Episode list

They discuss the famed East Area Rapist cases from the 70s.

Daryn and John continue with Part 2 of their discussion surrounding the East Area Rapist.

A teenager was murdered by her BFFs and John has a weird connection to the case.

John and Daryn discuss the "Talhotblond" catfish case which ends with a twist no one saw coming.

John and Daryn discuss the unsolved Keddie Cabin Murders which took place in Keddie, California in 1981.

John and Daryn discuss the case of Christine Paolilla, who was convicted of murdering her former best friends.

John and Daryn discuss the cold case of Kristin Smart, a beautiful college student who left a party one night and was never seen again.

John and Daryn reveal some interesting new details about the case of missing person Kristin Smart, including a truly bizarre connection to none other than Scott Peterson.

Pamela Smart was a school teacher who had an affair with one of her 15-year-old students. John and Daryn discuss the affair and how Pamela's marriage ended in murder.

Did Rachel Wade plan to kill Sarah Ludemann or was it an act of self defense? John and Daryn try to get to the bottom of this messy, murderous love triangle.

A man walked into a bank wearing a collar bomb, demanded money, and blew up moments later. John and Daryn discuss Marjorie Diehl-Armstrong's disturbing connection to the murder.

John chats with Co-Executive Producer and Narrator of Snapped Sharon Martin, about her experience living and working in the true crime genre for over 15 years. Plus, what is the one thing that almost all murderers have in common?

The Highway of Tears is a stretch of land in Canada where up to 40 women have mysteriously disappeared or have been murdered since 1969. John and Daryn highlight some of the victims and speculate on what could be causing this disturbing trend to continue.

Was it the daughter or her boyfriend? We may never know entirely. This week, John and Daryn talk about the case of Courtney Christine Schulhoff and her murdered father.

Isabelle Pedroza was a mom looking out for her daughter Linda's dangerous relationship. How did things escalate to murder so quickly?John and Daryn chat with professional counselor and author Raychelle Cassada Lohmann about the warning signs of troubled children.

John and Daryn take a week off from murders but rehash the murder of Skylar Neese.

Suzan and Michael Carson lived in San Francisco in the 70s and made it their mission to kill witches (among other things). John and Daryn discuss the tragic cases and theorize the couple's true motives.

Some fantasies go too far in the "Toy Box" as it's aptly called. From BDSM to murder, John and Daryn discuss the "Toy Box Killer" David Parker Ray.

Could Scott Peterson actually be innocent? John and Daryn discuss the famous case of Scott Peterson and the murder of his wife and unborn child.

Part 2 of the Scott Peterson conversation. Could he be innocent of killing his wife and newborn child?

Something didn't seem right about the way Sherri Rasmussen ended up dead in her own home. John and Daryn discuss the details and ultimate reveal of this unsettling cold case.

Live from Crime Con 2017 in Indianapolis, Indiana. John met up with many Martinis and Murder fans and even sat down with Nancy Grace, Kelly Siegler and Aphrodite Jones.

John and Daryn dive in to the murders of The Green River Killer. At the time, The Green River Killer was responsible for the largest number of serial killings in U.S. history.

Over the span of decades The Grim Sleeper managed to murder dozens and dozens of victims. John and Daryn explore this truly grisly and shocking case.

She was just supposed to be his Spanish tutor, but things took an unexpected turn for the worse. John and Daryn head to Mexico in this week's chilling case that involves a twist no one saw coming.

There was a blood stain in the back of the car. But there's no body to be found. John and Daryn try to figure out this very bizarre case with yet another verdict that left them speechless.

A group of high school students with interests in gothic clowns find themselves in the middle of a murder on this week. John and Daryn discuss the disturbing details. John gets attacked mid-podcast by Matt and isn't sure what to do next.

Thanks to an unknown caller for calling the Martinis and Murder hotline to give this week's case suggestion: The Kensington Strangler, from the Philadelphia, Pennsylvania area. John and Daryn discuss the gruesome details, but it turns out it's Matt who has a connection to the case this week.

When a woman's husband is gone for work, she finds companionship elsewhere. John and Daryn discuss a murder with a motive rooted in money.

When a young man's father, mother and sister end up dead in their own home, investigators start to track his every move. John and Daryn discuss what could have led to such a gruesome crime scene.

John and Daryn recap the horrific story that gripped the nation in 2005. The show also features snippets from an upcoming interview with Jessica Caiola, a friend of Natalee's who was on the trip with her in Aruba.

John and Daryn sit down with Dave Holloway, the father of missing teenager Natalee Holloway. Joining Dave Holloway is Private Investigator T.J. Ward who has been on the case with the Holloways since Natalee's disappearance in 2005.

A lesbian love triangle turns deadly when one woman disappears and police look to the other two for answers. John looks to Daryn to use her experience being a lesbian to help understand this mysterious murder.

A group of high school students with interests in gothic clowns find themselves in the middle of a murder. John and Daryn discuss the disturbing details. John gets attacked mid-podcast by Matt and isn't sure what to do next.

When a father ends up dead in a time and place that seems unusual, investigators begin questioning the family. John and Daryn discuss the mystery behind the death of John Parker.

Who took Johnny? That's the question on peoples' minds for the last several decades. John and Daryn discuss the case of missing boy Johnny Gosch and speak to the director of the documentary "Who Took Johnny?" David Beilinson.

Who Took Johnny? discussion continues with this bonus episode featuring former FBI prosecutor and co-host of the true crime podcast Best Case Worst Case, Francey Hakes. Francey's experience included running around the White House for briefings surrounding the horrible realities of child exploitation. John and Daryn have a very interesting conversation about human trafficking and ask Francey her thoughts about the Johnny Gosch case.

Maura Murray vanished in February of 2004 without a trace. Some people think she may still be alive. John and Daryn sit down to talk to Maura Murray experts Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna from the Missing Maura Murray podcast.

It follows The Menendez Brothers case as it was highly requested by Martinis and Murder fans.

Live from Carolines on Broadway in New York City.

This week we take on one of the most popular murder cases of the last decade: Jodi Arias.

This week it's Part 2 of the notoriously disturbing Jodi Arias case.

It focus on some of the craziest and creepiest stories about Exorcisms, Alien Abductions and Reincarnation just in time for Halloween.

John and Daryn discuss one of the most famous disappearance cases of all time: Madeleine McCann: A little girl who vanished while on vacation with her parents and siblings. Featuring an interview with Marissa Jones, host of The Vanished Podcast.

John and Daryn discuss one of the United States' most notorious serial killers, Jeffrey Dahmer.

A local homecoming queen becomes the epicenter of one of the most gruesome murders to hit her small town. John and Daryn discuss the disturbing details.

John and Daryn detail the events leading up to JFK's assassination, the devastating event itself, and the many conspiracy theories surrounding the tragedy.

John and Daryn discuss the case of Clara Jean Schwartz, whose father was found murdered and whose gaming companions were all suspects.

A man dressed as Santa Claus shows up at the door of a Christmas Eve party with the wrong kind of gifts.

Daryn and John discuss the infamous BTK murders, and the downfall of the serial killer.