Ellery Queen and the Murder Ring

Mrs Stack is a patron of a hospital who gets suspicious of how that establishment is being run. She calls Inspector Queen to provide her with a policeman who doesn't look like a policeman to make an undercover investigation there. Inspector Queen sends his son Ellery who manages to get himself admitted as a patient at the hospital. Mrs Stack is soon a patient there herself after getting hurt in a car collision. It's soon obvious that more than just one person is out to kill her before she is found dead after an operation.

You may find that this is one of the weaker of the seven Ellery Queen mysteries of the 1940 to 1942 period. It suffers from having too many comic characters involved. It's always good to see the saner presence of George Zucco who appears as the doctor under suspicion in this. His hospital becomes a bedlam of trolleys being switched and people under shrouds posing as corpses in order to hide themselves. And then there's people posing as nurses including a crook who does an unconvincing job on that score and also Ellery Queen's secretary who manages to get herself in uniform as well.

There are a number of characters who have murder as their intention. So it makes it difficult to guess the one who is actually responsible for the murders. I didn't get the killer until just before the reveal. Thus this film does satisfy as a whodunit even if you may tire a little of the comic knockabout.

Ralph Bellamy made four Ellery Queen movies for Larry Darmour, releasing through Columbia in the early 1940s. The fourth is a typically well constructed murder mystery. Blanche Yurka is a penny-pinching rich woman whom everyone wants dead: her son, Leon Ames, whom she won't give any money to; her daughter, Jean Fenwick, whom she keeps on a similarly tight leash; George Zucco, the head doctor at the hospital she owns, who wants to give his medical advance to the world, when she insists she owns it; and gangsters Paul Hurst and Tom Dugan, who have run her off the road to kill her on Ames' instruction. She winds up in the hospital, not dead.... but dies, strangled.... everyone wants her dead. No one could have done it.

A fine mystery and, like the others in the series, it plays fair with the fans of the genre. Unfortunately, it's a lot weaker than earlier entries, being weakened by a ot of dumb humor to eke its length out to a standard length of just over 69 minutes. It's good to see Bellamy, Margaret Linday as Nikki Porter and Charley Grapewin as Inspector Queen again, but the movie would have been more pleasing had it been a bit less stereotyped. and rote.

While in his first appearances as 'Ellery Queen', Ralph Bellamy had been very serious (almost too serious, compared to Donald Cook and Eddie Quillan, who had played the character before him), in his last film for the series he (and all the cast with him) shows his comical side for once. And surprisingly enough, this makes a fine mix with a - literally - deadly serious murder case, providing lots of corpses, greedy relatives, shady doctors, and at the same time dumb cops, even dumber crooks, and of course more funny quarrels with his assistant Nikki than ever before.

The plot, in fact, IS a classic 'whodunit', with many twists and surprises, and a challenge for every mystery fan - at least for those who've got a good sense of humor, too... So, if you don't take murder too seriously, this movie will provide you real good entertainment, varying from quite suspenseful and even creepy sections to moments of pure comedy!

Several of the other user reviewers LIKED this film. I could hardly wait for it to finish up and it was just a little over an hour long. . The silly bad guys tried to be like the stooges but couldn't even muster their level of low humor (riding around on a gurney, switched bodies, nurses uniform with a hoop skirt that kept exposing his shorts clad bottom (yawn) ) Bellamy and Zucco and other B players were wasted on this one. Even the title is meaningless.

Give it a skip !

Augusta Stack was almost killed in a deliberate traffic accident. As a result, she's in the hospital...where Ellery Queen (Ralph Bellamy) is working undercover. She was shaken up and her leg broken...but oddly she died in surgery! Soon, other bodies start piling up and when the cops and Queen investigate, they find lots of people who had reason to kill the old woman...and perhaps the rest. Can Ellery solve the crimes before his lady friend, Nikki (Margaret Lindsay) gets herself killed while snooping into the case as well?

During the 1930s and 40s, a zillion B-murder mysteries were made in Hollywood. They all had a lot of similarities and cliches (such as in this one where Nikki essentially confronts the murderer while having no backup nor a weapon with which to defend herself!). But it is an enjoyable film...worth seeing if you like the genre and a bit better made than usual.

By the way, unlike many sleuths (such as Charlie Chan), tons of different actors played Ellery Queen and none came to own the role or appear in more than a few films. It's a shame Bellamy didn't do more of these films...he was pretty good here.