morcego
Bienvenue sur nouveau profil
Nos mises à jour sont toujours en cours de développement. Bien que la version précédente de le profil ne soit plus accessible, nous travaillons activement à des améliorations, et certaines fonctionnalités manquantes seront bientôt de retour ! Restez à l'écoute de leur retour. En attendant, l’analyse des évaluations est toujours disponible sur nos applications iOS et Android, qui se trouvent sur la page de profil. Pour consulter la répartition de vos évaluations par année et par genre, veuillez consulter notre nouveau Guide d'aide.
Badges37
Pour savoir comment gagner des badges, rendez-vous sur page d'aide sur les badges.
Évaluations1,7 k
Note de morcego
Avis23
Note de morcego
Humm, lemme think how can I write a review without spoilers...
Oh, wait! There is nothing to spoil.
Formulaic, slow drawn for no purpose except to pad the run time (I'm being generous here).
Part 1 was not exactly good, but I, at least, could see some promise. Could see where it was heading, in it's hushed way. Part 2 is the oppose, in a bad way.
While part 1 hurried along, trying to created several hooks, deal with several issues and unite a lot of people, without stopping in any point to explore the possibilities, part 2 drags... and drags... and drags.... Long scenes of people harvesting grains is just an example, and far from the worse of it.
Sure, this is not as bad as, say, Moonfall or Battlefield Earth. And that is the thing I can say about it.
Formulaic, slow drawn for no purpose except to pad the run time (I'm being generous here).
Part 1 was not exactly good, but I, at least, could see some promise. Could see where it was heading, in it's hushed way. Part 2 is the oppose, in a bad way.
While part 1 hurried along, trying to created several hooks, deal with several issues and unite a lot of people, without stopping in any point to explore the possibilities, part 2 drags... and drags... and drags.... Long scenes of people harvesting grains is just an example, and far from the worse of it.
Sure, this is not as bad as, say, Moonfall or Battlefield Earth. And that is the thing I can say about it.
Remembrance of Earth's Past might be, if not my favorite book series, on the top three. When I've heard they were adapting it for Netflix, I was scared. When I've heard who was behind the project, I was even more scared. But, on the same time, I was... kind of hopeful? Sure, we had the Tecent adaptation... The news about the cast and and the teasers left me even more fearful.
I did get hopeful from time to time, like when I heard they were calling the others "San-Ti" and now "Treesolarians", showing they went back to the original language books.
I was right to be scared, and I was right to be hopeful.
The adaptation if good, but good in a very different way the books are good.
It is the same story (mostly), and they are being faithful to it (mostly). It can't compete with the books regarding the science, but it is good where the books are weak (character development).
The casting works. Liam Cunningham is going a great job. Marlo Kelly is perfectly cast. Benedict Wong is spot on. Everyone else is going a competent job at the very least.
The pacing is faster than the books but, then again, how could it not be. But not so fast that they don't take their time to show us the characters.
Even having had the books and knowing the story, it is worth the watch. Not only as an adaptation but, mostly, by itself.
I did get hopeful from time to time, like when I heard they were calling the others "San-Ti" and now "Treesolarians", showing they went back to the original language books.
I was right to be scared, and I was right to be hopeful.
The adaptation if good, but good in a very different way the books are good.
It is the same story (mostly), and they are being faithful to it (mostly). It can't compete with the books regarding the science, but it is good where the books are weak (character development).
The casting works. Liam Cunningham is going a great job. Marlo Kelly is perfectly cast. Benedict Wong is spot on. Everyone else is going a competent job at the very least.
The pacing is faster than the books but, then again, how could it not be. But not so fast that they don't take their time to show us the characters.
Even having had the books and knowing the story, it is worth the watch. Not only as an adaptation but, mostly, by itself.
Sondages effectués récemment
Total de 6 sondages effectués
