Hidden City

What a strange movie. The story is amazingly thought-provoking and intriguing. Think of all the hidden secrets a city like London hides beneath it's surface? All the archives of wartime experiments, government mysteries, documents and information never meant for public eye.

You have a young woman trying to convince a statistician (?) played by Charles Dance that there are hidden messages or clues of a bigger picture in some wartime archive films.

The story sadly never quite uses all of it's potential. It's interesting all the way, but you're never really sure what is going on until the very end and the motivations of the characters are left a bit unknown. They're basically just intrigued and driven by pure interest rather than a real cause.

What makes the movie a bit messy and difficult to follow, is the fact that there are a few separate leads they're following, the archived films and a few documents they find at a waste dump. You also have people trying to catch them, but you're not really sure why. At least I was left a bit puzzled of what's going on at times, but maybe that was the point. You never know what you find, if you just look carefully.

Definitely an interesting story, but the execution is a bit flawed and dated. It's got a very strong late 80s vibe to it and it's a bit of an artsy one. Someone might call this a "strange one", but definitely worthwhile if you catch it somewhere.

Of all Poliakoff's work on film, this is probably the most underrated and often missed , and is one of his two best works from the 1980s.

This is an interesting and thoughtful look at the workings of one aspect of modern government, which was well-received at the time and premiered at the Venice festival, but has become criminally and unjustly difficult to find. A proper DVD reissue is long overdue here.Charles Dance produces a typically strong performance with direction, performances and casting all solid ; this was a part of the important Film on Four strand that helped keep British cinema alive during some of its lowest points of the 1980s.

Hidden city is a film that I really wanted to like after reading the plot synopsis on the back of the Blu-ray cover. In many ways, I did like it; the plot was somewhat unique and interesting; the hidden locations in London really did spark a sense of wonder and imagination; and the main character is a reasonable educated individual which keeps the movie grounded. Some of the scenes were a little eerie in fact. I found the journey itself to be quaint, but a tad unrealistic in terms of character interactions. These quirks can be be more appreciated in older films like this one.

Sadly, the lead actress struggles to deliver her lines organically, it feels as though she's reading a script at times- memorised lines. That pulls the viewer out of the story. There is some general overacting with some of the side characters as well, but given the right atmosphere, this can be forgiven and I feel that Hidden City certainly has that atmosphere.

However, as is typical of an edgy 80s movie, there are unnecessary scenes and elements added which only take away from the storyline. Prolonged snogging scenes up close, lengthy moaning in the background of an office, some brief rear nudity on the TV screens in a party, and frontal nudity in one scene - all took this from a family appropriate mind-opening movie inspiring curiosity, to an awkward watch meant for a specific type of audience that I certainly am not. Were not for these moments, the film actually would have been one of my favourite films, despite all its other flaws.

The BFI Blu-ray looked good, albeit quite grainy, but as usual that only adds to the experience of this 80s film. BFI made the brilliant decision of adding old archive footage of London as special features to this disc, which I found thoroughly fascinating. It was as if I were experiencing a time capsule and it really matched the essence of the film. I can't think of other types of films that would be as appropriate to include the special content on than this one - which is all about exploration of undiscovered secret archives of London. Having these extras makes you feel like you are part of the preservation of London's history.

I only watched this picture because of my current obsession with Charles Dance. It's a very strange film, rather too artsy and noir for my taste, but in general a pretty good picture.

A few items: far too much is made of the "hidden city" component. Any older city has subterranean tunnels and chambers. Disused subways, dry drains, utility shafts and connectors, power cable channels, catacombs, and sewage pipes form a veritable honeycomb beneath a city's surface. Not secret so much as not relevant to the daily life of ordinary people. That these areas might be useful for file storage is sensible and efficient.

The more intriguing mystery for me was why the writers writers (who otherwise did an excellent job) failed to give us explanations to these questions:

Why would an intelligent, sophisticated, educated man disregard several days' worth of scheduled meetings in order to assist a complete stranger in an ill-defined quest for information of questionable value?

Why, having learned the mysterious government secret, do the pair do absolutely nothing with what they've learned? It's implausible that anybody would go to so much trouble merely to satisfy idle curiosity.

And finally, why do the pair decide to continue rummaging for secrets?

On the plus side, "Hidden City" does include a very excellent performance by Charles Dance. I think that one of the more difficult challenges for an actor is speaking lines that convey information the audience needs but would never be uttered in real-life conversation. The film contains an astonishingly large number of such lines, and Dance delivered them so naturally that only when I'd finished watching did I realize. In fact, I can't think of a better example of that sort of acting. Well done, Charles Dance!

This film is a such a unique gem. Anchored by two amazing main characters, with so many differences between them, and there are also so many side characters introduced, and every single one of them is likeable, interesting and believable. So many shots and scenes that give you the idea that this was a tremendous production. The opening scene through the water tunnels is mesmerizing.

The back and forth dramatic dialogue between the two protagonists is something you don't get much anymore. There are so many lines that consist of something you may have never heard of. This film rewards itself for having the magical combination of an ambitious and creative filmmaker, talented actors and a unique and thoroughly interesting script. Not only that but it takes place in some incredible locations.

This is a vibrant film, obviously the masterpiece of a painstaking and meticulous production. This film will show you parts of London many people have likely never seen. Kudos to Stephen Poliakoff. It is highly recommended to watch this with his commentary on the Blu-ray release.

The film is not without faults. I got the feeling that there was sometimes too much music. In some scenes, the music was perfect and elevated the moment to new heights. In other scenes, I wanted to plug my ears and enjoy the fantastic cinematography. Many of the best scenes are also the quietest and I think that says something. Quite possibly it could have been elevated to greater stardom if the music had just let the scenes breathe. This film will test your patience if what you're after is the mystery itself and not the journey. In this film you should be patient and enjoy the ride if you want to appreciate it more.

At times you might think the film takes itself a little too seriously. But if you keep watching you'll realize that they should indeed be taken seriously.