Marie: justice criminelle

Uninteresting vehicle for Sissy Spacek, an adaptation of the book "Marie: A True Story" by Peter Maas (the biographer of Frank Serpico), concerns divorced single mother Marie Ragghianti, who was fired from her job as chairman of the Tennessee Board of Pardons and Paroles in 1977 after refusing to release certain convicts (all rotten and threatening for effect) whose pardons were the result of bribes going back to the governor (similarly rotten). Ragghianti sees the corruption, understands its origins, and is tempted to go along with it for the sake of her job, but eventually has to take a stand for justice. Sally Field's Oscar-winning performance in 1979's "Norma Rae" provided a much-needed boost for actresses looking for substantial roles in 1980s cinema; however, by 1985, audiences had cooled on female stars such as Spacek, Field, Jessica Lange and Meryl Streep all taking noble stances on-screen for the sake of audience empathy (and prestige). Nothing in "Marie" rings true, not Spacek's relationships with her co-workers, her troubles with doctors over her sick son, nor her humble beginnings as an undereducated and abused housewife (the actor playing Spacek's bad-tempered husband looks about 10 years younger than the actress). The writing is vapid, Francis Lai's music is 'heart tugging' in the worst sense, and Roger Donaldson's direction is scattershot, with artificial details dotting the scenario. Fred Thompson plays himself as Marie's attorney, and is the only cast member to successfully overcome the phony dramatics. ** from ****

This movie is based on a true story, a story that is, in fact, much worse than is portrayed here.

The governor of Tennessee, Ray Blanton, must rank as the worst the state ever had and, as a son of Tennessee, let me tell you that is really saying something.

Not to spoil the movie, let me add that Bill Clinton ended his presidency much as did Blanton end his governorship. That fact is sort of hinted at by the movie, but Blanton's governorship was so rife with corruption, with members of his family and his friends and allies living and profiting at the expense of the taxpayers, one movie cannot do the story justice. It would take at least a miniseries to tell the whole tale.

This movie, though, makes a good stab at part of the story, the part played by the title character, Marie. Sissy Spacek does her usual good job as Marie, displaying not only her own mature beauty but an admirable emotional range as both the put-upon government employee and the concerned mother.

Fred Thompson ... well, there are not enough superlatives in my limited vocabulary to express all my admiration and respect for him. He is a fine actor, and he was one of the greatest U.S. senators ever to represent the usually misrepresented state of Tennessee. Certainly the two there now (2004) don't begin to be big enough to fill his shoes, nor do they remotely resemble him in moral stature, intelligence, or knowledge of the Constitution. Well, he is better off back in acting, but it is a serious loss to good government that Fred Thompson decided not to seek re-election.

I'm tempted to say, too, that any movie with John Cullum is a movie to see, if only to watch his scenes. What a superb actor, what a major talent he is. His big scene in "1776" just steals that movie, to name merely one.

Not to slight any other person in this excellent cast, but I have gone on long enough. They are excellent.

I will carp about three things: Some of the expository dialog was trite and silly, especially the character Kevin's last scene. The courtroom scene was missing something. I believe if I had been on the jury, I'd have voted differently simply because the evidence was not presented well enough. (One can understand Sen. Arlen Specter {more-or-less-R.- Pa.} and his "not proved" impeachment vote.)

And why was Bill Sanderson not cast in this? He is a marvelous actor, could probably have handled beautifully almost any role, and besides he is from Tennessee. And he is usually in Spacek's movies. Too bad, for us and for him.

Still, I'm glad I finally got to see "Marie." The story is important, and the movie is extremely well done.

One more quibble: A very well-known Edmund Burke quote is used several times, but in an odd paraphrase. Not inappropriate, but jarring because of the different phrasing. Never mind. This is a good movie, and I hope everyone sees it.

In case you've never heard of Marie Ragghianti, she escaped an abusive marriage and went to work for a firm, only to discover some unsavory things about it. In the movie "Marie", Sissy Spacek plays her as well as can be expected. However, I would agree with a previous reviewer that the movie sort of uses her as a conduit to tell the story, and otherwise seems incomplete.

But overall, they do a pretty good job showing how Marie was finally able to make something of herself, only to be faced with the dilemma of maintaining this position or blowing the whistle. Maybe not exactly a masterpiece, but certainly worth seeing. Also starring Jeff Daniels and Morgan Freeman.

Politics is a very dirty and corrupt business which is evident and clearly outlined in less than the two hours it took to watch this film. Sissy Spacek plays the real life victim and heroine Marie Fajardo Ragghianti, who after surviving and subsequently leaving an abusive husband with her three (3) young children in tow works hard, studies even harder to achieve a Master of Public Administration (M.P.A.) degree from the Harvard University John F. Kennedy School of Government in 1992. Like most novice civil servants who look for leadership from their superiors it did not take Marie too long to rise in the public ranks from 1997 through 1999, she worked as the chief of staff for the United States Parole Commission. Once in this prestigious position Marie realized that she was being duped and placed in her role to serve at the favor of a corrupt Tennessee Governor Ray Blanton.

When Marie started asking questions when her boss (who hired her) Eddie Sisk and Governor Ray Blanton insisted that she blindly approve a number of very dubious and questionable paroles of known and convicted criminals she spoke to the FBI. Marie was abruptly terminated under false accusations that she herself was acting fraudulently with her office expense account and drinking to excess.

After surviving an abusive husband, raising three (3) children on her own, one son with some very serious medical issues, completing her Masters degree, she decided to fight her firing in a civil suit. After winning her case, the perpetrators namely Eddie Sisk (her former boss) and the Governor of Tennessee Ray Blanton were found guilty of extravagant spending, mail fraud, taking bribes for approving liquor licenses and questions were raised about their role(s) in approving wrongful paroles of convicted felons and served prison time.

The movie itself is a period piece reflective of the 1980's corrupt politicians and blatant disregard for the rule of law and serving as a civil servant, except that Sissy Spacek who plays the victim and heroine Marie Fajardo Ragghianti, is someone we can all look up to and express our gratitude for agreeing to make this movie and shed a bright light on a few corrupt government officials.

The premise, good for a thriller, prevented mediocrity and made the movie effective, attention-grabbing, suspenseful and emotionally involving. The writing was vapid & murky, it bottomed out with the artificial details dotting the scenario, but the direction was vigorous and adequate, if scattershot. As to Sissy Spacek, she confirmed her proficiency to be also shown in Carrie - Prime Cut - Badlands - Coal Miners Daughter - Crimes of the Heart - Missing - Old Man & the Gun - - Affliction - Raggedy Man - Three Women - The River - In the Bedroom - An American Haunting - JFK - Castle Rock - and even Bloodline.