La grande évasion 2 - L'histoire enfin révélée

After watching this film I am waiting for a remake of Waterloo showing how the Americans beat Napoleon. That is just as fanciful as this ridiculous film. There is no attempt at vermisilitude..It goes beyond embarassment and an insult to the brave men who were murdered.

Bad acting and even worse story line. Where did all the American come from ???. The American had nothing to do with the Great Escape and definitely nothing to do with the investigation at the end of the war. Then when did Hollywood ever let the truth get in the way of a (not so) good story.

The issue with this "true story" is that it was a made for America TV film, as a follow up to a cinema film that had already been twisted to add an American interest. By the time you get to the stage of this film it's very difficult to make for an audience who will have very little connection to the real story - i.e. that 76 predominantly European or Commonwealth service men escaped from a PoW camp, 73 were re-captured and under direct orders from Hitler 50 were executed in ones and twos by SS and Gestapo henchmen.

The film itself, if it didn't have the silly "untold story" tag, would be passable TV fare. The investigation, the depiction of the nature of the murders (i.e. individuals rather than the 50 in a field as per the original) are realistic whilst not necessarily being true. The fact it plays loose with who did the investigating and what actually happened is only an issue if you are looking for the true story.

If you're looking for a film about war crimes and investigating them, then as TV movies go this is OK. If you're looking for the real "untold story" then don't believe everything you see in this production.

Beautifully restored by Arrow as part of their new release of John Sturges' masterpiece, The Great Escape II is a very high-profile made-for-TV film that isn't so much a sequel but more of a re-adaptation of the same book the 1963 film was based on and, you know what... it's an underrated little gem. While the first half of the film recounts and condenses much of the climactic events of the original before going off on a parallel tangent, it's the second half where things take a drastically different turn. Directed by Paul Wendkos and Jud Taylor, who played Goff in the original film, the film isn't without style, it genuinely took me by surprise given so much of the film looks rather remarkable, especially the stuff shot by Wendoks in Yugoslavia standing in for the German/Switz countryside. For an NBC TV movie, it's a great deal more brutal in parts than expected, it certainly gets away with a lot for its production. Johnny Mandel's music isn't great but does the job well for the parts that are scored, it lacks a lot of memorable sequences. Where this film really shines is in its performances, especially from the always-fantastic Christopher Reeve alongside Tony Denison and Judd Hirsch, Ian McShane also gets a beefy supporting role and a returning Donald Pleasence even crops up for a while. Granted things go a bit awry in the second half where Screenwriter Walter Davis seemingly shifts the scene to after the war, when Reeve and Denison hunt the war criminals who murdered 50 fellow escapees but it is done with such class and conviction from its cast the clichéd aspects of its writing are more than forgiven. Yes, the film may be a bit predictable and ponderous but if you look at the half that's full rather than the half that's empty, The Great Escape II isn't half-bad.

After one large movie and this made-for-TV version, why can't someone stop messing around with the true story of the "Great Escape" and present it as it actually happened. The ending also fails to make clear that there were 2 UK-mounted war crimes trials of the murderers of the 50 escapees. Also Burchardt in real life was sentenced to death by hanging at the 2nd trial, but was reprieved. There are loads of other changes from the real events, but then Hollywood and the film industry has rarely cared about accuracy.