Churchill and the Generals

A Well-crafted presentation of Winston Churchill and the interrelationships between the generals and the Prime Minister. The acting is superb, the dialogue captivating, and the war film footage brings back memories of the horrors and deaths of so many fine men and women. If only the memories could stop the future carnage of people.

I think I saw this on BBC tv when it was first shown. I was late teens and although I was obsessed by World War 2 it was not an easy watch for a teenager.

Between 1980 and now I have studied history and collected a great collection of books and films about World War 2.

I finally got the dvd a while back and have watched it several times.

It is a great telling of an interesting and inspiring story. One would have to be an American or Jeremy Corbyn to underrate the role of Britain and the empire in world events 1939-1942.

If you don't know it was Britain v the axis from May 1940 until June 1941 (USSR attacked) then in December 1941 Pearl Harbor was attacked,America joined the war.

History is not made by great men alone but Churchill was vital to the whole story. This 3 hour drama documentary is dated of course but the history is solid and the acting by a well chosen cast is superb.

It tells the story of the first part of the world war 2,so it is not all about America.

This under-rated drama has a classic quality all of its own. It gives a superb insight into the complexities of Churchill as a man and a leader. It also provides an intriguing peek at both military and political thinking on both sides of the Atlantic during the Second World War.

Casting can only be described as brilliant. Not only were the leading characters played superbly by established and fine actors but most had a physical resemblance to the real people they played.

It was released in the States on VHS a long time ago, but currently someone has posted it all on You Tube.

If you are interested in understanding the War from a different perspective, do watch it.

Winston Churchill who rallied his nation and may very well have saved civilization by keeping the UK fighting against Nazism until the Soviet Union and the USA entered the war, had some serious flaws as a military strategist. There was only one way of beating Hitler, go right through the front door of Western Europe. Churchill however wanted to nibble at the sides, hence the Mediterranean campaign, the attempt to take Norway back.

The fear was understandable. Everyone on both sides in Europe feared the four year stalemate that was World War I with the trench warfare in France. Anything to avoid that again, so the British shied away from a cross channel invasion and a campaign in France.

Timothy West captures the mercurial part of Churchill's nature as well as the inspiring one. In his long career, Churchill was both First Lord of the Admiralty and Secretary of State for War, the former post he held twice. He was educated at Sandhurst though he left the army for politics, he fancied himself a military strategist.

This made for TV docudrama shows a Churchill who hired and fired generals in much the same manner that Abraham Lincoln did in the Civil War. But Lincoln was more result oriented, the Churchill we see here is someone who got rid of people basically because they didn't kiss up to him.

He got rid of generals like Wavell who defeated the Italians at Addis Ababa and Auchinleck who slowed the Nazi advance at the first battle of El Alamein for pretty much that reason. The man who replaced Auchinleck in North Africa, Bernard Montgomery took Auchinleck's battle plan and turned the Nazis at the second El Alamein.

After that, the direction of war planning came more and more from the American military. In fact one of the reasons I like Churchill and the Generals is it shows just how much different things were with FDR and his generals and Churchill and his. Roosevelt was smart enough to know when he was not in his element and he left strategic planning to George C. Marshall and Ernest J. King in the Navy. Next to West as Churchill, I liked Joseph Cotten as Marshall.

A great inspirational leader, but one who his generals wished had just confined himself to making speeches in Parliament.

I remember watching this on PBS. Great series, particularly for a US audience, where there is not much said about the war prior to 12/7/1941. Wavell and Auchinleck did a good job and kept the Nazis and Facists at bay until the US got into the war, but got little credit for it. No stirring war scenes, but the dramatic dialogue between Churchill, his generals is gripping stuff since the fate of the world is at stake. That it is the actual messages between them lend an immediacy and emotional edge to the exchanges. You feel for the Generals, especially Wavell, far from London, at the end of a unsure pipeline of support of all types, logistical, political and moral, trying to soldier on.