I just finished watching Little Miss Innocent: Passion. Poison. Prison. The director and producer should be ashamed of themselves, for not including all of the evidence and making her look guilty. HERE ARE THE FACTS:
Kaitlyn had been in a relationship with someone else for five months at the time that Mary died. Kaitlyn even had evidence to counter these claims, including text messages of Adam begging her to be with him again. These texts, however, were not admitted to trial. Another piece of evidence not admitted was a lie detector test taken by Kaitlyn, in which she passed.
Kaitlyn claimed that she was off work in late 2014 through early 2015, when the colchicine was purchased from her work computer. Although the payroll books would have given her a solid alibi, Bill claimed that it was lost. The letter of intent to buy the poison that was supposedly written by Kaitlyn referenced biotechnology applications that Bill had used on his weed plants. They believe it is unlikely that Kaitlyn had much prior knowledge about this, and there were no searches made by her about these topics suggesting that she researched it.
Bill maintains that he never used that computer, although witnesses have said that they have seen him on that computer in the office. Not only that, but Bill had software on his computer that would allow him to access that specific computer from his own home office computer. Adding even more of a threat to Kaitlyn's security on her devices, her phone was not password protected. All office employees had to keep their phones in a separate room during their shift, which would have given Bill access to her phone. Adam also frequently used Kaitlyn's laptop, and they had a shared Apple ID.
Three of Mary's sisters are not convinced that Kaitlyn poisoned her, but instead they believe that her husband Bill did. When Mary first got to the hospital she was sick but she was not deathly ill. In their opinion, the sudden change of behavior after she had purged everything and seemed to feel better suggests that Mary had been poisoned with the lethal dose while she was in the hospital. Once Mary's condition started to deteriorate, Bill became unreachable both by Mary and by hospital staff. Police had to actually go to Bill's house and bang on his door, and even then it took awhile before he would answer. He told them he would get to the hospital as soon as possible. While this trip should have only taken Bill around fifteen minutes, it would be an hour later before he arrived.
Although the Yoder family found out that Mary had been poisoned on September 17, 2015, a police report was not filed by the family until almost 3 months after her death, when Sharon, one of Mary's sisters, filed one.
Adam and Bill refused lie detector tests.
