Coup de foudre

The way this film reads for me is as a sit-com or more specifically, a Larry David-style Curb Your Enthusiasm mayhem comedy. Enjoy.

The FBI analysis of this picture is, "Trumbo was one of the 'Hollywood Ten." and it got blackballed. I suspect very much that Hoover disliked a strong female protagonist.

J. Edgar Hoover grew up with his mother and lived with her for forty three years. Anna Marie was a strong disciplinarian.

In addition, J. Edgar Hoover's father, Dickerson Naylor Hoover, who was a map printmaker, suffered from severe depression to the point where he withered away in an asylum.

J. Edgar Hoover was well known to disfavor placing females in important positions in the government. You make the call. Oh yeah, the film is great comedy.

Did I say that? Pretty pretty pretty good.

Emergency Wedding (aka Jealousy) (1951) [D: Edward Buzzell. Larry Parks, Barbara Hale, Willard Parker] Peter Kirk, bored young millionaire, tired of running his inherited business, takes to the road, is caught in a car crash, meets Dr Helen Hunt, woos and marries her, only to fall prey to jealousy when he discovers she treats male patients (one of whom wants the good doctor for himself). A few complications ensue, Dr Hunt leaves him, but all ends happily when he finds a good cause, and the usual Hollywood bromides work on the doc to prevent a divorce. A piece of silly fluff, made as a 75 minute 2nd feature. Competent in all respects, but the only reason to keep watching is to see what will happen next. The theme of Dalton Trumbo's story could have made for a more subtle exploration of the roles of husbands and wives, but this was 1950, and a mere nod at this tricky issue was enough. Not bad of its type, but the type was I think already past its sell-by date in 1950. *½

Larry Parks has sold the family department store and is enjoying the money when he runs into Barbara Hale. Actually, she runs into him, and their cars wind up smashed. He's instantly in love and proposes marriage. She is a dedicated doctor and refuses, until he kisses her and promises she can keep on working if she wants. However, he's intensely jealous of any good-looking male patients.

It's a remake of YOU BELONG TO ME, and like many a post-war remake of a pre-war comedy, the changes in society render the humor in the situations a lot less funny; in addition, Parks and Miss Hale are not Henry Fonda and Barbara Stanwyck. The result is the two leads here seem perpetually grouchy, rather than amusing. There are some funny lines for Irving Bacon and George Meeker, but unlike most comedies that switch off when the plot gets going, this one actually gets more interesting with the drama about social issues. Meanwhile, Una Merkel, Jim Backus, and Alan Reed are largely wasted.

"Emergency Wedding" is a remake of "You Belong to Me"...a film I disliked. Why? Becauase the plot is very creepy and alarming! It's so alarming that I cannot imagine the film being made today.

When the story begins, Peter (Larry Parks) falls for a young woman he's just met! When he tells Helen (Barbara Hale) he wants to marry her, she oddly agrees! She also informs him she's a doctor and her practice must come first. Now here's where it gets VERY creepy. When he realizes she'll have male patients, he's suddenly insanely jealous and begins imagining all sorts of shenanigans. Part of this, undoubtedly, is because they barely know each other and trust hasn't been built. But most of it is just plain creepy...as Peter is very controlling and is the sort of husband that in real life might kill or physically abuse his wife. After all, he sneaks around watching her and even breaks into her appointments to make sure she's not cheating on him....the actions of a potentially dangerous jerk. Not surprisingly, Peter ultimately destroys his marraige due to his jealousy...but being Hollywood it's all supposed to be cute and he vows to reform. In real life, these sorts of guys sometimes kill...here it's all in good fun!

As a father of two grown daughters, this plot really bothered me. If they brought home a guy like Peter, I think I would call the cops....or 'accidentally' drop them off a cliff! And, I had a hard time looking past all this jealousy and enjoying the picture. Watch at your own peril, as the plot is ill-conceived and stupid.

This comedy might appear slightly too professional and exclusive, dealing with the problems of too much money and medical ethics. However, it is worth following it closely to the end, as some social problems also are brought up, and although quite outdated today, this was certainly an issue in those days, America being full of highly educated European refugees that were not allowed to work in America because of law formalisms. Barbara Hale is a qualified doctor who gets married to millionaire Larry Parks, who finds himself desperately jealous of all her male clients, one of them even flirting and wanting her to marry him. She has the upper hand because of her professionalism, while his money is of no value to her ethics and dedication to her job. However, he succeeds in turning the tables, while she discovers that other men (and all men) are just as much good-for-nothings as he. There are many twists to this comedy, but on the whole it holds water being splendidly spiritual with almost screwball ingredients, and the social chapter is interesting. Watching this will be no loss of time.