Esclaves pour Rio

They Were So Young (1954)

An early widescreen movie. It's low budget (showing how mainstream the format had become this first full year of its use), but has some terrific scenes and a fun twist of a plot about a scheme to trap young European girls into a modeling gig in Rio that turns into a kind of prostitution slave-girl trade.

The big star is Raymond Burr, who is excellent in his brief appearances, but the main man is a likable Scott Brady, who is an archetypal nice guy American who sees trouble in this foreign land and saves the damsels who would otherwise perish. It's an odd twist that the bad guys in Brazil are actually American, too (Burr), but that's probably good, not to typecast the South Americans as the bad guys.

Director Kurt Neumann is famous for the idiosyncratic and important original version of "The Fly" as well as the notoriously awful "She-Demon." The long list of his films includes a lot of dregs, including a series of half-length movies (called streamliners) that were super low budget fillers. But because of all this work he was an experienced pro by 1954, and adapted to the wide screen exotic scenario here pretty well. The story, however streamlined itself, is a believable and frightening one. If the outcome is too predictable, that's true with half of Hollywood, so just go for the ride.

This is a German film and not any American Hollywood production, and it is not filmed on location in the swamps of Brazil but actually in Hamburg studios, but it is well made and surprisingly convincing for being all artifice. The story is true though, these rackets did go on and probably still go on today, and we shall never know how many girls from how many countries were lost this way. The music is good also and the one enjoyable thing about the movie. Raymond Burr is as impressive as ever as a qualified villain of professional double standards, and Scott Brady is a positive surprise for his honest acting. Johanna Matz like the other girls all young and pretty also make one-sidedly good impressions, especially Johanna Matz for her innocence. The Brazilian insights, especially in the row aboard the river boat in the end, are delightful, and the story makes sense although scary without exaggerations. It is worth watching but no more.

I decided to give They Were So Young a try firstly because of the short run time and secondly because it had Raymond Burr. It started off badly enough but slowly, and ever so gradually it began to draw me in. Not sure exactly how it happened but it did. To its credit the whole thing does move along at a brisk pace and is tightly directed. The story is kind of interesting and it does manage to create some real suspense. A gently love story does develop but it isn't played to hard and keep it just a supporting element to the overall story. I became involved enough to the point that all of a sudden it was over. Slight but entertaining film worth checking out.

...or whenever. By which I mean it's mediocre but enjoyable if you aren't too demanding. Some reviewers were apparently hoping for something better and were disappointed, but after reading their reviews I knew not to expect too much. That said, the plot is reasonable, Scott Brady is as good as he pretty much always was, Johanna Matz is very believable if not outstanding and the rest of the cast does what they need to do in order for this to be a mildly fun little adventure. The sets were better than one often sees in this sort of 'B' grade flick and there were only two or three sequences when I thought it dragged a bit. I'd give it a 5.5 if that was possible, but I couldn't quite give it a 6.

Johanna Matz is hired to be a clothes model in Rio, but when she gets there she discovers that sometimes they don't want her to wear clothes. Scott Brady finds this out when it turns out she's not a prostitute hired by his boss Raymond Burr after he gets back to the city after months and months up at the mine. He's okay with her being a good girl and decides to help her escape.

This unlikely plot is well directed by director-cowriter Kurt Neumann, and it speaks to the mindset of people looking for a little well-intentioned smut. There isn't any smut but there is a fashion show and some pretty actresses in their early 1920s. Although it was financed by Lippert, it was shot mostly in Germany.