[go: up one dir, main page]

    Release CalendarTop 250 MoviesMost Popular MoviesBrowse Movies by GenreTop Box OfficeShowtimes & TicketsMovie NewsIndia Movie Spotlight
    What's on TV & StreamingTop 250 TV ShowsMost Popular TV ShowsBrowse TV Shows by GenreTV News
    What to WatchLatest TrailersIMDb OriginalsIMDb PicksIMDb SpotlightFamily Entertainment GuideIMDb Podcasts
    OscarsPride MonthAmerican Black Film FestivalSummer Watch GuideSTARmeter AwardsAwards CentralFestival CentralAll Events
    Born TodayMost Popular CelebsCelebrity News
    Help CenterContributor ZonePolls
For Industry Professionals
  • Language
  • Fully supported
  • English (United States)
    Partially supported
  • Français (Canada)
  • Français (France)
  • Deutsch (Deutschland)
  • हिंदी (भारत)
  • Italiano (Italia)
  • Português (Brasil)
  • Español (España)
  • Español (México)
Watchlist
Sign In
  • Fully supported
  • English (United States)
    Partially supported
  • Français (Canada)
  • Français (France)
  • Deutsch (Deutschland)
  • हिंदी (भारत)
  • Italiano (Italia)
  • Português (Brasil)
  • Español (España)
  • Español (México)
Use app
  • Cast & crew
  • User reviews
  • Trivia
IMDbPro

Un meurtre est un meurtre

  • 1972
  • 1h 43m
IMDb RATING
5.9/10
310
YOUR RATING
Un meurtre est un meurtre (1972)
CrimeDramaMystery

Murder mystery involving a man and his relationship with twin sisters.Murder mystery involving a man and his relationship with twin sisters.Murder mystery involving a man and his relationship with twin sisters.

  • Director
    • Etienne Périer
  • Writers
    • Dominique Fabre
    • Etienne Périer
  • Stars
    • Jean-Claude Brialy
    • Stéphane Audran
    • Robert Hossein
  • See production info at IMDbPro
  • IMDb RATING
    5.9/10
    310
    YOUR RATING
    • Director
      • Etienne Périer
    • Writers
      • Dominique Fabre
      • Etienne Périer
    • Stars
      • Jean-Claude Brialy
      • Stéphane Audran
      • Robert Hossein
    • 3User reviews
    • 2Critic reviews
  • See production info at IMDbPro
  • See production info at IMDbPro
  • Photos4

    View Poster
    View Poster
    View Poster
    View Poster

    Top cast17

    Edit
    Jean-Claude Brialy
    Jean-Claude Brialy
    • Paul Kastner
    Stéphane Audran
    Stéphane Audran
    • Marie Kastner…
    Robert Hossein
    Robert Hossein
    • Jean Carouse
    Michel Serrault
    Michel Serrault
    • Le commissaire Plouvier…
    Catherine Spaak
    Catherine Spaak
    • Françoise Noblet
    Michel Creton
    • Moureux le pharmacien
    Madeleine Damien
    Madeleine Damien
    • Une vieille dcommére
    Jeanne Pérez
    • Une vieille commére
    Isabelle Del Rio
      Antonia Lotito
      Philippe Lejour
      • L'employé de l'agence de voyages
      José Luccioni
      • le livreur de Carouse
      Paul Bisciglia
      Paul Bisciglia
      • L'employé de Kastner
      Marius Laurey
      Marius Laurey
      • Le dépanneur
      Pippo Merisi
      Olivier Hussenot
      Olivier Hussenot
      • Le notaire
      Claude Chabrol
      Claude Chabrol
      • Le contrôleur des wagons-lits…
      • Director
        • Etienne Périer
      • Writers
        • Dominique Fabre
        • Etienne Périer
      • All cast & crew
      • Production, box office & more at IMDbPro

      User reviews3

      5.9310
      1
      2
      3
      4
      5
      6
      7
      8
      9
      10

      Featured reviews

      6adrianovasconcelos

      Mediocre whodunnit thriller despite strong acting

      Belgian-born Etienne Perier is not a name that stands out among French cinema directors, and in UN MEURTRE EST UN MEURTRE (MURDER IS MURDER) he passes up on a good opportunity to do better, especially in view of the cast made available to him.

      Male lead Jean-Claude Brialy sadly has an accident with wealthy wife Stephane Audran who becomes wheel chair-ridden, and resentful of his ongoing affair with stunning clothes shop attendant Catherine Spaak. To cut a long story short, despite her paralysis, Audran is still able to drive her car but apparently forgets to use the hand brake and it slides down a slope and kills her as she goes down the middle of the road (none too careful, is she?)

      The real baffler to me is why Director Perier decided to show that sequence as the intro to the film, and he repeats it some 30 minutes later.

      That is when blackmailer Robert Hossein and police inspector Michel Serrault appear on screen, both delivering credible performances. For the record, both Brialy and Serrault would come out of the closet a few years later, and apparently had the hots for each other during this film. Spaak and Audran must have felt underused...

      The script by Dominique Fabre makes very economic use of logic. Why Audran should have a sister who wants to wear a wig like her and go around in a wheelchair like her is baffling to put it mildly. That, in addition, she should pick up a revolver and fire six shots into the night after police inspectors approach her place is only made more incredible by the fact that Hossein had just shown her how to use the gun because she had never fired a shot in her life!

      Toward the end, I did not know - and did not care - whether Audran was Marie or Anne any more. She was misused in the double role but at least Perier gave her the chance to show off her delicious legs as she ditches the wheelchair and shows Brialy and Spaak that she can walk.

      The ending, with Brialy and Spaak laughing as they shove the empty wheelchair down a street, and it poses a threat to potential oncoming drivers, is one of the stupidest I have ever seen.

      Effective cinematography by Marcel Grignon. 6/10.
      6boblipton

      Blackmailing A Man For A Murder He Didn't Commit

      Stéphane Audran has been in a wheelchair for years, since she and her husband, Jean-Claude Brialy were in an auto accident. Her disposition has, shall we say, soured over the years, and she orders Brialy's mistress, Catherine Spaak, to give him up. At home they get into an argument, and he locks her in; with the servants gone, he believes he will have a couple of days free. But she manages to get outside. Her wheelchair loses control, and she winds up dead. Inspector Michel Serrault clears him, and he can inherit his wife's enormous estate. There is one small catch, which he doesn't mind: he has to give her sister -- also played by Mlle Audran -- five hundred francs a month, and she is to live at his house. At least, he doesn't mind until she puts on a wig, sits down in her sister's wheelchair, and insists that he's trying to kill her to Serrault. Also Robert Hossein shows up and insists that Brialy pay him for killing his wife. Hossein also begins fabricating evidence that Brialy committed the murder.

      There are one or two psychological points in this psychological thriller directed by Etienne Périer that I don't find convincing. This, despite them specifically being addressed at the end. Probably it was the discontent at their continuing absurdity throughout that lingered.

      Nonetheless, as matters progress in logical but unforeseen manners, I found myself continually engaged by this mordant story. A small role for director Claude Chabrol as a half-blind railroad guard was a sizable asset, as well as a key role by Michel Creton as a pharmacist whose shop is next to Mlle. Spaak's.
      4dbdumonteil

      An ersatz Chabrol movie.

      The turn of the decade (sixties/seventies) was Chabrol 's heyday.To reproduce his (commercial and critical) success,the same ingredients were chosen(a murder mystery,a bourgeois house,Stephane Audran,Chabrol's then wife playing parts of twin sisters -after Olivia de Havilland,why not her?-,Chabrol in the flesh in a cameo -he's the Pullman's inspector-)to give the flick the aura of .... an ersatz Chabrol movie.There are ,at a pinch ,two good suspenseful scenes; the wheelchair on the road,pursued by a car,and the hanged man in the graveyard which pack a real wallop.

      Etienne Périer was to continue in the ersatz Chabrol vein with "la main à couper",but he was luckier with his "un si joli village" (1978) which was closer to Cayatte/Boisset social criticism.

      More like this

      Les Biches
      6.9
      Les Biches
      Roulette chinoise
      7.2
      Roulette chinoise
      Un si joli village...
      6.4
      Un si joli village...
      Le mystère des yeux bleus
      6.0
      Le mystère des yeux bleus
      Le lit conjugal
      7.0
      Le lit conjugal
      Saint-Tropez Blues
      5.6
      Saint-Tropez Blues
      Meurtre en 45 tours
      5.9
      Meurtre en 45 tours
      Manèges
      7.2
      Manèges
      Chassés-croisés sur une lame de rasoir
      5.7
      Chassés-croisés sur une lame de rasoir
      L'étoile du Nord
      6.5
      L'étoile du Nord
      Le Pont vers le Soleil
      7.1
      Le Pont vers le Soleil
      La part du feu
      5.7
      La part du feu

      Storyline

      Edit

      Did you know

      Edit
      • Trivia
        Italian censorship visa # 61255 delivered on 28-10-1972.
      • Goofs
        Excellent Film, but one issue. This is more to do with the English subtitles for this French movie that has been dubbed into Italian. The captions keep referring to Kastner's gun as a revolver, while in the Italian one can clearly here the word pistola, as opposed to rivoltella for revolver. The gun is clearly a small automatic pistol, resembling a .25 calibre Browning Baby, or some similar design.
      • Connections
        Featured in Dusk to Dawn Drive-In Trash-o-Rama Show Vol. 6 (1999)

      Top picks

      Sign in to rate and Watchlist for personalized recommendations
      Sign in

      Details

      Edit
      • Release date
        • August 23, 1972 (France)
      • Countries of origin
        • Italy
        • France
      • Language
        • French
      • Also known as
        • Murder Is a Murder
      • Filming locations
        • Garches, Paris, France
      • Production companies
        • Les Films de l'Epée
        • Peel
        • Planfilm
      • See more company credits at IMDbPro

      Tech specs

      Edit
      • Runtime
        1 hour 43 minutes
      • Sound mix
        • Mono
      • Aspect ratio
        • 1.66 : 1

      Contribute to this page

      Suggest an edit or add missing content
      Un meurtre est un meurtre (1972)
      Top Gap
      By what name was Un meurtre est un meurtre (1972) officially released in Canada in English?
      Answer
      • See more gaps
      • Learn more about contributing
      Edit page

      More to explore

      Recently viewed

      Please enable browser cookies to use this feature. Learn more.
      Get the IMDb app
      Sign in for more accessSign in for more access
      Follow IMDb on social
      Get the IMDb app
      For Android and iOS
      Get the IMDb app
      • Help
      • Site Index
      • IMDbPro
      • Box Office Mojo
      • License IMDb Data
      • Press Room
      • Advertising
      • Jobs
      • Conditions of Use
      • Privacy Policy
      • Your Ads Privacy Choices
      IMDb, an Amazon company

      © 1990-2025 by IMDb.com, Inc.