Guy Madison
- Wild Bill Hickok
- (archive footage)
Andy Devine
- Jingles
- (archive footage)
Gloria Talbott
- Consuelo
- (archive footage)
- (as Gloria Talbot)
Isabel Randolph
- Hepsibah
- (archive footage)
George J. Lewis
- Ramon
- (archive footage)
Murray Alper
- Kirby
- (archive footage)
George Eldredge
- Judge
- (archive footage)
Robert Bice
- Branton
- (archive footage)
Steve Pendleton
- Larson
- (archive footage)
Douglas Evans
- Grogan
- (archive footage)
Billy Griffith
- Jenkins
- (archive footage)
Larry Johns
- Collins
- (archive footage)
Jerry Sheldon
- Chief Marshal
- (archive footage)
- (as Jerome Sheldon)
