Aliens of London

Finally the first real indication in any Doctor Who that a companion's disappearance can have an impact on people's lives, their friends and families. Camille Coduri was genius casting as Rose's mum, her upset at Rose's unexplained year long absence is great, she was such an endearing character. Mickey is also much better in this one, he's seemingly been under suspicion for murdering Rose due to her absence. There are some real goodies in this one, the Bad Wolf theme is now ringing alarm bells as it's quite prevalent. We hear the Doctor call Micky 'Ricky,' Jackie's sideboard looks like it's full of tonics of some sort, both themes are picked up later on. We get the first new series appearance of UNIT and a first appearance of Toshiko. We get the usual BBC NEWS 24 updates (what happened to those, I used to love a news update.) Aliens of London is big and fun, from the Spaceships falling through London destroying Big Ben, the Slitheen themselves and the glorious performance of Penelope Wilton as Harriet Jones. It is hard not to watch this without a smile on your face, it's not iconic but it's fun. I understand the farting cabinet will irritate some of the die hard fans, but humour can be great when it's combined with a dark element, had this been a darker more sinister episode it would have worked a lot better, as it stood, it was a bit too light. Finally we get a Doctor Who cliffhanger and it's a good one, with multiple characters in danger, the Next week clip gave too much away though.

A first two part story of the newly resurrected show begins with the episode Aliens of London and concludes with World War Three.

The first part features an alien spacecraft crashing into Big Ben in a very well done effects scene. It turns out alien race the Slitheen have a dastardly plot which involves them gaining access to the Prime Minister and senior officials and inhabiting their bodies. The Doctor goes to Downing Street with Rose where UNIT and world scientists are gathering in the Slitheen's trap. He then has to battle the Slitheen to stop their plan. Backbench MP Harriet Jones (Penelope Wilton) helps them out. Wilton is a great actress and is fabulous in her role as Harriet Jones who went on to appear in later stories with the 10th Doctor. There are lots of other positives too and this is a fun adventure overall but there are flaws which detract from its quality.

There is a cheesiness to some of this production and some silly humour involving Slitheen making farting sounds as they struggle to remain hidden inside smaller human bodies. Those aspects do not make it bad in my opinion and indeed I am sure that a new generation of fans found it amusing but from my point of view as an older fan I couldn't help thinking that if this had been a darker story with Slitheen as a fully menacing and scary alien it could have been a better story. I personally wished the farting aspect wasn't used and that the humour had been restricted to the witty aspects with banter between Rose and the Doctor and Harriet Jones. I feel maybe pressures were felt to not be too dark and scary and maybe trying to make it kid friendly. In fact, many kids love to be scared and to have some dark edge to their entertainment. It is people judging what is 'good for kids' who have pressured Doctor Who makers to soften the content throughout the show's history. In this case they definitely softened the story for a family audience but Russell T Daves is clever enough not to take that too far and he still provides plenty of scary scenes as Slitheen reveal themselves and chase and kill people. So overall whilst this isn't a favourite of mine it is good fun for all the family.

My rating for both episodes: 7/10.

One for the kids, as in to have them laugh and also scare them more than any other episode of the New Who. A little to extreme at both ends of the spectrum for my taste. Too much switching from scary to childish in one episode.

Still worth the 7 stars

This episode was fantastic as it featured the dynamic between the main cast. It was the first episode to do that in the Revival and I appreciated it for that. It made it feel fun and fresh. And the new location was a fun watch. The satire and the political drama works well, no The Slitheen aren't really threatening or loosely threatening. But the episode hinders on the perfect dynamic and the action.

Mickey and Rose have more to work with together and feel more compatabile and Rose feels more like a human trying to live her life.

The constant jokes are fun but the episode has Eccleston at his A Game. I enjoyed his performance particularly in this episode because his mugging and his relationship goes further and deeper.

And I enjoy the story for making us go more political as it ends with a Banger. I get the hate, really I do. But for me this was a fun and well explored episode of differences, relationships and class. So for Development and more realism, it works a treat. And the cliffhanger was an immense send off.

Confusion reigns as the Doctor delivers Rose back a year later than expected, but bewilderment soon subsides, as an alien pilot more traditionally found in pies, charts a peculiar path from distant far-flung skies. In tandem, the Prime Minister seems to disappear and the Time Lord's excitement soon turns into fear, as the true culprits let rip with a sound you can hear, while presenting without any noticeable ear - they are aliens after all, although not having ears is the least of our concern considering their more noticeable features and characteristics - and the running CGI for that matter.