André Hardy Cow-Boy

Though this Hardy Family film is listed as a comedy, it includes a healthy dose of tears, which may be why it gets lesser marks than others in the series. Still, Andy Hardy (Mickey Rooney) brings his brand of teenage silliness to the proceedings.

The family goes out west to visit friends who own a working ranch. They are having problems that Judge Hardy (Lewis Stone) might be able to help with. Daughter Marian (Cecilia Parker) is smitten with a ranch hand, and Andy reluctantly pals around with a spunky cowgirl named Jake, played by Virginia Weidler (who appears in two other films with Rooney).

The show business adage says you should never work with children or animals, but Rooney does both here and, though Virginia is a real scene-stealer, he holds his own. A better film that shows Rooney's western talents is "Girl Crazy" (1943).

Judge Hardy and his family take off for Arizona when one of dad's close friends runs into some legal trouble and may lose her ranch. The elder daughter Marian falls for a foreman at the ranch (Gordon Jones), whose 8-year-old tomboy daughter "Jake" starts to get a crush of sorts on Andy Hardy. This wasn't an exceptional entry but it has its moments of comedy (Jake tries to sabotage Marian's efforts to impress the girl's father) and drama (Andy unintentionally causes Jake's favorite horse to break its leg). I am beginning to become aware already that Mickey Rooney mugs to wild extremes as Andy Hardy.

**1/2 out of ****

Judge Hardy gets a letter from a former flame. She needs legal help for her family's Arizona ranch. Their neighbor holds their water rights. Andy (Mickey Rooney) is getting conceited. Mom is obsessed with spring cleaning and growing frustrated. The Judge decides to bring the whole family out west for a break.

Judy Garland is gone. Andy takes a step back. The whole franchise takes a step back. At least, Andy gets his comeuppance in the end and Jake has some fun with him. This is not the best idea. It's an excuse for Andy to dress up as a cowboy and for Marian to kiss one. This is basically a family sitcom deciding to go on a trip to spice things up to start the new season.

The fifth entry in the Hardy family series is set out west on a ranch and uses a lot of fish-out-of-water comedy that many films employ when they involve city folks being placed out west. Mickey Rooney dresses up in chaps and even tries to walk bow-legged when he sees a ranch hand walk that way; Cecilia Parker is suckered into boiling Gordon Jones' boots and polishing them with molasses by Jones' jealous daughter, Virginia Weidler; and even Lewis Stone wears a cowboy hat. Unfortunately, most of the comedy is predictable, especially if you've seen City Slickers (1991) and other films of that type. The comedy is intermixed with some drama (Rooney causing Weidler's horse to break a leg, for example) and suspense.

I enjoyed the story and the resolution of all the problems that arose. Mickey Rooney seems to mug a bit more than usual, but he's fun to watch. Lewis Stone gives his usual fine performance dispensing his sage advice and Virginia Weidler is very good as the precocious eight-year old who out-slickers Rooney and Parker. If you're into the Hardy series, you'll enjoy the film.

Andy obnoxious and conceited letter in basketball??

When the story begins, Andy is behaving weirdly....even for Andy. He's quite obnoxious and conceited...and Polly is naturally angry at him. Why is he so fat-headed? Apparently, he just got his high school letter for...basketball(!!!!!). Now I know that basketball players were not as tall in the good old days, but at 5'2", hearing that he's a star basketball player is pretty weird and hard to believe.

In the midst of this, Judge Hardy announces he's taking the family on vacation at a dude ranch. For the judge, it's a working vacation and he's there to try to help the owners in a water rights dispute. Along the way, Andy's sister falls in love with a widower and Andy hangs around with a precocious kid (Virginia Weidler). How all this works out is for you to learn when you see this one.

This is a pretty good installment of the series....not among the best but still quite enjoyable.