Un cadeau de Noël presque parfait

A Christmas take on the film classic "Mannequin", but without the comedic finesse. In fact some of it is just quite silly.

It's another one of those where the girl can't see the great guy that's been there all along and it's quite frustrating.

The leads are fine, in fact Milo is mighty fine, but the best friend is far too over the top. However, somehow the assistant and her love interest works.

Not a lot of Christmas going on. It's all just a bit pretentious in it's need to be perfect, I guess that's where the British title comes from "A Perfect Christmas".

Holly wants everything to be perfect, even while her own life is not. And when I saw this movie, it was given the title "A Perfect Christmas", the message that department store window kept trying to drive home.

I like the formula, but that's what this is. Claire Coffee is pretty and plays a driven executive who can't seem to have what she thinks is perfection. And by the end of the movie, she may be on the way to finding what the audience wants her to have. Holly is likable enough and has a nice smile.

I know Ryan McPartlin from several roles. In only one of them, a major role in a series that lasted several seasons, did he show intelligence and range. Here, he's just what he needs to be--good-looking, charming, but shallow and lacking brains or emotion. I don't think the audience is supposed to want him to end up with Holly.

More likable is photographer Milo. Jeff Ward does a good job and shows somewhat more range than the others.

Another standout is Annie Quinn, the secretary who can't seem to do anything right but is adorable, and she looks great at the office party where she provides what less-informed people would describe as music. She has a potential romantic partner in nerdy co-worker Paul Elia.

As the best friend, Gabrielle Dennis can be likable, and she can be shallow and annoying. But she has some good scenes.

I think Matt Riedy and Robin Riker are Bo's perfect parents, who are so funny, especially when they show how they were once models in ad campaigns.

Megan Stevenson is too perfect looking and nasty. Every movie like this needs someone like her.

In several scenes, Aketza Lopez is the dashing Latin lover who is perfect and constantly reminds you of this. Why does she not like me, he wonders? Well, there are reasons. And unlike Bo, he is not perfect (in the way Bo is, which of course isn't perfect).

I have to say some of what was happening in this movie was too unpleasant and a possible way out is the phenomenon of a character hitting his or her head. While the movie works either way, things got so bad that I was hoping that Holly hitting her head meant this was all a fantasy.

The Christmas carolers who appear in two scenes are wonderful. There wasn't a lot in the way of Christmas music in this movie, and certainly none at the holiday party. There is some good background music but two scenes and the party have this loud obnoxious noise that no one in his right mind would call music.

Family friendly? I don't think anything is that bad. Kids might be bored. Bo and Holly don't actually do anything but given what movie characters often do on the first date, we can assume what happened when we weren't watching. Or maybe Bo is too much of a gentleman.

We've seen it many times before, but I always enjoy these movies.

Am not somebody who hates Christmas or has a bias against made for television Christmas films. The complete opposite on both counts and have made that clear more than once and will continue to do so if necessary (though am refraining as much as possible from reiterating too much). The premise did sound quite interesting and seemed like it was trying to do something a little different. So watched 'Holly's Holiday' with the intent to like it.

Sadly, there are just too many flaws with 'Holly's Holiday' for me to do that. It's not entirely terrible and has a few good things, but there is a lot wrong with it and it is another film where the worst of the bad things are executed pretty terribly. A case of a pretty decent premise not done anywhere near enough with and with mediocre at best execution. Am usually, or at least there is the attempt to be, a balanced and encouraging person when reviewing films, television etc. but 'Holly's Holiday' is one of those films where it is not always easy to take that attitude.

'Holly's Holiday' is not a complete loss. The best thing about it is Jeff Ward as the only character who is entertaining or likeable, he seemed fully engaged with his role and brought a smile to my face. Also think Claire Coffee did better than expected in a role that is easy to make obnoxious, but she brought the right amount of able charm to it.

The soundtrack is pleasant enough in parts as is some of the scenery.

On the other hand, a lot works against 'Holly's Holiday'. For my tastes Ryan McPartlin was too robotic and one-dimensional, even for the type of character he was playing. He and Coffee don't always seem at ease together and the writers overdo it with trying to make him too perfect (hence what was meant by one-dimensional). The supporting cast are not very memorable, while Gabrielle Dennis tries too hard in her role. The chemistry between the lead actors didn't seem natural, well developed or with much spark, pretty bland, while the characters are basically standard cliches with not much to them and don't feel real.

Didn't think that the script was good either. The more comedic elements were pretty cheesy and lack any kind of freshness, as well as feeling very strained. The drama lacks momentum and tends to be too mawkish. All the different elements in the script and story don't work individually and completely fail to gel together, parts being too jokey and others being over-serious. Add to that inane dialogue, no spark let alone charm, warmth or heart, emotional coldness, quite cheap production values that never look authentic (apart from some of the scenery, the editing is especially shoddy) and contrivance galore and you have a film that really does not work on most levels.

Concluding, weak. 3/10

Holly's Holiday(alternatively A Perfect Christmas) is a 2011 romantic fantasy starring Claire Coffee and Ryan McPartlin. Directed by Jim Fall the story follows a Marketing Executive named Holly who wants to find the perfect man,but sadly she is finding it hard to find Mr Right. Everyday she stops at a window mall to see a male mannequin that she admires. Strange events happen and the mannequin comes to life(think of Mannequin meets that other Mannequin made for TV film with the sculpture artist who wishes for her work of art to come alive and it does). Now Holly must choose between the hunky mannequin or the guy at work ?.

Silly and predictable.

This movie is about a woman who dates a storefront mannequin come to life. If that premise doesn't intrigue you, then you will not like it. The people are pretty and I just went with it.