Avaliações de usuários

I watched this movie out of curiosity because I have the book and have read it; five times. My book is 4" x 7" and is 311 pages long. That seemed like a lot for a two hour (I believe it was two hours) movie. I wanted to see how good the movie was and what parts of the book the movie omitted. I liked the movie despite the fact that it very understandably omitted a lot from the book. I read through the other user comments quickly and found two that said they like the movie better than the book. I would like to encourage those of you who have seen the movie but not read the book to get the book and read it. Parts of the book tend to be grandiose, which might be why the two users said they liked the movie better. To me, the book tells a great story with meaty characters that you get to know and care very much about. Central is Jane Withersteen who is being intimidated by the top Mormon men of her community. When she finally finds out how this intimidation campaign got started and, especially, who started it, she is rather shocked.

In most movies, gunslingers are cold men with hot bullets, but in this movie Ed Harris convinces the audience that no-one is beyond redemption. Killing out of hatred has not turned Lassiter into a robot with a gun, but a human being plagued by the life he has chosen. Great acting, by everyone.

Good and Evil depends on ones point of view. Who's side of the fence are you on and how do you fight that which you perceive as evil. Just as the person before me in his review stated, if you haven't read the book, you might want to, so that you will understand the obvious points that had to be left out of the movie. It really is important to make some understanding of the thought's that Zane Grey, one of the premiere western writers of the past. He was ahead of his time giving psychological reasoning for his character's as well as one of the best describers of surrounding beauty that the characters are enveloped in.

The evil men in this portrait of the depravity of men (even those of "religious' belief's) is portrayed vividly by the men of the Mormon church as they saw their duty. Greed set aside, this was about a belief as well. Right and wrong played out in a violent nature by violent men. Portrayed brilliantly by an outstanding cast.

Then comes Lassiter, who is violent in his own way and yet gentle and kind. He steps up to the plate and helps Jane Withersteen (played by Amy Madigan in one of her most impressive acting to date), while Lassiter (played in a hard as rock characterization by Ed Harris) still after those who caused his family member to commit suicide. I believe these characters played by this particular cast very brilliantly portrayed just as those envisioned by Zane Grey in his book "Riders of the Purple Sage".

The screen play is very well done by Gill Dennis from the book written by Zane Grey. Direction by Charles Haid proves he understands the west as well as how to get the best out of his actors and staff. If it was not a movie made for television, it would rank up there with the best like Eastwoods "The Unforgiven" and Costner's "Open Range" with each of those carrying "star power" and Rider's unsung actors.

Tough interpretation of a hard subject, still beyond it's time.

For any fan of a good western and Zane Gray this movie is well worth the viewing time. I had read the book several times over the years and found this movie lived up to my expectations. The movie was as true to the book as any movie of this nature can be. The action will draw you in, I had to go back and reread the book to see if I missed something. The authenticity of the scenery as well as the beauty really helped make the movie. Lassiter starts out as a somewhat questionable hero but quickly you realize that he is one of the quiet good guys. Reminded me of some of the older western movies like "Shane" or some of the newer ones like "Tom Horn" or "The Sackets. Read the book, see the movie, and then read the book again it will be worth your time.

Having read the original novel after seeing the film, I was most impressed how well it adhered to the original plot line from the Zane Grey novel.

Ed Harris, an actor that I usually do not care for, was very, very impressive in this film. As Lassiter, I loved his delivery of the line to the bad Mormons: "Where I come from, a woman's word is law." Harris conveys the right portion of menace and due respect when necessary in his role.

I saw this on TV; I wish it had been on the big screen

Too bad Zane Grey never saw this version; I sure he would have been very happy with this production.

Where can I start? I've heard/seen the title "Riders of the Purple Sage" for as long as I can remember, but never read the book, nor did I ever see any of the previous versions of this Zane Gray novel. It wasn't until I became a big Ed Harris fan that I started looking for more of his films, and ended up buying "Riders." I knew it was going to be good, but wow!, I couldn't have imagined it would be teriffic -by far the best western, and one of the best films, period, I've ever seen.

There is so much to this story. . . the two love stories of course; the hypocrisy of the "righteous", and the redeeming qualities of those who on the surface may appear to be "evil" or "bad guys"; the power of love between the most unlikely couples; and the spiritual power of love and trust, just for starters.

I don't know if the script was taken directly from the book, but the dialogue was magical in many scenes. Amy Madigan and Ed Harris were magical too, partly due to their personal relationship I'm sure, but their work together in this film was unforgetable. I couldn't help but notice how they kind of look alike! Common among some married couples.

The supporting cast was excellent, and the scenery unbelievable. This is one of the films I will be watching over and over again. It should be released in the theaters! See it.

Unlike the "western saga" with noise and unbelievable actions scenes, this movie is like watching the events as they happen. You are taken back to the time Zane Grey wanted to capture with his pen, and it was well translated in this film. Harris and Madigan bring a reality to a classic tale.

This is a movie that I enjoyed so much that I have watched it every chance I have had since then. The characters are so rich. the love story stayed on my mind for months afterward. It took me awhile to recognize Henry Thomas from "E.T." all grown up, and it made me look out for other stuff with Robin Tunney in them as she was so captivating. The scenery was breath-taking. The ending so intense that I was right there with the couple feeling like I was fighting with all my might for life and love. If anyone else likes this movie, may I suggest Sam Elliott and his wife Katherine Ross in "Conagher" and "The Shadow Riders"? Cowboys don't have to ride off into the sunset just with their horse anymore.

Mr. and Mrs. Ed Harris, like Mr. and Mrs. Paul Newman, Mr. and Mrs. Frederic March, Mr. and Mrs. Hume Cronyn, Mr. and Mrs. Ronald Colman, even Mr. and Mrs. Jack Benny work beautifully together as they help make sense out of Zane Grey's, "Riders Of the Purple Sage."

Unfortunately, that wonderful all-west title was borrowed by some sort of psychedelic band calling themselves, "New Riders of the Purple Sage."

I'll stick to the old riders, thank you just as the movie sticks closely to the original book.

The movie is up to its eyeballs in philosophy, but it is not so deep that the residents of Dolt City would be confused.

The background music is quite good, even if it does not include the Mormon Tabernacle Choir.

The story will keep you interested from top to bottom. In dialogue it is more than a tad above Gene, Roy, and Tex, etc., all of whom i deeply enjoy.

"Riders Of the Purple Sage" is a thinking person's western, while in no way losing the flavor of a western film.

Go see it. That is 'sage' advice.

Trying to create a film adaptation of one of the most popular books of all time almost 100 years after the book's original publication could delight and disappoint many. In doing so, the director must do the book justice while adapting it to a visual format that will engage modern audiences. When director Charles Haid helmed the second film version of Zane Grey's Riders of the Purple Sage, he pulled off the task of making a film that both entertains Grey neophytes and long-time readers. He accomplished this by sticking to what made the book tick: beautiful settings and archetypal characters.

Since Haid shot his film on location in Moab, UT, he merely had to let the camera pan to accomplish half what he needed to in the film. The gorgeous vistas of the Colorado Plateau color the entire film with an easy majesty and stark realism. Many times in the film, the characters simply provide an excuse for the presentation of the canyon lands around them. For instance, when Venters first finds himself outcast and expelled from the company of his beloved Jan and the town of Cottonwoods, he wonders off alone into the labyrinth of canyons where the outlaw Oldring hides. His isolation and search for identity and belonging find representation in the plunging canyons, lonely solitary rocks, and myriad colors surrounding him. While the book describes Venters state of mind in laborious detail, Haid merely lets his shooting location tell the tale.

Very little of the plot which first appears in Grey's book is changed in Haid's film version. Other than small, necessary changes that streamline the film and make it watchable, the characters and conflict run true to the book. While the book specifically names Mormons as the evil force out to ruin Jane, the movie opts instead to create a Unitarian-type Protestant church without picking by name on the Mormons. Where Grey uses three men to make up Jane's stable help, the film combines all three into one. While not the same as the book, the change works to simplify the film while not significantly changing the book's story.

In terms of characterization, an older Ed Harris and Amy Madigan play the leading roles of Lassiter and Jane. While Harris's skullet (bald with mullet) and Madigan's wrinkles may not accurately represent the young and beautiful vibrancy of the book's characters, these veteran actors more than make up in acting what they lack in appearance. You believe Jane's ambivalence towards her church and Lassiter when you hear Madigan's earnestly delivered lines. You find yourself taken in by Lassiter's tortured past and consuming present when Harris squints, rides, shoots, and weeps under the Utah sky. Robin Tunney, now of Prison Break fame, perfectly embodies the innocent, tomboyish Bess as she finds herself both shot and loved in the same day. Even little Elliot from E.T., Henry Thomas, pulls off a convincing, grown up performance as the spurned Venters.

In the end, this movie will entertain any fan of the Western film genre, while at the same time satisfying even the most devoted Zane Grey fan. With great settings from Moab, UT, a screenplay that does little to depart from the original text, and sound performances from good actors, this film works. It's no Unforgiven, but it beats the smarmy, Hollywood smugness of, say, Tombstone. Grey would approve.

I was an avid Zane Grey reader as a teenager in the forties & have not re-read the book since. However,when viewing the movie, I felt the same aura of old west romance that I remembered from many years before. I have always felt that, in spite of his rather blatant racism, Zane Grey wove exciting and entertaining stories. I wish there would be additional efforts to bring more of his books to either the small or large screen, and that they would be as well made as "Riders of the Purple Sage".

I was pleasantly surprised when I watched this movie. The

costuming is excellent, the location is perfect. Ed Harris plays a

rough and tumble gun-slinger named Lassiter. He's a man with a

mission and he means to see the mission through to the bitter

end, no matter what the cost. In the process he does some great

riding, some fancy gun play, and gives a solid performance as a

man who gets the job done. The romantic action between Harris

and Amy Madigan is subtle and beautifully portrayed. Some of the

supporting cast are a bit one dimensional but the overall film is

smooth paced, well-done, and has a happy ending. If you are

looking for a good modern western film, this is it.

I have watched this movie countless times and shown it to all my co-workers. It is one of the best movies I've ever seen. The screenplay extracted the best parts from the book, and it became a fantastic western romance. Lassiter is the baddest gunsliger I've ever seen. Amy Madigan was wonderful as Jane Lassiter. All other cast members were equally wonderful. The secondary love story is tender and sweet. It contains a particularly good stunt fall by a bad guy . When he hits the floor, there is no doubt he is dead. Lassiter and Jane's romance is so touching, the reveal-all scene on her porch during the rainstorm touches my heart every time I see it. The final scene is so beautiful I wish I had a picture of it, a kiss in the sunset. I can't praise it enough.

I've seen a lot of Westerns, "spaghetti" and otherwise, but none better photographed than "Riders of the Purple Sage". This is flat out one wonderful movie, greatly enhanced by the unbelievable setting and outstanding photography. The story of Mormon brain wiring is well told, and is quite bloody and exciting. Ed Harris as the revenge seeking gunslinger has never been better, and he works well with Amy Madigan and Henry Thomas. G.D. Spradlin is the Pastor in charge, and leader of those trying to destroy Madigan for not submitting to an arranged marriage. The film is loaded with surprising revelations that put a different spin on the story. This rarely seen Western should be on your "must see" list. - MERK

The best version based on Zane Gray's novel, in fact it surpasses the book, Amy Madigan and real life husband Ed Harris perform well together. A good feel of the true west and some of the religious fanatics and bigots that lived then. I think in some respects it was similar to Clint Eastwood's "Unforgiven" and in passing "Pale Rider"

Most of the new westerns being made these days (i.e. Unforgiven, Tombstone, etc.) are exceptional, but this may be the pick of the lot - the characters are real, the plot is believable, the photography is superb. I've never read the book, but I may now.

Enjoyed the story, acting, photography and location (Moab, Utah). They don't make many westerns (or movies, for that matter) like this anymore. Watch it. You'll like it. Ed Harris was nominated for best actor in Screen Actors Awards from best TV drama for his performance. Well deserved, and if I remember correctly, I believe he won the award.

Well I'm almost done with the book. I saw this and rented it. I, like others, liked it better than the book. I would have liked better if it was a feature film and maybe about fifteen minutes longer to flesh out some of the backstories more. But very impressively done for a made for tv movie. I had trouble reading parts of the book as Grey spends two whole pages at a time just describing scenery. Also, the ways he makes some of the characters talk is awkward and seems unrealistic to me. Like he came up with a fantastic story but could have used some help on the dialogue.

Anyway, the movie helped put me in the setting and make sense of the descriptive narrative from the book. It follows the major plot points and doesn't leave out any important chunks. Great movie!

Zayne gray was my mom's favorite author she had every one of his books. And Colonel sherman potter, he liked his books. Every one of them is a classic. So they wouldn't let me submit this, because I didn't have six hundred Character, so I'm just going to have to ramble on until I am out of characters right now, I have about 250 I guess they need about 250 more. So this thing will let me put this Review in now. I am a little bit less than 200, so I still got a yammer on for a little bit. You know, my friend Merlin could jammer on with the best of them? Oh only fifty more hopefully I could make it. Oh my goodness yes instantly.