Ave Maryam

Cutting off Maryam's background really affects the perception of her character dynamics and leaves some pieces missing, primarily since they intended to show her inner struggles at the monastery. While perhaps the crew wanted to have subtlety as the main element of this film within the performance, the cinematography, and the dialogues, it unfortunately resulted in a lack of cohesion. The main attractiveness that pulls Maryam and Yosef is practically non-existent, some of the scenes contained rather pretentious lines than reflections of the wisdom from the bible, and the emotions only peaked in the third act after the slow-paced first and second acts filled with misinterpretation of "ascetic" with stale. On a lighter note, I hope this film will bring more ideas amongst Indonesian filmmakers, that religion outside the majority religion as well as cities outside Jakarta and Bali, can be equally beautiful on screen.

This movie is soooo good, top notch cinematography and performaces by Maudy as Maryam. Have a lot memorable scene like "the cafe", "spiegel", "beach", "stairway". I love the musicand the mood. I love the set so much too, i never knew Semarang can so romantic. This movie is beauty. Just go watch it.

As my review headline stated, this will be very subjective according to me, my nostalgia to he exact.

I spent my chuldhood and adolescent elyears studying at a Marsudirini school in North Jakarta. It is an Asisi Fransiscan order school with a Sister as headmistress. They can dish out discipline and tough love like no one else, but they're all actually kind hearts.

The older sisters in the movie reminded me very much of my school's headmistresses. They too go to such nursing home in Semarang when their age caught up to them.

And the location's architecture and especially interior design details really is likw my school looked like. Tiles high on walls, faded pastel colors almost everywhere, that distinct style on doors and window railings, arching door frames and so on.

About the movie itself, I like how the direction kind of took a big chunk of the style of Hong Kong director Wong Kar Wai, telling its story strongly through combination of every element shown on screen and jot just theough dialogue. Thus the dialogue here fan often feel so very short, but it is sharp with less wasted words. I particularly liked the dinner scene, so creative and impactful.

The cinematography is a feast for the eyes, incorporating various angles, calmed color palette, and litlle camera movement which enhanced the aura of stillness commonly found in these kinds of places.

The acting was solid, the leads and supporting cast all gave out good performances.

Beautifully written, shot, diction. Ave Maryam is about a nun who live in Semarang that has her confusion what will she choose, the love or the vows she made. The story just as simple as that, what makes it more beautiful is the story with beautiful diction. "If my heaven is not promised by, then why I bothered your hell?" --this line is my most memorable words from this movie. Also beautiful cinematography. Love the Semarang shot and the beach shot. The acting is brilliant by its lead actress, Maudy Koesnaedi. Her acting just describe her confussion, her confession, her sadness. This movie have minuses. The dub of the conversation bothered me, not exact naturally from the movie. And there is shot of a beach, the priest give birthday cake for the sister, with candle afire. Beach, we know that that place is very windy right, and the candle is not out! Wow magic! Over all this movie offers you different Indonesian cinematic experience. Oh yes, this movie also told us about diversity, love, confession and faith.

Very outstanding DOP and great story, in very low budget (i beleive) in scene setup, such as modern car, and in train station its not like 1980's, its very recent.