Confession d'un tueur

Sometimes people forget how great an actor Charles Bronson really was. He delivers a terrific performance in "Showdown at Boot Hill". The rest of the cast is very good as well. This is also a great looking movie. "Showdown at Gun Hill" is a fast moving, often tense, western. It is also a surprisingly thoughtful movie. I'll be watching it again pretty soon.

Better known as a film editor over five decades, Gene Fowler Jr. earned himself a decent resume as a cult director, with seven titles over a three year period, none truly outstanding, but all deserving of praise for one reason or another. 1957's "Showdown at Boot Hill" was preceded by his debut, "I Was a Teenage Werewolf," and followed by "Gang War" (also with Charles Bronson), "I Married a Monster from Outer Space" (his best known), "Here Come the Jets," "The Rebel Set," and lastly, the mediocre Western "The Oregon Trail" (again with John Carradine). "Boot Hill" is chiefly remembered, if at all, as Bronson's very first starring role in a feature film, quickly followed by Roger Corman's better known "Machine-Gun Kelly," and already at this early stage, finds himself immersed in a role which allows him to be gritty and short on talk. Bronson's Deputy U. S. Marshal Luke Welsh arrives in Mound City with a warrant for the arrest of wanted outlaw Con Maynor (Thomas Browne Henry), guilty of killing three men in other territories. He quickly finds his man dining at the hotel and flirting with waitress Sally (Fintan Meyler), hardly batting an eye when the Marshal makes his presence known, almost bragging about his exploits as he gets ready to leave. Determined to collect the $200 bounty on Maynor's head, Welsh allows the outlaw to draw now or journey to St. Louis to be hanged; the expected result has Con Maynor dead, but the hostile townspeople unwilling to identify the corpse. Forced to stick around to try to collect his hard won bounty, Welsh learns how charitable Maynor was in this territory, and how protective they feel toward him, even acknowledging his murderous ways. Bronson's romance of waitress Sally tends to slow down an already actionless Western, but the top notch script by Louis Vittes, low key but sharp, allows the entire cast to shine (incredibly, "I Was a Teenage Werewolf" was the only Fowler title not written by Vittes). Robert Hutton gets second billing as Maynor's number one defender Sloane, praising the dead man for restoring his lost herd of cattle with one he no doubt stole himself, but allowed Sloane two years to pay off. Paul Maxey's part as the de facto judge makes the inquest appear as legal as possible considering everybody lied! Best of all is John Carradine, an old friend of the director's father (all part of the John Barrymore Rat Pack), playing the challenging role of Doc Weber, town barber, who does more shaving and undertaking than he does doctoring. Looking fairly dapper in moustache and beard, Carradine simply lights up the screen, and develops a wonderful rapport with Bronson, working together again in Carradine's very last Western, 1977's "The White Buffalo," again as an undertaker (with Irish accent). Perhaps their best scene together is in the barber shop, Weber informing the Marshal about the dead man's brother arriving at Boot Hill for the funeral, despite the protestations of his customer: "now, I didn't mention any names did I?" He had fine roles in other Westerns of the 50s ("Johnny Guitar," "Thunder Pass," "Stranger on Horseback," "The Kentuckian," "Hidden Guns," and "The Proud Rebel"), but "Showdown at Boot Hill" ranks on top as his best. As for Charles Bronson, this late 1957 production began a brief starring spree, with "Machine-Gun Kelly," "Gang War," and "When Hell Broke Loose," followed by his one TV series lead, MAN WITH A CAMERA. His feature career continued with supporting roles for another decade, but at least his vehicles would grow in stature ("The Magnificent Seven," "Battle of the Bulge," "The Dirty Dozen") before European stardom beckoned with Sergio Leone's "Once Upon a Time in the West."

This western with a message starts out fast with an early gunfight, but then slows down considerably & takes things at a leisurely pace for most of the remainder of the movie. Character development, especially of Bronson & his girlfriend, is very good, & meaningful issues are explored (e.g., "Is he a bad guy if he's a model citizen in his town, has helped his neighbors in important ways, but just happens to have killed three people elsewhere?"). The plight of short people is also explored to some extent. Overall, a solid story with some action. I rate it 8/10.

This was an entertaining film...mainly for the dialog, which at times was hilarious. For example: Saloon scene: When her client passes out, Jill (saloon owner) tells her: "Don't worry..you'll still get your percentage..but girl complains bitterly: "He wasn't even a gentleman..didn't take his hat off! to which Jill replied: "The ones that bother me are the one who don't take their boots off!" When in a western have you ever heard anything close to that in its implications? Bronson is as my mom would say "so homely, he is good looking." Good thing he kept that mop of hair his whole life. John Carradine was super fun to watch...his every word..his facial machinations..his "I've seen it all" attitude. It was very well cast and at times, almost had a "comic book" feel to it. By that I mean, the people were more like caricatures than real people. Yes, if it comes your way and you like 50s westerns, see it!

As with most films that "miss", it almost always comes down to a bad script...as it does here. The subject matter the movie tries to deal with is potentially interesting, and could have had some real emotional impact, but the slow, meandering pace and some goofy dialogue undermine what could have been a good psychological Western. It's really a shame because the directing is actually pretty good, the score feels just right, most of the actors hold their own, and the sets actually look remarkably authentic considering what an extremely low budget this movie clearly had.

Throughout the entire movie I kept thinking that it reminded me of another project, but couldn't put my finger on it...and then it dawned on me that the whole thing has the feel of a 1950s TV Western...it especially reminded me of the way the first season of "The Rifleman" was shot. Not sure if this movie was meant to be the second part of a drive-in movie double-bill, or (based on the quality and running time) if this might have actually been shot as a potential pilot for a TV series...Bronson looks fantastic here...he is young, fit, handsome, and would have made an excellent TV star had he been given the opportunity. This project might have passed as decent enough TV watching, but it misses the mark as a feature film, which is a shame considering its potential.

Not only did the film have potential, but you can see the potential Charles Bronson had if he'd chosen to become an actor instead of a silent-but-deadly action hero over the span of his career. His early work gave him some really good opportunities to emote, but I guess the other direction he went in paid a lot better. I suppose one can't argue with success, but it is interesting to think of what might have been.

"Showdown at Boot Hill" is certainly not worth paying money to rent or buy, but if it comes on cable, it is definitely a harmless enough way to spend an hour and change.