The Colgate Comedy Hour

Not all Colgate Comedy Hour episodes originated from New York. In fact, when it began, production originated from New York and was kine-scoped for West Coast broadcast. Beginning with the second season, production was divided between Hollywood and New York, with the majority of episodes originating from Southern California. The show started in New York and ended in L.A. The first Los Angeles-based episode of the show aired late in September 1951. All of the Los Angeles-based Colgate Comedy Hour episodes seem to have been filmed instead of aired live, as I have seen with a December 1952 Abbott and Costello-hosted episode. Fred Waring was the final host of the series, and on Christmas Day 1955. The first Colgate Comedy Hour to originate from outside New York or Los Angeles was from Philadelphia in 1951 not Las Vegas or Miami in 1954. No sooner did the show end did Los Angeles overtake Chicago as an important center for TV production, as it remains 50 years later.

Recently, Gloria O'Connor (Donald's widow) told me that she thought the Nov. 22, 1953 Colgate Comedy Hour was the first color telecast of the newly-approved color system. Evidently it was part of a test. Many old-timers have insisted that the Jan 1 Rose Bowl Parade was the first color telecast. Can anyone shed some light on the Colgate Comedy Hour? I met Joyce Smith, one of the original dancers, at an NBC Reunion and she also believed that the show was telecast in color. It would be a good thing to straighten this out for the history books. In addition, Joyce said the Comedy hour originated at the original 'El Capitan' theater on Vine Street.

An earlier comment claims that an episode in November 1953 was the first color television broadcast ever. That is not so. The Federal Communications Commission, on Oct. 10, 1950, approved a color television system developed by CBS that was not compatible with existing black and white television sets. However, a court challenge by RCA, which was developing its own color system that was compatible with black and white sets, tied up the inauguration of the CBS color system until a decision for CBS by the U.S. Supreme Court in May 1951.

Finally, on June 25, 1951, CBS broadcast a one-hour program in color, called "Premiere", featuring Ed Sullivan and other CBS stars, and carried it on a five-station East Coast CBS-TV hookup.

The episode of "The Colgate Comedy Hour" broadcast in color in November 1953 was actually the network debut of the rival RCA color television system. In December 1953, the FCC formally reversed its earlier decision and approved the RCA system as the color standard for American television.

My favorite episode was with Marcus "The Worm" Hicks and Tiny Boop Squigg Shorterly hitting those high Cs all night long. Guy's practically a household name for being the king of the Tuk Tuk sound and in my opinion far superior to Paul Bufano. Bufano is very meat and potatoes. Sure, Cafeteria Jangle was great but Bufano's later stuff is dwarfed in comparison to a Hicks and Shorterly bill. I'm also pretty big on Thaddeus Finks. He's no Roy Donk but I believe he was also a regular guest on the Colgate Hour. Mookie Kramer and the 8 balls was a can't miss performance as well. These artists were all ideal for those with a curious mind.

Another one of the earliest shows I've watched, I of course didn't finished this in it's entirety, which ran for over 200 episodes across 6 seasons from 1950 - 1955 live on NBC. Sponsored by the toothpaste Colgate (and other products), the comedy hour aired Sundays at 8PM and held that primetime slot for each year it ran. Dropping most talk-show aspects of the late night talk show, and keeping the music and comedy performances just more of them, the show was similar to many surrounding it at the time, but came to great success from the quality of the acts it brought on, from Martin & Lewis to Abbot & Costello. The DVD collection I watched featured performances from the latter, including their famous "Who's on first?" bit, as well as Frank Sinatra, Eddie Fisher, Eddie Cantor, and Victor Borge. All quite funny to see, the DVD unfortunately was more highlighted bits rather than full episodes, I turned to YouTube for a couple of those but being a live taped show in the 50s the quality remaining (physically of the tapes, not the material) is not great, and at times hard to watch. Aside from a throw-away reference in an I Think You Should Leave sketch I doubt many will have even heard of this show, and that's fairly fair. If you're really into television history, then for sure, check it out.