La justice par conviction

Host Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi is awesome! Empathetic, caring towards the families and friends of the victims and super knowledgeable with the detectives and prosecutors. I'm hooked!!

I actually really like this show! Not sure why the ratings are so low. I love this genre, and I think Anna-Sigga is a great host. Interesting stories, and she is a thorough and compassionate interviewer.

Interesting concept and love all other ID shows but this host is flat - has to show bra and tank tops in lame attempt to at least gain male interest but she is simply cold and boring. Comes across as false. I have to turn the channel off every time this show comes on because she is just off- putting. I don't believe in shaming people and do want to say she might be an excellent prosecutor or expert in her prior job - but she smacks of cheapness on tv - not trustworthy or interesting or actually interested in victims.

I fail to understand why she is 'hosting' this series. the cases are solved. her questions bring no additional insight - they could have taken anyone narrating this. I think she should have built on her own cases as a premise for this.

i'm asking myself, why the hell, as a former homicide prosecutor! is she doing this now? the only logical explanation for me would be: it's her hobby? & bc she is married to the channel-boss.... idk.... - i wouldn't recommend it...and i watch A LOT of crime-s***

With any good documentary or even true crime show, the best are those in which you rarely see the person documenting. In this case, so much film is totally wasted as the viewer is forced to watch the host of the show. I watched a few episodes and was done. The stories aren't even that compelling. The host is featured prominently in at least 50% of the show. Film that really should be used to properly document the facts, is shamefully wasted filming the host. In Maryland we call this an "Over cooked Ham" YAWN It really has to be said this host, in her quest for fame, does the victims and the families of the victims NO justice.