John Henry

This is another amazing animation from Disney. The unfinished look the cartoon has is very appealing, and the character design is very Disney. John Henry is a man who was once a slave, until the Emancipation Proclamation freed him and his love, who immediately get married. They go to strike it out and John Henry famously works on the railroad to get his wife and himself some land so they can be independent.

The short is fairly emotional and tackles some heavier themes for Disney (slavery, death), but does it nicely, in such a way that I could see young children be able to watch it without a qualm from parents. The music is very flavorful, being in the style of black gospel singers or backup singers. I could listen to this music for a while and not get tired of it. It's nice and fun for the kiddies to see, with some good messages about determination.

A late addition to the Disney folklore shorts, this short film more than holds its own. The slightly-unfinished style helps it feel right at home with the earlier films and also establishes a legendary aura to the story. You almost sense you are watching an animated story book. Early images of a woman quilting even hint that this is meant to be seen like a story told through quilted squares. Vocal performances are great and the addition of new characters builds a deeper sense of emotional connection to the old legend. The real strength comes from the music. True to the legends of John Henry, singing saturates and propels the story forward. Strong, Gospel-style numbers lift the film above a standard children's feature to something truly moving. The well-known conclusion hits all-the harder as a result. I watched this countless times growing up and now my kids love it too.

Considering this was just a project to keep animators occupied, it is a pretty darn impressive film. Disney's take on the tall tale is nothing new, but the style and look of this short is fantastic. The characters were made to look like animation before "clean-up" which is very interesting to watch, and also a brave move on Disney's part! Great backgrounds, too. Let's hope the Mouse takes more chances like this one!

The traditional story of John Henry is brought to life in this very unusual Disney short. I like some of the unusual qualities...one in particular I didn't. The quilt-like look and colors were great--and really eye-catching. I also liked the nice spiritual style of the music which dominates the film. What I wasn't so fond of was the unfinished look that the animators deliberately used--with pencil marks appearing and disappearing throughout the film--like they forgot to erase them. Stylish? Perhaps...but I thought it made an otherwise good film look unfinished. As for the story, it's pretty much the familiar folk tale--about an ex-slave named John Henry who does battle against a steam-powered machine and wins...at a big cost. Worth seeing but it just missed the mark.

I read about this film being made and that it would be released to theaters to play in front of Disney films released during the year. Well I never did see it and had forgotten about it when I saw that it would be included on a special DVD with several of the other Disney Tall Tale classics, Paul Bunyan, Johnny Appleseed and Casey Jones.

John Henry is an excellent short and it deserves a much higher rating. As mentioned the animation is made to look unfinished and rough. This only adds to the charm of the film. The music is also outstanding and the story is touching. I hope more people will check out John Henry as well as the other shorts on the DVD.