Hearts Around the Table: Jenna's First Love

What I found most bothersome about these movies is that there is no explanation for the single, childless foster mother having an enormous mansion on a large property. Did she just do a really good job of investing her payments for being a foster parent? I mean, come on! There is nothing even slightly rational about this storyline.

Let me just start off by saying I really wanted to like this movie. But it was so difficult to watch even though the leading lady is traditionally a great actress, but every other character was just awful. The leading man was such a bad actor and lowkey looked like he was holding in a fart the entire movie. The foster mom, Angie, was so weird looking it was hard to focus. The whole "foster family" dynamic was just so strange to me, and all of her siblings were just as bad at acting as the leading man.

He was extremely condescending, childish, and dismissive of Jenna. I really didn't think they should've ended up together. I thought she deserved way better than a grown ass man who gave her the silent treatment after the tiniest most irrelevant misconception. I would not have been disappointed if she chose herself at the end. Save yourself the hour and a half and don't bother watching.

Let me explain why we like this Hallmark movie and gave it a "10." Primarily, the female lead's clothing as well as hair and makeup were a monumental improvement from ALL earlier Hallmark movies. I would bet money that Hallmark (hopefully) fired every single person that dressed the stars in those tacky, ugly, unstylish clothing, especially the women, but men too. There is a saying that fits, which is: There only taste is in their mouth. Hair, makeup, and especially the women's clothing was always garbage. It is like they were trying to start a new and tasteless trend, that would never get off the ground in the real world. Awful. So thanks for giving good taste in clothing a chance.

The show is worth watching if only for the female lead's clothing. Very classy, and very tasteful. It complemented her nicely instead of Halmark's usual Halloween costumes.

Plus the script was pretty good too.

I wanted to like this movie or start off the series. I'm hoping the other movies are better. This one I didn't want the main ones to get together.

He came off arrogant and dismissive towards her ideas. And when they liked her idea better he made a face.

Like typical Hallmark you have miscommunication between the leads. If she "was the love of his life" why wait till like you're all old. He could have tried harder. Who carries around the old yearbook to an event.

I'm waiting for the next one. The main guy I was not a fan of. Sheri was the best of this movie.

Until the next one. Like the concept of this 4 movie series.

Let's start by summing this movie up with the extremely ridiculous post in the main character's , Andrew, yearbook which read - "You smelt like farts all sophomore year." If you find this humorous or cute, this movie is for you. If you are over the age of 18 and wondering why that was allowed to make it in as a prop, ummm not so much. (Prop person - you had one job). The characters weren't interesting so I wasn't invested in their story. The acting was kind of wooden for such an amazing cast (I blame the director). The storyline had promise but felt so rushed. I think with some more thought and edits, and removal of some of the silly dialogue, this would be a great movie. I would love to see a redo. With a different director.