Monsieur Vincent

I saw this film at St. John's Prep in Brooklyn, NY, around 1959. The school was run by the Vincentian Fathers (Congregation of Missions-CM). I was surprised to see that Jean Anouilh had written the screenplay; he also wrote Becket. It was somewhat episodic. But I remember each one. He was not a patsy. Food line for the needy. He stops one man and feels his muscles and asks what's wrong with him. Instead, he steers him to a job on the docks. A job is a job and one could argue about unionizing later.

The French movie about Father Vincent de Paul, who was the first to establish soup kitchens and homeless shelters, was honored by the Academy Awards by an Oscar for November 1947's "Monsieur Vincent." The filmmakers of picture on the French saint, who founded the Daughters of Charity, was handed the honorary award for best foreign language film before the Academy officially began giving out the Oscars in that category in 1956.

Co-written by Jean Anouilh, who later wrote the play 'Becket,' "Monsieur Vincent" was the second to win the honorary Oscar for the best foreign film (English films not included), the first being director Vittorio De Sica's 1946 "Shoeshine." From 1947 until 1955, the Academy handed out Oscars annually (except for 1953) to the top non-English language movie. "Monsieur Vincent" also won the Grand prix of French Cinema, and was nominated at the Golden Globes for Promoting International Understanding.

"Monsieur Vincent" opens with the Vincent de Paul (Pierre Fresnay) assigned to a dilapidated church in a town overwhelmed by fears of a pandemic. The new priest quickly jumps into action, administering aid and comfort to an infected woman, with no concerns about his own health. So extensive was Vincent's work, the movie sees him organizing charities for the poor, including the Foundation of the Charity, which was the forerunner for elderly care and medical healing for war victims. Vincent also founded a home for abandoned children and the 'Brotherhood of Charity,' a food pantry where those more fortunate donated to the poor. He's had numerous hospitals named after him, and was the spiritual advisor for the Queen of France (Germaine Dermoz), who became very familiar with Vincent's miraculous work.

Pierre Fresnay, 49, as Monsieur Vincent jumped into stage and film acting after serving three years in the French Army during World War One, appearing in Alfred Hitchcock's 1934 "The Man Who Knew Too Much" and Jean Renoir's 1937 "La Grande Illusion." Alec Guinness listed Fresnay as his favorite actor.

Film reviewer Steven Greydanus notes "Monsieur Vincent" only scratches the surface of this remarkable man. "No special background knowledge is necessary to perceive the spirit of the man's life, and the spirit of the man himself," wrote Greydanus. The movie, he said, "is a beautiful, inspiring film, one that rewards repeated viewing."

There are many heart-rending scenes in this film, like taken directly from the reality of the 17th century with all its infernos of gutter life of the poor, the hungry, the sick and the invalids - they are all here, collected in Monsieur Vincent's hospitals for everyone in need, in whatever condition they are, and his hospitals and almshouses are always crowded, even with beggars and invalids fighting over beds that just have become vacant after one patient has died. Pierre Fresnay makes an unforgettable impersonation of the great pioneer of charity, penetrating deeply into the mind and character of the humble priest, who basically had to stand alone all his life against the overwhelming inhumanity of man, and even of women. It is a rich film, not hesitating to expose every aspect of the saint's difficult life and all his adversities, as even the beginning of the film brings you right down the shocking abyss of the horrible recklessness of man, as he gets stoned by the villagers, hiding behind their closed windows, when he comes to take his office as a vicar in a village that has been without a priest for ten years, all the villagers having turned savage as a result. It is a walk through a hell that never ends, and when Monsieur Vincent finally feels his end is coming (at almost 80 years), his dominating feeling is of insufficiency, that he hadn't done enough, that he hadn't really done anything at all during his 50 years of constant overwork, only for the poor and the endless crowd of interminable and eternal incurable misery...

This was only the second movie to be honored with a Special Oscar as the year's Best Foreign-Language Film, after Vittorio De Sica's SHOESHINE (1946). In retrospect, while a fine achievement in itself, it is not quite in the top rank of French productions (even those made around this same time) – for the record, the country would receive two more such wins, both for director Rene' Clement, i.e. THE WALLS OF MALAPAGA (1949) and FORBIDDEN GAMES (1952), before the category was officially incorporated into the 1956 ceremony.

The film is a religious biopic, the subject being the priest revered for his unselfish aid towards the poor/moribund community in the 17th century and who would eventually be canonized as Saint Vincent De Paule; incidentally, the national old people's home (where my paternal grandfather expired in 2002) is named after him. The success of the movie rests more with Pierre Fresnay's commanding central performance (which earned him the Best Actor award at the Venice Film Festival), Jean-Jacques Grünenwald's rousing score and Claude Renoir's splendid cinematography (that said, the print I watched seemed unduly bright) than the narrative itself (though scripted by famed playwright Jean Anouilh) – which tells a pretty standard tale of a man being initially misunderstood and scorned, then endorsed and abetted. Even so, a few scenes certainly do stand out: the priest getting relentlessly stoned as he lends a helping hand to a would-be plague victim; taking the place of an exhausted galley slave; listening to the 'miserable' sounds of fellow residents at his lodgings; the fights between the myriad mangled patients for a place on the hospital's over-crowded beds, etc.

The supporting cast here is notable for showcasing future stars such as Claude Chabrol regulars Michel Bouquet and Jean Carmet. By the way, given the subject matter, I was reminded throughout of two of my favourite film-maker Luis Bunuel's best efforts, namely NAZARIN (1959; which, like MONSIEUR VINCENT itself, is included in the Vatican's 45-title list of "Some Important Films"!) and VIRIDIANA (1961).

A very good biopic about a great man,Saint Vincent de Paul,whose charity,abnegation,generosity and humanity were so huge that Queen Anne d' Autriche used to call him "the kingdom's conscience" Filmed in black and white ,in a style close to early Bresson,the film features many unforgettable scenes : the reunion with the noble ladies who are willing to "do something" but whose world is far from them ,the Poor;the scene on the royal galley where the legend tells that Monsieur Vincent took the place of an exhausted galley slave .

Pierre Fresnay,whose unquestionable faith would turn to bigotry in his late parts ("le Défroqué" "Tant d'Amour Perdu" )finds here his lifetime part.Sometimes it seems that the Saint rose from the dead.

Like this?Try these....

"Bernadette" Jean Delannoy 1987

"The song of Bernadette " Henry King 1940

"Thérèse" Alain Cavalier 1986