Les cadets de la mer

This is a fun period piece for graduates, parents of current midshipmen or of Naval Academy graduates, or staff and faculty of the Naval Academy to get a look at the US Naval Academy of the 1930's. It's fun light piece which provides some interesting historical perspective on the USNA - to include the left hand salute to Tecumseh, the rooms in Bancroft Hall, the yard prior to much of the WW2 and post WW2 construction etc. The story is light but fun and is a reflection of the pre-WW2 America in which it was made. Also fun to see a very young Jimmy Stewart and Robert Young, and the "Good Witch" from the Wizard of Oz.

Three young men (James Stewart, Robert Young, Tom Brown) who enter the Naval Academy became fast friends. Each one is a different clichéd character. Brown's the naive kid, Young's the cynical tough guy, Stewart's the nice one with a mystery. Brown and Stewart play to type well but Young steals the show as the hard case with a hidden heart of gold. We follow the ups and downs of each of these men at the academy, leading up to the big Army-Navy football game that they all play in.

There's nothing really new here, even for 1937, but it's undeniably enjoyable due to the generally upbeat tempo and likable leads. Nice supporting cast includes Lionel Barrymore, Billie Burke, Florence Rice, and Samuel S. Hinds. Dennis Morgan has a cute scene dancing with Burke. Sentimental, patriotic, and fun movie. Really hard to dislike this one.

Intellectually speaking, this is a very clichéd film. So many of the typical 1930s and 40s gimmicks for this sort of movie are all present...ALL. Yet, despite this, I really had a hard time disliking the movie. It was highly entertaining and the actors really made it shine.

The film is about three roommates who all have just been admitted to the prestigious US Naval Academy. They are all stereotypes, but the most ridiculously stereotyped is the guy played by Robert Young. I am surprised they didn't nickname him 'Blackie', as he was the archetypal dishonorable bad guy who just doesn't understand or want to understand the importance of teamwork and humility. He's an exceptional football player (despite Young being 30 at the time he played this part) and knows it...and doing it for anyone but himself is out of the question. Tom Brown plays the sweet rich guy who is the embodiment of niceness and pluck--sort of like a Horatio Alger character who is ALREADY rich. He gives up his wealth and status to serve his country--and women who went to see this film must have all felt a tremendous urge to hug him! The final guy is played by Jimmy Stewart. Like Brown, he's an alright guy and gained admittance to the Academy through the ranks--and he's got a secret that comes out late in the film. While receiving second billing, I think this film did a lot more for Stewart's career than for any other in the movie. I thought Brown was also very good, but today he's an all but forgotten actor--and that's a shame.

The film has it all...lots of sentiment, a strong dose of patriotism, an old man who just happens to be on the brink of death when the big game comes up with Westpoint, you name it! In many ways, the film seems even more clichéd and prototypical for a college football film than even "Knute Rockne, All-American"! But, because the dialog, characters and direction are all so good, you can accept the huge doses of sentiment, schmaltz and all the familiar (very familiar) plot devices. Very well done and a must-see for fans of classic films.

It's pleasant, even fun, but you pretty much know where it's going, almost from the beginning.

It's a nice look at football and how it was played in the 1930s; it's a nice look at how the U.S. Naval Academy at Annapolis was run at that time, with some silly rules that are probably still in effect.

But Hollywood turned out SO MANY movies in which a smart aleck who prefers to be just along for the ride, and a chance at the girl, gets turned around, turned into a credit to the team, to the regiment, to the ...

So it's not new, but it is fun. I do recommend it and it's available at YouTube.

... in that the script consists of tons of tired cliches - the guy who has to learn there is no I in team, the sister of one friend being the heartthrob of the other friends and sprouting a rivalry, the good guy with a deep secret that may derail his noble pursuit, the ancient relic who is almost a mascot because he has been around so long - nah, that was because Lionel Barrymore was a great actor who was becoming disabled as this film was being made, plus Louis B. Mayer was never going to fire a fellow old white guy with whom he identified. Plus - The Navy! - the armed forces and costume dramas became a common theme right after the production code was ushered in because patriotism always passed the censors. But, the performances and the chemistry between the main players makes this worth watching. Take that away and it would be a 6/10 at best.

This is the film that got James Stewart noticed. I've never seen him turn in a bad performance, but prior to this his assignments included warbling in a MGM musical, playing a crazy vengeful lover, and a bit part as the country bumpkin consolation prize boyfriend. This time he gets more of a spotlight and gets a part with more heart that really shows off his talents and his personal appeal.

The only thing that doesn't ring true in this film is Florence Rice, third billed, as a debutante who becomes the object of romance of two friends. Rice was pretty enough, but she was dull as dishwater. Perhaps MGM was trying to give her a build up and it didn't work out.

I'd recommend this one. There isn't any wasted space in it and the performances do make all of the difference.