Defteri fysi

Not worthy to be even played for fun, this is a non movie item, short or long. Awful scenery, awful scenario, the music was irritating, it would be better if it did not exist at all... I did not even understand the meaning behind this 'creation', it does not depict anything in particular, apart from an old military guy speaking with a little girl. If there was some kind of real dialoque, feeling expressions, dressed with a more beautiful scenery and a serious tune, this 11 minute film might worth seeing. However, the little girl seemed to have depth in her moves and face expressions, giving some dignity in the work. It would be a better idea if this film was actually longer, giving the audience some more clues about what is meant by the writer.

I found this fascinating, and loved every second of it. The cinematography and sound design stood out to me the most.

The film achieves what it set out to do, and that is reflect what the forces of nature might do to us if we're left alone with them. Whether that is make us terrified, or joyous.

Despite the lack of dialogue, I was able to connect with the characters. In part the acting, and in part the aforementioned cinematography and sound design.

I tend not to give 10/10's, because I always think things could be better. But this, this, I feel, is closest to perfect as it could be. I cannot find fault in it.

Also, ignore the review from 2012. Whoever wrote that hasn't seen it. There's no old military guy in it at all.