The Widow from Chicago

Edward G. Robinson certainly showed what the movie going public were destined to see in The Widow From Chicago. It was the film immediately proceeding his breakthrough and forever identifiable role as and in Little Caesar.

He's got a job to do and need's some out of town talent so he imports Neil Hamilton sight unseen. But the police get wind of it and have a cop gain entree to Robinson's gang by posing as Hamilton. Then Robinson gets wise and the cop is bumped off.

After that both Hamilton does show up and the sister of the slain officer shows up claiming to be Hamilton's wife. I have to say these two think fast on their feet and Hamilton decides to not expose Alice White the sister.

White was very effective in her role though I think for propriety's sake her sending Hamilton out of her room was a bit much even for 1930 audiences to follow. I mean they could have done a Walls of Jericho like arrangement.

It's sad what happened to Neil Hamilton who went from an A list player gradually down to some really horrid B flicks. That strong voice and clear diction should have made him a big star in talkies, bigger than the silent screen. But the man did have a thirst problem. He did bounce back as a character player later on and is now best known as the Caped Crusader's number one fan Commissioner Gordon on Batman.

Still this film is Robinson's show, but he had a much bigger show just awaiting him.

And I'll support that conclusion. However, I must preface my commentary by acceding to a predilection for Alice White's performances. I adore her no-apologies-for-pert, straight-ahead style that was the antithesis of 'real' actors who rolled their R's and eyes at every opportunity.

We are introduced to Polly (Alice White) and Jimmy (Harold Goodwin) as new tenants by the neighbors' gossiping. Are they married? The question remains unanswered until just before Jimmy, the precinct's newbie detective, leaves for work. The clever script puts a smile on your face just as Jimmy waves at his sister, Polly from the street, and becomes a drive-by shooting victim.

The scripts' powerful counterpoints and wit are enhanced by director Edward Cline's smart pacing and Sol Polito's brilliant photography. The avenging Polly, masquerades to mob boss Dominic (Edward G. Robinson) as the widow of a dead associate of the gang. But she becomes trapped in his office when the 'widow's husband returns from the dead. When Dominic goes out to meet him, we are left with a great insert of the edge of the office door. Slightly ajar, we watch it in anticipation while Dominic meets Polly's 'dead' husband. Will she make a break for it? Will Swifty confront her? Your mind races as the camera holds on that door. It's bravura filmmaking, and Cline keeps it coming. By the way, Polly embraces her 'husband' whispering "go along, I'm on the spot". The excitement's just beginning, Swifty is only too happy to go home with his 'wife'.

Neil Hamilton handles his role as Swifty Dorgan with effective menace, and Polly goes from being on the spot in Dominic's office to being in a spot behind her own (now locked) door. Frank McHugh's got a fine bit as one of Dominic's hentchmen 'Slug', and advises his fellow thug, Mullins, to give up the girl he can't get along with. Slug's smugness melts, however, when Mullins returns the girl's key only to discover the key is to Slug's girlfriend's apartment.

Earl Baldwin's script has plenty of sparks left, and Polito takes the shootout in the dark to a new level when a spotlight is introduced: not only being shot at, but everything its prowling eye touches gets killed. You'll wonder why Little Caesar is famous after seeing this terrific gangster film.

Considering that in the panoply of gangster movies this 1930 WB picture starring Edward G Robinson is usually ignored, it's surprisingly entertaining and actually pretty good. Compared with the dour LITTLE CAESAR made a couple of months later, in terms of depth and character development it's incredibly shallow but it's a lot more fun.

The story is stupid but somehow also great: sister of a murdered policeman infiltrates EGR's crime outfit to see that justice is done. Fortunately this was made at the very end of 1930; that's the post 'sound-on-disc' era, so production standards are fine with lots of dynamic camerawork giving this a lively, almost modern feel. Veteran director Edward Cline was not however one for evoking a modern feel. He doesn't do anything special with this so consequently the effect is a little pedestrian but it's lively enough to keep your interest.

Although EGR is now seen as the star of this, it was made as a vehicle for Alice White to demonstrate that she could play a serious dramatic role, an aspiration sadly unachieved. It's painful for me to admit this but Alice White is pretty awful in this. She had been fantastic portraying her iconic 'flapper' character in a series of fabulous fun films in the late 20s but with the approach of The Depression, audiences' tastes were changing. Warner Brothers/First National therefore decided to make no more musicals, no more silly Alice White films! This film bizarrely started life itself as a musical but all those numbers were edited out - thus the short running time.

Alice White needed to prove that she could act in proper dramatic films, effectively this was her auditioning for a new career. As a massive fan of her's, this film is really upsetting to watch. She looks like a dream in this, she's drop dead gorgeous and a flutter of her eyelids makes you melt into a heap but as an actress.... oh dear, she's truly awful. She just can't do it, she lacks any depth and is utterly unbelievable. Her co-star EGR described her as 'completely lacking any acting ability' and you wonder what must have been going through this trained actor's mind as he tried to do a serious scene with her.

Although she would make one more picture for WB/First National, THE NAUGHTY FLIRT, which is brilliant, this was the nail in her acting career. It's a fun, exciting, rip-roaring crime picture, albeit a bit too simplistic but it's difficult for an Alice White fan to watch this without shedding a silent tear.

A gangster film that's certainly not top-tier, but entertaining nonetheless, with a lively plot, the inimitable Edward G. Robinson, and a strong female character played by Alice White. While I loved seeing White on the screen though, unfortunately her acting was weak and not completely up to the role. It would have been interesting to see the complete film before the musical numbers were all cut, as it's kind of hard to imagine what that must have been like. As it is though, not bad if you like Robinson or White.

Ruthless gangster Dominic (Edward G. Robinson) bumps off a young detective impersonating Swifty Dorgan. The detective's sister (Alice White) sets out to get revenge. She passes herself off as Swifty's wife in order to infiltrate the gang. But then the real Swifty (Neil Hamilton) shows up.

Pre-Little Caesar gangster movie for Robinson, his first at Warner Bros. Also very early role for Frank McHugh, who already seems to be perfecting his screen persona. Alice White is pretty bad. She says every line the same way, regardless of what emotion she's supposed to be displaying. It's an early talkie so there's the expected amount of creakiness. Watchable, particularly for Robinson fans, but nothing special. Believe it or not, this was originally a musical!