Brooklyn Babylon

First of all, I'd like to reply to one of the reviewers (Kastellos) who dismisses hip-hop music as cheap and says that hip-hop artists become successful only on luck. Well, I'd like to inform him/her that The Roots are one of the most revered bands not only in the hip-hop world, but internationally, since they blend soul, hip-hop, rhythm'n'blues; their songs have been used for the soundtrack of dozens of movies and one of them topped the charts in 2002.

The Roots are a solid band, and it shows right from the beginning of the movie, when they perform one of the best songs of the soundtrack, a track a lot more mature and layered than your "average" hip-hop track.

I borrowed the DVD from the library mainly because of the soundtrack, and I have to admit it's what saves an altogether messy movie.

The actors are barely beyond amateurish, Karen Starc is very pretty but she definitely needs more acting lessons, like most of the cast (with the exception of Bonz Malone and David Vadim).

The story of the clash between black and Jewish communities could have been told much better with a better script and cast. Some "documentary" takes give a flavor of reality, but the movie falls in many ways.

All in all, a mediocre movie saved by a great soundtrack.

I saw this last nite and while I enjoyed many of the performances and certain scenes I was left with nothing after I left the theatre.

The whole movie was contrived and did not offer any solution or direction towards resolving the plot. The beginning fools you into believing the movie takes place in 1991 but according to Marc Levin, who spoke after the show alongside tariq trotter, the movie takes place in the present.

I think Levin has no idea what he's doing. Give me that $4 million budget and I will bring a masterpiece the theatre.

On a lot of levels this movies comes after several other films that belong in the same genre...do the right thing, save the last dance, romeo and juliet...etcetera...but all films take from other films and all are designed to showcase something new against something familiar...for me it was the fact there is such a tension in the city...and how against such a huge mess, ppl still have unique and personal problems to solve.... I also though this film was very well shot, i loved the way they used the pull focus technique throughout and let the camera get intimate with the characters during the scenes... I loved the music and thought that was brilliant how it showcased their talents without it being a "concert movie" good rental, would recommend it... agreed, that I would like to see the lead actors in a more demanding story...

:In the troubled neighborhood of Crown Heights in the Borough of Churches, a sheltered Jewish Girl -- Karen Starc -- and a Black rapper -- Tariq Trotter -- fall in love.

Despite some issues with the location shooting -- one sequence shot in the subway shows one of the Canal Street stations as clean as my grandmother's kitchen after the pre-Passover cleaning -- it's a lovely modernized version of the Romeo & Juliet story, with many references to Solomon and the Queen of Sheba; indeed, Trotter's character is named Solomon. There's a nice sociological undertone of each culture struggling to maintain its identity that plays nicely into the story, with Trotter's efforts to come to some understanding of the deep love he feels for the lady, and Miss Starc trying to calm her hot-headed relative, played by David Vadim.

I agree with the last reviewer that the best thing about this film is the fact that it features DA ROOOOOOTS!!! Tariq "Black Thought" Trotter stars as an up and coming MC of an organic hip hop band.... basically he does a fine job playing a character based on himself. Karen Goberman is also good as the female lead, although their relationship isn't very well written, which holds true for the writing as a whole. Everything about the film except for the performances feels contrived.... their relationship, the tension between the Black and Jewish communities that it's set against (even with the understanding that these tensions are very real). I'd like to see Tariq and The Roots working on other films.... hopefully next time they'll have a better script to work with.