Sous deux drapeaux

Ronald Colman stars as Sgt. Victor, a member of the French Foreign Legion. He's assigned to a new post in southern Algeria under the command of Major Doyle (Victor McLaglen). Victor soon catches the eye of local saloon girl "Cigarette" (Claudette Colbert), who is in turn the object of Doyle's affection. As for Victor, he's found romance with visiting English society woman Lady Venetia (Rosalind Russell). Doyle keeps attempting to get Victor out of the way by issuing him dangerous assignments, but Victor keeps surviving them. That could change with an uprising that may spell the end for them all. Also featuring Tor Johnson.

This was a major production, with large sets and plenty of extras. The battle scenes near the end of the film are very impressive in scope and execution, and there are several nice shots of caravans moving across the high desert sands. Unfortunately the romance part of the story is bland and predictable. Colman, McLaglen, and Russell all bring their usual personas to the story, but Colbert seems out of place as a lowly singing girl. Simone Simon was originally cast in the part, and even filmed the entire movie, but producer Darryl Zanuck didn't like the end result so he hired Colbert and reshot her entire part! Maybe she was awful, but I would think Simon would have been much better suited to the role.

A Foreign Legion outpost in the desert (where else?) is troubled by enemies without and dissention within as a soldier who used to be a blue-blood is torn between two women, an upper class lady and a schemer who works in the local bar.

Ouida's book is eviscerated, but it was too long. Wren's BEAU GESTE might be a rip-off but it's a great book. However, in the 1800s UNDER TWO FLAGS was very popular.

Ronald Colman is one of my favorite actors but he can't do much with his role. This movie needs twice it's running time.

Nigel Bruce is perfectly cast as a sully English man.

Claudette Colbert isn't bad as Cigarette, the bar-girl; but I never could get past thinking "That's Claudette Colbert" as she's known these days.

For a better Foreign Legion flick check out "Beau Geste" with Gary Cooper (Colman made a silent version but I haven't seen it; sorry).

I love Colman but he's been tons better. This is for Foreign Legion completists.

Unfortunately, Ouida's great classical novel of dishonor, exile, love, war and sacrifice in Algeria with the French foreign legion has not been awarded with that great film script it deserves. A deep tragedy of human greatness has been transformed into a rather superficial Hollywood romance entertainment, where even Ronald Colman makes a rather poor figure, far from the sadly noble hero of the original. Nevertheless, it's a Frank Lloyd film, who also made "Cavalcade" and "Mutiny on the Bounty", and there are great moments, especially of the desert scenery. Claudette Colbert as Cigarette is the real star of the film, though, but then she is also the most memorable character in the novel. Rosalind Russell is good enough and adds some heart-warming romance, while the worst failure of the film is the alteration of the grim reality of the French foreign legion with a sinister discipline worse than that of the 'Bounty' into some loose barrack ballads with plenty of brandy. The grim nature of the colonel in the novel is deleted, and Victor McLaglen is only Victor McLaglen, whom you can't take seriously. It's a good enough entertainment but not more than that, while the novel is so much more.

During the 1930s and 40s, there were a bunch of movies that glorified the French Foreign Legion and featured them as the good guys. Considering the films were made here in the States, it does seem odd that these colonials were talked about at all as well as glorified...but there was apparently some sort of romantic notion of bravery and chivalry associated with this army. Films such as "Beau Hunks", "Beau Geste", "Under Two Flags" and "Abbott & Costello in the Foreign Legion" are just a few of the many such films of the era about this outfit.

This film is set in North Africa and you must ignore that the natives are sometimes referred to as Arabs...they are most likely Libyans, Algerians, Tunesians or, perhaps, Moroccans--all North African countries occupied by the French at that time. The commanding officer, the Major (Victor McLaglen), has a bit of an infatuation with a girl oddly named 'Cigarette' (Claudette Colbert) and after a while, so does Sergeant Victor (Ronald Colman). But when a British lady (Rosalind Russell) shows up in the middle of this desert town, Victor is smitten and now has TWO ladies who think he's their boyfriend. Amidst these smoldering passions is an uprising (what else?!) among the natives and it's up to the Legion to kick butt and restore the peace.

While the cast is quite nice in this one, the film itself is only ordinary. I think much of the problem is that "Beau Geste" came out about the same time and was simply a much more exciting and interesting movie. It's watchable and mildly interesting but not much more.

FYI--It is interesting to see Claudette Colbert playing a French lady and using a French accent, as she was born and lived in France until she was a young girl. I assume her family must have spoken French at home and approximating the French accent must have been pretty natural for her.

You would have expected a better movie reading down the cast members. It took effort to make the first half boring--as if it didn't know what it wanted to be as a movie--a romance or a light action film. The second half was a bit better, but not enough to make up for the first half. My rating is more in recognition of the cast than the quality of the movie.