Shin akai misshitsu (heya): Kowareta ningyô-tachi

How anyone tries to justify the enjoyment in watching a film like this is beyond my realm of comprehension.

It's just an exercise in showing how much visual degradation it takes to make a video for the depraved. It's not a horror movie,, it's not even a thriller . There is no fun to be had here, only senseless acts thrown together.

The only reason I saw it was that I ran across this bit of dribble at a horror-movie website . It just gives horror movies a bad name.

While the producers have every right to film such a piece of crap ( I oppose censorship).., I have every right to call it what it is.. degrading trash. And I'm so glad I'm in the majority of those who feel the same.

After the disappointment of part 1 it was time to correct the failures made. Indeed, there is more blood involved than the first part and it even gets a bit weird by pulling out a fetus from the womb while fisting a girl. Yes, you read it right, gore galore but but, there is something really wrong with it. There is of course some nudity involved but again, Eastern culture knowing it is forbidden to show private parts so we only see a man cum on a girls face and we see some suggesting that a man is putting his fingers and later his fist into a girls vagina with the well known result. So far so good. The movie clocks in 13 minutes longer than part 1, but it's more blah blah so they could have cut it there. But the let down is the part when we get to know who one of the girls really is. Sadly that isn't really realistic. To conclude, rougher than part one put a stupid plot.

i have just seen this movie and it was hilarious! i was kinda scared to watch it as i have read so much about it in advance, but this thing is not scary or disturbing AT ALL. there are a lot of drastic and disgusting IDEAS that this movie is based on and if someone would read the actual script or a short novel based on this script it would be disturbing as hell.

the thing that turns this film from a Japanese shock movie is the lack of budget combined with really terrible sound and special FX. i don't know what intention the director had with this movie, but it is for sure not scary or shocking. there is no second while watching that you forget that this is all "just a movie". none of the fx are believable and the over-the-top sound FX turn this into pure dark humor. intentionally or not.

the basic idea of the story when put into the right hands with the right budget and writers would make one hell of a scary movie. give this thing to the crew of "saw 1" and you would fear for your life while watching this at your local cinema.

as much as the final result made me laugh at some points, apart from the brilliant basic ideas, there are some events happening that you just won't believe happening. as ridiculous as those were and as much as i chuckled about them they were surprising as hell and there would not have been any chance in the world that anybody could have predicted them.

there are some things that are so ridiculous that you can only describe them as surreal. i have seen directors try to get away with really really unbelievable stuff, but this tops it all. this is so ridiculous that it becomes brilliant.

confused? watch it. i can't describe it any better. i don't think anybody can.

"Red Room 2" is a continuation of the same theme from "Red Room" albeit with new players.Again there are some truly twisted scenes of sadism,gore and sexual violence for example a guy gets his nasal passages scrubbed with a toothbrush for minutes on end until blood erupts everywhere or in a truly repulsive scene a guy who is fisting one of the females in the cage feels something inside her.He grabs hold and pulls with all his strength,wrenching a three inch long fetus and yards of umbilical chord!So if you liked "Red Room" you won't be disappointed with this piece of nihilism.I still think that Daisuke Yamanouchi's "Mu Zan E" is a much better film.Give it a look as well.

After Red Room 1, the director clearly thought that he hadn't repulsed enough people or gone over the line enough. There were still boundaries to be tampered with and unchartered taboos to explore.

Cue Red Room 2, a rather sick experiment in just how far cinema can go before losing all of its artistic merit and becoming purely an experiment in how thoroughly we can sicken ourselves. Unfortunately all our 'loved' characters bar one from the last installment are next to dead, so we're now presented with four fresh hopefuls.

The drill is exactly the same as the last film - four contenders sit in a room and draw cards. The outcome of the draws decides who will receive a certain 'punishment' as part of the game, who will administer it, who will just watch, and who will decide what it is. The one left alive at the end of all the rounds wins the game. The punishments themselves are all the more intense and immoral than in Red Room 1, involving toothbrushes, hammers, a bowl of vomit [which looks too much like porridge] and one particular scene involving a pregnant girl which is totally over the mark.

The only problem with this film is that it tries so hard to shock its audience that it's very easy to see it for exactly what it is, an exercise in violence and bad taste, so labeling it as 'horror' is giving it too much credit. As well as this, the budget is so obviously low and the effects so unconvincing that we are more sickened by the concepts of the actions taking place than by their physical representations, which at times are laughably fake. Still, the only reason anyone would watch this film is out of some form of twisted curiosity. It nevertheless succeeds in what it sets out to do - to thoughtlessly repulse and to sicken - making it a totally shallow and merit less piece of filming, although it doesn't pretend to be anything else.