My Grown-Up Christmas List

The movie was good and thought it was cute. The military aspect as way off though. The hair was too long, lapel rifles crooked, etc. If they're going to use the military in a story line at least make sure things look more put together.

This is a prime example of how Hallmark re-hashes the same old plot lines in some of their new Christmas movies.

There's really nothing here that you haven't seen done before, but the saving grace is that it is so well acted by the cast, particularly the leads. Kayla Wallace and Kevin McGarry are very good as a woman who has lost her Christmas spirit and the military man she becomes involved with. Together, they elevate the script so much so that you can't help being entertained by this endearing, yet often told, story. Plus, it really is winter - there is no fake snow here so the cinematography is very attractive at times. It looks and feels real. All in all, it's worth watching.

My husband proudly served in the United States Army and we are a patriotic family. I really enjoyed, "My Grown-up Christmas List." In fact, it's in my top two movies so far this season. I looked past the errors made regarding military protocol because the storyline, acting and chemistry made me happy. I also like that it was filmed in the winter, so the weather wasn't faked. The times of separation between Taylor and Luke got to me as well. We appreciate that our military was honored by the characters and always watch the Hallmark movies that do so. I'd love to see more with Kevin and Kayla. They have great chemistry and make a wonderful couple.

7.1 stars.

There is a great chemistry between these two actors, but they did not get to explore it enough. The romantic scenes were very nice, and actually quite realistic, they didn't waste any time setting up his laid back flirtations and her reciprocations. She made the first real move to hold his hand, and soon they are proclaiming their love for each other. He goes oversees, now the second year in a row they are apart.

It's a long distance romance movie, and while the acting was expertly done, the script didn't leave us any room to enjoy a real romantic relationship. It's way too much anticipation, and hoping they will be together at long last, and not getting to realize it for the potentially great love story it might have been.

I know he's a heartthrob, I've seen him in various films. She is new for me, but she's absolutely adorable.

She seems a bit juvenile and reticent at first, but skillfully matures in the relationship. I was impressed by her adaptability.

Also there is a strange pacing to it, the romantic gestures happen so quickly and naturally, yet the rest of the events move in slow motion. What happened to the Christmas spirit and the Charles Dickens angles? They seemed to fade away.

It appears an unorthodox formula was used in this film, which I have to admit I somewhat enjoyed even though it was difficult at times to relate to the inevitable interpretation of a splintered story.

Sweet movie, but lacking in more story, and the biggest problem was definitely the military issues. As my husband said, "If this was a drinking game to drink whenever you find an error, you'd be on the floor before the movie was done." He was in the Army & Air Force for 20 years, and is a military history aficionado. Even I noticed that there was too much long hair and facial hair for any of the US military. My husband noticed too many points to mention, (or completely understand) including all of the military vehicles with civilian plates. Please hire someone to get these things correct! My husband, along with several other US Vets are available!