Un rude cow-boy

This Western is based on a Zane Grey story about a crooked rancher who is stealing cattle. George O'Brien plays the owner of the ranch, who through a case of mistaken identity, is thought to be the Dude Ranger on the ranch. He is after the crooked bosses daughter, played by Irene Harvey.

The film as the typical western sidekick, in this case a guitar playing singer. The film is OK, nothing special, and is an example of a cheap B-Western film, filmed with spectacular scenery. Irene Hervey was loaned out from her home film studio to play the role in this film. LeRoy Mason plays one of the villains.

Although containing less heated "action" than most B-westerns, "The Dude Ranger" is a sensitive but yet swiftly-moving film with well-acted roles and direction that reflects predetermined camera angles and logical call-and-response sequencing. Irene Hervey, appearing here as a loaner in only her second year under contract with MGM, is handed a role that demands more than most B-western heroines are asked to provide. She does a real nice job as a modern woman, at once haughty and seemingly so self-assured in her "lack of competition" femininity, who has found herself immersed in an abundance of Old West masculinity. Although surrounded by all sort of male characters, she needs a "realized" man to enter her life, and guess what...? Ms. Hervey is photographed beautifully in this picture and handles her acting duties very well, communicating plenty of varied and nuanced emotion. George O'Brien is his old reliable self, mostly easy-going but heroic when need be. They also came up with a unique signature behavior for Syd Saylor's nicely-played sidekick role. The entire cast is sharp. Then there is the location scenery... definitely a cut above, with backdrops that include locales well-known to visitors of national parks and monuments in Arizona and Utah. The well-attended barn dance is notable in that the music played there is surprisingly "uptown hot" for 1934, a musical style that was just beginning to legitimize itself in New York and Chicago at that time, certainly not one anticipated to be provided for a remote Arizona ranch dance... but oh well. This film also includes a score of sorts, especially in the latter half, that is not intrusively overdone; one could argue it actually enhances the impact of the closing scene. In summary, one will find in this picture a well-executed adult film treatment of the cowboy genre', longer on romance than most films of the day, and a little shorter on guns, fights, and chases. Satisfying for sure!

Ernest Selby (George O'Brien) is an Easterner who has traveled west to take possession of a ranch he inherited. However, before arriving, he learns that about half is cattle have disappeared! But instead of sending in the sheriff to investigate, Selby decides to go undercover himself to see if he can learn the truth. He approaches the man running the ranch, Hepburn, and gets a job as a hired hand...telling no one about his real identity. Soon Hepburn's daughter begins showing a ton of interest in him....which could be a problem if Hepburn himself is stealing the cattle. What's next? See the film.

In many ways, this B-western is better than average. The locations for the shoot were amazing--incorporating many of the greatest spots in the American Southwest, such as the Grand Canyon, Zion National Park and Bryce National Park. It's just gorgeous because of this. Additionally, O'Brien is quite nice as the hero....very enjoyable and a good western actor. The only negatives are the use of a few of the usual cliches and a somewhat weak ending where the villain sure was stupid and sloppy! Still, the good outwieghs the bad and this one is worth seeing.

Syd Saylor was as good a serious side-kick as ever forked a horse, but he was thoroughly capable of playing a comic, or occasionally comic, partner as well.

He proved it in this excellent B Western, with a lot of by-play between him and star George O'Brien.

O'Brien was as good-looking and healthy a specimen as ever played a cowboy hero, fully capable of action heroics as well as romantic scenes.

The story, by iconic Zane Grey, is beautifully presented in a script by Barry Barringer directed by Edward Cline.

What makes this stand out is the characterization by all the performers, including the lovely Irene Hervey. She plays a spoiled, even seemingly conceited young lady of the range in a breezy city-slicker manner, but proves actually very likable, if sometimes flighty.

LeRoy Mason, here Le Roy, is his usual good-looking but rotten villain, alternating between seemingly likable and trustworthy ranch foreman and lecherous and traitorous thief.

Again, the entire cast is just about perfect, from the briefly seen Vesper Pegg, who just steals his scene of bringing up a mount, to the West-loving Earl Dwire, to Slim Whitaker and Lafe McKee and ... well, several others, none of whom get screen credit, but who all give us good reason to praise IMDb for providing the information.

There are a couple of flaws, a moment of trite action happening in just the right place, for example, that brought down the rating from that perfect 10, but I highly recommend "The Dude Ranger" which is available at YouTube.

Solidly entertaining in all departments, this Dude will disappoint in only one respect. Some bloodthirsty fans may find it a little lacking in action. Mind you, there was certainly enough for me. I enjoyed the equal measures of romance, humor and mystery. True, the basic plot is a familiar one, but it's given a very classy work-out here.

Irene Hervey walks away with the picture's acting honors, closely followed by personable hero O'Brien, surly heavy Mason, and, of all people, comic sidekick Syd Saylor — whom I usually can't stand! That in itself is a sure-fire indication of the top-grade entertainment qualities of script, direction and photography.