Três Segredos

From 1950, Three Secrets stars Eleanor Parker, Patricia Neal, and Ruth Roman in a dated but well-acted story.

There are many horrible things a person can do; evidently, the most unforgivable, horrific things was having sex before marriage resulting in a pregnancy.

When an adopted five year-old boy is the sole survivor of a plane crash that killed his parents, three women believe he is the child she gave up.

As they gather at the rescue site, a mountain, we learn their stories: Susan (Parker) loved a soldier and finds out he loves another girl at home; Phyllis (Neal), an ambitious reporter whose husband objects to her career, learns she's pregnant after he remarries; and Ann (Roman), pregnant by a man she believes loves her, goes to prison after she kills her boyfriend when he dumps her.

Well directed by Robert Wise, the three women are fleshed out so that we feel for them - we know who we want to be the mother - and, like the women, we wait to find out. A stunning Neal's dry wit and sarcasm come through, as well as her heart. Hers is the strongest role, but Parker and Roman are wonderful with sad stories.

I thought the film was a bit too long - too much footage of reporters interviewing the climbers, etc.

There ending is very touching. Recommended.

Whatever suspense THREE SECRETS has is derived from the audience not knowing (until the end) which woman's boy has survived a plane crash. Each woman (ELEANOR PARKER, RUTH ROMAN and PATRICIA NEAL) thinks it's her own abandoned five year-old son. As they wait patiently for more news on the identity of the boy, each woman reflects in flashbacks on what led up to their heart-breaking decision.

Robert Wise has directed all of the melodrama with some fine touches and a steady hand, so that Parker, Roman and Neal are all seen to advantage in a plot vaguely similar to that of A LETTER TO THREE WIVES in which three women await news on which husband deserted them.

Parker is a woman who had an illegitimate child; Roman had to give up her child while she served a jail term; Neal was a career woman who preferred career to domestic chores.

Sensibily acted and directed, it's a rather low-key melodrama that might not meet the demands of fans not enthusiastic about so-called chick flicks.

A plane crashes on a mountain peak. Everyone is dead, except possibly the five-year-old adopted son of two of the passengers. As reporters gather to cover the story of the men preparing to climb to mountain to rescue the child, the movie concentrates on three women present: tough-as-nails reporter Patricia Neal, married, childless housewife Eleanor Parker, and Ruth Roman, convicted of slaying the father of her unborn child. Each had given a child up for adoption on the same day to the same adoption agency, the day the child was adopted.

The situation is remarkably similar to Wilder's mordant ACE IN THE HOLE, but Robert Wise's movie is more about the story of the three women and their suffering. The performances are prime work; even Leif Erickson as Miss Parker's lawyer husband recites his few lines in stalwart tones. 1920s Sennett clown Billy Bevan gets three lines, and other actors like Frank Lovejoy and Larry Keating give good performances, but the emphasis is on the three women: tamped-down Miss Neal, fragile Miss Parker and almost hysterical Miss Roman. I'm not terribly fond of these stories, but this is a well told one.

This marvelous 1950 film deals with 3 women who gave up their baby boy for adoption. 5 years later, the child is involved in a plane crash that killed his parents. Each of the women believe that the boy is theirs.

Patricia Neal, as one of the women, is a hard-nosed reporter. As with the others, the film goes back to show the situation that would lead them to give up the baby. Neal had divorced her husband only to learn that she was a reporter. A career woman, she could never care for a child or hold on to her marriage.

Then there is Ruth Roman who went to prison for killing her boyfriend. The latter wanted her to have an abortion when she told him of her pregnancy.

Eleanor Parker is a sweet woman who gave up an illegitimate child and is now happily married. You're rooting for Parker to be the mother. She can provide the boy with the proper upbringing. True, it will mean that she will have to tell her husband about her past, but she can provide the right nurturing environment.

Of course, the 3 women will come to the mountain area where the boy is in the plane. Neal will have to use her paper connections to get to who the real mother is.

As a reader, please connect to this film via your video store. It's well worth the trip.

Naturally, each of the women

Smartly combining a bit of the disaster movie with melodrama, Robert Wise was very good at directing actresses; his precedent movie, "the set-up" ,although taking place in the boxing world , featured a prominent female character (the boxer's wife was not only decorative and she had this sublime sentence :" WE've won tonight" .)

By and large ,the first part is given over to Parker, then Neal dominates the second one -and her evolution from an arrogant journalist to a compassionate woman is convincing - ;Roman appears late in the story (apart from a brief glimpse in "the shelter" ) but her character is the only one who does not belong to a privileged milieu :an ex-convict ,she 's lost everything and she clings to this hope : a child who could be hers ,should he be found still alive. The audience sides with her when she slaps in the tabloid press journalist's face.

The rapport the three actresses have is deeply moving , and although we eventually learn the true identity of the mother ,it does not seem to matter anymore ; it's OUR child .