The Oath (Le serment d'Hippocrate)

We've seen this story told many times before but this still seems fresh and the acting is quite good. A little slow to get started but when it does, it's quite suspenseful. It's worth a watch, and the Icelandic settings are a relief from the usual American locales.

Possible Spoilers!

I gave this very worthy flick 10 stars just to redress the balance of the negative reviews it has received here.

Works on all levels. The dramatic tension is consistent throughout. The father/daughter relationship is very realistic, particularly her lack of self awareness and immaturity wich are very recognisable traits of addicts.

Gísli Örn Garðarsson was convincing as Ottar. He wasn't painted as just a two dimensional villain. Just as real villains are not just villains. They love, have families, have a sense of humour, pets and hobbies and are often victims of bigger villains than themselves.

I laud Baltasar Kormakur as both a fine director and actor.

I like Kormákur as an actor and director but not here, the plot is illogical, I agree with other reviewer about full of cliché, unnecessary dialogues. Look like Baltasar Kormákur tried to put little pieces from different thrillers in this, just hope his next work will be good as usual.

I was having a rough week and wanted to watch something I knew would be high quality and a good watch so I looked for a Baltasar Kormakur joint. Always enjoy his films. This one has an interesting plot and good acting and beautiful shots of Iceland, but I think my main issue was I just did not like the daughter. Dad was doing his thing trying to look out for her but then he took it too far. Too bad because he seemed like a great doctor and cool father until this loser boyfriend showed up. His whole life went downhill fast. So this wasn't a great choice to cheer me up after my rough week but I'm glad I could check this one off my list. I'm trying to see everything BK does because I enjoy his work so much.

The movie has a gread subject and well actors. Also I admire the buildings as an architect. Thats also a good point but movie hasn't an ending. I think move is unfinished and needs a final scene about punishment of dad