Intent
As explained in my last post, my intention is to aim for opposing forces to refight the Battle of Verneuil, 1424. However, ideally I want the collection to be flexible enough to be used for all the battles of the 1420s, and possibly some either side. The battles this includes are:
1421 – Battle of Baugé https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Baug%C3%A9
1423 – Battle of La Brossinière https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_La_Brossini%C3%A8re
1423 – Battle of Cravant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Cravant
1424 – Battle of Verneuil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Verneuil
1426 – Battle of St James https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_St._James
1429 – Battle of The Herrings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Herrings
1429 – Battle of Patay https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Patay
I intend to complete the project using Perry Miniatures plastic sets. However, the majority of the battles included some sort of mounted element, and the Mounted Men at Arms for the Agincourt to Orleans range has not yet been released – though it will be the next release according to the news from this year’s Salute (https://leadadventureforum.com/index.php?topic=108711.0).
Luckily, the Battle of Cravant seems to have been fought exclusively by infantry forces, so this represents a good starting point to get troops onto the table. It also includes a river crossing for which the terrain will double up for Baugé. Cravant (as per all the other battles) is also significantly smaller than Verneuil.
Rules
In order to determine the requirements as far as figures go, I need to determine which ruleset(s) I intend to use. I have two in mind – Impetus for larger battles, and Lion Rampant for smaller actions and possibly future sieges. There is not much science to this selection, other than I have previously played some Basic Impetus (the free version, not the newly published commercial rules) and it seemed to represent later medieval warfare quite well. It has some mechanics that will definitely be needed, such as archers’ stakes and the ability for a unit to make multiple moves in the same turn, and no obvious show stoppers.
As for Lion Rampant, it is a popular set that is good for a reasonable number of models, and I also have a Wargames Illustrated issue containing siege rules (more on this in a future post).
Impetus suggests that each base (120mm x 40-60mm for 28mm figures) represents 600-1200 men on an infantry base, and 400-600 on a cavalry base. My belief is that for medieval warfare, where armies were generally smaller, this representation is at the lower end – i.e. 600 infantry and 400 cavalry.
Lion Rampant uses individually based figures, each representing a single man.
Requirements
Based on the above, I can develop what figures I will need. With Verneuil as the end goal, what will I need? Unlike Agincourt, there is less disagreement on the numbers involved. It is generally accepted that around 9000 English troops faced around 15000 French, Scottish and Lombard soldiers.
In this period, English forces were split for professional duty on the continent into archers and men at arms (which included everyone from the king down to squires). There was also a split between foot and mounted for pay reasons, but English armies almost exclusively fought on foot. The ratio for different troop types was commonly 1 man at arms per 3 archers.
9000 troops at 600 men per base comes to 15 bases. An approximate 1:3 ratio will turn this into 11 bases of archers and 4 bases of men at arms.
The French forces and their allies and mercenaries are slightly more complex. It appears that French royal armies generally used a similar split between men at arms and archers (usually, but not exclusively crossbowmen rather than longbowmen), but at a ratio of 2 men at arms to 1 archer. My belief is that the “men at arms” is a broader description than in England, and would include general infantry troops as well, though I am still researching this – any knowledge welcome in the comments!
The Scottish forces are fairly similar to the English, including longbow archers as the dominant troop type, as well as men at arms and general infantry. There were around 6000-6500 at Verneuil.
Lombards and other allies were generally recruited as mounted men at arms. These formed a significant number of troops at the Battle of Verneil – possibly as many as 3000.
Discounting the mounted contingent for the moment, I will look to represent 6000 French and 6000 Scottish troops – 10 bases each. The Scots will have 2 bases of men at arms, 2 bases of spear armed infantry and 6 bases of archers. The French will have 4 bases of men at arms, 3 bases of general infantry and 3 bases of crossbowmen.