set by the initiating user in the auction parameters communicated in step
310, subject to a system-defined minimum and maximum. This enables users of
the CTI system to initiate auctions at any time and limit them to MPs with verified
contra-interest, in sharp contrast with the POSIT.RTM. system in which users must
wait for periodic matching sessions which are not targeted in any way. In alternate
embodiments, there is a fixed, system-defined accumulation period. In another
preferred embodiment, the system sets the end of the accumulation period, subject
to a minimum and maximum. If possible, the system sets the end of the
accumulation period to match the end of the accumulation period of any other
pending auction SO that the auctions can be combined to increase total liquidity. In
the preferred embodiment, during the accumulation period, the initiating user and
the notified MPs can modify or cancel their orders placed in the auction server.
Alternate embodiments place restrictions on this ability. For example, an alternate
embodiment does not permit the initiating user to cancel the auction after notified
MPs have responded with contra-orders; the initiator is locked into the order once a
MP has relied on it to respond with a contra-order.
[0491] In step 430, the auction server 60 of a preferred embodiment
prioritizes the contra-orders sent by notified MPs. The preferred embodiment
creates an execution priority by the following sequential rules: 1) Total matched
size--Combinations of contra-orders are chosen which maximize total size
executed. 2) Price limit--If competing MP contra-orders would produce equal
matched quantities, the auction server will first execute MP contra-orders with
more aggressive price limits. 3) Size limit--If competing MP contra-orders have
the same (or no) price limit, the auction server will first execute orders with more
aggressive size limits. 4) Time of entry--If competing MP contra-orders have the
same size limit, the auction server will first execute orders entered earlier. 2025204532
[0492] Alternate embodiments that employ different execution priority
rules will be apparent to those skilled in the art. For example, one alternate
embodiment ignores the size limit of the contra-order; in another alternate
embodiment, where there are no price limits and actual execution is at the market
midpoint at the moment of matching, execution priority is by time of entry.
[0493] The above description assumes that the initiating interest is the only
order on one side, and all orders sent to the auction server by notified MPs are on
the contra-side. It is possible that a notified MP responds with an order on the same
side as the initiating interest, necessitating an execution priority for that side as
well. In a preferred embodiment, the initiating interest has absolute execution
priority over subsequent MP orders. This is an additional benefit of the CTI system
from the initiating user's perspective. The system enables the initiating user to
target dissemination of a confidential trading interest to MPs with a certified
contra-interest, to influence the auction timing, and obtain priority in matching
over contra-orders placed in response. All orders placed by notified MPs on the
same side as the initiating interest are executed only after the initiating interest is
filled, and according to the execution priority outlined above. Once again, alternate
embodiments that employ different execution priority rules will be apparent to
those skilled in the art. Furthermore, in an alternate embodiment, the initiating
interest is not granted absolute priority over competing orders subsequently placed
by notified MPs, and must compete according to the ordinary execution priority.
[0494] In another embodiment, more than one auction can be combined to
pool liquidity. In a combined auction, each initiating interest is given exclusivity
over contra-orders placed by notified MPs in response to that respective initiating
order. By "exclusivity" it is meant that a contra-order placed in response to an
initiating order cannot be matched with any other order until the initiating order is
filled or canceled. In an alternate preferred embodiment, there is no priority or
exclusivity granted to the initiating orders in a combined auction, and all orders
compete according to the same execution priority. Alternate embodiments that
employ other means of combining auctions will be apparent to those skilled in the
art.
[0495] In step 440, the auction server executes the orders according to the 2025204532
execution priority set in step 430, all at a price set by the type of auction employed.
If there are no MP responses or no trade is possible given the limit prices, the
auction is unsuccessful and is terminated. In a preferred embodiment, the auction
server employs a midpoint cross auction, where all orders are executed at market
midpoint at a certain time. To avoid peg gaming, in the preferred embodiment the
execution price is pegged to market at a random time during a ten minute "fuzz
period" after the end of the accumulation period. In an alternate embodiment, there
is no fuzz period and the auction execution price is determined at a known time at
the end of the accumulation period.
[0496] Alternate embodiments employ various other auction types. For
example, one alternate embodiment employs a "sealed envelope" auction where the
limit price on all orders is kept confidential, and a single price is chosen to
maximize the size of the matched execution. Another embodiment employs a
"private outcry" auction where the initiating user and all notified MP can see all
orders and their limit prices as they accumulate, and there is price competition
among the responding MPs to trade with the initiating interest. The examples given
assume that all orders are executed at the same price; another alternate
embodiment employs discriminatory pricing where all orders from responding
MPs trade at their limit price. This list is not intended to be exhaustive, as alternate
embodiments that employ different auction types will be apparent to those skilled
in the art. An alternate embodiment enables the initiating user to choose from more
than one different auction type such as those described above.
[0497] In step 450, the auction server informs the initiating user and all
responding users of the status of their respective orders (i.e., "fill," "partial
execution," "canceled," "open," "expired"). In step 460, the auction server of the
preferred embodiment enables participants in the auction to communicate with
each other and a system administrator to resolve any perceived errors. In a
preferred embodiment this communication is via semi-private chat messaging, but
alternate embodiments supply telephone contact information. Users can break the
trade or negotiate an amendment during a temporary window, after which the trade
is final. The use of this window represents a tradeoff between the interest in instant
finality to trades and the interest in minimizing the costs and disruption caused by 2025204532
errors. An alternate preferred embodiment does not offer a temporary window to
negotiate changes to the executed auction. In step 470, the CTI manager 10
processes the auction activity and updates the CTI user information database to
reflect the initiation, response, execution, and trade break activity that took place.
[0498] In an alternate preferred embodiment, the auction server 60 also
contains a depository of orders not related to an active auction. In this embodiment,
any user can place an order in the depository without initiating an auction or
invoking CTI targeted notification. These orders are dormant until an auction is
initiated in that stock, at which time they are treated by the auction server as a
response received from a notified MP in step 410. In an alternate embodiment, the
auction server performs a match at periodic intervals without any CTI initiation to
clear out the depository of dormant orders. An alternate embodiment performs
these auctions only when sufficient dormant interest has accumulated, rather than
at defined intervals. In yet another embodiment, these orders are not dormant and
are continuously executable subject to their price limit, as in an ECN. Another
embodiment enables live execution but with a price limit defined relative to an
external price, such as the market midpoint or a certain spread to the end of day
VWAP.
[0499] In an alternate preferred embodiment, there is no auction server or
execution functionality, and the CTI system functions as the targeted information
dissemination mechanism depicted in FIG. 25. In this alternate embodiment, after
the notification process depicted in FIG. 26, the CTI system does not perform the
auction process depicted in FIG. 27, but rather enables the notified MPs to respond
to the initiating user via a private or semi-private negotiation chat session as
described above. Alternate preferred embodiments also provide the notified MPs
with the initiating user's phone number and/or e-mail address to provide other
channels of direct communication. After the initiating interest expires or is
canceled, the preferred embodiment updates the CTI user database to reflect the
initiation and response activity.
[0500] In an alternate embodiment, a third-party matching facility, such as
Optimark, uses the CTI system to drum up liquidity for a match, then executes the
match. For example, a MP may send an order to Optimark and request that a 2025204532
notification be sent out announcing: "There is an order for DELL in Optimark for
the next round; please participate." In this embodiment, there is no chat, but there
is an address (in the example, Optimark's) where the match is to be executed.
[0501] In a further preferred embodiment, the CTI system functions in a
manner roughly analogous to a rating service. In this embodiment, the system
compares non-certified disseminations of trading activity (such as the disclosures
on AutEx+.RTM.) to actual certified information, to generate a measure of the
overall accuracy of market participants' disclosures. This accuracy rating can be
used by other market participants to discriminate among the disclosures on the
basis of demonstrated trustworthiness. In another embodiment, the CTI system
rates a market participant's compliance with the MP's own stated trading limits. For
example, when a MP is negotiating a trade, in order to receive a better price the
MP may agree to be bound to a trading cap, to demonstrate that the present order is
not part of a much larger trading interest, and that the MP is not simultaneously
negotiating similar trades with other MPs. The CTI system can compare the MP's
stated trading limits to actual certified information, to generate a measure of the
MP's demonstrated trustworthiness. This rating can be used by other MPs to
accurately price the likelihood that a negotiated order is part of a much larger
order.
[0502] In a further embodiment, the CTI system monitors a MP's trading
activity for correlation to inappropriate trading behavior, to generate a behavior
rating. In this embodiment, the CTI system monitors MP activity for suspected
front running. When the system becomes aware that a MP has been notified of a
large trading interest (e.g., from an auction notification on the system or through a
CTI disseminated over the system), the system monitors the subsequent trading
activity of notified MPs to analyze correlation between their trading activity and
the revealed CTI. In another embodiment, the CTI system monitors MP activity for
suspected peg gaming. The system monitors the trading activity of MPs
participating in auctions (on the CTI system or on another system such as
POSIT.RTM.) in which the price is set relative to a market price such as the
midpoint. This trading activity is monitored for negative correlation to represented
auction orders (e.g., MPs who sell while a buy order is represented in the auction), 2025204532
which indicates a possible attempt to manipulate the price of the auction execution.
In another embodiment, the behavior rating also incorporates information
regarding the MP's history of trade breaks.
[0503] In all of these "rating service" embodiments, the MP being rated
permits the CTI system to use confidential information to rate the MP's past
behavior (e.g., disclosures, trade breaks, inappropriate trading activity) in order to
receive better prices on future trades or more order flow. This rating information is
stored in the CTI user database 50 and can come in many forms, as will be
apparent to one skilled in the art. Examples of ratings forms include numerical data
(percent divergence between disclosed and actual trading activity or between stated
trading cap and actual trading activity), boolean indicators (has the market
participant exhibited inappropriate trading behavior or not), or scaled ratings
(rating from 1 to n that incorporates information regarding various trading activity
scaled according to, for example, recency and frequency of certain activity, degree
of correlation to inappropriate behavior, etc.). These examples are not exhaustive,
and many representations of the rating data will be apparent to those skilled in the
art. In an alternate embodiment, an MP may request that a rating "certificate" be
provided to a potential counterparty, to demonstrate to the counterparty the
trustworthiness of the MP. The certificate is a certified report based on the MP's
market behavior history.
[0504] These embodiments provide the described "rating service" function
in addition to the auction and execution functionality described in FIG. 27; the
ratings can also be used as a dissemination parameter in these embodiments.
Alternate embodiments that provide the rating function do not offer the execution
functionality and operate as the targeted information dissemination mechanism
depicted in FIG. 25; the ratings can be used as a dissemination parameter in these
embodiments as well. Further embodiments do not offer execution or targeted
dissemination functionality and simply operate as a certification and rating system.
[0505] While the embodiments shown and described herein are fully
capable of achieving the objects of the subject invention, it is evident that
numerous alternatives, modifications, and variations will be apparent to those
skilled in the art in light of the foregoing description. These alternatives, 2025204532
modifications, and variations are within the scope of the subject invention, and it is
to be understood that the embodiments describe herein are shown only for the
purpose of illustration and not for the purpose of limitation.
XIV. More Embodiments
[0506] The following should be interpreted as embodiments, not claims.
1. A method comprising:
receiving an order query, the order query identifying a firm order
for a financial instrument;
determining if the firm order matches an order stored by an order
management system; and
only if the firm order is determined to match the order associated with the
order management system, providing a representation of the firm order, and
enabling a binding acceptance of the firm order.
2. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
if the firm order is determined not to match the order associated with the
order management system, suppressing evidence of the determination.
3. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
receiving an indication of the binding acceptance; and
facilitating execution of a trade fulfilling at least part of the firm order.
4. The method of claim 3, in which facilitating includes at least one of
executing the trade, and transmitting a request to a remote system to execute the
trade.
5. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
if an indication of the binding acceptance is not received, suppressing 2025204532
evidence of the determination of the match.
6. The method of claim 1, in which the order query is received from a
marketplace.
7. The method of claim 1, in which determining if the firm order matches
the order stored by the order management system includes applying a filter to the
firm order.
8. The method of claim 1, in which the representation is provided to a
trader associated with the order management system.
9. A method comprising:
receiving a firm order for a financial instrument;
transmitting an order query identifying the firm order to each of a plurality
of trading systems for comparison with orders associated with a respective order
management system of each trading system;
only if a determination that a matching order is stored in a respective order
management system is made, and the firm order is accepted, receiving a reply from
at least one of the plurality of trading systems identifying acceptance of the firm
order; and
in response to receiving the reply, facilitating execution of a trade fulfilling
at least part of the firm order.
10. The method of claim 9, in which each of the plurality of trading
systems includes at least one of a respective order management system, and a
respective participant system coupled to the respective order management system.
11. The method of claim 9, in which receiving the firm order, transmitting
the order query, receiving the reply, and facilitating execution are performed by a 2025204532
marketplace.
12. The method of claim 9, in which the firm order is accepted by a trader
associated with the respective order management system.
13. The method of claim 9, in which facilitating execution includes at least
one of executing the trade, and transmitting a request to a remote system to execute
the trade.
14. A method comprising:
receiving a first firm order for a financial instrument;
determining if a second firm order matching the first firm order has been
received;
if the second firm order has been received, facilitating execution of a trade
fulfilling at least part of the first firm order and at least part of the second firm
order; and
if the second firm order has not been received, transmitting an order query
identifying the first firm order to each of a plurality of trading systems, each
trading system configured to determine if the first firm order matches an order
associated with a respective order management system, and to attempt to facilitate
a trade if the first firm order matches the order associated with the respective order
management system.
15. The method of claim 14, in which facilitating the trade includes
providing a representation of the firm order configured to allow a binding
acceptance of the firm order.
16. The method of claim 14, in which each of the plurality of trading
systems includes at least one of a respective order management system, and a
respective participant system coupled to the respective order management system.
17. The method of claim 14, in which the actions are performed at a 2025204532
marketplace.
18. The method of claim 14, in which facilitating execution includes at
least one of executing the trade, and transmitting a request to a remote system to
execute the trade.
19. A system comprising:
a computer system configured to transmit order queries identifying firm
orders to each of a plurality of trading systems,
in which each of the plurality of trading systems is configured to determine
if the firm order matches an order associated with a respective order management
system and to attempt to facilitate a trade if the firm order matches the order
associated with the respective order management system.
20. The method of claim 19, in which each of the plurality of trading
systems includes at least one of a respective order management system, and a
respective participant system coupled to the respective order management system.
21. The method of claim 19, in which facilitating execution includes at
least one of executing the trade, and transmitting a request to a remote system to
execute the trade.
22. A method comprising:
submitting a firm order to a system of claim 19.
23. A method comprising:
submitting an order for storage by an order management system, in
which the order management system is configured to allow comparison of firm
order queries with orders stored by the order management system, and
receiving an indication that a firm order query matches the order, the
indication allowing a binding acceptance of the firm order query. 2025204532
24. The method of claim 23, further comprising transmitting an indication
of the binding acceptance to a marketplace.
25. The method of claim 23, in which the binding acceptance includes an
indication that a trade should be automatically executed.
The following should be interpreted as embodiments, not as claims:
1. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of a non-firm order from a first participant, in which
the non-firm order defines a side of a trade for a financial instrument;
transmitting a first query asking if a matching order to the non-firm order is
stored in an order management system, in which the matching order defines an
opposite side of the trade for the financial instrument;
transmitting a second query asking if an offer to enter into a trade that
fulfills at least a portion of each of the non-firm order and the matching order is
accepted;
receiving an indication of an acceptance of the non-firm order;
in response to receiving the indication of the acceptance, transmitting a
request for confirmation of the non-firm order to the first participant;
receiving an indication of a confirmation of the non-firm order; and
facilitating execution of the trade fulfilling at least the portion of each of
the non-firm order and the matching order.
2. The method of claim 1, in which facilitating the execution includes facilitating
the execution with a price and a quantity that may be identified from the query.
3. The method of claim 2, further comprising preventing the first participant from
changing at one of a price associated with the non-firm order, and a quantity
associated with the non-firm order.
4. The method of claim 2, in which facilitating the execution includes facilitating 2025204532
the execution without initiating a negotiation about a price of the trade and without
initiating a negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments traded.
5. The method of claim 1, further comprising requiring the first participant to
respond to the request for confirmation in a time period.
6. The method of claim 5, in which the time period begins when the request for
confirmation is transmitted.
7. The method of claim 5, in which the time period begins when the request for
confirmation is received by the first participant.
8. The method of claim 5, in which the time period includes a time period between
about 10 milliseconds and about 1 second.
9. The method of claim 5, in which the indication of the confirmation is received in
the time period.
10. The method of claim 5, in which the indication of the confirmation is
transmitted in the time period.
11. The method of claim 1, further comprising receiving an indication of an
agreement that the first participant will confirm the non-firm order unless at least
one of the non-firm order is cancelled and at least a part of the non-firm order is
fulfilled SO that the at least the portion of the non-firm order is no longer available
before at least one of the transmission of the request for confirmation and a receipt
of the request for confirmation.
12. The method of claim 11, further comprising determining whether the at least
the part of the non-firm order is fulfilled. 2025204532
13. The method of claim 12, in which determining whether the at least the part of
the non-firm order is fulfilled includes determining if at least one of an agreement
to execute a trade fulfilling the at least the part of the non-firm order and another
order has been entered into by the first participant, a trade fulfilling the at least the
part of the non-firm order and another order has been executed, and an act entering
the first participant into a trade fulfilling the at least the part of the non-firm order
and another order has occurred.
14. The method of claim 12, in which determining whether the at least the part of
the non-firm order is fulfilled includes receiving an indication of whether the at
least the part of the non-firm order is fulfilled.
15. The method of claim 11, further comprising determining whether the non-firm
order is cancelled.
16. The method of claim 15, in which determining whether the non-firm order is
cancelled includes determining if at least one of a request to cancel the non-firm
order is received from an originator of the non-firm order by the first participant, a
request to cancel the non-firm order is processed by the first participant, and a time
period during which the non-firm order is scheduled to remain active expires.
17. The method of claim 15, in which determining whether the non-firm order is
cancelled includes receiving an indication of whether the non-firm order is
cancelled.
18. The method of claim 1, further comprising receiving an indication that the first
participant agrees to prevent a human from obtaining information regarding
confirming unless the non-firm order is confirmed.
19. The method of claim 1, in which the offer includes an offer to enter into a trade
that fulfills only a portion of the non-firm order. 2025204532
20. The method of claim 19, further comprising determining the portion of the non-
firm order.
21. The method of claim 19, further comprising algorithmically determining the
portion of the non-firm order.
22. The method of claim 19, further comprising determining the portion of the non-
firm order based on historical information.
23. The method of claim 19, in which the portion of the non-firm order includes a
percentage of the non-firm order.
24. The method of claim 19, in which the portion includes a portion that is
expected to be confirmed by the first participant.
25. The method of claim 1, in which the query includes an indication that the order
is not a firm order.
26. The method of claim 1, in which the query includes an indication that the non-
firm order is a firm order.
27. The method of claim 1, in which transmitting the query includes transmitting
the query to a system configured to determine if the matching order is stored in the
order management system, determine if the offer is accepted, and respond to the
query only if the matching order is stored in the order management system and the
offer is accepted.
28. The method of claim 1, in which transmitting the first query and transmitting
the second query includes transmitting a single query to a computer system
configured to interpret the single query as asking if the matching order is stored in 2025204532
the order management system and, if the matching order is stored in the order
management system, if the offer is accepted.
29. The method of claim 1, in which the confirmation includes an acceptance of an
offer to enter into the trade.
30. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 1.
31. A system comprising:
one or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 1; and
the one or more processors.
32. A method comprising submitting a non-firm order to the system of claim 31.
33. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of a non-firm order from a first participant, in which
the non-firm order defines a side of a trade for a financial instrument;
determining that a matching order to the non-firm order is stored in an
order management system and that an offer to enter into a trade that fulfills at least
a portion of each of the non-firm order and the matching order is accepted, in
which the matching order defines an opposite side of the trade for the financial
instrument;
transmitting a request for confirmation of the non-firm order to the first
participant;
receiving an indication of a confirmation of the non-firm order; and
facilitating execution of the trade fulfilling at least the portion of each of
the non-firm order and the matching order. 2025204532
34. The method of claim 33, in which facilitating the execution includes
facilitating the execution without initiating a negotiation about a price of the trade
and without initiating a negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments
traded.
35. The method of claim 33, further comprising preventing the first participant
from changing a price associated with the non-firm order, and a quantity associated
with the non-firm order.
36. The method of claim 33, further comprising requiring the first participant to
confirm the non-firm order in a time period.
37. The method of claim 36, in which the time period begins when the request for
confirmation is transmitted.
38. The method of claim 36, in which the time period begins when the request for
confirmation is received by the first participant.
39. The method of claim 36, in which the time period includes a time period
between about 10 milliseconds and about 1 second.
40. The method of claim 36, in which the indication of the confirmation is received
in the time period.
41. The method of claim 36, in which the indication of the confirmation is
transmitted in the time period.
42. The method of claim 33, further comprising receiving an indication of an
agreement that the first participant will confirm the non-firm order unless at least
one of the non-firm order is cancelled and at least a part of the non-firm order is
fulfilled SO that the at least the portion of the non-firm order is no longer available
before at least one of the transmission of the request for confirmation and a receipt 2025204532
of the request for confirmation.
43. The method of claim 42, further comprising determining whether the at least
the part of the non-firm order is fulfilled.
44. The method of claim 43, in which determining whether the at least the part of
the non-firm order is fulfilled includes determining if at least one of an agreement
to execute a trade fulfilling the at least the part of the non-firm order and another
order has been entered into by the first participant, a trade fulfilling the at least the
part of the non-firm order and another order has been executed, and an act that
entering the first participant into a trade fulfilling the at least the part of the non-
firm order and another order has occurred.
45. The method of claim 43, in which determining whether the at least the part of
the non-firm order is fulfilled includes receiving an indication of whether the at
least the part of the non-firm order is fulfilled.
46. The method of claim 42, further comprising determining whether the non-firm
order is cancelled.
47. The method of claim 46, in which determining whether the non-firm order is
cancelled includes determining if at least one of a request to cancel the non-firm
order is received from an originator of the non-firm order by the first participant, a
request to cancel the non-firm order is processed by the first participant, and a time
period during which the non-firm order is scheduled to remain active expires.
48. The method of claim 46, in which determining whether the non-firm order is
cancelled includes receiving an indication of whether the non-firm order is
cancelled.
49. The method of claim 33, further comprising receiving an indication that the
first participant agrees to prevent a human from obtaining information regarding 2025204532
confirming unless the non-firm order is confirmed.
50. The method of claim 33, in which the offer includes an offer to enter into a
trade that fulfills only a portion of the non-firm order.
51. The method of claim 50, further comprising determining the portion of the non-
firm order.
52. The method of claim 50, further comprising algorithmically determining the
portion of the non-firm order.
53. The method of claim 50, further comprising determining the portion of the non-
firm order based on historical information.
54. The method of claim 50, in which the portion of the non-firm order includes a
percentage of the non-firm order.
55. The method of claim 50, in which the portion includes a portion that is
expected to be confirmed by the first participant.
56. The method of claim 33, in which determining includes querying a second
participant.
57. The method of claim 56, in which the query includes an indication that the
order is not a firm order.
58. The method of claim 56, in which the query includes an indication that the non-
firm order is a firm order.
59. The method of claim 33, in which determining includes transmitting a single
query to a computer system configured to interpret the single query as asking if the
matching order is stored in the order management system and, if the matching 2025204532
order is stored in the order management system, if the offer is accepted, and
receiving an indication of an acceptance of the non-firm order;
60. The method of claim 33, in which the confirmation includes an acceptance of
an offer to enter into the trade.
61. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 33.
62. A system comprising:
one or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 33; and
the one or more processors.
63. A method comprising submitting a non-firm order to the system of claim 62.
64. A system comprising:
a processor operable to execute a plurality of instructions stored on a
machine readable medium; and
the machine readable medium having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that, when executed by the processor, cause the processor to:
determine if a matching order to the non-firm order is stored in an order
management system and if an offer to enter into a trade that fulfills at least a
portion of each of a non-firm order and the matching order is accepted, in which
the non-firm order defines a side of a trade for a financial instrument, and in which
the matching order defines an opposite side of the trade for the financial
instrument;
if it is determined that the offer is accepted, transmit a request for
confirmation of the non-firm order;
determine whether an indication of a confirmation of the non-firm order 2025204532
was received; and
if it is determined that the indication of the confirmation of the non-firm
order was received, facilitate execution of the trade fulfilling at least the portion of
each of the non-firm order and the matching order.
65. The system of claim 64, in which the plurality of instructions, when executed
by the processor, further cause the processor to:
if it is determined that the indication of the confirmation of the non-firm
order was not received, receive information identifying circumstances that
overcome an agreement to confirm the non-firm order.
66. The system of claim 65, in which the circumstances include at least one of a
cancelation of the non-firm order and a fulfillment of at least a portion of the non-
firm order by another order.
67. The system of claim 65 further comprising receiving an indication of the
agreement, in which the agreement includes an agreement to confirm the non-firm
order if the non-firm order is available.
68. The system of claim 67, in which the non-firm order is available if the non-firm
order is not cancelled, and if at least a part of the non-firm order sufficient to fulfill
the matching order has not been fulfilled by another order.
69. The system of claim 64, in which facilitating the execution includes facilitating
the execution without initiating a negotiation about a price of the trade and without
initiating a negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments traded.
70. The system of claim 64, in which the plurality of instructions, when executed
by the processor, further cause the processor to:
prevent a change in a price associated with the non-firm order, and a
quantity associated with the non-firm order. 2025204532
71. The system of claim 64, in which determining whether the indication of the
confirmation was received, includes determining whether the indication of the
confirmation was received in a time period.
72. The system of claim 71, in which the time period begins when the request for
confirmation is transmitted.
73. The system of claim 71, in which the time period includes a time period
between about 10 milliseconds and about 1 second.
74. The system of claim 71, in which the plurality of instructions, when executed
by the processor, further cause the processor to:
determine if the time period has expired and if either an indication of the
confirmation has been received or an indication of a non-confirmation has been
received; and
if it is determined that the time period has expired and neither an indication
of the confirmation nor an indication of a non-confirmation has been received,
facilitate execution of the trade fulfilling at least the portion of each of the non-
firm order and the matching order.
75. The system of claim 64, in which the plurality of instructions, when executed
by the processor, further cause the processor to:
receive an indication that a submitter of the non-firm order agrees to
prevent a human from obtaining information regarding confirming unless the non-
firm order is confirmed before determine if the matching order is stored in the
order management system and if the offer to enter into a trade that fulfills at least
the portion of each of the non-firm order and the matching order is accepted,
76. The system of claim 64, in which the offer includes an offer to enter into a
trade that fulfills only a portion of the non-firm order. 2025204532
77. The system of claim 76, in which the plurality of instructions, when executed
by the processor, further cause the processor to:
determine the portion of the non-firm order.
78. The system of claim 77, in which determining the portion of the non-firm order
includes algorithmically determining the portion of the non-firm order.
79. The system of claim 77, in which determining the portion of the non-firm order
includes determining the portion of the non-firm order based on historical
information.
80. The system of claim 77, in which determining the portion of the non-firm order
includes determining a percentage of the non-firm order.
81. The system of claim 77, in which determining the portion of the non-firm order
includes determining a portion that is expected to be confirmed.
82. The system of claim 64, in which determining if the matching order is stored in
the order management system and if the offer to enter into a trade that fulfills at
least a portion of each of the non-firm order and the matching order is accepted,
includes querying a participant.
83. The system of claim 82, in which the query includes an indication that the non-
firm order is not a firm order.
84. The system of claim 82, in which the query includes an indication that the non-
firm order is a firm order.
85. The system of claim 64, in which the confirmation includes an acceptance of
an offer to enter into the trade. 2025204532
86. A method comprising submitting a non-firm order to the system of claim 64.
87. A method comprising:
transmitting an indication of a non-firm order, in which the non-firm order
defines a side of a trade for a financial instrument;
receiving, from a system configured to find matching orders to the non-firm
order in the content of a plurality of order management systems, an indication
defining a matching firm order, in which the matching firm order defines an
opposite side of the trade for the financial instrument;
determining that the non-firm order is available for a trade involving the
matching firm order; and
transmitting a confirmation identifying that an execution of the trade should
be facilitated.
88. The method of claim 87, in which the confirmation identifies that the execution
should take place without a negotiation about a price of the trade and without a
negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments traded.
89. The method of claim 87, in which the confirmation is transmitted within a
prescribed time period.
90. The method of claim 89, in which the time period begins when the indication
defining the matching firm order is received.
91. The method of claim 89, in which the time period begins when the indication
defining the matching firm order is transmitted.
92. The method of claim 89, in which the time period includes a time period
between about 10 milliseconds and about 1 seconds.
93. The method of claim 87, in which determining that the non-firm order is
available for the trade involving the matching firm order includes: 2025204532
determining that the non-firm order has not been cancelled; and
determining that at least a portion of the non-firm order that is large enough
to fulfill the matching firm order has not been fulfilled by another order.
94. The method of claim 87, in which determining that at least the portion of the
non-firm order that is large enough to fulfill the matching firm order has not been
fulfilled by another order includes determining whether at least one of an
agreement to execute a trade that fulfills at least a part of the portion has been
entered into, a trade fulfilling at least a part of the portion has been executed, and
an entering into a trade that fulfills at least part of the portion has occurred.
95. The method of claim 94, in which determining that the non-firm order has not
been cancelled includes determining whether at least one of a request to cancel the
non-firm order is received from an originator of the non-firm order, a request to
cancel the non-firm order is processed, and a time period during which the non-
firm order is scheduled to remain active is expired.
96. The method of claim 87, further comprising preventing a change to at one of a
price associated with the non-firm order, and a quantity associated with the non-
firm order.
97. The method of claim 87, in which the confirmation includes an acceptance of
an offer to enter into the trade.
98. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 87.
[0507] The following should be interpreted as embodiments, not as claims: 2025204532
1. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of an order, in which the order defines a side of a
trade for a first financial instrument;
transmitting a first query asking if a matching order to the order is stored in
an order management system, in which the matching order defines an opposite side
of a trade for a second financial instrument, and in which the first financial
instrument is substitutable for the second financial instrument;
transmitting a second query asking if an offer to enter into a trade that
fulfills at least a portion of each of the order and the matching order is accepted;
receiving an indication of an acceptance of the order; and
in response to receiving the acceptance, facilitating execution of the trade
fulfilling at least the portion of each of the order and the matching order.
2. The method of claim 1, in which facilitating the execution includes facilitating
the execution with a price and a quantity that may be identified from the second
query.
3. The method of claim 2, further comprising preventing a submitter of the order
from changing at least one of a price associated with the order, and a quantity
associated with the order.
4. The method of claim 2, in which facilitating the execution includes facilitating
the execution without initiating a negotiation about a price of the trade and without
initiating a negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments traded.
5. The method of claim 1, in which the second financial instrument includes a
financial instrument with at least one similar characteristic to the first financial
instrument.
6. The method of claim 5, in which the at least one characteristic includes at least
one of an industry, a type of financial instrument, and a market capitalization. 2025204532
7. The method of claim 1, in which the order management system identifies
whether the first financial instrument is substitutable for the second financial
instrument.
8. The method of claim 1, in which the first query identifies whether the first
financial instrument is substitutable for the second financial instrument.
9. The method of claim 1, in which a quantity of the first financial instrument to be
traded is based on at least one of on an exchange rate determined by the order
management system between the first financial instrument and the second financial
instrument, an exchange rate determined from a market price of the first financial
instrument compared to a market price of the second financial instrument, and an
exchange rate indicated by the first query.
10. The method of claim 1, in which transmitting the first query and transmitting
the second query includes transmitting a single query to a computer system
configured to interpret the single query as asking if the matching order is stored in
the order management system and, if the matching order is stored in the order
management system, if the offer is accepted.
11. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 1.
12. A method comprising submitting an order to a system operable to perform the
method of claim 1.
13. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of an order, in which the order defines a side of a
trade for a first financial instrument; 2025204532
determining that a matching order to the order is stored in an order
management system and that an offer to enter into a trade that fulfills at least a
portion of each of the order and the matching order is accepted, in which the
matching order defines an opposite side of a trade for a second financial
instrument, and in which the first financial instrument is substitutable for the
second financial instrument;
receiving an acceptance of the order; and
in response to receiving the acceptance, facilitating execution of the trade
fulfilling at least the portion of each of the order and the matching order.
14. The method of claim 13, further comprising preventing a submitter of the order
from changing at least one of a price associated with the order, and a quantity
associated with the order.
15. The method of claim 13, in which facilitating the execution includes
facilitating the execution without initiating a negotiation about a price of the trade
and without initiating a negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments
traded.
16. The method of claim 13, in which the second financial instrument includes a
financial instrument with at least one similar characteristic to the first financial
instrument.
17. The method of claim 16, in which the at least one characteristic includes at
least one of an industry, a type of financial instrument, and a market capitalization.
18. The method of claim 13, in which the order management system identifies
whether a financial instrument is substitutable for another financial instrument.
19. The method of claim 13, in which a quantity of the first financial instrument to
be traded is based on at least one of on an exchange rate determined by the order
management system between the first financial instrument and the second financial 2025204532
instrument, and an exchange rate determined from a market price of the first
financial instrument compared to a market price of the second financial instrument.
20. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 13.
21. A method comprising submitting an order to a system operable to perform the
method of claim 13.
22. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of an order, in which the order defines a side of a
trade for a first financial instrument;
determining that a matching order to the order is stored in an order
management system, in which the matching order defines an opposite side of a
trade for a second financial instrument, and in which the first financial instrument
is substitutable for the second financial instrument;
soliciting a binding acceptance of a trade, in which the trade fulfills at least
a portion of the matching order and the order; and
only if an acceptance of the trade is received, facilitating execution of the
trade.
23. The method of claim 22, in which the second financial instrument includes a
financial instrument with at least one similar characteristic to the first financial
instrument.
24. The method of claim 23, in which the at least one characteristic includes at
least one of an industry, a type of financial instrument, and a market capitalization.
25. The method of claim 22, in which the order management system identifies
whether a financial instrument is substitutable for another financial instrument, 2025204532
26. The method of claim 22, in which facilitating the execution includes
facilitating the execution without initiating a negotiation about a price of the trade
and without initiating a negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments
traded.
27. The method of claim 22, in which soliciting includes at least one of providing
an interface through which the binding acceptance is requested, and transmitting a
request for the binding acceptance.
28. The method of claim 22, in which the indication of the order identifies whether
a financial instrument is substitutable for another financial instrument.
29. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 22.
The following should be interpreted as embodiments, not as claims:
1. A method comprising:
transmitting a plurality of sets of queries to a plurality of participants, in
which each set of queries asks the plurality of participants about a respective order,
in which each query of each set of queries asks a respective participant if a
respective matching order to the respective order is stored in a respective order
management system associated with a respective participant and if the respective
participant accepts a respective offer to enter into a respective trade that fulfills at
least a portion of each of the order and the respective matching order;
for each query, if a participant accepts the respective offer, facilitating an
execution of the respective trade,
based on results from the plurality of sets of queries, assigning each of the
plurality of participants to a respective one of a plurality of risk pools, in which
each risk pool corresponds to at least one rate of positive responses to offers to
enter into trades; and 2025204532
allowing a submitter of an order to identify one or more risk pools to which
queries regarding the order should not be transmitted.
2. The method of claim 1, in which the at least one rate of positive responses
includes a rate of positive responses to all offers to enter into a trade when a
matching order is stored in an order management system.
3. The method of claim 1, in which the rate of positive responses includes a rate of
positive responses to offers to enter into a trade when a matching order is stored in
an order management system and associated with the submitter.
4. The method of claim 1, in which the rate of positive responses includes a rate of
positive responses to offers to enter into a trade when a matching order is stored in
an order management system and associated with an order having at least one
similar characteristic to the order of the submitter.
5. The method of claim 4, in which the at least one characteristic includes at least
one of a financial instrument, a quantity range, a price range, a market
capitalization, an industry, and a financial instrument type.
6. The method of claim 1, in which the rate of positive responses includes a
comparison between a number of positive responses and a number of offers.
7. The method of claim 1, in which the order includes a firm order.
8. The method of claim 1, in which the order includes a non-firm order.
9. The method of claim 1, in which allowing includes providing an interface
through which the one or more risk pools may be selected.
10. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to 2025204532
perform the method of claim 1.
11. A method comprising submitting an order to a system operable to perform the
method of claim 1.
12. A method comprising:
for each of a plurality of firm orders, determining if each of a plurality of
participants has a respective matching order stored in an order management
systems associated with the participant and if the participant accepts a respective
offer to enter into a respective trade that fulfills at least a portion of each of the
firm order and the respective matching order;
for each offer, if a respective participant accepts the respective offer,
facilitating an execution of the respective trade;
based on the outcomes of the offers, assigning each of the plurality of
participants to a respective one of a plurality of risk pools, in which each risk pools
correspond to at least one rate of positive responses to the offers to enter into
trades; and
allowing a submitter of an order to identify one or more risk pools to which
offers regarding the order should not be made.
13. The method of claim 12, in which the at least one rate of positive responses
includes a rate of positive responses to all offers to enter into a trade when a
matching order is stored in an order management system.
14. The method of claim 12, in which the rate of positive responses includes a rate
of positive responses to offers to enter into a trade when a matching order is stored
in an order management system and associated with the submitter.
15. The method of claim 12, in which the rate of positive responses includes a rate
of positive responses to offers to enter into a trade when a matching order is stored 2025204532
in an order management system and associated with an order having at least one
similar characteristic to the order of the submitter.
16. The method of claim 15, in which the at least one characteristic includes at
least one of a financial instrument, a quantity range, a price range, a market
capitalization, an industry, and a financial instrument type.
17. The method of claim 12, in which the rate of positive responses includes a
comparison between a number of positive responses and a number of offers.
18. The method of claim 12, in which the order includes a firm order.
19. The method of claim 12, in which the order includes a non-firm order.
20. The method of claim 12, in which allowing includes providing an interface
through which the one or more risk pools may be selected.
21. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 12.
22. A method comprising submitting an order to a system operable to perform the
method of claim 12.
23. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of a plurality of risk pools, in which each risk pool
corresponds to a range of positive response rates to offers for acceptance of
respective orders, and in which each risk pool includes a number of participants
that correspond to respective positive response rates in the respective ranges;
receiving a selection of at least one risk pool;
transmitting an indication that participants associated with the at least one 2025204532
selected risk pool should be queried regarding an order, in which the order defines
a side of a trade for a financial instrument;
receiving an indication that a matching order to the order was stored in an
order management system associated with a participant in the at least one risk pool,
that the participant accepted an offer to enter into a trade that fulfills at least a
portion of each of the order and the matching order, and that an execution of the
trade was facilitated; and
providing an indication that the execution was facilitated.
24. The method of claim 23, in which the positive response rates include rates of
positive responses to all offers sent to participants to enter into a trade when a
matching order is stored in an order management system associated with the
participants.
25. The method of claim 23, in which the positive response rates include rates of
positive responses to offers sent to participants to enter into a trade when a
matching order is stored in an order management system associated with the
participants and associated with a submitter of the order.
26. The method of claim 23, in which the positive response rates include rates of
positive responses to offers sent to participants to enter into a trade when a
matching order is stored in an order management system associated with the
participant and associated with a second order having at least one similar
characteristic to the order.
27. The method of claim 26, in which the at least one characteristic includes at
least one of a financial instrument, a quantity range, a price range, a market
capitalization, an industry, and a financial instrument type.
28. The method of claim 23, in which providing the indication that the execution
was facilitated includes at least one of providing a display on an interface, and 2025204532
transmitting an electronic message.
29. The method of claim 23, in which the positive response rates includes a
comparison between a number of positive responses and a number of offers.
30. The method of claim 23, in which the order includes a firm order.
31. The method of claim 23, in which the order includes a non-firm order.
32 The method of claim 23, in which the execution was facilitated without a
negotiation about a price of the trade and without a negotiation about a quantity of
financial instruments in the trade.
33. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 23.
The following should be interpreted as embodiments, not as claims:
1. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of a composition of a fund, in which the
composition includes a plurality of financial instruments that are owned by the
fund;
receiving a plurality of orders, in which each order defines a side of a trade
for a financial instrument;
for each order, determining if a respective financial instrument of a
respective trade is part of the composition of the fund; and
for each order, if it is determined that the respective financial instrument of
the respective trade is part of the composition of the fund,
transmitting a respective first query asking if a respective offer to
enter into a respective trade that fulfills at least a portion of each of the order and a
respective matching order that matches the order is accepted by an operator of the
fund. 2025204532
2. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
receiving an indication of an acceptance of a trade defined by a respective
first query; and
facilitating an execution of the trade.
3. The method of claim 1, in which facilitating includes facilitating the execution
without a negotiation about a price of the trade and without a negotiation about a
quantity of financial instruments in the trade.
4. The method of claim 3, in which facilitating the execution includes facilitating
the execution with a price and a quantity that may be identified from the respective
first query.
5. The method of claim 3, in which facilitating the execution includes facilitating
the execution without initiating a negotiation about a price and without initiating a
negotiation about a quantity.
6. The method of claim 3, in which facilitating the execution includes facilitating
the execution in response to receiving the indication of the acceptance.
7. The method of claim 1, further comprising suppressing evidence of the
transmission of the respective queries.
8. The method of claim 1, in which the fund includes at least one of a mutual fund
and an exchange traded fund.
9. The method of claim 1, comprising: for each order, if it is determined that the
respective financial instrument of the respective trade defined by the order is part
of the composition of the fund, transmitting a respective second query asking if a
respective matching order to the respective order is stored in an order management
system associated with the fund. 2025204532
10. The method of claim 9, in which transmitting each respective first query and
each respective second query includes transmitting a respective single query to a
computer system configured to interpret the single query as asking if the respective
matching order is stored in the respective order management system and, if the
respective matching order is stored in the respective order management system, if
the respective offer is accepted.
11. The method of claim 1, in which transmitting each respective first query
includes transmitting the respective query to a respective system configured to
determine if the respective matching order is stored in a respective order
management system, determine if the respective offer is accepted, and respond to
the respective query only if the respective matching order is stored in the
respective order management system and the respective offer is accepted.
12. The method of claim 1, in which the order includes a firm order.
13. The method of claim 1, in which the order includes a non-firm order.
14. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 1.
15. A method comprising submitting an order to a system operable to perform the
method of claim 1.
16. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of a composition of a fund, in which the
composition includes a plurality of financial instruments that are owned by the
fund;
receiving an indication of an order, in which the order defines a side of a
trade for a financial instrument; 2025204532
determining that the financial instrument is part of the composition of the
fund;
determining that an offer to enter into a that fulfills at least a portion of
each of the order and a matching order to the order is accepted by an operator of
the fund, in which the matching order defines an opposite side of the trade for the
financial instrument; and
facilitating an execution of the trade.
17. The method of claim 16, in which determining that the offer is accepted
includes determining that the matching order to the order is stored in an order
management system associated with the fund.
18. The method of claim 17, in which determining that the offer is accepted
includes:
transmitting a first query asking if the matching order to the order is stored
in the order management system;
transmitting a second query asking if the offer is accepted; and
receiving an indication of an acceptance of the offer.
19. The method of claim 18, in which transmitting the first query and the second
query includes transmitting a single query to a computer system configured to
interpret the single query as asking if the matching order is stored in the order
management system and, if the matching order is stored in the order management
system, if the offer is accepted.
20. The method of claim 19, further comprising suppressing evidence of the
transmission of the single query.
21. The method of claim 17, in which facilitating the execution includes
facilitating the execution in response to receiving the indication of the acceptance. 2025204532
22. The method of claim 16, in which the fund includes at least one of a mutual
fund and an exchange traded fund.
23. The method of claim 16, in which facilitating includes facilitating the
execution without a negotiation about a price of the trade and without a negotiation
about a quantity of financial instruments in the trade.
24. The method of claim 16, in which facilitating the execution includes
facilitating the execution without initiating a negotiation about a price and without
initiating a negotiation about a quantity.
25. The method of claim 16, in which the order includes a firm order.
26. The method of claim 16, in which the order includes a non-firm order.
27. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 16.
28. A method comprising submitting an order to a system operable to perform the
method of claim 16.
29. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of a composition of a fund, in which the
composition includes a plurality of financial instruments that are owned by the
fund;
receiving an indication of an order, in which the order defines a side of a
trade for a financial instrument;
determining that the financial instrument is part of the composition of the
fund;
determining a change in price of the financial instrument;
based on the change in price of the financial instrument, determining if an 2025204532
operator of the fund is likely to be interested in an opposite side of the trade for the
financial instrument;
if the operator is determined to be likely to be interested in the opposite
side of the trade for the financial instrument, determining that an offer to enter into
a that fulfills at least a portion of each of the order and a matching order to the
order is accepted by an operator of the fund
facilitating an execution of the trade fulfilling.
30. The method of claim 29, in which determining that the offer is accepted
includes determining that the matching order to the order is stored in an order
management system associated with the fund.
31. The method of claim 30, in which determining that the offer is accepted
includes:
transmitting a first query asking if the matching order to the order is stored
in the order management system;
transmitting a second query asking if the offer is accepted; and
receiving an indication of an acceptance of the offer.
32. The method of claim 31, in which transmitting the first query and the second
query includes transmitting a single query to a computer system configured to
interpret the single query as asking if the matching order is stored in the order
management system and, if the matching order is stored in the order management
system, if the offer is accepted.
33. The method of claim 32, further comprising suppressing evidence of the
transmission of the single query.
34. The method of claim 30, in which facilitating the execution includes
facilitating the execution in response to receiving the indication of the acceptance. 2025204532
35. The method of claim 29, in which determining if the operator is likely to be
interested in the opposite side of the trade for the financial instrument includes
determining if the price change includes an increase or a decrease in price.
36. The method of claim 35, in which if the opposite side of the trade includes a
sale of the financial instrument, then the operator is determined to be interested if
the price change includes an increase.
37. The method of claim 35, in which if the opposite side of the trade includes a
buy of the financial instrument, then the operator is determined to be interested if
the price change includes a decrease.
38. The method of claim 29, in which the fund includes at least one of a mutual
fund and an exchange traded fund.
39. The method of claim 29, in which facilitating includes facilitating the
execution without a negotiation about a price of the trade and without a negotiation
about a quantity of financial instruments in the trade.
40. The method of claim 29, in which facilitating the execution includes
facilitating the execution without initiating a negotiation about a price and without
initiating a negotiation about a quantity.
41. The method of claim 29, in which the order includes a firm order.
42. The method of claim 29, in which the order includes a non-firm order.
43. The method of claim 29, in which the change in price includes a change in
price from a receipt of the indication of the composition.
44. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to 2025204532
perform the method of claim 29.
45. A method comprising submitting an order to a system operable to perform the
method of claim 29.
The following should be interpreted as embodiments, not as claims:
1. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of a firm order, in which the firm order defines a
side of a trade for a financial instrument;
determining if a matching order to the firm order is stored in an order
management system and if an offer to enter into a trade that fulfills at least a
portion of each of the firm order and the matching order is accepted, in which the
matching order defines an opposite side of the trade for the financial instrument;
constraining a cancellation of the firm order for a first period of time; and
allowing the cancellation of the firm order after the first period of time if
the matching order is not determined to be stored in the order management system
or if the participant is not determined to accept the offer before first period of time
expires.
2. The method of claim 1, in which the period of time includes a period of time
determined before receiving the indication of the firm order.
3. The method of claim 1, in which the period of time includes a randomly
determined period of time.
4. The method of claim 1, in which the period of time includes a period between
about 20 seconds and about 1 minute.
5. The method of claim 1, in which determining includes querying the participant
to determine if the matching order is stored in the order management system
associated with the participant and if the participant accepts the offer to enter into 2025204532
the trade
6. The method of claim 5, in which querying includes providing an indication of
whether the time period has passed to the participant.
7. The method of claim 6, in which the indication includes at least one of an
indication of a remaining time in the time period, and a color coding for an
interface.
8. The method of claim 5, in which the matching order is determined to be stored
in the order management system and the participant is determined to accept the
offer only if an acceptance of the firm order is received.
9. The method of claim 1, further comprising providing an indication of whether
the time period has passed to a submitter of the firm order.
10. The method of claim 1, further comprising: if the matching order is determined
to be stored in the order management system and the participant is determined to
accept the offer and the firm order has not been cancelled, facilitating execution of
a trade fulfilling at least a portion of each of the firm order and the matching order.
11. The method of claim 10, in which facilitating the execution includes
facilitating the execution without initiating a negotiation about a price of the trade
and without initiating a negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments
traded.
12. The method of claim 10, further comprising preventing the first participant
from changing a price associated with the firm order, and a quantity associated
with the firm order.
13. The method of claim 10, in which facilitating the execution includes
facilitating the execution without a negotiation about a price of the trade and 2025204532
without a negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments traded.
14. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
receiving a request to cancel the firm order during the first time period; and
cancelling the first order after the first time period.
15. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
receiving a request to cancel the firm order during the first time period;
determining that a matching order is stored in the order management
system and the participant is determined to accept the offer during the first time
period; and
facilitating execution of a trade fulfilling at least a portion of each of the
firm order and the matching order.
16. The method of claim 15, in which the request to cancel the firm order is
received before the determination is made.
17. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 1.
18. A system comprising:
one or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 1; and
the one or more processors.
19. A method comprising submitting a firm order to the system of claim 18.
20. A system comprising:
a processor operable to execute a plurality of instructions stored on a
machine readable medium; and 2025204532
the machine readable medium having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that, when executed by the processor, cause the processor to:
determine that a matching order to a firm order is stored in an order
management system and that an offer to enter into a trade that fulfills at least a
portion of each of the firm order and the matching order is accepted, in which the
firm order defines a side of a trade for a financial instrument, and in which the
matching order defines an opposite side of the trade for the financial instrument;
determine if a request for cancellation of the firm order is received during a
first period of time;
if it is determined that the request for cancellation of the firm order is
received during the first time period and the determination that the matching order
is stored in the order management system and that the offer is accepted is
completed during the first time period, facilitate execution of a trade fulfilling at
least the portion of each of the firm order and the matching order;
determine if the request for cancellation of the firm order is received after
the first period of time; and
if it is determined that the request for cancellation is received after the first
period of time, and the determination of whether the matching order is stored in the
order management system and the offer is accepted has not been completed before
the receipt of the cancellation of the firm order, cancel the firm order.
21. The system of claim 20, in which the period of time includes a period of time
determined before an indication of the firm order is received.
22. The system of claim 20, in which the period of time includes a randomly
determined period of time.
23. The system of claim 20, in which the period of time includes a period between
about 20 seconds and about 1 minute.
24. The system of claim 20, in which determining that the matching order is stored
in the order management system and that the offer to enter into the trade that 2025204532
fulfills at least the portion of each of the firm order and the matching order is
accepted includes querying a participant.
25. The system of claim 24, in which querying includes providing an indication of
whether the time period has passed to the participant.
26. The system of claim 25, in which the indication includes at least one of an
indication of a remaining time in the time period, and a color coding for an
interface.
27. The system of claim 20, in which the plurality of instructions, when executed
by the processor, further cause the processor to: provide an indication of whether
the time period has passed to a submitter of the firm order.
28. The system of claim 20, in which facilitating the execution includes facilitating
the execution without initiating a negotiation about a price of the trade and without
initiating a negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments traded.
29. The system of claim 20, in which the plurality of instructions, when executed
by the processor, further cause the processor to: prevent a submitter of the firm
order from changing a price associated with the firm order, and a quantity
associated with the firm order.
30. The system of claim 20, in which facilitating the execution includes facilitating
the execution without a negotiation about a price of the trade and without a
negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments traded.
31. A method comprising submitting a firm order to the system of claim 20.
32. A method comprising:
transmitting , to a system configured to find matching orders to a firm order
in the content of a plurality of order management systems, an indication of the firm 2025204532
order; and
providing, a first indication of a time period during which the firm order
may not be cancelled.
33. The method of claim 32, further comprising receiving an indication of the time
period.
34. The method of claim 32, in which the indication includes at least one of a color
coding of an interface, and an indication of an amount of time remaining in the
period.
35. The method of claim 32, in which the period of time includes a randomly
determined period of time.
36. The method of claim 32, in which the period of time includes a period of time
configured to suppress evidence of the determination.
37. The method of claim 32, in which transmitting the indication includes agreeing
that if a matching order is determined to be stored in an order management system
and a participant is determined to accept an offer to enter into a trade fulfilling at
least a portion of each of the firm order and the matching order, and the firm order
has not been cancelled, that execution of a trade fulfilling at least a portion of each
of the firm order and the matching order will be facilitated.
38. The method of claim 37, in which facilitating the execution includes
facilitating the execution without initiating a negotiation about a price of the trade
and without initiating a negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments
traded.
39. The method of claim 37, further comprising preventing a changing to a price
associated with the firm order and a quantity associated with the firm order. 2025204532
40. The method of claim 37, in which facilitating the execution includes
facilitating the execution without a negotiation about a price of the trade and
without a negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments traded.
41. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 37.
42. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of a firm order, in which the indication identifies
whether a time period during which the firm order may not be canceled has
expired;
determining if a matching order to the firm order is stored in an order
management system; and
if the matching order is stored in the order management system, soliciting a
binding acceptance of the firm order from a person associated with the order
management system, in which the solicitation includes indicating whether the time
period has expired.
43. The method of claim 42, further comprising:
receiving the binding acceptance; and
transmitting an indication that an execution of a trade fulfilling at least a
portion of each of the firm order and the matching order should be facilitated.
44. The method of claim 43, in which the indication that the execution of the trade
should be facilitated includes an indication that the execution of the trade should be
facilitated without initiating a negotiation about a price of the trade and without
initiating a negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments traded.
45. The method of claim 43, further comprising preventing a change to a price
associated with the firm order, and a quantity associated with the firm order. 2025204532
46. The method of claim 43, in which facilitating the execution includes
facilitating the execution without a negotiation about a price of the trade and
without a negotiation about a quantity of financial instruments traded.
47. The method of claim 42, in which the period of time includes a randomly
determined period of time.
48. The method of claim 42, in which the time period includes about 20 seconds to
about 1 minute.
49. The method of claim 42, in which the indication includes at least one of an
indication of a remaining time in the period, and a color coding of an interface.
50. The method of claim 42, in which the solicitation includes at least one of
providing an interface through which the binding acceptance is requested, and
transmitting a request for the binding acceptance.
51. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 42.
The following should be interpreted as embodiments, not as claims:
1. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of an order, in which the order includes a side of a
trade for a financial instrument;
determining that a matching order is stored in an order management system
associated with a participant, in which a matching order includes an opposite side
of the trade for the financial instrument;
providing, to the participant, information identifying that the order for the
financial instrument exists, in which the information does not include the side of
the trade; and 2025204532
requesting that the participant perform an action in order to receive
additional information about the order.
2. The method of claim 1, in which the action includes converting the matching
order to a firm order.
3. The method of claim 1, in which the action includes agreeing to positively
respond to a query about the order; and the method further includes transmitting
the query to the participant, in which the query includes a request for a binding
acceptance of the order.
4. The method of claim 1, in which the information identifies that the order for the
financial instrument and a plurality of other orders for the financial instrument
exist.
5. The method of claim 4, in which identifying the existence includes identifying a
number of pending orders for the financial instrument.
6. The method of claim 5, in which the pending orders include firm orders.
7. The method of claim 5, in which the pending orders include orders stored on an
OMS.
8. The method of claim 1, in which the information does not include an identity of
a participant associated with the order.
9. The method of claim 1, in which the information does not include a price
associated with the order.
10. The method of claim 1, in which the information does not includes a quantity
of the financial instrument associated with the order. 2025204532
11. The method of claim 1, further comprising receiving the information from an
OMS.
12. A machine readable medium having stored thereon a plurality of instruments,
that when executed by a processor, cause the processor to perform the method of
claim 1.
The following should be interpreted as embodiments, not as claims:
1. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of an order that is pending in an order book of a
trading system, in which the order defines a side of a trade for a financial
instrument;
transmitting a first query asking if a matching order to the order is stored in
an order management system, in which the matching order defines an opposite side
of the trade for the financial instrument;
transmitting a second query asking if an offer to enter into a trade that
fulfills at least a portion of each of the order and the matching order is accepted;
receiving an indication of an acceptance of the offer; and
in response to receiving the indication of the acceptance, transmitting an
indication that the trade should be executed to the trading system.
2. The method of claim 1, in which transmitting the first query and transmitting the
second query includes transmitting a single query to a computer system configured
to interpret the single query as asking if the matching order is stored in the order
management system and, if the matching order is stored in the order management
system, if the offer is accepted.
3. The method of claim 2, in which transmitting the single query includes
identifying that the order is associated with the trading system.
4. The method of claim 2, in which transmitting the single query includes
identifying that the order is not a firm order. 2025204532
5. The method of claim 2, in which transmitting the single query includes treating
the order as if the order were a firm order received from a participant.
6. The method of claim 1, in which the offer includes an offer to enter into a trade
that fulfills only a portion of the order.
7. The method of claim 6, further comprising determining the portion of the order.
8. The method of claim 6, further comprising algorithmically determining the
portion.
9. The method of claim 6, further comprising determining the portion based on
historical information.
10. The method of claim 6, in which the portion includes a percentage of the order.
11. The method of claim 6, in which the portion includes a portion that is expected
to be available in the order book.
12. The method of claim 6, further comprising determining the portion based on a
speed of communication with the trading system.
13. The method of claim 1, in which receiving the indication of the order includes
accessing the order book of the trading system.
14. The method of claim 13, further comprising:
receiving an indication of at least one possible characteristic of orders; and
determining that the at least one characteristic is matched by the order
before transmitting the first and second query.
15. The method of claim 14, in which the at least one characteristic includes at 2025204532
least one of a size of the order, a financial instrument associated with the order, and
a number of orders pending in the order book.
16. The method of claim 1, in which the trading system includes an alternative
trading system.
17. The method of claim 16, in which the alternative trading system includes a
non-exchange trading venue.
18. The method of claim 1, in which the trading system includes a matching engine
configured to find matches between pending orders.
19. The method of claim 1, in which the method is performed by a second trading
system.
20. The method of claim 1, further comprising querying the trading system
requesting the indication of the order.
21. The method of claim 1, further comprising accessing the order book of the
trading system.
22. The method of claim 21, in which accessing the order book includes searching
at least one of the order book and a copy of the order book.
23. The method of claim 21, further comprising:
receiving an indication of at least one possible characteristic of orders; and
determining that the order matches the at least one characteristic before
transmitting the first and second query.
24. The method of claim 23, in which the at least one characteristic includes at
least one of a size of the order, and a financial instrument associated with the order. 2025204532
25. The method of claim 21, further comprising:
determining that a number orders in the order book exceeds a
predetermined number before transmitting the first and second query.
26. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
receiving an indication of an agreement that the trading system will execute
the trade if the acceptance of the offer is identified unless at least one of the order
is cancelled and at least a part of the order is fulfilled such that the at least the part
of the order is no longer available when the acceptance is identified.
27. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
determining that the at least one of the orders is not cancelled;
determining that the at least the part is available;
determining that the trade was not executed.
28. The method of claim 27, further comprising penalizing an operator of the
trading system.
29. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 1.
30. An apparatus comprising:
one or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 1; and
the one or more processors.
31. A method comprising:
receiving information about a plurality of orders, in which each order of the
plurality of orders is pending on a respective trading system;
for each order of the plurality of orders, determining that a respective 2025204532
matching order to the order is stored in a respective order management system and
that a respective offer to enter into a respective trade that fulfills at least part of
each of the order and the respective matching order is accepted; and
for each order or the plurality of orders, in response to the determination,
transmitting a respective indication that the respective trade should be executed to
the respective trading system.
32. The method of claim 31, in which the determining includes querying at least
one participant.
33. The method of claim 32, in which querying includes identifying that the orders
are associated with the trading systems.
34. The method of claim 32, in which querying includes identifying that the orders
are not a firm orders.
35. The method of claim 32, in which querying includes treating the orders as if the
orders were firm orders received from a second participant.
36. The method of claim 31, further comprising determining the part of the orders.
37. The method of claim 36, further comprising algorithmically determining the
parts.
38. The method of claim 36, further comprising determining the part based on
historical information.
39. The method of claim 36, in which the part includes a percentage of the order.
40. The method of claim 36, in which the part includes a portion that is expected to
be available in the order books. 2025204532
41. The method of claim 36, further comprising determining the respective parts
based on a speed of communication with the respective trading systems.
42. The method of claim 31, in which receiving the information about the orders
includes accessing order books of the trading systems.
43. The method of claim 31, in which the trading systems include alternative
trading systems.
44. The method of claim 43, in which the alternative trading systems include non-
exchange trading venues.
45. The method of claim 31, in which the trading systems include matching
engines configured to find matches between pending orders.
46. The method of claim 31, in which the method is performed by a second trading
system.
47. The method of claim 31, further comprising querying the trading systems
requesting the information.
48. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 31.
49. A system comprising:
one or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 31; and
the one or more processors.
50. A method comprising: 2025204532
receiving an indication of an order that is pending in an order book of a
trading system, in which the order defines a side of a trade for a financial
instrument;
determining that a matching order to the order is stored in an order
management system and that an offer to enter into a trade that fulfills at least a
portion of each of the order and the matching order is accepted, in which the
matching order defines an opposite side of the trade for the financial instrument;
and
transmitting an indication that the trade should be executed to the trading
system.
51. The method of claim 50, in which the determining includes querying at least
one participant.
52. The method of claim 51, in which querying includes identifying that the order
is associated with the trading system.
53. The method of claim 51, in which querying includes identifying that the order
is not a firm order.
54. The method of claim 51, in which querying includes treating the order as if the
order was a firm order received from a second participant.
55. The method of claim 50, in which the offer includes an offer to enter into a
trade that fulfills only a portion of the order.
56. The method of claim 55, further comprising determining the portion of the
order.
57. The method of claim 55, further comprising algorithmically determining the
portion. 2025204532
58. The method of claim 55, further comprising determining the portion based on
historical information.
59. The method of claim 55, in which the portion includes a percentage of the
order.
60. The method of claim 55, in which the portion includes a portion that is
expected to be available in the order book.
61. The method of claim 55, further comprising determining the portion based on a
speed of communication with the trading system.
62. The method of claim 50, in which receiving the indication of the order includes
accessing the order book of the trading system.
63. The method of claim 62, further comprising:
receiving an indication of at least one possible characteristic of orders; and
determining that the order matches the at least one characteristic before
transmitting the first and second query.
64. The method of claim 63, in which the at least one characteristic includes at
least one of a size of the order, a financial instrument associated with the order, and
a number of orders pending in the order book.
65. The method of claim 50, in which the trading system includes an alternative
trading system.
66. The method of claim 65, in which the alternative trading system includes a
non-exchange trading venue.
67. The method of claim 50, in which the trading system includes a matching
engine configured to find matches between pending orders. 2025204532
68. The method of claim 50, in which the method is performed by a second trading
system.
69. The method of claim 50, further comprising querying the trading system
requesting the indication of the order.
70. The method of claim 50, further comprising accessing the order book of the
trading system.
71. The method of claim 70, in which accessing the order book includes searching
at least one of the order book and a copy of the order book.
72. The method of claim 70, further comprising:
receiving an indication of at least one characteristic; and
determining that the order matches the at least one characteristic before
transmitting the first and second query.
73. The method of claim 72, in which the at least one characteristic includes at
least one of a size of the order, and a financial instrument associated with the order.
74. The method of claim 70, further comprising:
determining that a number orders in the order book exceeds a
predetermined number before transmitting the first and second query.
75. The method of claim 50, further comprising:
receiving an indication of an agreement that the trading system will execute
the trade if the acceptance of the offer is identified unless at least one of the order
is cancelled and at least a part of the order is fulfilled such that the at least the part
of the order is no longer available when the acceptance is identified.
76. The method of claim 50, further comprising: 2025204532
determining that the at least one of the orders is not cancelled;
determining that the at least the part is available;
determining that the trade was not executed.
77. The method of claim 76, further comprising penalizing an operator of the
trading system.
78. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 50.
79. A system comprising:
one or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 50; and
the one or more processors.
[0508] The following should be interpreted as embodiments, not as claims:
1. An apparatus comprising:
a processor operable to execute a plurality of instructions stored on a
machine readable medium; and
the machine readable medium having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that, when executed by the processor, cause the processor to:
receive an indication of a plurality of orders;
store information about the orders in an order book of a first
trading system;
transmit an indication of a first order of the plurality of
orders to a second trading system, in which the first order defines a
side of a trade for a financial instrument; 2025204532
receive an indication of an acceptance of an offer to enter
into a first trade that fulfills at least part of the first order;
if the acceptance is identified before a matching order to the
first order is identified by the first trading system, execute the first
trade; and
if the matching order to the first order is identified by the
first trading system before the acceptance is identified, execute a
second trade that fulfills at least part of the matching order and the
first order.
2. The apparatus of claim 1, in which the matching order is identified when at least
one of:
an indication of the matching order is received by the first trading system,
the matching order is stored in the order book,
a matching engine of the first trading system identifies that the matching
order and the first order match,
the first order is removed from the order book, and
the matching order is processed by the first trading system.
3. The apparatus of claim 1, in which the acceptance is identified when at least one
of:
an indication of the acceptance is received by the second trading system,
an indication of the acceptance is transmitted from the second trading
system to the first trading system,
an indication of thee acceptance is received by the first trading system, and
the indication of the acceptance is processed by the first trading system.
4. The apparatus of claim 1, in which the order book includes at least one of a
database, a queue, a list, and a collection.
5. The apparatus of claim 1, in which the first trading system includes a first
alternative trading system. 2025204532
6. The apparatus of claim 5, in which the first alternative trading system includes a
non-exchange trading venue
7. The apparatus of claim 1, in which the first trading system includes a matching
engine configured to find matches between pending orders.
8. The apparatus of claim 1, in which the apparatus is part of the first trading
system.
9. The apparatus of claim 1, in which the instructions, when executed by the
processor, further cause the processor to:
receive an indication of at least one possible characteristic of orders; and
determine that the first order matches the at least one characteristic before
transmitting the indication to the second trading system.
10. The apparatus of claim 9, in which the at least one characteristic includes at
least one of a quantity of the order, and a financial instrument associated with the
order.
11. The apparatus of claim 1, in which the instructions, when executed by the
processor, further cause the processor to:
determine that a number of the plurality of orders exceeds a predetermined
number before transmitting the indication to the second trading system.
12. The apparatus of claim 1, in which transmitting the indication includes
responding to a query from the second trading system.
13. the apparatus of claim 12, in which the instructions, when executed by the
processor, further cause the processor to:
receive the query, and wherein responding to the query includes processing 2025204532
the query.
14. The apparatus of claim 1, in which transmitting the indication includes
providing access to the order book to the second trading system.
15. The apparatus of claim 1, in which the instructions, when executed by the
processor, further cause the processor to:
transmit an indication of an agreement that the first trading system will
execute the first trade if the acceptance of the offer is identified unless at least one
of the first order is cancelled and at least a part of the first order is fulfilled such
that the at least the part of the first order is no longer available when the
acceptance is identified.
16. A method comprising submitting an order to the apparatus of claim 1.
17. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of an order, in which the order defines a side of a
trade for a financial instrument;
storing information about the order in an order book;
transmitting an indication of the order to a second trading system;
receiving, from the second trading system, an indication of an acceptance
of an offer to enter into a trade that fulfills at least part of the order;
determining if the order is available, and
if the order is available, facilitating execution of the trade.
18. The method of claim 17, in which the indication of the acceptance identifies a
matching order to the order, in which the matching order defines a trade for an
opposite side of the financial instrument.
19. The method of claim 17, in which the second trading system is configured to
query a participant to determine if a matching order is stored in an order 2025204532
management system associated with the participant and if the participant accepts
the offer.
20. The method of claim 17, in which determining if the order is available includes
determining if the order is available in the order book.
21. The method of claim 17, in which the order book includes at least one of a
database, a queue, a list, and a collection.
22. The method of claim 17, in which the method is performed by a first trading
system, and the order book includes an order book of the first trading system.
23. The method of claim 22, in which the first trading system includes a first
alternative trading system.
24. The method of claim 23, in which the first alternative trading system includes a
non-exchange trading venue.
25. The method of claim 22, in which the first trading system includes a matching
engine configured to find matches between pending orders.
26. The method of claim 17, further comprising:
receiving an indication of at least one possible characteristic of orders; and
determining that the first order matches the at least one characteristic before
transmitting the indication to the second trading system.
27. The method of claim 26, in which the at least one characteristic includes at
least one of a size of the order, and a financial instrument associated with the order.
28. The method of claim 17, further comprising:
determining that a number orders in the order book exceeds a
predetermined number before transmitting the indication to the second trading 2025204532
system.
29. The method of claim 17, in which transmitting the indication includes
responding to a query from the second trading system.
30. The method of claim 29, further comprising receiving the query, and wherein
responding to the query includes processing the query.
31. The method of claim 17, in which transmitting the indication includes
providing access to the order book to the second trading system.
32. The method of claim 17, further comprising:
transmitting an indication of an agreement that the first trading system will
execute the trade if the acceptance of the offer is identified unless at least one of
the order is cancelled and at least a part of the order is fulfilled such that the at
least the part of the order is no longer available when the acceptance is identified.
33. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 17.
34. An apparatus comprising:
one or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 17; and
the one or more processors.
35. A method comprising submitting an order to the system of claim 34.
36. An alternative trading system comprising:
a processor operable to execute a plurality of instructions stored on a
machine readable medium; and 2025204532
the machine readable medium having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that, when executed by the processor, cause the processor to:
receive an indication of a plurality of orders;
store information about the orders in an order book of the
alternative trading system;
transmit an indication of a first order of the plurality of
orders to a second trading system, in which the first order defines a
side of a trade for a financial instrument;
receive an indication of an acceptance of an offer to enter
into a first trade that fulfills at least part of the first order;
if the acceptance is identified before a matching order to the
first order is identified by the alternative trading system, execute the
first trade; and
if the matching order to the first order is identified by the
alternative trading system before the acceptance is identified,
execute a second trade that fulfills at least part of the matching
order and the first order.
37. The alternative trading system of claim 36, in which the matching order is
identified when at least one of:
an indication of the matching order is received by the alternative trading
system,
the matching order is stored in the order book,
a matching engine of the alternative trading system identifies that the
matching order and the first order match,
the first order is removed from the order book, and
the matching order is processed by the alternative trading system.
38. The alternative trading system of claim 37, in which the acceptance is
identified when at least one of:
an indication of the acceptance is received by the second trading system,
an indication of the acceptance is transmitted from the second trading 2025204532
system to the alternative trading system,
an indication of thee acceptance is received by the alternative trading
system, and
the indication of the acceptance is processed by the alternative trading
system.
39. The alternative trading system of claim 37, in which the order book includes at
least one of a database, a queue, a list, and a collection.
40. The alternative trading system of claim 39, in which the alternative trading
system includes a non-exchange trading venue.
41. The alternative trading system of claim 37, in which the alternative trading
system includes a matching engine configured to find matches between pending
orders.
42. The alternative trading system of claim 37, in which the instructions, when
executed by the processor, further cause the processor to:
receive an indication of at least one possible characteristic of orders; and
determine that the first order matches the at least one characteristic before
transmitting the indication to the second trading system.
43. The alternative trading system of claim 42, in which the at least one
characteristic includes at least one of a quantity of the order, and a financial
instrument associated with the order.
44. The alternative trading system of claim 37, in which the instructions, when
executed by the processor, further cause the processor to:
determine that a number of the plurality of orders exceeds a predetermined
number before transmitting the indication to the second trading system.
45. The alternative trading system of claim 37, in which transmitting the indication 2025204532
includes responding to a query from the second trading system.
46. The alternative trading system of claim 45, in which the instructions, when
executed by the processor, further cause the processor to:
receive the query, and wherein responding to the query includes processing
the query.
47. The alternative trading system of claim 37, in which transmitting the indication
includes providing access to the order book to the second trading system.
48. The alternative trading system of claim 37, in which the instructions, when
executed by the processor, further cause the processor to:
transmit an indication of an agreement that the alternative trading system
will execute the first trade if the acceptance of the offer is identified unless at least
one of the first order is cancelled and at least a part of the first order is fulfilled
such that the at least the part of the first order is no longer available when the
acceptance is identified.
49. A method comprising submitting an order to the alternative trading system of
claim 37.
50. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of an order, in which the order defines a side of a
trade for a financial instrument;
determining which of a plurality of trading systems first identifies a
matching order to the order, in which the matching order defines an opposite side
of a trade for the financial instrument;
based on the determination, executing an execution of a trade that fulfills at
least a part of each of the matching order and the order. 2025204532
51. The method of claim 50, in which determining includes determining whether
an indication of an acceptance was received from one of the plurality of trading
systems before an indication of a second matching order is received.
52. The method of claim 50, in which the method is performed by a first trading
system.
53. The method of claim 52, in which the first trading system includes a first
alternative trading system.
54. The method of claim 53, in which the first alternative trading system includes a
non-exchange trading venue.
55. The method of claim 52, in which the first trading system includes a matching
engine configured to find matches between pending orders.
56. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 50.
57. An apparatus comprising:
one or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 50; and
the one or more processors.
58. A method comprising submitting an order to the system of claim 57.
[0509] The following should be interpreted as embodiments, not as claims:
1. A method comprising:
receiving a number of first indications, in which each first indications 2025204532
indicates a respective first order, in which each first order defines a respective first
trade;
querying a plurality of participants regarding the first orders;
after receiving the number of first indications, receiving a second indication
of a second order, in which the second order defines a second trade;
constraining a cancellation of the second order for a period of time;
querying the plurality of participants regarding the second order; and
allowing the cancellation of the second order after the period of time if an
acceptance to enter into the second trade is not identified during the period of time.
2. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
for each of the first orders, determining at least one of:
that no matching order is stored in an order management system
associated with any of the plurality of participants, and
that none of the plurality of participants accepts an offer to enter
into the respective first trade defined by the first order.
3. The method of claim 2, in which determining at least one of: that no matching
order is stored in the order management system associated with any of the plurality
of participants, and that none of the plurality of participants accepts the offer to
enter into the respective first trade defined by the first order, includes determining
that no matching order is stored in the order management system associated with
any of the plurality of participants.
4. The method of claim 3, in which determining that no matching order is stored in
the order management system associated with any of the plurality of participants
includes determining that no indication that a matching order is stored in the order
management system associated with any of the plurality of participants was
received.
5. The method of claim 2, in which determining at least one of: that no matching
order is stored in the order management system associated with any of the plurality 2025204532
of participants, and that none of the plurality of participants accepts the offer to
enter into the respective first trade defined by the first order, includes determining
that none of the plurality of participants accepts the offer to enter into the
respective first trade defined by the first order.
6. The method of claim 5, in which determining that none of the plurality of
participants accepts the offer to enter into the respective first trade defined by the
first order includes determining that no indication of an acceptance of the offer was
received.
7. The method of claim 1, further comprising determining that each of the first
orders have not been fulfilled by a trade by any of the plurality of participants.
8. The method of claim 1, further comprising determining the number.
9. The method of claim 8, in which determining the number includes randomly
determining the number.
10. The method of claim 1, in which each of the number of first indications and the
second indication is received from a single submitter.
11. The method of claim 1, in which the number of first indications are received
from a plurality of submitters.
12. The method of claim 1, in which the time period includes about 5 seconds.
13. The method of claim 1, in which querying the plurality of participants
regarding the first orders includes querying each participant of the plurality of
participants to determine if a respective matching order for each first order is
stored in a respective order management system associated with the participant and
if the participant accepts an offer to enter into the respective first trade, 2025204532
14. The method of claim 1, in which querying the plurality of participants
regarding the second order includes querying each participant of the plurality of
participants to determine if a matching order for the second order is stored in a
respective order management system associated with the participant and if the
participant accepts an offer to enter into the second trade.
15. The method of claim 1, further comprising providing an indication of whether
the time period has passed to a submitter of the second order.
16. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
receiving a request to cancel the second order during the time period; and in
which constraining the cancellation includes queuing the request for cancellation
until after the time period.
17. The method of claim 16, further comprising cancelling the second order after
the time period.
18. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
receiving a request to cancel the second order during the first time period;
determining that a matching order of the second order is stored in an order
management system associated with a participant of the plurality of participants
and the participant accepts an offer to enter into a trade fulfilling at least part of
each of the matching order and the second order during the time period; and
facilitating execution of a trade fulfilling at least a portion of each of the
second order and the matching order.
19. The method of claim 18, in which the request to cancel the second order is
received before the determination is made.
20. The method of claim 1, further comprising determining that no matching order
to the second order is stored in an order management system associated with any of
the plurality of participants before the end of the time period. 2025204532
21. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 1.
22. A system comprising:
one or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 1; and
the one or more processors.
23. A method comprising
receiving a number of first indications, in which each first indications
indicates a respective first order, in which each first order defines a respective first
trade;
for each of the first orders, determining at least one of:
that no matching order is stored in an order management system
associated with any of a plurality of participants, and
that none of the plurality of participants accepts an offer to enter
into the respective first trade defined by the first order;
after receiving the number of first indications, receiving a second indication
of a second order
constraining a cancellation of the second order for a first period of time;
and
allowing the cancellation of the second order after the period of time if an
acceptance to enter into the second trade is not identified during the period of time.
24. The method of claim 23, in which determining at least one of: that no
matching order is stored in the order management system associated with any of
the plurality of participants, and that none of the plurality of participants accepts
the offer to enter into the respective first trade defined by the first order, includes
determining that no matching order is stored in the order management system 2025204532
associated with any of the plurality of participants.
25. The method of claim 24, in which determining that no matching order is stored
in the order management system associated with any of the plurality of participants
includes determining that no indication that a matching order is stored in the order
management system associated with any of the plurality of participants was
received.
26. The method of claim 23, in which determining at least one of: that no
matching order is stored in the order management system associated with any of
the plurality of participants, and that none of the plurality of participants accepts
the offer to enter into the respective first trade defined by the first order, includes
determining that none of the plurality of participants accepts the offer to enter into
the respective first trade defined by the first order.
27. the method of claim 26, in which determining that none of the plurality of
participants accepts the offer to enter into the respective first trade defined by the
first order includes determining that no indication of an acceptance of the offer was
received.
28. The method of claim 23, further comprising determining the number.
29. The method of claim 28, in which determining the number includes randomly
determining the number.
30. The method of claim 23, in which each of the number of first indications and
the second indication is received from a single submitter.
31. The method of claim 23, in which the number of first indications are received
from a plurality of submitters. 2025204532
32. The method of claim 23, in which the time period includes about 5 seconds.
33. The method of claim 23, further comprising querying each participant of the
plurality of participants to determine if a respective matching order for each first
order is stored in a respective order management system associated with the
participant and if the participant accepts an offer to enter into the respective first
trade.
34. The method of claim 23, further comprising querying each participant of the
plurality of participants to determine if a respective matching order for the second
order is stored in a respective order management system associated with the
participant and if the participant accepts an offer to enter into the second trade.
35. The method of claim 23, further comprising providing an indication of whether
the time period has passed to a submitter of the second order.
36. The method of claim 23, further comprising:
receiving a request to cancel the second order during the time period; and in
which constraining the cancellation includes queuing the request for cancellation
until after the time period.
37. The method of claim 36, further comprising cancelling the second order after
the time period.
38. The method of claim 23, further comprising:
receiving a request to cancel the second order during the time period;
determining that a matching order of the second order is stored in an order
management system associated with a participant of the plurality of participants
and the participant accepts an offer to enter into a trade fulfilling at least part of
each of the matching order and the second order during the time period; and
facilitating execution of a trade fulfilling at least a portion of each of the
second order and the matching order. 2025204532
39. The method of claim 38, in which the request to cancel the second order is
received before the determination is made.
40. The method of claim 23, further comprising determining that no matching
order to the second order is stored in an order management system associated with
any of the plurality of participants before the end of the time period.
41. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 23.
42. A system comprising:
one or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 23; and
the one or more processors.
43. A method comprising:
receiving an indication of an order, in which the order defines a trade of a
financial instrument;
determining that no matching order to the order is stored in a respective
order management system associated with any of a plurality of participants before
an end of a time period;
determining that a cancellation of the order should be constrained during
the time period; and
constraining the cancellation of the order during the time period.
44. The method of claim 43, further comprising allowing the cancellation of the
order after the time period.
45. The method of claim 43, in which determining that the cancellation of the order 2025204532
should be constrained includes determining that a number of orders have been
received from a submitter of the order before the indication of the order is
received.
46. The method of claim 45, in which the number of orders includes orders that
were not fulfilled when the indication of the order is received.
47. The method of claim 45, in which the number of orders includes orders that at
least one of: have no matching orders stored in the order management systems of
any of the plurality of participants and have not been accepted by any of the
plurality of participants.
48. The method of claim 43, in which determining the cancellation of the order
should be constrained includes making a random determination.
49. The method of claim 43, further comprising querying each participant of a
plurality of participants to determine if a matching order for the order is stored in a
respective order management system associated with the participant and if the
participant accepts an offer to enter into the second trade.
50. The method of claim 43, further comprising providing an indication of whether
the time period has passed to a submitter of the order.
51. The method of claim 43, further comprising:
receiving a request to cancel the order during the time period; and in which
constraining the cancellation includes queuing the request for cancellation until
after the time period.
52. The method of claim 51, further comprising cancelling the second order after
the time period. 2025204532
54. The method of claim 43, further comprising:
receiving a request to cancel the order during the time period;
determining that a matching order of the order is stored in an order
management system associated with a participant of the plurality of participants
and the participant accepts an offer to enter into a trade fulfilling at least part of
each of the matching order and the order during the time period; and
facilitating execution of a trade fulfilling at least a portion of each of the
order and the matching order.
55. The method of claim 54, in which the request to cancel the order is received
before the determination is made.
56. The method of claim 43, in which determining that no matching order to the
order is stored in the order management system associated with any of the plurality
of participants before an end of a time period, includes determining that no
indication that the matching order is stored in an order management system was
received.
57. The method of claim 43, in which determining that no matching order to the
order is stored in the order management system associated with any of the plurality
of participants before an end of a time period, includes determining that an
indication that no matching order is stored in an order management system from
each of the plurality of participants.
58. One or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 43.
59. A system comprising:
one or more machine-readable media having stored thereon a plurality of 2025204532
instructions that when executed by one or more processors cause the processors to
perform the method of claim 43; and
the one or more processors.
Whatisisclaimed claimed is: 18 Jun 2025
What is:
1. 1. A methodcomprising: A method comprising: receiving, by a marketplace, a firm order for a financial instrument from a first participant receiving, by a marketplace, a firm order for a financial instrument from a first participant
of the marketplace, in which the firm order defines a side of a trade for the financial instrument, of the marketplace, in which the firm order defines a side of a trade for the financial instrument,
and in which the firm order includes an order to execute the trade without additional authorization and in which the firm order includes an order to execute the trade without additional authorization
from the first participant; from the first participant; 2025204532
in response in responsetotoreceiving receiving the the firmfirm orderorder by theby the marketplace, marketplace, transmitting, transmitting, by the by the marketplace, ananorder marketplace, orderquery queryidentifying identifyingthethefirm firm order order from from the the marketplace marketplace to a to a plurality plurality of of participants of the marketplace, in which each of the plurality of participants includes a respective participants of the marketplace, in which each of the plurality of participants includes a respective
order management order management system, system, in which in which eacheach respective respective order order management management system system is configured is configured to to store securely store securely information informationabout about a plurality a plurality of order of order interests interests associated associated with with a respective a respective
participant without revealing existence of the plurality of order interests outside of the respective participant without revealing existence of the plurality of order interests outside of the respective
participant, in which each of the plurality of participants includes a module configured to securely participant, in which each of the plurality of participants includes a module configured to securely
interface with interface with the the respective respectiveorder ordermanagement systemofofthe management system therespective respectiveparticipant; participant; in response in response toto receiving receivinga arespective respectiveorder orderquery query by the by the respective respective participant participant of of the the plurality of participants, determining, by a respective module configured to securely interface with plurality of participants, determining, by a respective module configured to securely interface with
the respective the respective order order management system management system of of thethe respective respective participant,a adetermination participant, determinationresult resultthat that a matching a orderthat matching order that matches the firm matches the firm order order is is stored stored in inthe therespective respectiveorder ordermanagement system management system
associated with associated withthe therespective respectiveparticipant participantwithout withoutrevealing revealing existence existence about about respective respective orderorder
interests of the respective participant outside of the respective participant, in which the respective interests of the respective participant outside of the respective participant, in which the respective
moduleisisconfigured module configuredtotomaintain maintain secrecy secrecy of the of the existence existence of order of order interests interests of the of the respective respective
participant except in response to execution of a trade; participant except in response to execution of a trade;
in response to determining the determination result, providing, by the respective module of in response to determining the determination result, providing, by the respective module of
the respective participant, a request for acceptance of the firm order without revealing information the respective participant, a request for acceptance of the firm order without revealing information
about respective trading interests of the respective participant outside of the respective participant; about respective trading interests of the respective participant outside of the respective participant;
receiving, by the respective module of the respective participant, a positive reply to the receiving, by the respective module of the respective participant, a positive reply to the
request for acceptance; request for acceptance;
in response to receiving the positive reply, transmitting, from the respective participant to in response to receiving the positive reply, transmitting, from the respective participant to
the marketplace, an indication that a trade fulfilling at least a part of the firm order and at least a the marketplace, an indication that a trade fulfilling at least a part of the firm order and at least a
part of part of the thematching matching order order should be executed; should be executed;
219 receiving, by the marketplace, the indication that the trade should be executed; and 18 Jun 2025 receiving, by the marketplace, the indication that the trade should be executed; and in response to receiving the indication that the trade should be executed by the marketplace, in response to receiving the indication that the trade should be executed by the marketplace, facilitating by the facilitating by themarketplace, marketplace, execution execution oftrade of the the trade fulfilling fulfilling at least at least part part offirm of the the order firm order and and at least part of the matching order without a further communication with the first participant, in at least part of the matching order without a further communication with the first participant, in which the marketplace is configured to maintain secrecy of the order query until after the trade is which the marketplace is configured to maintain secrecy of the order query until after the trade is executed at which time only notification of execution is provided without notification of an identity executed at which time only notification of execution is provided without notification of an identity of the respective participant; and of the respective participant; and 2025204532 wherein transmitting the order query to the plurality of participants comprises querying the wherein transmitting the order query to the plurality of participants comprises querying the order by one of a plurality of buy side participants among the plurality of participants to one or order by one of a plurality of buy side participants among the plurality of participants to one or more other ones of the plurality of buy side participants; and more other ones of the plurality of buy side participants; and whereinthe wherein the marketplace marketplacecomprises comprisesananelectronic electronicmarketplace. marketplace.
2. The 2. Themethod methodofofclaim claim1,1,ininwhich whicheach eachofofthe theplurality plurality of of modules of the modules of the participants participants isis
configured toto interface configured interface with withthethemarketplace marketplace and and a user a user interface, interface, andwhich and in in which an act an of act of determiningthat determining that aa matching order is matching order is stored storedin inthe respective the order respective management order management system associated system associated
with the with the respective respective participant participant is is made basedonona checking made based a checking of orders of orders currently currently stored stored in the in the
respective order respective order management system, management system, in in which which such such check check is made is made after after receiving receiving thethe respective respective
order query. order query.
3. The 3. The method methodofofclaim claim1,1,further further comprising: comprising: receiving a second indication, by the marketplace from a second respective participant, that receiving a second indication, by the marketplace from a second respective participant, that
a second trade fulfilling at least the part of the firm order and at least a part of a second matching a second trade fulfilling at least the part of the firm order and at least a part of a second matching
order should order be executed; should be and executed; and
before facilitating before facilitating the the execution of the execution of the trade, trade, determining, basedonona arate determining, based rateofofactivity activity associated with the respective participant and the second respective participant, that the respective associated with the respective participant and the second respective participant, that the respective
participant has priority over the second respective participant, and participant has priority over the second respective participant, and
in which in whichfacilitating facilitating the the execution executionincludes includesfacilitating facilitating the theexecution executionin inresponse response to to determining that the respective participant has priority. determining that the respective participant has priority.
4. The 4. Themethod methodofofclaim claim1,1,further further comprising: comprising: receiving, by receiving, by a second respective a second respective participant, participant, a a respective respectiveorder orderquery queryfrom from the the
220

Claims (1)

  1. marketplace; 18 Jun 2025
    marketplace;
    in response in responsetotoreceiving, receiving,determining, determining, by by a second a second respective respective modulemodule configured configured to to securely interface securely interface with with a a second order management second order management system system of the of the second second respective respective participant, participant,
    that there that thereisis nonomatching matching order orderininthe second the secondorder ordermanagement systemassociated management system associatedwith withthe thesecond second respective participant respective participant without without revealing revealinginformation information about about respective respective trading trading interests interests of of the the second respective participant outside of the second respective participant; second respective participant outside of the second respective participant;
    in response in response toto determining determiningbyby thethe second second respective respective module, module, suppressing suppressing evidence evidence of of 2025204532
    determining determining by by the the second second respective respective participant. participant.
    5. Themethod 5. The methodof of claim claim 4, 4, inin which which suppressing suppressing evidence evidence includes includes preventing preventing a reply a reply to to
    the order the order query query from beingsent from being sent to to the the marketplace fromthe marketplace from the second secondrespective respectiveparticipant. participant.
    6. The 6. Themethod methodofofclaim claim5,5,ininwhich whichthe themethod method furthercomprises: further comprises: determining, by determining, bythe the marketplace, marketplace,that thatnonoreply replytotothe theorder orderquery querywas wasreceived received from from thethe
    second respective participant; and second respective participant; and
    in response to determining that no reply was received, preventing a transmission of at least in response to determining that no reply was received, preventing a transmission of at least
    one future order query to the second respective participant. one future order query to the second respective participant.
    7. The 7. methodofofclaim The method claim5,5,in in which whichsuppressing suppressingevidence evidenceincludes includespreventing preventinga arequest requestfor for acceptanceof acceptance of the the firm firm order order from frombeing beingprovided providedfrom from a second a second respective respective module module whenwhen such such a a request would request otherwisehave would otherwise havebeen beenprovided. provided.
    8. Themethod 8. The methodofofclaim claim1,1,further further comprising: comprising: suppressing, bybythe suppressing, themarketplace, marketplace, evidence evidence of receiving of receiving the positive the positive reply,reply, in in which which suppressing evidence suppressing evidenceincludes includesnot notcommunicating communicating a reply a reply to to anyone anyone other other thanthan necessary necessary parties parties
    for the execution for the execution until until after after thethe execution, execution, in which in which the necessary the necessary parties parties do do not not include theinclude first the first participant. participant.
    9. The method of claim 1, in which the positive reply includes a binding acceptance of the 9. The method of claim 1, in which the positive reply includes a binding acceptance of the
    firm order. firm order.
    221
    10. Themethod 10. The methodof of claim claim 1, further 1, further comprising: comprising: never never receiving receiving a negative a negative replyreply to anto an
    order query, order query,
    in which in communication which communication includes includes negotiation. negotiation.
    11. Themethod 11. The methodof of claim claim 1, 1, ininwhich which each each participantisisconfigured participant configuredtotonot notsend sendany anyreply reply to the order query to the marketplace if a respective determination that there is no matching order to the order query to the marketplace if a respective determination that there is no matching order 2025204532
    stored in a respective order management system associated with the respective participant is made. stored in a respective order management system associated with the respective participant is made.
    12. Themethod 12. The methodofofclaim claim1,1,further furthercomprising: comprising: receiving, by receiving, by the the marketplace fromaasecond marketplace from secondparticipant, participant, aa second secondfirm firmorder orderfor for aa second second financial instrument; financial instrument;
    in response to receiving from the second participant, determining, by the marketplace, that in response to receiving from the second participant, determining, by the marketplace, that
    a matching a firmorder matching firm order has has previously previouslybeen beenposted postedtotoananorder orderbook bookofofthe themarketplace; marketplace;and and in response to determining that the matching order has been posted, facilitating execution in response to determining that the matching order has been posted, facilitating execution
    of an order fulfilling at least part of each of the second firm order and the matching firm order. of an order fulfilling at least part of each of the second firm order and the matching firm order.
    13. Themethod 13. The methodof of claim claim 1, 1, in in which which each each of of thethe order order queries queries andand reply reply areare transmitted transmitted
    using respective using respective encrypted messages. encrypted messages.
    14. Themethod 14. The methodofof claim1,1,ininwhich claim whichthe themethod method furthercomprises: further comprises: before receiving before receivingthe thepositive positivereply, reply,periodically periodicallytransmitting transmittingadditional additionalorder order queries queries
    identifying the firm order from the marketplace to each of the plurality of participants. identifying the firm order from the marketplace to each of the plurality of participants.
    15. Themethod 15. The method of claim of claim 1, which 1, in in which the respective the respective module module is configured is configured to maintain to maintain
    secrecy of trading interests of the respective participant except to respond to the order query, and secrecy of trading interests of the respective participant except to respond to the order query, and
    in which the marketplace is configured to maintain secrecy of the order query until after the trade in which the marketplace is configured to maintain secrecy of the order query until after the trade
    is executed. is executed.
    16. Anapparatus 16. An apparatuscomprising: comprising: a processor; a processor; and and
    222 memory storinginstructions instructionsthat, that, when executed,cause causethe theprocessor processorto: to: 18 Jun 2025 memory storing when executed, receive, by a marketplace, a firm order for a financial instrument from a first participant receive, by a marketplace, a firm order for a financial instrument from a first participant of the marketplace, in which the firm order defines a side of a trade for the financial instrument, of the marketplace, in which the firm order defines a side of a trade for the financial instrument, and in which the firm order includes an order to execute the trade without additional authorization and in which the firm order includes an order to execute the trade without additional authorization from the first participant; from the first participant; in response in response to to receiving receiving the the firm firm order order by by the the marketplace, marketplace, transmit, transmit, by by the the marketplace,ananorder marketplace, orderquery query identifyingthethe identifying firm firm order order from from the the marketplace marketplace to a to a plurality plurality of of 2025204532 participants of the marketplace, in which each of the plurality of participants includes a respective participants of the marketplace, in which each of the plurality of participants includes a respective order management order management system, system, in which in which eacheach respective respective order order management management system system is configured is configured to to store securely store securely information informationabout about a plurality a plurality of order of order interests interests associated associated with with a respective a respective participant without revealing existence of the plurality of order interests outside of the respective participant without revealing existence of the plurality of order interests outside of the respective participant participant in response in to receiving response to receiving aa respective respective order order query query by bythe therespective respectiveparticipant participant of of the the plurality of participants, determining, by a respective module configured to securely interface with plurality of participants, determining, by a respective module configured to securely interface with the respective the respective order order management system management system of of thethe respective respective participant,that participant, thataamatching matchingorder orderthat that matchesthe matches thefirm firmorder orderisis stored stored in in the the respective respective order order management system management system associated associated withwith the the respective participant without revealing existence about respective order interests of the respective respective participant without revealing existence about respective order interests of the respective participant outside of the respective participant, in which the respective module is configured to participant outside of the respective participant, in which the respective module is configured to maintain secrecy of the existence of order interests of the respective participant except in response maintain secrecy of the existence of order interests of the respective participant except in response to execution of a trade; to execution of a trade; receive, by receive, by the themarketplace, marketplace, from from the the respective respective module module configured configured to securely to securely interface with the respective order management system of the respective participant of the plurality interface with the respective order management system of the respective participant of the plurality of participants, an indication that a trade fulfilling at least a part of the firm order and at least part of participants, an indication that a trade fulfilling at least a part of the firm order and at least part of the matching order that is stored in the respective order management system should be executed; of the matching order that is stored in the respective order management system should be executed; and and in response in responsetotoreceiving receivingthetheindication indicationthat thatthethe trade trade should should be executed be executed by theby the marketplace, facilitate by the marketplace, execution of the trade fulfilling at least part of the firm marketplace, facilitate by the marketplace, execution of the trade fulfilling at least part of the firm order and order andatat least least part part of of the the matching matchingorder order without without a further a further communication communication with with the the first first participant, ininwhich participant, which the the marketplace is configured marketplace is configuredtoto maintain maintainsecrecy secrecyofofthe theorder orderquery queryuntil until after the after the trade is executed trade is at which executed at whichtime time only only notification notification of execution of execution is provided is provided without without notification of an identity of the respective participant; and notification of an identity of the respective participant; and
    223 wherein transmitting the order query to the plurality of participants comprises querying the 18 Jun 2025 wherein transmitting the order query to the plurality of participants comprises querying the order by one of a plurality of buy side participants among the plurality of participants to one or order by one of a plurality of buy side participants among the plurality of participants to one or more other ones of the plurality of buy side participants, and more other ones of the plurality of buy side participants, and whereinthe wherein the marketplace marketplacecomprises comprisesan an electronicmarketplace. electronic marketplace. 2025204532
    224
    103
    123
    121 103
    105 119 111
    107 117
    101 109
    113 115
    101 101
    FIGURE 1
    205 205 205 205 2025204532
    203 201
    203 213 213 203 203
    211 211 207 209 209 207 FIGURE 2
    300 BEGIN
    303 RECEIVE A FIRM ORDER 2025204532
    305
    DETERMINE IF MATCHING FIRM ORDER IS AVAILABLE
    NO YES IS A MATCHING FIRM ORDER AVAILABLE?
    311 307
    EXECUTE A TRADE QUERY PARTICIPANT FULFILLING THE FIRM FOR MATCHING ORDERS ORDER AND THE 313 MATCHING FIRM ORDER RECEIVE ADDITIONAL FIRM ORDERS 309 END 315 YES NO HAS MATCHING ORDER BEEN FOUND?
    317
    FACILITATE EXECUTION OF TRADE FULFILLING THE FIRM ORDER AND THE MATCHING ORDER
    319 END
    FIGURE 3
    400 401 BEGIN
    403
    RECEIVE AN INDICATION OF AN ORDER 2025204532
    405
    DETERMINE IF ORDER IS A FIRM ORDER
    YES NO IS ORDER A FIRM ORDER?
    411
    PROVIDE INFORMATION ABOUT THE FIRM ORDER 407 STORE INFORMATION FOR EXECUTION ABOUT THE ORDER
    409 RECIEVE INCOMING FIRM 413 ORDER QUERIES END
    DETERMINE THAT A QUERY 415 MATCHES THE ORDER
    FACILITATE EXECUTION 417 OF A TRADE FULFILLING THE ORDER WITH A MATCHING FIRM ORDER QUERY
    419 END
    FIGURE 4
    BEGIN 501 503 2025204532
    IDENTIFY PARTICIPANT SERVERS
    505
    RECEIVE INDICATION OF FIRM ORDER 507
    TRANSMIT REQUEST FOR MATCHING ORDER TO THE PARTICIPANT SERVERS
    509 NO RESPONSE RECEIVED?
    511 YES
    FACILITATE EXECUTION OF TRADE FULFILLING THE FIRM ORDER AND THE MATCHING ORDER
    513
    END
    FIGURE 5
    600 BEGIN 603
    RECEIVING INDICATION OF ONE OR MORE ORDERS 2025204532
    605 RECEIVING A FIRM ORDER QUERY
    607 FILTER FIRM ORDER QUERY 609
    DETERMINING IF THE FIRM ORDER MATCHES ANY OF THE ORDERS
    611 NO YES DOES FIRM ORDER MATCH AN ORDER? 613 615 END PROVIDE AN INDICATION OF THE MATCHING FIRM ORDER 617
    AWAIT RESPONSE 623 619 FACILITATE EXECUTION OF YES POSITIVE A TRADE FULFILLING THE FIRM ORDER AND RESPONSE RECEIVED? THE MATCHING ORDER 621 625 END END
    FIGURE 6
    701 BEGIN 703 2025204532
    PROVIDING AN INTERFACE THROUGH WHICH BOTH FIRM ORDERS AND PRIVATE ORDERS MAY BE ENTERED
    705 RECEIVING INFORMATION ABOUT AN ORDER
    707 NO YES IS THE ORDER A FIRM ORDER?
    713 709
    TRANSMITTING THE ORDER TO BE TRANSMITTING THE ORDER USED TO MATCH WITH INCOMING FOR AUTOMATIC EXECUTION QUERY REQUESTS IDENTIFYING WITH MATCHING ORDERS MATCHING FIRM ORDERS
    711 715 END END
    FIGURE 7 enn 48.30 x 48.34 SIVB BUY 100 " 500
    Symbol
    is 500.000 MIDPOINT a DAY Sit
    Sane Price Time in Force
    500.000 .01 48.32 Minimum Fill increment Limit
    AQUA Show Full Size of
    SUBMIT CANCEL
    50.000 652 750,000
    801
    FIGURE 8
    901 BEGIN
    903 2025204532
    RECEIVING AND INDICATION THAT A FIRM ORDER MATCHES A PRIVATE ORDER
    905
    PROVIDING AN INTERFACE IDENTIFYING THAT A MATCH EXISTS
    NO IS A POSITIVE 907 RESPONSE TO THE REQUEST RECEIVED?
    END YES 909 911
    TRANSMIT A REQUEST TO EXECUTE A TRADE FULFILLING THE FIRM ORDER AND THE MATCHING ORDER
    913 END
    FIGURE 9
    10 / 26 18 Jun 2025 2025204532
    FIRM OFFER (Broker) SIVB SV8 Financial Group 48.30 X 48.34 100-500
    500,000 48.32 AQUA 15 Sane Price Shot Clock
    150,000 Minimum F@ BUY IGNORE
    Notify Me At: 48.32 15:30 Price or Time
    FIGURE 10
    1100 BEGIN 1101 /
    RECEIVING AN INDICATION OF A NON-FIRM ORDER 2025204532
    1103
    TRANSMITTING A FIRST QUERY ASKING IF A MATCHING ORDER TO THE NON-FIRM ORDER IS STORED IN AN ORDER MANAGEMENT SYSTEM 1105 TRANSMITTING A SECOND QUERY ASKING IF AN OFFER TO ENTER INTO A TRADE THAT FULFILLS AT LEAST A PORTION OF EACH OF THE NON-FIRM ORDER AND THE MATCHING ORDER IS ACCEPTED 1107 RECEIVING AN INDICATION OF AN ACCEPTANCE OF THE NON-FIRM ORDER
    1109 IN RESPONSE TO RECEIVING THE INDICATION OF THE ACCEPTANCE, TRANSMITTING A REQUEST FOR CONFIRMATION OF THE NON-FIRM ORDER TO THE FIRST PARTICIPANT 1111
    RECEIVING AN INDICATION OF A CONFIRMATION OF THE NON-FIRM ORDER
    FACILITATING EXECUTION OF THE TRADE FULFILLING AT LEAST THE PORTION OF EACH OF THE NON-FIRM ORDER AND THE MATCHING ORDER
    1113
    END
    FIGURE 11
    2025204532
    1215
    1211
    1209 1207
    1201
    1205
    1203
    FIGURE 12
    2025204532
    BEGIN 1301
    RECEIVING AN INDICATION OF ORDER THAT IS PENDING IN AN ORDER BOOK OF AN ALTERNATIVE TRADING SYSTEM 1303
    DETERMINING THAT A MATCHING ORDER TO THE ORDER IS STORED IN AN ORDER MANAGEMENT SYSTEM AND THAT AN OFFER TO ENTER INTO A TRADE THAT FULFILLS AT LEAST A PORTION OF EACH OF THE ORDER AND THE MATCHING ORDER IS ACCEPTED
    TRANSMITTING AN INDICATION THAT THE TRADE SHOULD BE EXECUTED TO THE ALTERNATIVE TRADING SYSTEM
    1305
    END
    FIGURE 13
    BEGIN 1401 2025204532
    RECEIVING AN INDICATION OF ONE OR MORE ORDERS
    1403 STORING INFORMATION ABOUT THE ONE OR MORE ORDERS IN AN ORDER BOOK OF AN ALTERNATIVE TRADING SYSTEM
    1405 TRANSMITTING AN INDICATION OF AN ORDER TO A TRADING SYSTEM 1407
    RECEIVING AN INDICATION OF AN ACCEPTANCE OF AN OFFER TO ENTER INTO A TRADE THAT FULFILLS AT LEAST PART OF THE ORDER
    1409 DETERMINING IF THE ORDER IS AVAILABLE
    FACILITATING EXECUTION OF THE TRADE THAT FULFILLS AT LEAST PART OF THE ORDER IF IT IS DETERMINED THAT THE ORDER IS AVAILABLE
    1411
    END
    FIGURE 14
AU2025204532A 2007-11-15 2025-06-18 Electronic trading systems and methods Pending AU2025204532A1 (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
AU2025204532A AU2025204532A1 (en) 2007-11-15 2025-06-18 Electronic trading systems and methods

Applications Claiming Priority (18)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
US60/988,426 2007-11-15
US12/015,990 2008-01-17
US12/135,479 2008-06-09
US12/204,403 2008-09-04
US12/204,341 2008-09-04
US12/237,958 2008-09-25
US12/237,941 2008-09-25
US12/237,976 2008-09-25
US12/239,804 2008-09-28
US12/239,803 2008-09-28
US12/257,499 2008-10-24
AU2008322494A AU2008322494B2 (en) 2007-11-15 2008-11-14 Electronic trading systems and methods
AU2012244193A AU2012244193A1 (en) 2007-11-15 2012-10-25 Electronic trading systems and methods
AU2016203638A AU2016203638A1 (en) 2007-11-15 2016-05-31 Electronic trading systems and methods
AU2018263977A AU2018263977A1 (en) 2007-11-15 2018-11-13 Electronic trading systems and methods
AU2021200152A AU2021200152A1 (en) 2007-11-15 2021-01-12 Electronic trading systems and methods
AU2023202021A AU2023202021A1 (en) 2007-11-15 2023-04-03 Electronic trading systems and methods
AU2025204532A AU2025204532A1 (en) 2007-11-15 2025-06-18 Electronic trading systems and methods

Related Parent Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
AU2023202021A Division AU2023202021A1 (en) 2007-11-15 2023-04-03 Electronic trading systems and methods

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
AU2025204532A1 true AU2025204532A1 (en) 2025-07-10

Family

ID=47144687

Family Applications (3)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
AU2012244193A Abandoned AU2012244193A1 (en) 2007-11-15 2012-10-25 Electronic trading systems and methods
AU2023202021A Abandoned AU2023202021A1 (en) 2007-11-15 2023-04-03 Electronic trading systems and methods
AU2025204532A Pending AU2025204532A1 (en) 2007-11-15 2025-06-18 Electronic trading systems and methods

Family Applications Before (2)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
AU2012244193A Abandoned AU2012244193A1 (en) 2007-11-15 2012-10-25 Electronic trading systems and methods
AU2023202021A Abandoned AU2023202021A1 (en) 2007-11-15 2023-04-03 Electronic trading systems and methods

Country Status (1)

Country Link
AU (3) AU2012244193A1 (en)

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
AU2023202021A1 (en) 2023-05-04
AU2012244193A1 (en) 2012-11-15

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
US12112376B2 (en) Method and system for order management
US20250104130A1 (en) Order cancellation
US20240403958A1 (en) Multicomputer distributed processing of trading information
US20210042833A1 (en) Interprogram communication using messages related to groups of orders
US20100332368A1 (en) Multicomputer distributed processing of data regarding trading opportunities
US20100082500A1 (en) Interaction with trading systems
US20110137786A1 (en) Multicomputer distributed processing techniques to prevent information leakage
US20120005062A1 (en) Multicomputer distributed processing of order and/or pricing information
US20100057627A1 (en) Non-firm orders in electronic marketplaces
US20100082495A1 (en) Trading system accessibility
US20100191638A1 (en) Multicomputer distributed processing of data related to automation of trading
US20100076883A1 (en) Generating risk pools
US20100057626A1 (en) Cancellation timing in an electronic marketplace
AU2016203637A1 (en) Multicomputer distributed processing techniques to prevent information leakage
US20100076896A1 (en) Substitutability of financial instruments
AU2008322494B2 (en) Electronic trading systems and methods
AU2021200152A1 (en) Electronic trading systems and methods
AU2025204532A1 (en) Electronic trading systems and methods