Strange Bargain

A sedate thriller built upon the insecurities of the newly emergent white-collar class, Strange Bargain offers solid production values and brisk direction. Jeffrey Lynn (who looks like a solution of Ray Milland and Bruce Bennett) is a hard-working family man who earns his keep as an accountant. One morning when the milk bill comes due he screws up his courage to ask for a raise; when he does, his boss tells him that the firm's at the brink of bankruptcy, and lets him go. But wait -- there's more! The boss plans to kill himself but make it look like murder so his wife can collect the insurance; for helping, he offers Lynn $10-grand. Lynn tries to prevent the suicide but arrives too late, finding his boss already dead. Enter a police detective (Harry Morgan) whose instincts tell him all is not as it seems (not only to him, but to us as well). Morgan aside, you're not likely to recognize any of the cast, but the story works itself out neatly and holds your interest. Too polite and middle-class to be true noir, Strange Bargain nontheless delivers what it promises.

When JEFFREY LYNN had to leave his career during WWII for the armed services, it seemed to cut into whatever momentum he had built up at Warner Brothers. By the time he did STRANGE BARGAIN for RKO, his dwindling career wasn't exactly in high gear. Nevertheless, he gives a good performance here as a man unwillingly caught up in a chain of events that almost lands him in a great deal of trouble.

He's an assistant bookkeeper at a law firm that is going through hard times. On the day that he gets up enough courage to ask for a raise, he's told that because of all the cuts being made, he has to be let go. His boss, however, has a strange bargain to make with him and that's the nub of the story without giving any more of the plot away.

MARTHA SCOTT is fine as his loving wife who never suspects anything is wrong until she makes a certain discovery. HARRY MORGAN is the detective who knows something isn't quite right when Lynn's boss is found not a victim of suicide, as had been planned, but a victim of murder. KATHERINE EMERY, an interesting actress who had been used well in THE LOCKET, has a pivotal role as the dead man's widow but plays the role so stiffly that it's not easy to believe the film's ending.

It's a story that catches interest from the start and maintains that suspense throughout. JEFFREY LYNN, never an actor given to much emotion, is calm and stalwart as the innocent victim of circumstances beyond his control.

A B-film worth catching if you can.

Assistant bookkeeper Sam Wilson (Jeffrey Lynn) can't make ends meet for himself, his wife, and two children, so he goes to his boss Mr. Jarvis asking for a raise. Instead of a raise he finds out from Jarvis that he is going to be let go shortly because the firm cannot afford him. It is then that Jarvis tells Wilson that he is broke and that, rather than see his wife and son destitute, he intends to kill himself so that they can collect the insurance money - 250K. But he needs Sam's help to cover up the suicide so that it looks like a murder/robbery so that the insurance will pay off. In return he will give Sam ten thousand dollars. Sam refuses.

The following night Jarvis calls Sam anyways and tells him the password for the suicide he plans to commit. Sam races over to his house to try and stop him, but he is too late. Jarvis is dead on the floor. So, realizing it is too late to stop the suicide, seeing the 10K on the desk, and reading Jarvis' written plea to Sam to help him cover the suicide, he decides that not helping him now will do no good, and so he does make it look like a robbery, takes the 10K, and throws the gun into the bay. What Sam doesn't realize is that everything he has just done not only makes it look like a murder, it makes it look like a murder he could have committed.

Besides the rather clever plot and red herrings thrown all over the place for such a short B feature with no A list stars, this is really a museum piece of post war middle class life and even business values of the time. The USA is headed into HUAC/Red Scare land at this point, so time is taken to show the Wilson family praying before eating, there is talk of going to church like it would ordinarily be a weekly event, and note that even people who had desk jobs worked half a day on Saturday at this point in time. As for business values, Mr. Jarvis knows his employees and they know him. Even down to Sam the assistant bookkeeper for twelve years - Jarvis couldn't have found him THAT valuable to keep him in a lower level position all of that time.

Harry Morgan plays Lt. Webb, a police detective whose only job at this point is to find Jarvis' murderer. He even comes to Jarvis' company and fingerprints all of the employees! I can't believe if someone like workaday cog in the machine Sam had been murdered there would have been much more than a police report. Since Morgan has been playing lots of bad guys and moral cowards up to this point in time, quite a bit of unlikability bleeds into his performance to where I want somebody to drag him away by that cane of his.

Finally I have to give Jeffrey Lynn his due. He carries off being the central character in this film very well, often just telegraphing his feelings by posture and facial expression, particularly when he comes across Jarvis' suicide scene. This is time well spent at just over an hour.

What's neat about 1949's Strange Bargain is that on an episode of Murder, She Wrote, some of the cast returned for a sequel, during which Jessica tries to get to the bottom of the case. The film solved the case, but for the Murder, She Wrote episode, "The Days Dwindle Down," they added another twist to what we saw.

Anyway, it was a good idea because the film was used in flashbacks. The returning stars were Martha Scott, Jeffrey Lynn (who had long ago left show business and made a fortune in real estate) and Harry Morgan.

In the film Strange Bargain, Jeffrey Lynn plays Sam Wilson, an assistant bookkeeper at a company that is going under. He and his wife, Georgia (Scott) are having trouble making ends meet. With the encouragement of his wife, Sam goes in to ask for a raise and learns then that he's fired. Later on, as he's leaving, his boss, Mr. Jarvis (Richard Gaines) asks him to have a drink.

Jarvis admits that he's gone through the $500,000 his father left him (the equivalent of about 4 million today), and he is basically broke. He plans on killing himself and making it look like murder so his wife (Katherine Emery) can collect his $250,000 insurance policy; with double indemnity, that makes $500,000. He's going to set it up as a robbery. He will call Sam and give him a signal, and he wants Sam to come to his home then and remove the gun and dump it in the river. For that, he'll leave Sam $10,000 in the open safe.

Sam refuses to help him and attempts to talk Jarvis out of it, but he won't be swayed. Sam still refuses to help.

However, Jarvis calls him and gives the signal. Sam pleads with him to wait until he can get there and talk to him, but he's too late. He removes the gun and the money.

The police (Harry Morgan and Walter Sande) start an investigation and hone in on Jarvis' partner, Timothy Hearne (Henry O'Neill). Sam insists that Hearne couldn't have done it, but he's afraid that the man will be arrested.

This is a pretty good film. Lynn's career never recovered after World War II - he was a pleasant enough actor, and still made occasional TV appearances even after he left. Katherine Emery always reminds me of Mercedes McCambridge.

Watch it with the Murder She Wrote episode which you can stream.

An interesting note about this movie: The TV Series "Murder, She Wrote" produced a "sequel" to it in a 1987 episode, "The Days Dwindle Down," (episode # 3.21). Several actors, including Harry Morgan, reprise their roles. Jessica Fletcher re-solves the original crime by interviewing several of the original characters some 30 years after the fact (actually closer to 40 years!). The episode makes nice use of scenes from the original movie as flashbacks to explain the plot. Imagine the surprise of watching a typical MSW episode about an old murder, and then a 34-year-old Harry Morgan suddenly pops up in B&W interviewing the same (though younger) witnesses about the same murder!